header-langage
简体中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Encryption legal experts debate WEB3 regulation: compliance or decentralization?

Read this article in 17 Minutes
Compliance, or decentralization? this is a problem.
Original source: Shenchao TechFlow


< /a>

< path d="M12.4376 15.6C4.77778 15.6 2 20.3999 2 20.3999C2 12.5999 5.88889 8.4 12.4376 8.4V3L22 11.9812L12.4376 21V15.6Z" stroke-wid th="1.5" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin=" round">


2022 On August 9th, a ban broke the tranquility of the encryption market, and a regulatory storm fanned by a butterfly made the encryption world jittery.


The Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) of the U.S. Department of the Treasury announced the sanctions against Tornado Cash, the developer of Tornado Cash was subsequently arrested in the Netherlands. "Hear the news and move."


USDC issuer Circle has officially blacklisted Ethereum addresses from the U.S. Treasury Department’s sanctions list.


Uniswap blocked 253 encrypted addresses related to stolen funds or sanctions; lending protocol Aave also blocked many addresses that had interactive transfers with Tornado Cash… …


CeFi/DeFi applications are gradually accepting "supervision". What about the public chain at the protocol layer? If one day OFAC wants to review or sanction Ethereum after it has been converted to PoS (Proof of Stake), is it possible?


Faced with this problem, Vitalik Buterin, the founder of Ethereum, responded via Twitter that if the regulatory authority approves node service providers of certain protocols (such as Lido, Coinbase) Conduct a protocol-level review of Ethereum, and he will regard this review as an attack on Ethereum. If there is such a situation, he will choose to destroy these nodes through a broader consensus (social consensus).


For CeFi/DeFi projects, one is the ideal of decentralization; , how to choose? How will regulation affect the future development of the crypto world?


Shenchao invited the general counsel of Fenbushi Capital, a high-quality blue-collar worker, and Cobo COO Lily King, two practitioners with legal backgrounds, to jointly explore encryption Implications behind regulation and future developments.

Guests:

High-quality blue-collar, general counsel of Fenbushi Capital, senior legal expert in the blockchain industry and researcher.

LilyKing from Boundary, Cobo COO, Chinese and American lawyers, in-depth research on social policies and collaboration mechanisms.


After the merger of Ethereum, will the transformation of the POS consensus mechanism bring greater regulatory risks?   


Blue Collar:

There will be no greater regulatory risk due to mergers and POS transformation It is a matter at the infrastructure level and does not directly involve financial services. However, for the consensus mechanism to become POS, for regulators, the specific regulatory measures may be adjusted.


In theory, regulators can impose certain scrutiny on each verification node of the Ethereum network, whether it is POW or POS——POW Era review can start from mining pools (but it will not be implemented in time), while POS era will start from node hosting service providers. Considering that most of the node hosting service providers are in the United States, it will be more convenient for the US regulators to implement some kind of review measures.


Lily King:

Currently, ETH, like BTC, is recognized as a "commodity" in the United States rather than a "commodity" Securities". The transition to POS may bring about a new round of discussions on whether ETH is a security. Adam Levitin, a professor of law at Georgetown University, recently tweeted that the staking/staking profit model is similar to investment profit, and meets the "Howey" standard for securities defined in the United States - "to profit completely from other people's labor], so POS Token Both have the risk of being identified as securities. But Ethereum is sufficiently decentralized, and Token does not have a centralized issuer like securities. Moreover, Staker is a participant in the network rather than a purely passive investor, which does not meet Howey So I don’t think the risk is high.


 How will regulation affect DeFi applications?  


Blue collar:

Any DeFi project must first distinguish two different things: (1) the smart contract itself; (2) the project company operated by the relevant developer (usually The project company will provide some centralized services based on DeFi).


For example, Uniswap’s smart contracts on Ethereum and Uniswap Labs, both of which Although it may be regarded as the same DeFi project by the outside world, it is two independent things at the legal level, and the regulatory issues they face are different.


< b>The smart contract part of DeFi (only referring to those deployed on the public blockchain) is not currently considered as an object to be directly regulated, because at present, the laws of various countries do not include smart contracts As a subject that can take responsibility for itself (although legislation may change in the future).


Therefore, regulators can only adopt a roundabout strategy for smart contracts. That is to prohibit or restrict relevant individuals/institutions from using such smart contracts, thus indirectly marginalizing or even eliminating the smart contracts from the mainstream market. However, considering that the jurisdiction of various national regulatory agencies has geographical restrictions, generally speaking The United States has the strongest regulatory capacity in this regard, because the jurisdiction of the US regulatory authorities can cover the most and widest range of individuals/institutions, and accordingly can make a smart contract the most affected. In contrast, the regulatory measures of small countries may It has almost no practical impact on the smart contract, even if the relevant person is banned from using the smart contract in name.


For the operating company of the DeFi project (usually the developer himself Established companies), because they provide various centralized Internet services/financial services, they will be routinely regulated in accordance with existing laws and regulations.Please note that this kind of centralized service and "decentralized "Finance" itself is not contradictory, but can coexist in a DeFi project (objectively, it does often coexist).


For example, most DeFi operating companies provide web front-end services, which are typical Internet information services, so conventional regulatory regulations will naturally apply (For example, Uniswap Labs must hide the trading interface of those illegal securities tokens from the front end of the web page, even if Uniswap's smart contracts have not changed).


If the operating company also holds certain financial business licenses, it will also have additional regulatory requirements to be met while providing additional centralized financial services. In general, the supervision of DeFi operating companies falls within the scope of conventional supervision, and no special legislation is required, nor will the original regulatory requirements no longer apply because DeFi uses blockchain technology.


Looking forward to the future, in order to further strengthen the supervision of DeFi, there will be new legislation (especially in the United States) to make some special regulations for DeFi smart contracts< /b> ——Smart contracts that meet certain conditions may be regarded as a special business entity, which needs to bear certain legal responsibilities, especially those DeFi projects that are DAOs. In addition, certain KYC requirements may also be imposed on DeFi users themselves, or various restrictions may be imposed on the capital flow of non-KYC users.


What does regulation mean for Ethereum Validators nodes? How should we deal with it?   


Blue-collar:

It doesn’t mean anything for now. Since ETH itself is Permissionless (no license), potential regulatory measures in the future may be at the level of node hosting service providers, that is, service providers need to take KYC and other measures for node customers. For the individual as a Validator, there is no potential risk of being directly supervised for the time being.


The most fundamental reason for this is that the main chain of ETH does not directly handle financial transactions, on the contrary, it is the business of each specific DeFi project on the chain (ie: DeFi Smart contracts and the ETH blockchain are decoupled), so DeFi is the focus of regulation.


Of course, if the new law is introduced, the regulatory tentacles will go deep into the ETH blockchain itself, so that it will directly impose some form of restrictions on any ETH validator Regulatory requirements (although I feel unlikely), that would indeed jeopardize the vision of ETH itself as a Permissionless Ledger. At that time, the Ethereum Foundation (Ethereum Foundation) will inevitably take technical countermeasures. Of course, this regulatory requirement will certainly not be specific to ETH, but applies to all public chains.


How does stronger regulation affect the relationship between DeFi and traditional finance?   


LilyKing:

In the short term, more capital will enter a wait-and-see state. However, with the gradual clarification of regulatory rules, institutional capital will enter DeFi more smoothly. The great potential of DeFi lies in becoming the next generation of financial infrastructure. To achieve that vision, it must break the circle and introduce trillion-level assets from traditional finance and the real economy. It is inevitable to deal with regulation in this process.


However, coping with regulation does not mean complete surrender - encryption companies need to retain their own decentralized characteristics under the regulatory framework, this is not a black and white choice . Even in American politics, there are enough officials who value the innovative power of the encryption movement and oppose excessive government intervention. In the end, it is very likely that all parties will coordinate and reach a balance:regulators feel that they can achieve the purpose of preventing financial crimes and protecting ordinary investors, while the encryption forces can still retain the openness and freedom far beyond the existing financial system .


The future encryption world is diverse. At the protocol layer like Ethereum, it is very likely to maintain a very strong decentralization, which is where the value of the blockchain lies. This is also where the current encryption community is most united. Even the CEO of Coinbase said that he would rather cancel the Staking service than accept Protocol (protocol) level review.


But there will be differentiation at the application layer. Some encryption teams will insist on retaining the greatest degree of freedom and privacy, and will not cooperate with any supervision and review, and they will still have their own living space. But they will need to face the limitations of pure virtual assets, and they will also need to give up the markets of some countries.


For encryption projects that aim to achieve mass adoption, a balance needs to be found between supervision and anti-censorship. On the one hand, most users cannot survive in the Wild West on their own, and they do need some protection. On the other hand, if you want to have a relationship with people and assets under the chain, you will inevitably have a relationship with laws and traditional financial institutions, and you need to cater to social rules.


 What does stronger regulation mean for crypto investors?   


Blue collar:

Distinguish between traditional institutions and Crypto Native Investors. The latter obviously don't like regulatory measures, so they will turn to projects and markets that are less regulated, but for the former, regulated DeFi is their familiar and advantageous battlefield.


Due to the amount of funds, the funds of traditional institutions are much larger, so the liquidity of regulated DeFi will be much higher. Those DeFi projects that are deliberately designed to avoid regulation will gradually be marginalized and become a niche market, but there is still room for survival. Crypto Native Investors need to be prepared for this change (Gradually Then Suddenly), at some point they will have to make a choice.


Innovation brought about by any technology cannot avoid government power in the end (unless the government itself disappears in human society), but will only change the government's exercise of power Specific ways of power.


What does stronger regulation mean for crypto businesses and DAOs?   


LilyKing:

Whether it is an encryption company or a DAO, it is necessary to strengthen Regulation Intelligence and gain insight into the policies of different countries and regions. Analyze where to register, how to pay taxes, how to do KYC, what licenses need to be obtained, etc., and then make the most beneficial arrangements for your team. The recent series of strong measures of the US SEC may bring a wave of American teams going overseas. But in fact, South Korea, Singapore, Japan, Europe, and India are continuously introducing regulatory policies for the encryption industry.


Even a Crypto Native DAO needs a deep understanding of regulatory rules to strive for the most favorable regulatory environment for itself. We have seen that many project teams have launched decentralized roadmaps, gradually withdrawing the centralized founding team, and minimizing the centralized infrastructure. For example, DYDX will change its current order book that is currently stored centrally under the chain to be run by nodes in a decentralized manner, and at the same time, Protocol profits will no longer be collected by centralized institutions. In addition to their high-profile promotion of "handing over control to the community", this change also prevents them from being strictly supervised by the SEC like traditional companies.


For DAOs that issue Tokens, the next biggest challenge is whether they are regarded as issuers of securities, and if so, they must Facing the supervision of institutions such as the SEC. To avoid your own Token being identified as securities, you need to have a deep understanding of securities-related laws and regulations, and design your own Tokenomics and Governance accordingly.


Decentralization is the most important talisman of the DAO. What regulators are good at is to focus on centralized institutions, and they have no way to start with the real Peer-To-Peer (peer-to-peer) network. Moreover, the rationality of supervision is based on the protection of ordinary users, preventing someone from using information asymmetry to harm ordinary users, but this does not apply to highly-participatory DAOs that truly share information transparently.


Regulation is not entirely bad for users. After all, smart contracts cannot completely prevent DAO members from acting against users. Not to mention the many RugPulls, just in the recent Tribe shutdown, Tribe DAO’s voting decision made many of its partners and users feel cheated, and some even threatened to sue them with the SEC.


For encryption companies with traditional shareholding structures and even listing ambitions, the cost of compliance is really high. Let’s look at Coinbase’s expenditure in this area. knew. But paying such a price is to be able to connect with the trillion-level traditional financial market, and the encrypted world also needs such enterprises.


 As a practitioner with a legal education background, what do you think of "Code is law"?   


Blue-collar:

The reason for this sentence is that part of the meaning of Code in English is consistent with that of Law (Chinese will be translated as "code"). But obviously in the Chinese context, the word "code" and "law" do not have much overlapping meanings, and cannot cause puns.


For smart contracts, Code is the code written unilaterally by the developer without any consensus process. It is obviously absurd to interpret such unilaterally written content as mandatory universal law. The code can only be the embodiment of the will and ability of the developer, but it is neither universal nor mandatory (the user cannot be directly forced to run the code), and even the content of the code may be completely unreasonable, so it does not have legal due properties.


However, it is reasonable to interpret the code of the smart contract as a contract, that is, the contract between the developer and the contract user, or the contract contract between users. Because it can be defaulted that "once you use the smart contract based on this code, it means that you agree to accept the results of the relevant program operation". The act expresses agreement to the agreed conditions", which is generally in line with the legal principles of contract law in most countries.


But it must be noted that even if the code of the smart contract is interpreted as a contract, it does not mean that all execution results of the smart contract must be unconditional Accept and follow. In reality, many contracts can be found to be invalid, unenforceable, revocable, pending effect and other irregular results in accordance with relevant laws under specific circumstances. The possible reasons include illegality, lack of proper authorization, fraud, obvious Unfairness, force majeure, failure of contract purpose, etc. (laws vary from country to country). At this time, even if the smart contract automatically runs a certain result, the result will be required by law to roll back, or restore the original state or change the result in other technically feasible ways.


So Code is law can only be said to be the value proposition of some technical geek groups at best, but it is neither the consensus of the whole society nor the law level of reality. Even if a person agrees with Code is law in his heart, he has to admit that the reality is not the case.


LilyKing:

When Harvard Law School professor Lawrence Lessig first proposed the concept of "Code is law" in 1999, what he said It's not that Code can replace law, but that Code has almost the same power as law in the Internet world, so we should design Code with the same principles as designing a constitution to ensure that Code is transparent and fair, and does not harm the rights of users.

In the current encrypted world, "Code is law" is widely understood as having a Code is enough, and Law is not required. It represents an ideology that limits government power and protects individual liberty and privacy.


But in the offline world, Code has no way to guarantee the exchange of assets. You can use Token to represent the ownership of a property, but when the seller refuses to move after the transaction, you still have to seek help from law enforcement agencies. A large number of human behaviors still occur in the off-chain society. For example, Code cannot prevent money laundering or terrorist financing-this requires Law.


Even online, we have seen many Rugbull, hacking incidents or interest disputes, users in the encryption world will seek help from the legal department and often It is found that the law enforcement effect of the legal department is quite impressive.


The next step in the development of the encryption movement should change the real world. The more you have a relationship with people and assets in the offline world, the more you need Code+ Law's symbiotic system.


How can distributed and Cobo help institutions and DAOs face the ever-changing regulatory environment?   


Blue Collar:

This mainly depends on changes in the regulatory environment itself. At present, in all countries, the legal status and regulatory environment of DAOs are unclear. Even in the United States, some state laws allow DAO to be registered as a commercial vehicle, but the DAO registered according to the law is actually not the same as the DAO in the blockchain industry (semantic pollution). In this state of unclear regulatory policies, it is difficult to say that there is any definite answer to help DAO comply with regulations.


But even so, there are some fundamental legal principles about DAOs that can be applied prospectively:

( 1) DAO’s treasury management is the core issue, requires governance measures similar to those of listed companies or public welfare organizations, including the proper establishment of governance institutions, voting procedures for expenditure items, and daily use of expenditure funds Supervision, etc. In the future, the DAO legislation in various countries will most likely first stipulate the DAO treasury management;


(2) The access mechanism for DAO members , certain restrictions need to be imposed, unlike the current Permissionless (as long as you hold coins, you will automatically become a DAO member), and KYC must be done when necessary. Correspondingly, there must be an exit mechanism for members, instead of automatically exiting if they sell the coins they hold;


(3) DAO requires There is a mature and stable version of the convention or constitution (not just the code), it is clear that all members are obliged to abide by it, which is a necessary condition for all organizations to exist independently;


(4) Scope of the DAO, including defining which on-chain smart contracts and which real-world entities/assets its components cover. It is the future direction of development to form a DAO composed of various factors, not just related smart contracts and tokens.


LilyKing:

Cobo has been focusing on strengthening its Regulation Intelligence and closely tracking the policy trends of various countries. While the current regulatory storm has rocked the crypto community, the reality is not all dark. Even in the United States, new things tend to enjoy more regulatory dividends. Tokenization is a financial tool as powerful as securities, but because it is a new thing, it faces much looser regulation than securities. The supervision of agencies such as the SEC does not currently appear to be aimed at killing the encryption movement. The latest article by SEC Chairman Gensler compares the blockchain to a new technology like a car in the 20th century. All he does is require cars to be equipped with seat belts. . When we manage regulatory risks, we should not ignore the regulatory dividends that are well deserved.


Cobo's smart contract hosting platform Argus has the function of helping institutions and DAOs to produce auditable reports, and we are developing a new generation of decentralized Custody chain Cobo Chain. These decentralized technology solutions and asset management methods also allow our institutions and DAO users to reduce the risk of regulatory scrutiny.


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit