header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Vitalik’s new article: How to ensure information security in the post-deep fake era?

Read this article in 5 Minutes
A technology does not need to be perfect to be effective, and combining multiple technologies together can still ensure safety.
Original Title: "Ask security questions"
Author: Vitalik
Translation: Luccy, BlockBeats

Editor's Note:
On February 4th, a finance employee of a multinational company was scammed out of $25 million during a video conference call, as the fraudsters used deepfake technology to impersonate the company's CFO. Initially, the employee suspected that a message claiming to be from the company's CFO in the UK was a phishing email, as it mentioned the need for a secret transaction. However, after the video call, the employee put aside their initial doubts because everyone else in attendance looked and sounded like colleagues they knew, but in reality, they were all deepfake entertainment products.

In response, Vitalik believes that encryption cannot solve all problems. He points out that using the information foundation that humans are naturally good at remembering to set security questions is worth incorporating into the workflow beyond other protective layers. However, he also acknowledges that while security questions are useful, they are not yet user-friendly enough. BlockBeats has translated the original article as follows:


Special thanks to Hudson Jameson, OfficerCIA, and samczsun for their feedback and review.


Recently, there has been an article circulating in the past week about a company losing 25 million dollars due to a finance staff member being scammed into transferring money to a fraudster posing as the CFO through a highly convincing deepfake video call.



Recently, deepfake technology (i.e. fake audio and video generated by artificial intelligence) has been appearing more and more frequently in the cryptocurrency industry and other fields. In the past few months, my deepfake videos have been used to promote various scams and dogecoin. The quality of deepfakes is rapidly improving, although the deepfake videos from 2020 were very bad, they have become increasingly difficult to distinguish in recent months. People who know me well can still recognize that the video of me promoting dogecoin is fake because I say "let's f***ing go" in the video, while I only use "LFG" to mean "looking for group". However, people who have only heard my voice a few times may easily be fooled.


I mentioned the above-mentioned theft of $25 million to security experts, and they unanimously believe that this is an embarrassing failure of enterprise operation security at multiple levels, and the standard practice is to require multiple levels of signature before approving any transfer of a similar amount. But there is still a fact: by 2024, a person's audio or even video stream is no longer a secure way to confirm their identity.


This raises a question: what is a secure method of identity verification?


Only relying on encryption methods cannot solve the problem


It is important for various people in various situations to be able to securely verify their identities: individuals need to recover their multi-signature or social recovery wallets, businesses need to approve commercial transactions, individuals need to approve large transactions for personal use (such as investing in startups, buying homes, sending remittances), whether using cryptocurrency or fiat currency, or even family members need to verify each other in emergency situations. Therefore, we need a good solution to deal with the upcoming era of deepfake videos.


In the cryptocurrency industry, I often hear one answer to this question: "You can verify yourself by providing an encrypted signature of your ENS/human proof configuration file/public PGP key address." This answer is attractive. However, it completely ignores why involving others in signing transactions is useful. Suppose you represent an individual user with a personal multisignature wallet and you are sending a transaction that requires approval from some co-signers. When will they approve it? When they are sure that you are the person who really wants to transfer the funds. If they judge that the trader is a hacker who stole your key or a kidnapper, they will not approve the transaction. In the corporate environment, there are usually more layers of defense; but even so, attackers may impersonate managers, and not only the final request, but also the early stages of the approval process. They may even hijack legitimate requests in progress by providing incorrect addresses.


Therefore, in many cases, the practice of other signers accepting your signature with your key to confirm "you are you" destroys the entire purpose: it turns the entire contract into a 1-to-1 multi-signature, where controlling your single key is enough to steal funds!


This is the practical and meaningful answer we have come up with: security issues.


Security Issues


Assuming someone sends you a text message claiming to be your friend, let's say "John Doe". They are using an account you have never seen before and claim to have lost all their devices. How do you verify if it is really them?


There is an obvious answer: ask about things that only they would know, which should be related to the following:


· You know.

· You expect them to remember· Unknown to the Internet· Unpredictable

· Ideally, even those who have already invaded corporate and government databases would not know.


Naturally, ask them about shared experiences, such as:


· Last time we met, which restaurant did we have dinner at and what food did you eat?

· Which politician did our friend mention when telling a joke about an ancient politician in the past?

· Do you not like the movie we recently watched?

· Last week you suggested that I talk to someone to see if they can help us with the research of XXX?


Recent practical examples of security questions used to verify my identity


Your question is better the more unique it is. The best questions are those that are right on the edge of people's ability to think for a few seconds or even forget the answer. But if the person you're asking claims to have forgotten, be sure to ask them three more questions. Asking for "micro" details (what someone likes or dislikes, specific jokes, etc.) is usually better than asking for "macro" details, as the former is often harder for third parties to accidentally unearth, for example, even if only one person posts a photo of dinner on Instagram, modern LLMs may be able to quickly capture and provide real-time location. If your question is likely to be guessed, that is, there are only a few possible reasonable options, then add another question to increase entropy.


If security issues are boring, people usually stop participating in security practices, so security issues should be made interesting. They can be a way to remember positive shared experiences and can also be a motivation to truly have these experiences.


Security Issue Supplement












Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit