Original title: What can cooperatives and DAOs learn from Each other?
原文作者:Austin Robey
原文编译:Block unicorn
In 2014, a year before Ethereum launched, Trebor Scholz, an academic activist and professor at the New School in New York, coined a new term: "platform collaborationism." In a blog post, Scholz outlined a bold alternative to the extractive Web 2.0 sharing economy: a platform run as a cooperative, owned and controlled by its workers and users. The goal is to find ways to create a future in which ride-hailing apps will be owned by drivers, grocery delivery platforms by individual shoppers, and websites like Patreon (art creators) will be owned by creators.
Since 2014, platform cooperatism has become a growing global tech subculture. At conferences in New York, Hong Kong and Berlin, aspiring community organizers and social entrepreneurs come together every year to support each other, swap stories and empathize with the difficulties of finding funding.
A few years ago, I started a digital co-op called Ampled, an alternative to musician Patreon owned by artists and workers. Recently, I've also participated in several DAOs, including Forefront, Seed Club, and Friends With Benefits. Having one foot in the platformist movement and the other in the DAO space has been enlightening, and I've come to believe that both fields yield valuable new tools when it comes to human organization, collective ownership, and cultural production. While sometimes these innovations seem to be happening in parallel and in isolation, I believe the two communities can learn a lot from each other -- and even open the door to meaningful hybrid approaches between the two.

Cooperatives or "co-operatives" are businesses whose ownership is shared by workers, customers, or both, and which operate on a one-member, one-vote basis. Although this ownership structure forms the basis of the cooperative model, its applications and cultures are diverse. There are agricultural cooperatives, just as there are digital cooperation technology platforms. This article will focus on workers and platform cooperatives, but other examples include:
· Consumer cooperatives
· Purchasing Cooperatives
· Multi-stakeholder cooperatives
· Housing cooperatives
· Marketing cooperatives
· Producer cooperatives
The DAO, a blockchain-based Token coordinated Internet native organization, also takes many forms. These include:
· Protocol/platform DAO
· Creator DAO
DAO DE service
Design the DAO,
The DAO, investment
The social DAO,
Although both cooperatives and DAOS are collectively owned and jointly determined forms of organization, there are some key differences. Above all, cooperative executes one member one vote management. That means people vote, not dollars. No one member of the cooperative can buy more electricity than anyone else.
While DAOs can simulate cooperative governance, the more common is the one-coin-one-vote governance model that is easier to implement, as verifying a person's identity is still an emerging field in the blockchain world.

Differences aside, the DAO and platform co-ops are increasingly in the same ideological space. Both forms seek to expand collective ownership and governance of digital infrastructure. Both have a culture that prioritizes collective control and the creation of shared goods.
Based on my experience in both areas, I have noticed that DAOs tend to be better at achieving large-scale collective ownership, even if they have a relatively underdeveloped cultural understanding of the rights, responsibilities, and accountability associated with ownership. While co-operatives tend to be less successful in securing funding, they are also more likely to get the root causes of inequality right through a sober rejection of capitalist realism. Below, I'll share some of the points I've gleaned about how DAOs and co-ops can learn from each other.

A large number of contributors in 2021
People in the DAO world mistakenly think of the collective work and organization model as a technology-related invention. In fact, communities have practiced mutual assistance and democratic ownership in almost every corner of the world throughout history.
In the United States, the tradition of cooperation has a history of neglect, with marginalized groups forced to build solidarity networks in order to survive and be self-sufficient. In her book, Collective courage: The history of African American cooperative economic thought and practice. Jessica Gordon-Nembhard, a professor at John Jay College, Outlines examples of economic coordination involving free and enslaved African Americans hundreds of years ago, This includes pooling funds to buy freedom for individuals and building conscious communities and mutual-aid societies. The underground railroad itself was a network of solidarity. These forms of cooperation predate the Rochdale Society of Equitable Pioneers, a British consumer co-operative founded in 1844 to expand access to quality food and supplies for skilled workers forced out of work by mechanization, and are widely regarded as the fundamental movement of modern co-operatives.
During the Great Depression, Americans pioneered alternative networks of barter and value exchange, such as the Oakland Unemployment Exchange Association. Most of rural America is powered by electric cooperatives because existing utilities consider certain areas too unprofitable. The US also has a rich history of communities and local currencies, including the Ithaca Hour (the local currency formerly used in Ithaca, New York) and BerkShares (a local currency circulated in the Berkshire area of Massachusetts).
Daos can learn a lot from these historical examples, especially with regard to non-hierarchical work patterns and collective decision-making. Studying failed co-operatives is also instructive to avoid mistakes. However, I believe that studying past co-operatives and solidarity networks is particularly illuminating for the DAO in three areas: bringing people together to fight for racial and economic justice, fostering a strong sense of shared ownership, and building communities based on shared principles.
Cooperatives often emerge as an attempt to deal with market failures and exploitative economic systems. They are designed to bring benefits to their members: good jobs, dignity and collective agency. Because cooperatives are motivated by the needs of their members rather than profit, they are often guided by racial and economic justice missions. There is no specific structural mechanism that can make cooperatives pay more attention to social justice than DAO; It's more a matter of building motivation.
In crypto, by contrast, some of the most famous examples of collective economic organizations have formed memes or served as exercises in commodification and speculation. Examples such as PleasrDAO's segmentation of Doge memes, or ConstitutionDAO's raising of more than $40m to buy copies of the US Constitution, are valuable because they offer a template for a new model of global economic co-ordination. So far, however, few of these DAo-funded pools seem to coalesced around goals that involve helping underserved individuals and communities meet their basic needs.
There have been some encouraging conversations around the impact of decentralized organization, which could be a useful framework for allocating resources for long-term social impact outcomes. Despite the growing number of mutual and mission-driven DAOs (including the PleaserDAO's Free Ross DAO), these projects have not generated the same amount of collective excitement, support, or resources. But for those who want to make a difference with Web3, the stories of co-ops like the Jackson co-op and the 40 Acre co-op reflect those values in coming together to pursue common goals and build organizations.

Cryptonetworks and DAOs often use the concept of "ownership economy," a concept first developed by venture capitalist Jesse Walden as a guiding philosophical infrastructure.
「所有权经济并不总是意味着 Token 、股票期权或股权的字面分配,」瓦尔登在一篇概述这一想法的帖子中写道。「相反,这意味着所有权——可能表现为新的经济奖励、平台治理或新形式的社会资本——可以成为用户体验的新基石,有大量的设计空间可供探索。」
By defining ownership so broadly, this argument risks diluting the concept of ownership to mean only "exposure to upside risk" or "a sense of ownership". As Cory Rosen, director of the National Center for Employee Ownership, puts it, "Ownership is like dinner." But the concept of an "ownership economy" ignores some key principles of real ownership, such as giving members transparency over investments and agreements, a say in hiring and other important decisions, and the ability to hold leadership accountable.
In this regard, cooperatives have a long professional track record and a proven toolbox to build strong shared ownership through legal means: bylaws, operating agreements and ownership of intellectual property, in addition to clearly defined rights, responsibilities and scope of liability.
As the DAO continues to develop new forms of collective governance, from the East Bay Permanent Real Estate Co-op's charter to Stocksy's (platform collaboration for freelance artists) proposal flow charts to enlarged decision matrices, it's useful to look to smaller or older collaboration models as inspiration.
Co-operatives also have something in common: they tend to unite around a common set of principles. The Rochdale Principles are a set of collaborative ideas developed by the Rochdale Equity Pioneers Association. Nearly two centuries later, cooperatives around the world are still based on them.
The first three principles outline how cooperatives should operate:
1. Open membership voluntarily
2. Control by democratic members
3. Economic participation of members
The other four principles outline common virtues and values:
1. Autonomy and independence
2. Education, training and information
3. Cooperation among cooperatives
4. Care about your community
Not all DAOs are interested in adopting a shared set of principles. But for those of us who are motivated by collaboration, influence and joining forces around common social or technological goals, it is important to ask ourselves the right questions: what are our shared values? Do we want to prioritize transparency, participation and collaboration like the open source movement? If we do enough introspection, we may find that we share many principles with the cooperative movement, including principle 6: DAOs should seek to collaborate with other DAOs.
As new entrants flood the Web3 ecosystem to form DAOs, it may be useful to develop a set of general principles that can guide us in building Web3 -- values that can help us avoid recreating the dark model of Web2 that could form the basis for collaboration among like-minded DAOs. DWeb principles are a set of values that emphasize human nature and distribute benefits in "autonomous organization". Although it is not comprehensive when applied to workers' organization, it is a good inspiration. Combining the DWeb principles with the Rochdale principles might be a good place to start.
In April 2021, Mirror founder Denis Nazarov floated the idea of a tool called PartyBid on Twitter that would enable a group of people to bid and buy NFT. Shortly thereafter, PartyDAO got together, raised $100,000, and then quickly built and delivered an impressive product that allowed collective bidding and decentralized ownership. In just a few months, the distributed team created a collectively owned platform that has since resulted in multimillion-dollar bids.
Because DAOs are blockchain-based organizations that are not typically tied to business entities, they leave a lot of room for rapid experimentation in organizational and incentive design. Members can come up with an idea together, pool jointly managed resources into a common goal, iterate and release quickly.
By contrast, co-operatives typically spend a lot of time arguing with lawyers over their charter and registration process, making them harder to set up than traditional companies. Rather than being slowed down by the complex formalized processes of traditional cooperatives, it is better to examine DAOs like PartyDAO that can deliver products quickly and scale impact -- providing an initial proof of concept on which to build as an organization.

The image of the distribution of Helium network nodes is displayed
使用 Token 引导网络
Cooperatives have long faced financial difficulties. Because they are for-profit organizations in nature, it is difficult to qualify for grants. And because they revolve around group ownership and democratic collective control, they are functionally ineligible for traditional equity-based venture capital, which requires the sale of a majority of ownership to investors.
除了作为协调和投票的强大工具之外, Token 还可以让合作社在现金不足的情况下更轻松地进行引导。Helium 是一种用于「LongFi」无线互联网基础设施的分布式网络,就是一个例子。为了为网络供电,全球各地的人们在家中和办公室设置路由器作为网络中的节点。节点用 $HNT 补偿,这是一种代表治理能力并持有价值的原生 Helium Token 。如果没有这个 Token 和聪明的经济激励措施,很难想象如此规模的去中心化网络如何形成。
Token 化社区的成员也可以从他们的贡献中获得有形的东西。可以对 Token 进行编码,以便在有收入流时自动接收赞助红利。这使合作成员或贡献者能够获取他们创造的价值,这与离线团结网络使用的时间银行(时间银行是一种服务以物易物系统,人们用服务换取基于劳动时间的信用,而不是金钱)系统不同。
如果合作社维护公共或共享商品,则将 Token 分发给该商品的早期采用者可以被视为一种忠诚度奖励:根据过去的消费或支持,在项目中授予人们自动成员资格、投票权或所有权。
一个例子是 Ethereum Name Service (ENS) 最近的 Token 空投,这是一种公共实用程序,允许您注册与您的 Ethereum 地址相关联的以「.eth」结尾的 Web3 用户名。这使人们更容易发送和接收以太坊,而无需记住长长的公钥。
ENS 已经开发了 4 年多,最初由一小部分人控制。但他们希望将控制和管理分散到他们的社区,因此他们评估了之前注册 .eth 域的用户,并提出了一种算法,将 ENS 供应的 25% 公平分配给这些用户。在最初的分配之后,用户最终比核心贡献者拥有更多的控制权和权力,他们总共获得了 18.96% 的 Token 供应。
虽然合作社可能希望坚持使用一人一票的决策模式,但 Token 空投可以成为在松散和大型网络中分配奖励并吸引更多决策成员加入组织的一种方式。
For those who have long advocated quitting the community, or as a way for startups to transfer ownership to employees and stakeholders as an alternative to an IPO or acquisition, the DAO airdrop can be a powerful tool to distribute control of the community.
Not surprisingly, many organizations are experimenting with the CONCEPT of DAO in conjunction with the collaboration model. DisCo (Distributed Co-op) is a framework that uses feminist economics to reorient our ideas about how DAOs can function more like traditional co-ops. Some other examples:
· ETHDenver,一个最近推出 Token 的会议和法律合作社。
· Opolis,一个数字就业合作社,推出了 DAO 和自己的 WORK Token 。
· Common Lands, a "decentralized autonomous housing co-op" that aims to help one million families become first-time home buyers through community-owned, affordable co-op housing.
· SongADAO, a DAO formed around musician Jonathan Mann's daily song releases, recently merged into a legal cooperative
归根结底,组织的最佳框架可能不是在合作模式或 DAO 模型之间进行选择,而是两者的结合。将合作价值纳入加密网络可以采取传统合作的形式,通过链上 Token 化贡献来引导其网络,或者 DAO 可以决定在某些情况下采用合作一票治理。
By learning from the past and looking to the future, we can create communities that embody the best of both worlds: effective, principled, and well-resourced organizations committed to building a more equitable, democratic, and collectively owned future.
The original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia