Original title: "A Theory of Justice for Web3"
Original author: Li Jin & Katie Parrott
Original compilation: Kxp, Rhythm BlockBeats
Anyone who knows me knows that the views of the late political philosopher John Rawls are in my system of thought occupies an important position. Although his masterpiece "A Theory of Justice" was published half a century ago, Rawls' ideas are still applicable in today's Internet age, given that platforms are still seeking new profit opportunities and further widening the gap between rich and poor. The theory of using the "veil of ignorance" to realize the fair distribution of social resources proposed in his book is very suitable for our current discussion on Web3.
Earlier today , published in Harvard Business Review. In this article, I assess Web2 and Web3 using Rawls' theory of justice and provide a set of guiding principles for the development of Web3 to create A fairer and better Internet environment. I hope this article will spark a discussion about the development of Web3, and pay more attention to the impact we have as builders and participants in the ecosystem. If you like this article , welcome to join the discussion on Twitter.

Magdiel Lopez/Belmont Creative< p>The most common statement about Web3 is that it aims to create a better and fairer Internet. Specifically, Web3 proponents envision an Internet in which users can take back power from a few centralized institutions, and each Every netizen can enjoy a fair Internet environment.
However, Web2 also had a similar setting at the beginning, that is, to give individuals Creator power and removal of intermediaries has not been achieved. Now, standing on the cusp of a new era of the Internet, we should ask ourselves: Does Web3 truly democratize opportunity? If not, how can we better Design fair platforms and systems of governance?
In his 1971 book A Theory of Justice, social and political philosopher John Rawls "The thought experiment of "the veil of ignorance" is proposed, which provides an effective thinking framework for these questions. Rawls believes that in building an ideal society, we should not construct our place in it in advance, but should use the "veil of ignorance". In other words, a truly just society should be a society where "people are willing to join randomly after fully understanding the society". Rawls adds to this:
"One of the fundamental characteristics of such a society is that no one knows his or her class or social position in the society, No one knows their own personal property and abilities, and I can even assume that they don’t know their own concepts of right and wrong, good and evil, and whether they have special psychological tendencies.”
Rawls's thought experiment is of great significance to our society now, because we are at the inflection point conceived by the veil of ignorance. The development of Web3 provides us with a new opportunity to rebuild a new Internet and Internet economy. The question then becomes: what kind of Internet should we build?
Some might say that Web3 is still young and these issues will resolve themselves over time. However, issues of influence and externalities have not been addressed in the design of Web2, which has led to undesirable consequences such as election manipulation and misinformation about vaccines. Some indicators suggest that some early designs of Web3 are reproducing and even exacerbating the inequalities between Web2 and the real world.
If we want Web3 to truly live up to its vision of substantially improving the situation for everyone in the ecosystem, not just the few at the top, We need to design it according to the principles that can achieve this goal.
For centuries, philosophers and thinkers have debated how best to allocate resources among the actors in society. Systems of thought that specifically address these issues are known as "distributive justice," and there are different schools of thought within the discipline:
Strong egalitarians believe that true justice The best system is that resources can be allocated absolutely equally. In other words, everyone should have the same amount of material goods. The rationale behind this principle is that since everyone is morally equal, they should all have equal access to goods and services.
· Luck egalitarians believe that the most important equality is the equality of the starting position, and any inequality after that is a personal acquired effort decided.
·Libertarians believe that individual freedom should be the only consideration for people and that any distribution of resources violates this freedom.
· Utilitarians believe that the most just system is the one that maximizes the happiness of all participants. According to utilitarianism, the redistribution of wealth is desirable, because from the perspective of marginal effects, such as the happiness of the rich, each dollar can increase the happiness of the poor to a greater extent.
At the heart of these schools of thought are two equally important but often opposing themes: liberty and equality. A perfectly free society tends to have a great deal of inequality, because individuals have different motives for pursuing wealth and act in ways that prioritize their own interests. Conversely, a perfectly egalitarian society also limits individual freedom, because individuals must act in an equality-oriented manner, even if such unequal outcomes are "won" through individual efforts.
Based on the reasoning of the veil of ignorance, Rawls put forward his own theory of distributive justice, the so-called "fair justice". It consists of two parts: the principle of maximum equal liberty and the principle of difference. The principle of maximum equality and freedom refers to giving all citizens equal rights and freedoms to the greatest extent on the premise of fairness and justice.
The difference principle states that any social or economic inequality in a society should satisfy two conditions. First, they must be able to "hold positions and positions open to all under conditions of fairness and equality," and social work positions should be open to all and allocated on the basis of merit. In other words, a person's success should be determined by his personal gifts and his ability to use them, not by his social class or background. Second, any inequality that does exist should benefit the least well-off the most. According to this principle, doctors should be paid more than cleaners because this difference in pay would incentivize doctors to pursue their careers and ensure that cleaners (and everyone else) receive high-quality care when they are sick.
Rawls' theory has nuances, but in general it addresses the mutual The central contradiction between opposing needs. By allowing inequality to benefit the most vulnerable, he established a natural and rational corrective to the ever-growing inequalities that would otherwise only grow in any libertarian system.
The balance between freedom and equality in Rawls's theory makes it a very convincing framework for Internet thinking. According to his thinking, aspiring and intelligent builders will be more actively involved in ecosystem construction under incentives. At the same time, under this framework, builders and the entire ecosystem will also create more opportunities for disadvantaged groups.
How big is the current Internet To what extent does it comply with Rawls' principle? In many ways, the Web2 Internet creates opportunity for more people. It is more in line with Rawls's difference principle than it was in the pre-Internet era. Before the advent of the Internet, participation opportunities in various industries were only in the hands of a few people, but now the development of the Internet and social media platforms allows anyone to participate in content creation and dissemination, thus allowing more creators to succeed.
But it's clear that the Web2 internet falls short in other ways, with constraints on equality and violations of the difference principle: gig economy platforms generate billions of dollars income, while front-line workers who provide services earn meager salaries and are disenfranchised from the decisions that affect their lives; social media companies and media platforms earn billions of dollars in advertising revenue through algorithms, but spread Misinformation and causing harm to disadvantaged communities; the platform’s Creator Fund tends to reward creators with the most views and engagement, and these people often already have sufficient income, while those who aspire to become excellent creators It is difficult for low-income creators of creators to obtain rewards from the platform. As we have said in previous articles, the Internet is not equipped with direct payment functions, which has also led to the extractive business model based on advertisements in today's Internet economy.
However, not only did the Web2 platform fail to meet Rawls’s standard of justice, but the current Web3 is also exacerbating inequality. Web3 projects often regard Crypto as digital value, and the early Token distribution mechanism is unfair, rewarding speculators instead of those who really continue to provide value to the network. Some P2E games adopt a dual Token system, where users can earn income but have no governance rights, which further exacerbates wealth inequality. Business writer Evan Armstrong pointed out that what some current NFT projects have in common with multi-level marketing schemes is that due to the design limitations of the system itself, late users in the ecosystem cannot obtain the same benefits as early users.
We have Understand that neither the Web2 Internet nor the early iterations of Web3 have been able to create a free and level playing field that benefits the underprivileged. Therefore, in order to create an Internet that truly meets the Rawls standard, we should pay attention to the following universal principles:
Don't build a system that only benefits the rich, but also pay attention to the poor Interests.
· Don't build a system that is overly biased towards early adopters so that all users have access to the early knowledge network.
· Do not build a system that requires too much technical proficiency, as it will be difficult to accommodate users who do not have the ability or resources to learn these skills .
Under the guidance of these principles, the builders and participants of the Web3 ecosystem can take three measures to realize Rawls's freedom, Principles of equality and difference. First, to promote self-determination and agency; second, to reward user participation, not just capital investment; and third, to develop measures that benefit disadvantaged groups.
Self-determination is Web3 One of the important principles: Unlike the Web2 platform, the Web3 community will be controlled by its members, not the founders, executives and shareholders in the Web2 platform. This is consistent with the "immigration, advice, and loyalty" model proposed by the economist Albert O. Hirschman, which describes the choices individuals make when they are dissatisfied with institutions and the state. Ideally, on the Web3 platform, users can choose to express themselves, change their situation, or use another platform, or wait for the platform's problems to be resolved.
But today, the real situation is more complicated. The early governance structures basically adopted the Token weighted voting model. As a result, the plutocratic system derived from this model is no different from the board of directors they correct. The problem with the plutocratic system, whether it’s on a board or a DAO’s Discord channel, is that those in power only have their own interests in mind.
In order to make the future Web3 comply with Rawls's principle of justice, the participants and construction of the Web3 ecosystem should first build a democratic governance system, so that all members have A voice, not just for an elite few. That is, everyone should have equal rights in the systems they participate in.
We can also establish the following governance systems to curb the wealth system:
· Reputation-based governance model: assign governance rights according to personal reputation.
· Proxy Model: Community members can delegate others to vote on their behalf.
· Pods/subDAO: Create small groups within an organization for small-scale governance.
Mirror diversifies its users through the WRITE Token airdrop project. Users can use this Token to register a Customize subdomains and participate in governance in the future. In order to expand the user base capable of influencing governance, the algorithm on which token distribution is based will maximize community diversity. According to Mirror, the airdrop "further democratizes the user selection process and eases barriers to entry. The growth of the Mirror community will be determined by those who have actively shaped its future so far."
< br>
In addition to internal governance through proposals, participants also need a viable exit route. Web2 platforms use network effects and closed data to keep users engaged with their platform, while exiting the platform means the creator no longer has access to his audience or content. But in Web3, with digital ownership, open data, and a network based on open source software, users can truly achieve agency and self-determination.
A core tenet of Web3 is that there are many ways to provide value to an ecosystem other than capital. Furthermore, the value should not only be bought, but earned as well. Obviously, this is very different from the existing structure. In the existing structure, investment earns more than people earn from working, and this slowly widens the gap between rich and poor.
In the past, ownership would only be allocated to employees and investors who participated in the construction of the platform, while users who really contributed valuable content to the platform were excluded. Now, users will also have the opportunity to gain ownership, which is also a major shift for the platform.
To build a fair and just Web3, we must ensure that everyone has equal status and can obtain corresponding rights and rewards according to their contributions. In practice, those in the correct knowledge network can increase their wealth by creating multiple accounts and other strategies to obtain additional Token airdrops. Although the early Token distribution mechanism led to some short-term profit-seeking behaviors, such as participating in liquidity mining and exiting after a few days to seek higher returns, we now have the opportunity to change this situation and maintain the long-term stability of the network Retention and Sustainability. We can gain ownership through ongoing participation rather than capital investment, and platforms such as RabbitHole, Layer3, Gitcoin, BanklessDAO, and FWB are already actively adopting this ownership distribution model.
The principle of difference The underlying concept is that inequality itself is not a bad thing. Under the premise of equal opportunities, inequality is the inevitable result of people's different personal abilities, desires to earn money, and levels of effort. However, when inequalities arise, do vulnerable groups in society also receive the attention they deserve?
Although this is a challenging proposition in the context of technological development, we can consider whether current social network feedback algorithms are spreading Content for low-income people? Does the creator fund of the platform based on the number of views and participation take care of the creative income of the less wealthy? I think the answer may be no. Top creators often have many ways to make money, and they can produce content without relying on creator funds, but for low-income creators, it may be difficult for them to continue content creation due to economic constraints.
The difference principle is critical to the democratization of Web3, as participants will join the ecosystem at different times, with background, income, technical proficiency and Access rights vary. At present, many projects are already using Crypto to improve the welfare level of low-income people. Among them, SuperHi, a for-profit creative education platform, is planning to decentralize ownership among its members and mentors, and has tested a basic income scheme with the goal of increasing access to creative careers. Projects like Proof of Humanity and ImpactMarket are building on blockchain technology to provide basic income to those in need. Meanwhile, communities like LaborDAO are leveraging building blocks to build worker power, while communities like she256, We3, and Komorebi Collective are focused on increasing diversity in the blockchain space.
In addition to projects with a mission of social good, all Web3 networks should adhere to the principle of difference to bring the greatest benefit to the disadvantaged, and this can also Maximize the attraction of new participants and further drive the network effect. As I said before, a fair network is a network that users are willing to enter at any time, with any identity, with any number of Tokens.
The arrival of Web3 presents us with a new opportunity - an opportunity to reimagine the internet and build new platforms from first principles. However, we should agree on the content and necessity of these principles in order to achieve this goal. Rawls' principles of justice give us a solid starting point we need to build a new system that is fair and takes all members into account without fully knowing where we stand.
Original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia