header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Exploring Bitcoin applications: What are "Ordinal NFTs"?

Read this article in 12 Minutes
A new method has emerged recently for minting NFTs on the Bitcoin blockchain, which allows for the complete essence of the NFT to be stored on the Bitcoin blockchain.
Original Title: "Exploring Bitcoin Applications: What are "Ordinal NFTs"?"
Original Author: Colin Harper
Translated by: BTCStudy


Unexpected or pleasantly surprised?


Recently, a new method has emerged for minting non-fungible tokens (NFTs) on the Bitcoin blockchain, which allows the essence of the NFT to be fully placed on the Bitcoin blockchain.


Only the creator of this standard, Casey Rodarmor, is not willing to call these things NFTs. He believes that the term has been stigmatized, so he refers to these things as "digital artworks". Whether you call them "digital artworks" or "ordinal NFTs", they use "ordinal theory" to label and track these "inscriptions", which are data/content embedded in the blockchain.


The so-called "ordinal number" refers to the number that describes a specific position within a sequence (for example, "first", "second"). Here, "ordinal number" refers to a specific UTXO (unspent transaction output) of a particular satoshi (the smallest unit of Bitcoin). This satoshi "contains" an inscription, which is the content of the NFT and can be text, image, HTML file, or even MP3 (music file). The ordinal number marks this satoshi with added inscription as a special transaction, so users can locate and track them. Surprisingly, such a system for sorting satoshis was proposed as early as 2012.


Since its launch in January, over 1000 digital artworks have been permanently stored on the Bitcoin blockchain. These inscriptions include Twitter screenshots, emerging NFT series, advertisements for Keet.io software, and even an 8-pixel video game (like a clone of the traditional shooting game Doom, which you can play on the ordinal block browser).


Aside from these trivial but enjoyable things like pictures, video games, etc., ordinal NFTs can also be used as tamper-resistant and censorship-resistant storage for sensitive information.


Exploring Bitcoin Applications: What are The traditional shooting game Doom now exists permanently on the Bitcoin blockchain.


Unlike previous NFTs based on the Bitcoin blockchain, ordinal NFTs do not use Bitcoin's OP_RETURN output (which also allows users to store arbitrary data on the chain). Instead, it uses the transaction witness data field of the Bitcoin block, as well as tapscript (a script programming feature that emerged due to the 2021 Taproot upgrade).


Ordinal NFT is native to Bitcoin, so it does not require a new blockchain or a new Token. Additionally, it stores all the content of the NFT on the chain, unlike other NFT standards that only place a link on the chain.


This innovation has unlocked new applications for the blockchain space (at least, it has lowered the barrier to entry for new use cases). Naturally, this has led some miners to hope that ordinal NFTs can further drive demand for blockchain space and generate greater transaction fee revenue. However, not everyone is thrilled about this innovation - some members of the Bitcoin cult believe that it is either a trivial novelty or an attack on Bitcoin.


Counterparty, RarePepes, and the Return of Bitcoin NFTs


Before we delve into the world of ordinal NFTs, let's take a moment to explore past attempts at minting NFTs on Bitcoin.


Anyway, NFTs did originate from Bitcoin. Before CryptoPunks and Bored Ape Yacht Club on Ethereum and Solana, there were already trading cards and "Pepe the Frog" on Bitcoin.


NFT first appeared in 2015 on Counterparty; this is a blockchain network that uses Bitcoin's OP_RETURN output to create non-fungible assets.


After the introduction of OP_RETURN in March 2014, Robby Dermody, Adam Krellenstein, and Ouziel Slama launched Counterparty in November. In 2015, the first set of NFTs appeared on this platform, a card trading game similar to "Magic-the-Gathering" called "Spells of Genesis".


Traffic congestion, the real explosion of Counterparty, came after the release of 1774 NFTs in the Frog Pepe trading card series. Collectors use the Counterparty wallet to store these NFTs, and Counterparty uses OP_RETURN output to anchor the index of these NFTs to the Bitcoin blockchain. The data size that can be attached to OP_RETURN output is limited to 80 bytes, which is only enough for Counterparty to put the description, name, and quantity of the NFTs in it (but for ordinal NFTs, the only limit on data volume is the volume limit of the Bitcoin block, which we will discuss later) (Translator's note: If continuous storage is not required, mounting data like OP_RETURN can also be considered to be limited only by the block size, but this upper limit will be lower than the method used for ordinal NFTs).


The transaction volume of OP_RETURN transactions reached its peak at the end of 2018, dropped to a low point in the spring of 2019, and then gradually disappeared in 2020 with the exit of OMNI (the platform where Tether initially issued USDT) and Counterparty. The period from 2019 to 2020 was also a time when USDT migrated to Ethereum and early NFT projects emerged on Ethereum.


探索比特币应用:什么是「序数 NFT」?


The above picture poses a loud question to the emerging ordinal NFT industry: will they follow in their footsteps or create a greater impact?


What is ordinal NFT (digital art, inscriptions)?


Continuing from the previous discussion, let's take a look at several basic modules of ordinal NFT:


The witness data field of the transaction: it is the place where the data and content of the NFT are stored.


Inscription: It is the main body of NFT - the actual content put on the Bitcoin blockchain, and NFT represents the ownership of these contents. The inscription will be engraved in the witness data field of the transaction input, and the NFT will be assigned to the first satoshi of the first output of the transaction. You will also see people referring to the inscription as "digital artwork/ordinal NFT" - these three terms can be used interchangeably.


Envelope: The inscription will be stored in an area called "envelope" in the witness data, which is composed of OP_IF and OP_FALSE opcodes. Like OP_RETURN, these opcodes are used to send instructions to the Bitcoin blockchain. In this usage of "envelope", OP_IF stores the engraved data, while OP_FALSE ensures that these data will never be executed and pushed onto the stack (so, although some cultists are causing panic, full nodes do not need to process and verify the inscription, only need to process and verify the UTXO set, and NFT is free in it).


Ordinal: a mathematical theory of numbering using digits. Here, it is used to identify individual items as "digital art pieces" (i.e. "ordinal NFTs"). Ordinals define the first output of a transaction as the first NFT; once marked, this output can be traded and transferred like any other NFT.


Unlike Counterparty NFTs (which only have 80 bytes on-chain), ordinal NFTs have no volume limit and are only limited by the 4MB volume limit of the transaction witness data field. Therefore, if your file is large enough, theoretically you can mint an ordinal NFT that fills up the entire Bitcoin block with just its inscription.


Taproot upgrade brings tapscript, and the transaction witness data field brought by the Segregated Witness upgrade, allowing all of this to be combined.


After the isolation upgrade in 2017, the signature of Bitcoin transactions can be moved from the "ScriptSig" field to the witness data field, and the data in this field will not be included in the transaction Merkle tree of the block, but is specifically placed in a separate area (hence its name "Segregated Witness").


The Segregated Witness essentially expands the upper limit of the block volume, because the data contained in the witness data field will not occupy the 1MB space originally arranged for the block. Therefore, the Segregated Witness upgrade introduces a new way of measuring block volume, called "block weight". The data placed in the witness data field will be "lighter" than the data placed in the original block space. Therefore, storing data in the witness data field of a Segregated Witness transaction is cheaper than storing data in the block (e.g. OP_RETURN output). This is the so-called "witness data discount", which is also the key to the production of ordinal NFTs.


Another key is the Taproot upgrade. Although witness data discounts have been introduced, there are still restrictions on the amount of data that can be placed in the witness data field for a single transaction with segregated witness. The Taproot upgrade relaxes these requirements and completely removes the restrictions, so theoretically you can use all of the block space (or more accurately, the witness data space) to engrave an NFT with a content size of up to 4 MB. (Note from the translator: We at Luxor have actually put this into practice and mined a block with an electronic artwork of 3.9 MB, which is the largest block ever mined.)


Exploring Bitcoin Applications: What are The largest block ever; the engraved NFT is 3.94 MB, and the total block size is 3.96 MB.

"The transaction with additional inscriptions is a spending transaction of the taproot output, which will expose the corresponding tapscript, so the content and file type of the inscription will also be exposed," said Casey Rodarmor, the founder of Ordinal NFT, in a mobile interview. "The inscription will 'attach' to the first output of such a transaction on the first satoshi... and then the ordinal protocol allows you to transfer these satoshis using ordinary Bitcoin transactions."


As pointed out by Bitcoin developer Peter Todd, ordinal NFTs could even be implemented before the segregated witness activation upgrade in August 2017. However, Taproot makes them cheaper and allows for larger file uploads in one go. Some commentators say that Rodarmor stumbled upon this innovation accidentally, like making a mistake by chance.


"I wouldn't call this an accident - I think people will be pleasantly surprised," said Raodarmor.


Bitcoin users need a special wallet and block explorer (Ord Wallet) to index and track ordinal NFTs, but any Bitcoin address can be used to send and receive these NFTs. Because electronic artworks require taproot to be minted, Ord Wallet will enable Taproot addresses by default.


It should also be noted that a Con attached with an inscription is indistinguishable from other Cons on the chain, meaning it can be spent just like any other Con and there is no difference in spending method. Currently, a Con can only be inscribed once, but Rodarmor is developing an upgrade that will allow users to re-inscribe previously inscribed Cons (called "copying").


What does ordinal NFT mean for Bitcoin miners?


Despite the founder of ordinal NFTs attempting to avoid controversy by referring to them as "digital artworks", they have become a hot topic among Bitcoin enthusiasts.


There are basically two camps. Those who support believe that the block space of Bitcoin is a free market; as long as you can pay the transaction fee, you can use the block space regardless of the size or content of the transaction. Those who oppose claim that NFTs are scams that will occupy block space, and these junk transactions will squeeze out more meaningful economic transactions (such as ordinary transfers); moreover, this "occupation" will increase the bandwidth requirements for downloading and running Bitcoin full nodes.


Ordinal NFT has also entered a larger debate due to Bitcoin's security budget issues (whatever you call it). Supporters argue that this new application will drive demand for block space, which is good for the future of Bitcoin because Bitcoin's block rewards will eventually drop to zero. Naturally, the debate about block space and transaction fees has also piqued the interest of miners, as transaction fee revenue once accounted for 30% of their total revenue, but now only accounts for 3% at best.


Currently, there are only over 1000 ordinal NFTs in circulation, so they cannot yet reach the point where transaction fees increase exponentially. In other words, while transaction fees and block volume for Bitcoin did increase significantly in the last two days of January, part of the reason for this growth may be due to a 3% decrease in Bitcoin's hash rate from its historical high, resulting in longer block times and higher transaction fees. However, without the craze for ordinal NFTs, we may not have seen an increase in transaction fees and block volume.


探索比特币应用:什么是「序数 NFT」?

There were no astronomical numbers, but the ordinal NFT did have an impact on block size and transaction fees. Source: Hashrate Index

The ordinal NFT is unlikely to increase transaction fees. Of course, they could potentially lead to higher fees, but not in the way you might think. After all, theoretically, a block filled with electronic art, which receives a discount from segregated witness, could carry less fees than a block filled with regular Bitcoin transactions.


However, if enough users start minting ordinal NFTs, they will fiercely compete for block space with regular transactions, and users broadcasting regular transactions will need to increase their transaction fees to get their transactions included in a block. As a result, miners may prioritize packing as many regular transactions as possible because they pay higher fees per data, so the more regular transactions packed, the higher the transaction fee income.


Therefore, even if the ordinal NFT generates pressure for transaction fee increase, miners may still prioritize packing more regular transactions to generate higher transaction fees.


Scarcity


What may truly benefit miners is not transaction fees, but mining electronic artworks - specifically, the scarce Cong.


In a blog post discussing ordinal theory, Casey Rodarmot listed a chart of different levels of rarity for different satoshis. This classification method mainly revolves around Bitcoin's proof-of-work self-adjustment events, namely difficulty adjustment events and halving events. For example, the first satoshi in the first block after a halving event would be classified as an "Epic" satoshi; if there is demand for such satoshis, they can be sold for a better price among collectors.


The chart is as follows:


Exploring Bitcoin Applications: What are Rare satoshis can bring additional and lucrative sources of income to miners.

Once such a collectibles market emerges, miners will be able to make big money by selling these satoshis to collectors. Of course, this scarcity is entirely based on the assumption that such a market will emerge. However, from monkeys to stones, and even chickens, they have all found their collectors in the frenzy of NFT trading. It is not strange to imagine that some Bitcoiners will join this trend and chase after the first satoshis of a new halving cycle or a new difficulty cycle.


Ordinal NFT: Abnormal?


Casey Rodarmor's innovation has only been around for about a month, but it has already become the most controversial topic in the Bitcoin community this year.


The opposition is very strong. Luke Dashjr, a contributor to Bitcoin Core, has written a rough filter for node operators (translator's note: this can be used to prevent nodes from receiving and forwarding these transactions to their own transaction pool), although the effectiveness and impact of this tool are still in question. In any case, OP_FALSE means that the script data does not need to be verified, and pruned nodes will not save the witness data of the transaction.


There are also people standing on the other side, many of whom - including followers of the Bitgod cult and ordinary cryptocurrency enthusiasts - are excited about this new NFT minting method. In addition to images and collectibles, ordinal NFTs can also be used to publish sensitive files, which can benefit from permanent, censorship-resistant storage and replication. To borrow the words of Brandon Bailey from Galaxy Digital, Bitcoin users can plan an "immutable library" by engraving ordinal NFTs.


For miners, this innovation can lead to an increase in transaction fees in the future, and open up additional income streams (mining rare sats), and even generate "Miner Extractable Value (MEV)".


Regardless of the circumstances, ordinal NFTs will not disappear. The only question is how much impact they will have and whether inscriptions can create an NFT craze like Ethereum and other blockchains.


Original article link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit