Original title: "On Aggregation Theory And Web3"
Original author: Joel John
Original Compilation: The Way of DeFi
In today’s article, I will look at the problem from a larger perspective, and I will pass Look at Web3 from the perspective of Aggregation Theory. This post might be a bit long, but I hope you stick with it, as we detail how blockchain investing will happen in the next decade.
In 2015, Ben Thompson first proposed the concept of Aggregation Theory to explain how the Internet facilitates the evolution of markets. Ben described Aggregation Theory about seven years ago this way:
The value chain of any given consumer market is divided into three parts: Suppliers, Distributors and consumer or user. The best way to achieve excess profits in these markets is to obtain a horizontal monopoly in one of the three segments, or to integrate two of these segments to have a competitive advantage in providing vertical solutions. In the pre-Internet era, the latter depended on controlling distribution.
The fundamental disruption of the Internet is to change this dynamic. First, the Internet enables free distribution (of digital goods), which neutralizes the advantages of pre-Internet era distributors taking advantage of integration with suppliers. Second, the Internet makes transaction costs close to zero, making it possible to integrate distributors with end users or consumers on a large scale.

Image by Ben Thompson in 2015 Article
We believe that for those working on Web3, this theory deserves a fresh look. We've seen how giants like Ramp, Stripe, and Spotify built on compression in distribution and collection prices. But how does this theory apply to Web3 companies? We believe that, in addition to compressing the cost of collecting payments, blockchain can lower the price of verification and trust. This makes it possible to create multi-billion dollar entities that have historically been impossible. New-age blockchain-based aggregators can also help drive innovation at the protocol layer and enable a new business model: Hyperfinancialization-as-a-Service. But before that, let's explain Aggregation Theory in detail for those who haven't followed Ben Thompson.
The following is an analysis of Uber through the lens of Aggregation Theory . Before Uber, seller (supplier) and buyer (demand) relationships were local and there was a limit to the number of customers a driver could have. Also, there are limited choices in who might provide rides, which is why some drivers with bad attitudes still don't get laid off. At the same time, the supply side of the market is also chaotic, such as it has a bad reputation, suffers from ineffective pricing and unpredictable prices in many cities. The emergence of Uber organized the supply side.
This is a carefully curated subset of users whose reputations are continuously verified and tracked, rather than being made up of random drivers. Think about the information you get every time you ask for a ride: you know how many rides the driver has taken, the driver's average rating, and the exact amount you can expect to pay.
Why is this shift from taxi alliances to in-app drivers happening? Because Uber controls the supply side through their app. Users who want to book a ride prefer the convenience of hailing a ride remotely, rather than waiting outside on the curb of the street, only to be turned down by a random taxi driver. This model works because the Internet has enabled Uber to build a venture from the comfort of their San Francisco office, or any new hipster location, and scale it globally.
It also enables Uber to collect payments and waive fees for itself, rather than relying on regional partners to do it for them. The rise of digital currencies has accelerated the adoption of Uber, which might not exist if we still paid for rides primarily in physical cash.
The largest companies on the Internet today can be associated with Aggregation Theory. Companies like AirBnB, Deliveroo, Spotify, Steam, Amazon, and Twitter have all upended previously chaotic markets through the power of the internet. Aggregators accumulate so much value because they organize what are often large, chaotic markets. newspaper? There are thousands of newspapers on the market expressing differing opinions, often with inaccurate sources. It was you who replaced them with news aggregators.
How about renting a house in a small town for a few months? Airbnb made it "good" to live in a stranger's home. Customers gravitate towards these aggregators as they can expect the same level of service, quality and standards that ample list of suppliers offers here. You get the security of a familiar platform and options across the market. Going back to the Airbnb example I mentioned earlier, users know they can register on the site and submit a complaint to get a refund if something goes wrong with their booking. What about Amazon? Refunds happen almost instantly.
Aggregators enable reputation and fair distribution of suppliers. When you buy something on Amazon, you can look up reviews. In exchange, they take a cut of the transactions that happen on their platforms. As a platform goes digital, the frequency of transactions tends to increase, allowing aggregators to operate at far lower costs than a brick-and-mortar experience. Why? Because delivering a digital product (like movie streaming) costs a fraction of the cost of a physical experience (like a flight).
Users can only take one flight at a time. And on the same flight, you might see multiple movies being played by one user. Or, if they're like us, they might buy countless altcoins or NFTs, and maybe they'll regret it as soon as they get off the plane. Hopefully by the end of this section you have a good idea of what aggregation platforms are and how big they are, now let's get back to Web3.
Just like the Internet compresses the cost of distribution and collection, Publicly verifiable blockchains also compress the cost of verification and trust. In fact, all the giant businesses we see in the context of Web3 are built on this principle. Blockchain enables anyone to query and verify that a digital product being sold is actually from the source it claims to be. Digital consumer goods like NFTs sold via blockchain platforms have no counterparty risk because validating smart contracts ensure you get exactly what you paid for.
What does this mean for those aggregators operating in Web3? It means that the cost of verifying and trusting suppliers when selling digital goods is a fraction of that in Web2. When Netflix or iTunes first launched, they had to spend months or years negotiating contracts to ensure they could come to market with a large enough inventory of digital goods to attract users.
Even today, Netflix spends about $16 billion producing content internally based on user data. As these aggregators scaled, they became the best place to sell digital consumer goods, and having distribution rights gave them that advantage after a decade of effort.
But some interactions are not possible in a Web2 aggregator because of the inherent friction introduced by siled databases and closed data. For example, you can't browse a property listing through Zillow, make an offer on it, and refinance the property on the same platform. You have to go to another place, like Figure, and go through their various compliance and onboarding procedures, which are unique to each platform.
It also makes it harder, and more expensive, for other application developers to easily leverage your aggregate and build new and interesting services on top of it . On-chain identity, data, and verification standards can solve this problem and make Web3 aggregators more efficient than Web2 aggregators.
In stark contrast, OpenSea doesn't spend much time worrying about licensing. They can almost instantly verify that a third-party’s NFT is from a legitimate source and track its movement through their user base. So what about Uniswap? As long as the user accurately adds the address of the coin, there is no need for people to participate in verifying that the coin being traded on it is legitimate.
The blockchain abstracts the verification layer and minimizes the resulting costs. Does trust itself generate a premium? I think so. Let's consider a few examples where platforms have commercial rights and compare with platforms that don't. Music would be a great subject, so we'll use Spotify and Soundcloud as examples.
One is the go-to platform for streaming music around the world, while the other is the occasional option for finding some live music at the gym. Arguably, Soundcloud is an incredible business because of its focus on the community and making new artists discoverable. But if you look at it purely from a revenue generation standpoint, you can see how the two businesses differ.

The two businesses operate in different ways. Spotify claims to have 406 million monthly active users, about 180 million of which are paid subscribers. Their margins are about ±25%, so you can discount the $9 billion in annual revenue you calculate in the chart below. But even with that in mind, you'll notice that Spotify's revenue is much higher than Soundcloud's.
Part of the reason for this is that Soundcloud needs volume in terms of user streaming to expand ad-driven revenue. But why should all users come to Soundcloud if they are on the premium platform? This is a phenomenon you can see across product categories.
As an independent platform, Amazon has a larger e-commerce volume than Shopify's store. Steam (the king of gaming) earns more than a single game studio. Why? What it boils down to is that the customer chooses the store with the greatest selectivity and the least friction. The greater the number of choices, the more likely commercial activity will be concentrated on one avenue, making it easier for platforms to offer more choices while keeping costs low due to the scale of operations. This is the flywheel of modern business. Max Olson did a great job of visualizing these on Twitter a while back.

Web3 is interesting because it changes the unit economics of authentication and trust. Historically, aggregators have acquired the intellectual property for the most desirable digital consumer goods. As we shall soon see, in emerging markets like India, holding streaming rights to cricket paves the way for TV networks to scale. Blockchain enables platforms to prove provenance and distribution rights from anyone on the network at a very low cost.
This means spending incurred on legal fees and time spent going through bureaucracy can now be replaced by on-chain verification, identity and verification. This principle will be key to making aggregators in Web3 so powerful. do not trust me? Let’s take a look at some aggregators in the current ecosystem and how they use blockchain to their benefit.
Zerion is a wallet interface that focuses on enabling users Ability to track their portfolios. The product currently tracks NFTs, allowing tokens to be swapped and letting users see how all the tokens in their wallets are performing. Interfaces like those offered by Zerion are quickly becoming the “home” of DeFi. They allow users to interact with complex host applications without connecting to a single website interface. Additionally, these interfaces eliminate the high risk of phishing, losing keys, and signing wrong smart contracts by allowing users to interact with them directly through their interface. They help users gain access to features like lending through curated protocols, and they also drive innovation at the protocol layer by giving customers more options to offer them competitive pricing and features. To be sure, billions of dollars worth of assets are currently managed through Zerion's interface.
How risky is Zerion? No. They do not take custody of assets and do not manage smart contracts. Instead, they are responsible for embedding each of these protocols into a product, forming a super application. According to a recent press release, they interface with about 50,000 assets across 60 protocols. Wallet-like interfaces like DeBank, Frontier, and ImTrust have been at the forefront of enabling more retail participants to find their way in the complex Web3 ecosystem.
How do they do it? They reduce the trust barrier needed for users to use an application, because end users believe that the creator of the interface has done their due diligence. Second, they enable new applications to be discovered more smoothly than through complex information networking platforms such as Twitter. Finally, and most importantly, they combine the fundraising capabilities of multiple DeFi Dapps (Decentralized Applications) in one interface. As users' needs within the industry evolved, they also started integrating on-ramps and tax software.
I am using Zerion as an example here because it is a centralized entity that acts as an interface to plug into multiple Defi DApps. However, aggregation functionality in DeFi goes beyond this, here are some examples:
Orderflow - 1inch and Matcha.xyz allow users to Trade assets to find the best prices without having to go to individual platforms. It does not keep assets for trading itself, but seeks liquidity from third-party platforms. Matcha takes this a step further by integrating an RFQ model into the product. To date, they have done about $42 billion in cumulative volume across ±900,000 orders. This feature allows centralized market makers on the backend to quote large order sizes, bringing the experience closer to what a centralized exchange like Binance can provide.
Yield - The holy grail of DeFi has historically been the ability to deliver yield. A huge risk of lending or a decentralized exchange platform is the possibility of being hacked. But what if you could build an interface for users to deploy capital in a pool without necessarily holding the assets themselves? Rari, Alpaca and Gp. The aggregator itself does not hold any NFTs listed on the platform, they use Dune to provide analysis results to users. Once you click on an NFT collection, the interface allows you to bid on the listing directly in Opensea and LooksRare. Now, this is where it gets more interesting, aggregators like Gp become where the price discovery is because users are basically discovering and tracking their portfolios and bidding through them.
In the future, they will also cover features that further blur the lines between DeFi and NFTs through lending and automated inventory management. Traditional art or physical marketplaces have some of the aforementioned constraints associated with Web2 aggregators that prevent them from providing these services with low friction and low cost. Furthermore, some other verticals like Gaming and Metaverse don't even have historical analogs - Web3 aggregators will be the first efficient marketplaces to support and enable these digital asset classes.
Over time, their influence will be enough to determine which NFT collections are "discovered", because what they accumulate is basically the market's attention . How much is this attention worth? I don't know yet, but it's worth enough to drive $400 million in transaction volume through the platform. Gp is also affecting the market share of the underlying NFT market itself. Because users have nothing to do with the market, they will buy and sell assets whenever there are favorable bids/offers. For example, LooksRare’s market share in NFT volume has risen compared to OpenSea since the launch of Gp.
We believe that the aggregation of NFT connected assets will happen on a topical basis. For example, Parcel allows individuals to bid on real estate-pegged NFTs. Likewise, there will be a separate marketplace for gaming-related NFTs. Currently, there is still a gap in the home of NFT markets related to sports, music, and movies. Partly because the thematic focus on asset types enables founders to curate communities around them, it creates an initial flywheel for enabling transactions through the platform itself.
We have discussed how Aggregation Theory in the context of Web3 can create new market. Aggregation models of Web3 connections work because they focus primarily on digital assets. One area that could be considered more “digital” than tokens and NFTs is the data marketplace.
Data marketplaces in Web3 are attractive because:
- Provides all Datasets can be queried and validated by third parties on the fly
- they are embedded directly into multiple third-party applications, so can scale exponentially
- increasing the cost of each new chain typically Tends to be lower
- delivery of product (data) is immediate
- in case of agreement, cost of maintaining network infrastructure is outsourced
You can break down this market into two categories. One is to provide end users with direct data access through graphs and queries, presenting information in a consumable form. These are centralized businesses like Nansen or Dune. Nansen has built a business by focusing on the interface, their centralized aspect involves the tags of the 100+ million wallets and the chains they index. Users don't create queries themselves, Nasen's team handles these, but once queries to extract data are crafted, they can be replicated across chains. Therefore, the unit cost of scaling to each new chain is trending down. Nasen's initial investment was in tokenization and setup queries for top holders, smart contracts or wallet interactions on each chain.
Nansen does a great job of providing users with pre-defined queries, while Dune wins by providing an infrastructure that anyone can query. Nansen has built their moat based on their extensive work around tokenizing over 100 million wallets, Dune, on the other hand, has built their moat through their extensive user base that is fighting for their spot on the leaderboard .
It is relatively easy for third-party platforms to replicate the data that Dune currently has, but it is very difficult to replicate community members without a positive incentive system. These two platforms are unique in that they can (i) sell data digitally, (ii) do so almost instantly, and (iii) have limited marginal costs in scaling the number of blockchains they support . Of course, in addition to centralized businesses, there are also protocol-based counterparts in this field.
Covalent, Graph, Pyth, and Chainlink are protocol-based alternatives to the same model. Each of them supports an entire ecosystem of DApps and responds to millions of queries on a regular basis. Protocols at the data layer are more attractive because they don't necessarily have the hardware infrastructure to make these datasets available. Instead, indexing of datasets is done in third-party infrastructure, which is incentivized through the protocol’s native token. In a traditional data enterprise, the cost of running the infrastructure can eat into a company's profitability. In the case of protocols, the perceived "value" of a network increases with each new node hosting data on those networks due to the reduced likelihood of an entire data network being brought down.
Before making the final summary, let us revisit Let’s review the core argument of this article. We believe that blockchain will enable a whole new category of markets that enable instant verification of on-chain events. This will minimize the cost of large-scale verification of intellectual property rights, thereby creating new business models. Today's Web3 aggregators provide interfaces that display on-chain data and allow users to interact with smart contracts from multiple platforms. They do not own the risk of custody of these assets and typically do not incur the exponentially high costs of supporting additional networks. Covalent and Nansen are able to generate exponential value with each new chain added (this is usually a linear payout).
In the next ten years, the core proposition of Web3 aggregation will be in streamlining large, chaotic processes with multiple parties in low-trust systems. An example where this happens is AngelList. The platform structurally simplifies the amount of friction involved in structuring venture capital rounds by combining legal, bank and LP (liquidity provider) management into a single interface. How much is it worth? According to their latest funding round, about $4 billion. Large, chaotic markets with multiple moving parts are difficult to consolidate at scale unless you have the time or capital. It took AngelList about 8 years to build its monopoly, while Uber had to raise about $25.5 billion to become the behemoth it is today. I believe blockchain will compress the unit economics around this and hyperfinancialize the process. Combining the removal of inefficiencies from a historically long and messy process with incentives that allow people to profit from it can be a powerful combination.
This is already happening in some emerging markets. In an upcoming article, we will introduce a business that executes, verifies and validates the stack required for traditional contracts in Africa. In the context of Web3, aggregation reduces the level of corruption and inefficiency. Emerging markets that have historically been rife with corruption and lack of transparency will benefit the most, think DAO (Decentralized Autonomous Organization). Today, it takes 5 minutes and $200 to form a DAO on Ethereum. In stark contrast, it took me six months and numerous phone calls to register a company in India. Part of this delay is due to a lack of trust and the ability to verify my data on the fly. Blockchain can help close this gap, we are just the makers of a trust production machine for a trust deficient society.
Disclosure: The author of this article has invested in some of the above projects.
Original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia