Original title: "Three Difficulties in DeFi Off-Chain Governance From the Uniswap Discord Community"
Original Author: Toby Shorin, Joanna Pope, Laura Lotti, Aaron Z.Lewis, Maria Gomez
Original compilation: Hu Tao, Bran
Cryptography enables the creation of decentralized communities of contributors Owned and developed applications are possible. Anyone, anywhere in the world can access and participate in these open, borderless, and censorship-free applications without the need for permission from a centralized authority.
By contributing resources (such as computing power or storage space) to the network, participants can earn tokens that give ownership of the network itself as award. A subset of these tokens also empower community members - often being able to use wallets on issues such as protocol design and protocol treasury fund disbursements Vote. These governance tokens are often distributed directly to early contributors and adopters.
As the space evolves, many crypto communities have highlighted the importance and promise of on-chain governance. All decisions are formally voted on, with community members expressing their preferences using tokens. “Off-chain governance” usually refers to a voting process that does not trigger on-chain protocol changes, such as “signal voting” span> or other forms of deliberation.
With all the attention focused on formal voting mechanisms, there is no interest in informal meeting places where discussions and decisions The design is given enough attention. But these cultural hubs are where on-chain proposals and other meaningful contributions take root.
We believe that the social structure and organizational psychology of the crypto community space deserves as much attention as the formal voting system. Arranging conversation infrastructure for discussions (i.e. Discord channels, forum organizations, group chat interfaces, etc.) is critical to the development of thriving virtual communities.
Discord servers have become the de facto place where people can learn about protocols, meet community members, and discover ways to get involved in the network. Ideally, in Discord chats and forum debates, ideas for proposals are generated and developed through dialogue, sometimes resulting in healthy disagreements. Informal communication through these channels is key to increasing participation and participation in the crypto community.
In addition, they help to engage and identify key stakeholders and Contributors - for example, because there are not enough tokens to meaningfully influence the voting process. Therefore, decentralized protocols should create the space and conditions for generative informal communication within the formal governance process.
Uniswap community is currently the largest on-chain governance protocol One of the communities. While it's not the first crypto community to adopt this process, the scale of its initiative is vast. With over $4 billion in funds and $782 million in 24-hour volume, the community around Uniswap is experimenting with decentralized decision-making on a very large scale.
The Uniswap protocol is a decentralized encrypted currency exchange, which allows users to exchange one cryptocurrency for another, while No third-party intermediary is required. For the first few years, the core team focused primarily on building core functionality and increasing usage of its platform.
But in the last year, Uniswap Labs (the core developer of the protocol) created a native cryptocurrency called UNI, And distributed about $500 million to all users who executed trades or provided liquidity before last September. " Shared community ownership, development of a vibrant, diverse and dedicated governance system that will actively steer the protocol towards the future and self-sustainability. "
Uniswap Labs and the Uniswap community want the protocol and funds to be governed by the people who use it. This formal governance system has two distinct components: on-chain voting on protocol parameters, and on-chain voting on the allocation of treasury funds. But there are also more informal parts to the governance process.
Uniswap has a Discord channel where users and stakeholders come together for chat and support, and a Discourse forum for Longer discussions on proposals. These platforms play an important role in Uniswap’s off-chain governance — that is, the social processes and rules that precede on-chain decisions like fund allocation.
Our research was guided by the following question: What are the barriers to increasing user engagement? How can the process of turning informal ideas into official governance recommendations be improved? What is it like to have a vault managed by a large number of users spread across multiple platforms? How does collective decision-making work when each communication interface enforces its own unique norms and culture? Our research with the Uniswap community provides a starting point for answering these questions.
In the following sections we analyze these core contradictions, make short-term recommendations and outline areas for further research, It also explores how the Uniswap team and community have leveraged Discord's capabilities to improve their community-oriented governance process.
Teams, community managers and Crypto politicians will be interested in this report.
1) Ordinary User - the type of user who does not have an explicit Discord role label or a self-clarifying relationship with Uniswap.
2) Developers - Developers integrating Uniswap into their applications. Conversation topics and requests from these parties can be broken down into several categories:Subgraph query help, reliability issues, Uniswap interface support requests, and V3 overall explanations.
3) Traders and LPs - Traders and LPs identify themselves through the questions they ask and answer in the relevant channels identity of.
4) Debaters - Debaters are most active in the #governance and #feedback channels. Debaters are members who have filed complaints about Uniswap management or governance activities, and they use Discord as a public forum to air their grievances. Complaints are often directed at Uniswap Labs, key token holders, and moderators who are seen to represent Uniswap as a whole.
5) Moderators - There are several different types of moderators, with several different Discord roles:“Friends of Uniswap”, “Tpp Mod”, “Admin” and ”Serv.Eth”There is no clear or public division of responsibilities between these roles. p>
6) Serv.Eth - The Serv.Eth team is employed by service businesses through the Uniswap grant program and Several other agreements signed up to manage support requests via Discord.
7) Penguin Party——Penguin Party is a group of open source Developers and UNI token holders who coordinatevoting as a group in Uniswap governance.
The Uniswap Discord helps users get answers to technical questions, but the sheer amount of support content prevents it from being a thriving community gathering space.
In interviews, the Uniswap Labs and review team stated that they want Discord to be a community dialogue and share ideas for the future of Uniswap and participate in governance. However, this aspiration is not fulfilled by the current Discord approach to organization and governance, which largely treats users ascustomers.
< /p>
Discord is a place for casual discussions and for people to “feel ” a part of something (e.g. sports, culture). There should be a place for people to “ sit around a table and yell at each other ”. “Problem Solving ” is an important part of this. It's hard to find more thoughtful, high-quality posts without a space that's more 「lively, bar or table space」. People should think out loud!
There was a cultural dialogue in the first year with longer topics and ideas for debate, but after DeFi in the summer of 2020, It was all suppressed and never recovered.
Support requests constitute by far the largest category of activity on the Uniswap Discord. Serving as a support line, Discord helps community members with basic questions about features, scams, and using the Uniswap app answered. In this way, Discord users are seen as customers entitled to timely answers to their questions and concerns — and thus, they may start to see themselves that way, too.
There are 6 support-specific channels dedicated to various support topics, but support requests extend to most other channels as well .
In response to a large number of support requests, Serv.Eth and the moderator team have integrated a semi-automated ticketing system, ticketbot.net. When a support request is made, the moderator issues a keyword command to /tag in the bot, which then prompts the user to open a dedicated support channel via Ticketbot. These "ticketbot" create a private support channel that is visible to moderators.
< span>The team said: "The amount of support has outstripped every other culture going on out there. It's like an invasive weed! It's almost impossible for any real discussion to happen because every channel Both are flooded with support chat spam and support teams have to fight spam and scammers. Support messages flow into every channel. It becomes a bad feedback loop. It stops people from coming for other reasons.< span>”
Uniswap Discord has a review and support staff of 7-10 people. Most of these moderators are from existing Discord users, and have started to initiate support campaigns on their own before formally assuming mod roles. In addition to this self-selected user group, Discord is served by a second set of moderators from Serv.Eth, a business that manages tech support as a service across different Discord servers.
3 months after the launch of Discord, Boris (BOR4) was the main community leader and before being hired by Uniswap Labs, he Is a passionate and active contributor. His job is to help with the high volume of support requests. The Serv.Eth team joined around the same time.
Recently, the group gathered a group called 「The Stable」 span> Subcommittee. The committee received a $114,000 grant from the Uniswap Grants Program to reward these community members for their positive contributions. With this move, BOR4 was funded to devote his full time to Discord management. Other moderators and assistants funded through The Stable program include roles involved in development support, non-English community support, interface translation, spam bot prevention, and scam monitoring.
The Stable review team does not have any formally defined metrics or KPIs, and instead manages support as they see fit. When asked what their own success criteria were, team members reiterated that the core team wanted a space for ideas and discussions, but also emphasized the need to keep support functionality in Discord.
Most moderation teams seem to be happy with Discord's existing structure and usage. We think this is because mod teams are encouraged to engage with the community in the way they used to prefer, albeit now for a fee.
This extends to current community leader responsibilities that involve improving and continuing existing support-focused activities. In terms of formal role expectations, community leaders and stable members have no responsibility nor ability to change Discord in any way.
The review team took for granted the separation of the governance forum and Discord. Let's say people wantmore informal conversations in Discord and structured discussions in the Discourse forum. On the other hand, the review team expressed a strong opinion that support should not be separated from the community.
All of the Uniswap Labs team members we interviewed expressed a desire to transition from heavily support-oriented usage of the Discord server to a place where people can experience belonging sense of space. There are several steps that can be taken to achieve this goal, but each has its own complexities, some typical of community governance challenges and some unique to Uniswap's unique situation.
A practical first step is to migrate support activities to other platforms. This appears to be already underway, with a dedicated help site (help.uniswap.org) recently being set up.
However, removing the ticketing system and high-touch personal support from Discord may be seen as a reduced user experience for existing users.
For the mods we talked about, the purpose of the Uniswap Discord community is so closely tied to answering questions and providing support to members that Support is considered a form of community management itself. The decision to migrate support functionality away from Discord needs to take into account the desire, experience, and beliefs of current modders that they may be more invested in preventing this change from happening.
This question points us to one final potential obstacle: There is currently no decision-making process regarding communications and community infrastructure. Are governance mechanisms possible, necessary, or desirable to inform decisions around Uniswap's own communication and community infrastructure?
Despite the various choices the Uniswap Labs team has made to shape the history of the Uniswap online community, no member of the core team currently takes full responsibility Its long-term community management strategy.
These challenges illustrate a larger problem: the pressure on Uniswap Labs to deliver a coherent and competitive The fundamental contradiction between the desire to create a thriving community culture.
Uniswap’s protocol and products built on top of it are widely used in the crypto space, driving The need for high-quality user experience.
But the desire to see community members as end users versus seeing them as stakeholders, discussion participants, or governance leaders Conflict. This conflict is visible in Discord, where support crowds out other conversations, but also in the fragmentation of stakeholder types across different platforms.
Governance is seen as a process that should engage all participants in discussions, but the structure and process of governance are disjointed , which cannot be accessed by normal users.
< /p>
Discord should be an accessible place for Uniswap token holders to discuss governance, regardless of how many tokens they own, ultimately driving more proposal activity.
There is now a Discord community Talk to each other a lot, but we want it to be more of a place for UNI token holders to discuss governance decisions.
Many governance discussions are dominated by those who own tokens and control votes leading. We don't want to cater just to those people, we want to cater to people who have 50 or 100 UNI.
Uniswap Labs team members initially wanted Discord to link informal conversations with formal governance procedures. However, the Uniswap ecosystem is fragmented, with governance decisions happening across a variety of public and private channels and platforms.
This situation is arguably more favorable to UNI whales than smaller token holders - there is no reason for whales and VCs to be in Present yourself in Discord and engage with the smaller community of token holders, as they do not need to vote to achieve their governance goals. But the lack of effective connection procedures between these platforms also prevents the community from self-empowerment and participation in governance.
Discord is highly disconnected from the Uniswap protocol and other areas of the community.
Uniswap is an ecosystem with multiple moving parts, each with different dynamics. Its other three main infrastructure components are the Discourse Governance Forum, the UniswapLabs Slack, and the Uniswap Grants Program Slack. But in reality, Discord is largely disconnected from all of these areas.
1) Uniswap Governance Forum
Discussions on proposals and governance take place primarily in the dedicated Discourse forum at gov.uniswap.org. The Discourse forum was created after the UNI airdrop to facilitate financial management and fee switching.
The Discourse Forum describes 3 key phases of the Uniswap governance process: Temperature Checks, Consensus Checks, Governance Proposals. The first two stages are off-chain votes designed to gauge interest and feedback on specific proposals. The final stage is on-chain voting, which may lead to changes in Uniswap protocol parameters (such as fee conversions that have not yet occurred) or decisions that affect the decentralization of funds (such as funding for DeFi education funds).
In addition to the formal voting structure, the Uniswap forum encourages “soft governance” - Discussions that inform the direction and implementation process of policy, but that are not themselves consistent with policy requirements.
This forum attempts to present itself by presenting itself as a "public park" and 「share community resources」 to create an environment of mutual respect. However, it's surprisingly quiet. It is primarily used for proposal discussions and feedback (especially temperature checks), and for proxying.
2) Core Team and Uniswap Labs Slack
The Uniswap Labs core team maintains a closed Slack for internal coordination and is not active on Discord. This is fine in itself, but represents how protocol updates are shared (or not shared) with the wider ecosystem. The core protocol roadmap is not overseen by community governance, and updates are designed, built, and released without community input. From time to time, upcoming features and other internal updates are shared with the Discord moderator team when relevant, but not with Discord users prior to the official announcement.
3) Uniswap Grant Program and UGP Slack
The Uniswap grants program is funded by the UNI treasury via on-chain voting and has been active for about six months. Grantees are invited to a dedicated UGP Slack channel where they can interact with Uniswap Labs members and fellow grantees.
According to grant manager Ken Ng's focus on developer adoption, the given reasons for this closer connection between teams are many Funding involves building integration or engineering documentation.
Membership to UGP Slack allows recipients to gain access to influential community members and key token holders by participating in this chat There are, and governance discussions often take place privately here.
A channel called #governance in Discord hosts small talk about how Uniswap could or should evolve. Much of the activity here consists of questions about how the governance process works, as well as complaints about poor decisions made by the core team or whales and representatives.
While disagreements are normal and expected in open forums like Discord, leading to Conversations for posts are rare. Discussions on Discord are reactive, following governance recommendations and decisions rather than leading them.
From our research it appears that UNI whales and key reps are not active participants in the channel. Most Discord users do not have the 2.5 million UNI required to submit proposals. The #governance channel is not seen as a place to gain community support for proposals, nor is it a place for smaller token holders to attract delegate attention. As such, there was never a conversation on the #governance channel in Discord that started and passed the temperature check phase of the governance proposal.
Community calls in the Uniswap Discord are currently held every two weeks. They bring interested members together to learn about Uniswap-related projects, tools, startups, and discuss ongoing issues and debates in Discord and other Uniswap community channels. These topics may be related to governance, but are usually more technical.
A number of channels have been created in Discord for active and past on-chain proposals. These only correspond to final on-chain votes and are not created for the temperature check and consensus check phases of the process. It's unclear how the policy was created, but it turned out to passively, if unintentionally, stymie discussion of new proposals.
Discord can serve as an onboarding platform for how to post on a forum, or provide a breakout channel for faster discussion of ongoing topics React. A dedicated channel with forum usage FAQs and a channel where people update on interesting forum topics are two possibilities.
In each case, the desired outcomes and design formats need to be specifically defined to support them. For example, regular voice calls on workshop proposals can be helpful if more governance proposals from small token holders are needed.
These interventions stem from a key insight: In ecosystems and communities that form around truly decentralized protocols, transparency is less Discoverability and accessibility matter. Inevitably, different stakeholders will have private conversations, and not everyone has the same knowledge.
However, it is unacceptable to passively withhold key information and availability from participants about how to participate. For decentralization to be successful, channels and opportunities to foster participation and share knowledge must be created, facilitated and actively maintained. Withoutthis, individual groups are more likely to have full awareness and power.
Uniswap Labs has always advocated in the agreement, “fully decentralized” and community-controlled approaches to funding and governance. Autonomy here does not mean “leaderless”, it means that the organization or system can be autonomous. Therefore, individuals at Uniswap Labs refuse to participate too much in the governance process.
The result of this approach, however, is a reluctance to foster the type of community that can guide protocols without oversight and guidance. Not many leaders emerged in the community, and the overall quality of governance proposals was low. Discord and other off-chain social spaces need to be more intentionally designed if the goal is for governance decisions to originate from the community itself.
The Discord community has no specific strategy or vision, nor does it have a process or role in place to develop community autonomy. Despite high expectations for community self-organization, the hands-off approach meant that the community did not provide opportunities and avenues for greater responsibility. We'll examine two examples of Discord campaigns that missed opportunities to strengthen community action: community calls and developer chat channels.
p>
Using Discord's platform capabilities, community conference calls offer speaking privileges for 5-10 members who actively participate as moderators. They could be moderators, Penguin Party members, and highly active Discord users without formal roles. Boris serves as the main moderator and moderator, and coordinates the community calls. 50-150 community members participate in the conference call as an audience. The call was voice-only and was recorded as a screencast, which is publicly available on The Stable's YouTube channel.
The speakers begin the call by presenting their projects. Boris selects and invites projects to speak, and he also asks interview-style questions of the speakers. Individuals can also contact Boris and ask to showcase their work in a community call, as was the case with DeFi Education Fund's Larry Sukernik joining a recent call after they decided to immediately liquidate half of the 1 million UNI they received from the Ministry of Finance , received a largely critical response on Discord, forums, and Twitter.
Speakers may be members of the Discord community, or may be invited to join the server to share their work in the community call. These demos take up about 20-30 minutes of airtime and are promotional in nature, mostly technical in terms of explaining items and asking questions, assuming a relatively high level of background knowledge from the audience.
Other presenters on stage may also make additional comments to Boris' questions or ask their own Questions are sent through the dedicated Community Call SMS chat channel, although this does not guarantee that the moderator will convey the question to the guest speaker.
There is little additional encouragement for the audience to participate in discussions via chat, and little possibility of being invited ask questions. The most impact a Discord member can have on a community appeal is by suggesting items to add to the agenda, either through a dedicated agenda channel or privately via a Google questionnaire, though again this does not guarantee that they will be picked for inclusion by Boris.
Overall, community appeals reflect the level of responsiveness to Discord discussions, e.g. the DeFi Education Fund is a community response to their activities It was discussed after a broader, controversial reaction, but not in the previous few weeks, although their proposal has been discussed on forums and Twitter.
Developers primarily use the developer-facing chat to discuss integration and interpretation of Uniswap protocol features, and to get help from each other. Questions are asked and answered in an ad-hoc fashion, with no formal guidelines.
Developer conversations often require multiple back and forth between participants. The lack of threads in Discord means that these conversations are interspersed with more requests, requiring heavy use of the trackback-reply feature. This can make the chat visually cluttered, with many questions left unanswered. Asking multiple times or asking questions repeatedly is common.
While this is an area where community members often help each other out, in practice the line between developer questions and support requests is blurry . Some support staff have taken on de facto developer relations roles in Discord.
A short-term solution to this might be to hire a community manager who Foster the desired community outcomes from Uniswap Labs.
In recent years, the "Community Manager" has become a popular industry title, but it evokes a somewhat hierarchical, top-down approach to growing a community. Their ability to act as community players and truly align themselves with Uniswap's growth goals is often beyond what would normally be expected from a PR specialist or social media marketer.
One way to solve this problem is to hire (and possibly also train) a highly dedicated Discord user as a community manager . Another solution is to hire more experienced community managers and onboard them in the Uniswap culture and community in a gradual manner, giving potential community managers time to first observe, learn, and understand community behavior in order to be better able to shape they.
If Uniswap Labs intends to foster a stronger developer community and ensure that ideas discussed in Discord are more likely to become official governance proposals, they will need to design their off-chain social processes more carefully. This may entail incentivizing desirable behavior: reward exemplary behavior in Discord, or core team members who model the behavior they would like to see.
You can only post on certain channels after learning the rules. It may also create stronger accountability models and metrics for The Stable members. Regardless, this process of change will require a dedicated community steward and advocate for the challenges of steps along the way.Finding the right person will be difficult and it can be challenging: “ from the community People who are ” motivated are not necessarily the best managers. On the other hand, as one core team member pointed out:
“It’s tough, Because Uniswap has a specific voice and culture around it and the brand. We're kind of like OG DeFi, so we need someone who has a deep understanding of the space and the history of the space and understands the people and is immersed in the culture of Ethereum. These types of people have always been They're around and rich, so they're hard to recruit because they only want to do what they're interested in. What I'd like to do is find people who are already in the community and promote them to full members of the team, but it's hard to know who the good guys are. ”
If autonomous communities cannot be created without leadership and guidance, Uniswap Labs must ultimately ask itself: what kind of community does it want to have? What should the community revolve around? Why?
If community self-leadership in the Uniswap ecosystem is happening, it is happening in a more informal way through grants programs of. The grants program as a whole is taking on an unofficial role in off-chain governance as a channel that is soliciting more active participation and building closer relationships with key token holders and key teams.
We believe the Uniswap grants program has a unique opportunity to support the community autonomy that Uniswap Labs would like to see. Communities are often formed around shared values and visions for the future - grant programs give participants the opportunity to directly influence which futures receive funding.
Cryptography is one of the most dynamic and fastest growing industries. However, it is still a nascent ecosystem, and we are still just beginning to explore the new opportunities and challenges that a community-driven open web presents.
From this perspective, analyzing the social processes and spaces through which a crypto community exercises governance power is critical to building strong decentralized Ecosystems matter.
Original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia