header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Blockchain Killer: The "Impossible Triangle" that plagues transaction quality.

Read this article in 4 Minutes
Spam emails, DDoS attacks, and minor MEV are killers of future blockchain transaction quality.
Original Title: "Transaction quality trilemma - blockchain killers"
Original Author: polynya
Translated by: Kaori, BlockBeats


In October 2021, I wrote a speculative article about the "trilemma of transaction quality". Since then, almost all chains have implemented a minimum fee within the range of $0.01 to $0.50, but there are still some chains like Immutable X, Solana, or Arbitrum Nova that are unwilling to comply, which has given us some data.


As you know, I no longer talk about expansion and infrastructure. What I wrote in 2021 has been deeply understood and proven, so I don't need to write about them anymore. I believe that it is more important for application developers to delve into the basics of blockchain and write articles about applications and governance when we have almost unlimited expansion, one-click Rollup, and a huge data layer in our vision. EigenDA claims to process 100 MB per second. With state compression, this is 5 million "TPS" on EigenDA, only settling data on Validiums/Optimiums. But this also means that as expansion becomes excessive, the triple dilemma of transaction quality will once again become an important topic.


Once your transaction fees drop significantly below $0.01, the infrastructure of the chain becomes vulnerable to spam, DDoS, and minor MEV attacks. This is especially true if the chain has a financial ecosystem. Let's consider two chains with fees in the sub-$0.01 range - Arbitrum Nova and Solana. For strategic reasons, Arbitrum Nova is more heavily marketed as a gaming and NFT chain, while Solana is more like a frenzied casino chain. Both have more functionality, but in my opinion, these are their primary use cases. The latter comes with a financial ecosystem, leading to a large amount of minor MEV and spam transactions - the "low-quality" transactions I described earlier.


But first, let's talk about MEV. The lower your fees, the more likely you are to encounter low-value MEV opportunities. People are eager to seize these opportunities, leading to many failed transactions. Even Solana and Arbitrum Nova have minimum fees, but other chains may attempt even lower fees, ultimately resulting in over 99% of transactions being failed, junk, and worthless.


Now, some people may say, what's the problem? Let them spam attack chains to their heart's content. There are two major issues:


Sustainability and Cost: Spam emails are shared across the entire network, and historical data can accumulate to several PB in a short amount of time. Innovations like Proof of Stake can significantly reduce computational burden, but for sequence generators/builders, linear cost remains, and historical data remains the ultimate bottleneck. By simply not processing worthless transactions, the marginal cost of legitimate transactions becomes cheaper - for chains where >90% of transactions are spam, tiny MEV, or failures, costs are reduced by several orders of magnitude. It may be easy to set aside these issues in the short term, but in the long run, they may become fatal weaknesses.


0.01 USD is too expensive for some use cases: some use cases require free transactions. If you make a $100 DeFi transaction, the difference between 0.01 USD and 0.001 USD is negligible, but if you take action in on-chain games or social networks, the difference between 0.001 USD and 0 USD is everything.


Therefore, it is obvious that we need a solution to the "trilemma" of transaction quality. This leads to Immutable X and Sorare, which are currently the best solutions. They offer free transactions, but use a "Web2-style" spam mitigation method. The key is to provide an alternative anti-censorship path, which comes at a cost. This way, you can have the best of both worlds - providing free transactions for those who need it, but also offering anti-censorship for edge cases. Ideally, you may want to provide free transactions while also offering anti-censorship, but this is more difficult to solve.


The key to achieving this goal is:


a) State Isolation


b) Spam relief.


a) is crucial, otherwise you will end up with minimal MEV and irrelevant spam. In theory, this can be accomplished within a chain (L2 or L1), but currently it is best implemented on L2, as demonstrated by Immutable X and Sorare.


Currently, the obvious drawback here is the lack of composability, but the solution may lie in restricted composability with other L2/L1s. It is also worth considering that almost all imaginable use cases that require zero-cost microtransactions only require composability - social, gaming, etc.


Spam relief is an open problem - I feel that a lot of research and engineering work is still needed in developing the best solution. I suspect this will require tailored solutions to fit specific applications.


Finally, for chains focused on high-value financial transactions, a lower limit of around 0.01 USD is acceptable. This is enough to cover almost all valuable transactions while reducing minimal spam or minor MEV. I don't know what the optimal number is, but it may be in the range of 0.01 USD to 0.10 USD.


「Original article link」


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit