header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Web3: overcoming the social trap of Web2

Read this article in 4 Minutes
Take you through the SINS of Web2

Facebook's rebranding of its parent company to Meta may be the most "exciting" news of the week.


The Meta name means to most people that Facebook, led by Zuckerberg, is making a big push into the Metaverse, However, many have also joked that Meta might mean Manipulate Everyone Through Ads.


Facebook, as we all know, makes money in two words: advertising and nothing else. And since the ultimate goal of corporations is to maximize shareholder value, manipulating Everyone Through Ads isn't that hard to understand the irony of manipulating Everyone Through Ads by using more immersive Ads in the meta-universe to more deeply influence consumer behavior, for example.


Today's centralized companies have collected all kinds of privacy information and browsing habits of users. When companies iterate their products into the meta-universe, the data generated by users will increase exponentially, and users will really become playthings for companies to profit from at will.


This article from Status, a Web3.0 tool provider, looks at some of the SINS companies have committed in the Web2.0 era. BlockBeats translated the full text:


在 Facebook、Instagram、WhatsApp、Google+、Twitter、SnapChat、LinkedIn、Clubhouse 平台上面,数以亿计用户的登录信息、消息、身份、履历、个人介绍、电话号码、屏幕截图、GPS 数据、音频记录、以及由人工智能判断出的权威派别、性取向、对广告的敏感度等各种信息,都正被转卖出去。


You must have noticedFacebook is preparing to charge users.WhatsApp changes its privacy policy(Users will not be able to use the software if they do not agree),Clubhouse is hoarding data.Reddit is also going crazy with censorship。


Web2 时代的大实验即将结束。我们已经掌握了所有需要的数据,Web2 公司也掌握了所有他们能得到的个人数据。我们从中能看到什么?——


-中心化的公司并不会将用户的利益最大化。

-用户只不过是产品罢了。

-你的隐私权早就被剥夺了。

-你的言论会遭到平台审查。

-你的数据并不安全。

-权威控制着你的数据和言论。

-「被众人爱戴的开源化」并不是真的源码的。

-中心化阻碍了民主化进程。


我们还能做得更好,而且也是时候给 Web2 画上一个句号了。


中心化 Web2 公司的动机与用户产生了冲突,大规模的隐私数据因此遭到泄漏。与此同时,这让权威干涉的影响更为严重,数据安全难以保障,各项服务也不能自主运作。


你们的利益激励并不相同


中心化的公司以盈利为目标这件事本身并没有太大问题,但他们在盈利的同时并没有照顾到用户体验,这才是问题所在。


用户当然都追求更好的用户体验,而中心化的公司当然也想赚到钱。有时这两个愿景可以兼得:公司通过提供良好的用户体验来增加其用户基数。但有些时候,二者却不可能兼容:Facebook 就会用你的个人数据来挣钱,通过牺牲用户体验的方式从用户身上谋取更高的利润。


更宽泛地说,中心化公司需要实现的是股东利润最大化,而不是用户体验的最大化,如果这两者产生了冲突的话,那公司一定会优先保证利润。


Centralized companies are desperate to get their hands on your personal data because, once it falls into their hands and you unwittingly cooperate, they can make money from it. Not only that, but they can make more of your money in the process because they can use it to sell you products and even get you to vote,As Cambridge Analytica confirmed。


DeFi 之所以能取得成功,部分原因就在于其去中心化组织和协议的激励结构:它们被打造成公共产品,各项服务盈利模式及过程清晰透明,并且不会窃取用户数据进行出售。


These services are so successful precisely because the motivations of their creators and users are the same, and theirCreators are users themselves,二者之间没有绝对界限。


Web3 社交网络必将胜过 Web2,因为它不会再为了最大化利益而去牺牲用户体验,也不再会泄漏用户的个人隐私。


权威会说,「安全与隐私,你会选择哪个?」


The public (or not-so-public) authorities often say: For your personal safety, you can't have any privacy. Encrypted communication? That's what lawbreakers use. After all, if you don't have any skeletons in your closet,So there's nothing to worry about。


权威的干涉让想保护用户隐私的公司都难以独善其身。2020 年 11 月,德国法院下令让以隐私保护著称的电子邮件服务平台 Tutanota 监控一个账户,并勒令其上交该账户所有发出和接收到的明文邮件。


Reddit was also ordered to monitor an account in real time over several years (2016-2017, 2019-2020) and report on itCommunication metadata for the account. Reddit, Google and Facebook all have internal guidelines on how to efficiently file search warrants and subpoenas. Ancestry.com and 23andme.com can even do this without you ever using themMaking inferences about your DNA。


使用中心化 Web2 服务就等于你同意把你的个人信息交予权威了,因为只要权威或相关 Web2 企业认为你犯了某些错误,就会立刻调走你的隐私数据。而一旦你的数据被收走了,你就再也无法拿回来了,就算最后他们发现你被错怪了,也已经无济于事了。如果你运气够好,权威可能会把你的隐私数据还给你,但在此之前早就有人看了这些数据,进而了解了你的行为方式、消费习惯以及浏览记录,这已然覆水难收了。


IndiaauthorityIs forcingFacebook, WhatsApp and Twitter help censor all the messages they want and record metadata that can identify users Posting such messages. Not only that, Reddit has also been censoring on behalf of individuals and multiple authoritiesA long time。所以说,只要中心化还存在,强制审查就永远不会结束。


用户安全并没有得到保障


Equifax has had problems with its security systemsThat gives hackers an opening,超过 1.63 亿人因此丢失了隐私数据。他们的姓名、生日、地址、社保号码和银行卡号均被盗取,当年全美有一半以上的成年人的隐私数据都泄漏了出去。


自 2013 年以来,Facebook 至少已经发生了 5 起数据泄露事件。泄露的内容包括密码(因密码在 2019 年还是以明文形式储存的)、电话号码、姓名以及生日。2019 年的那次泄漏事件甚至波及了 5.4 亿个账户,Facebook 解释说泄漏的都是「旧数据」,不会就本次事件向用户提出任何建议。


Yahoo said it had encountered an incidentThe biggest data breach in historya:30 亿用户的姓名、生日、电子邮箱、电话号码、密保问题答案和密码哈希均遭泄露。


A centralized financial company, First American Corporation, had885 million lost交易记录、社保号码、账户记录等数据。


Marriott International, was leaked in a multi-year data breachMore than 300 million guests的姓名、电子邮件、电话号码、护照号码和旅游记录。


民主还是战胜不了权威


In 2018, more than 3,100 Google employees demanded that the company stop serving the DEFENSE Department's ARTIFICIAL intelligence computer vision program, insisting that Google should not be "aiding the development of war technology."Google compromised,没有续签该项目的合同。


However, the efforts of peaceful Googlers were soon in vain, and within two years Google had reached an agreement with the Department of DefenseAnother project agreement。这件事比其他讲述公司决策与员工意愿相冲突的故事都更加广为流传,也引发了不小的关注。如果你曾经有过这样的经历,你明明发现你的老板或经理做错了事,但他却拒绝接受任何建议,你应该就能理解目前中心化所面临的困境了。


Web3 会是什么样子


在 Web3 中,我们人人都是架构师,都能参与 Web3 的建设,而且至少目前来看,它发展得非常不错。虽然如此,我们也应该谨慎行事,以免和中心化犯同样的错误。智能合约和区块链为我们提供了一个良好基础,但依然远远不够,我们还需要一个强大的社区来建立端到端的加密通信,用非托管的钱包和工具来防止 Crypto 领域出现中心化,并用抗审查协议来抵制权威。总之,我们要不断建立健全的 Web3 相关基础设施。


Decentralized platforms don't treat you like a product, they provide you with better services and are more secure. Not only that, but these platforms are not susceptible to authority interference. RightSystemic failure的抵抗力也更强,更能维护自主性、个人隐私以及言论自由。


Web3 social reduces the burden of trust to participate in a social network where you no longer have to disclose your private data in order to use the web. Which means that youThere's no need再去相信中心化的权威机构了。


DeSo (or W3So), IPFS, DAO, DeX's, DeFi: many of the future Web3 tools are nowIt's ready to use,它们能保护你的数据、捍卫你的隐私,并为自由而战。


The original link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit