header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Talking to Ethereum Foundation Fellows: What the merger means for Ethereum

Read this article in 11 Minutes
"There are so many things happening on Ethereum every day that we believe it will continue to grow."

Original title: What the Merge Means for Ethereum
Original article by Danny Ryan and Jeff Benson
Kxp, BlockBeats


After years of research, development, and testing, Ethereum will transition from proof of work to proof of equity in the coming months. Unlike "miners" who use computing resources to process transactions, "validators" lock or pledge their assets in the network in exchange for ETH rewards. This not only improves security, but also greatly reduces the impact of decentralized networks on the environment.


Danny Ryan, a researcher at the Ethereum Foundation, is coordinating the network upgrade. This update is an important step in an upgrade plan known as Ethereum2.0 that aims to build a more secure, sustainable, and scalable network.

-

Ryan spoke with us today about the merger, and in part 1 he explains why security and sustainability are temporarily prioritizing scalability, how the upgrade will facilitate liquidity pledges and bring in new players, and why Ethereum is not going down.


In the second part, he talks about the features users want to see in subsequent upgrades, whether on-chain voting can be used for future upgrade decisions, and why shadow fork is the way forward.


Security and sustainability


FUTURE: What's the purpose of the merger?


DANNY RYAN: Broadly speaking, we want to help Ethereum become more secure, sustainable, scalable over the next few years while maintaining its decentralized nature.


There is an ongoing debate over whether proof of employment or proof of entitlement is safer. But as we've looked at many factors, in general the Ethereum community and researchers agree that proof of interest is safer than proof of work.


Proof of work requires far more energy for sustainability than proof of equity. So, with proof of entitlement, you can get about a 99% reduction in energy consumption, which is pretty impressive.


If Ethereum still uses proof of work and ETH prices double, the number of mining nodes on the Ethereum platform will eventually double as well. And if you use proof of equity, then even if the price of ETH doubles, the dynamic balance of the number of nodes on the network doesn't change very much it doesn't really change. The number of nodes on the network can be very large, but its energy consumption can be significantly reduced.


"We haven't been able to improve Ethereum's scalability with this merger, but we've certainly laid the groundwork for it."


According to the Ethereum white paper, "In the future, it is likely that Ethereum will switch to proof of interest to ensure its security, reducing the issue requirement to between 0 and 0.05 times per year." But you just mentioned not only security, but sustainability, when did it become as important as security?


I don't know if this is covered in the white paper, but in some of the early Ethereum.org blog posts, and even around the world (around 13 or 14 years old), the linear relationship between asset prices and energy consumed for proof of work is well known. I would say that as the Ethereum community began to include non-crypto currency native players, especially in the arts and NFTS, energy consumption came into focus, as increasing ETH prices would increase total mining energy consumption. While this will allow us to have a more diverse community, the energy cost of this will also have to be looked at, as it will greatly impact Ethereum's sustainability.


scalability


Many are already counting on the long-term benefits of the merger, such as lower fees and less congestion. However, the most basic work of merging should be......


That's certainly scalability, and while merging doesn't directly improve Ethereum's scalability, it does set the stage for it.


So now that Ethereum is just starting to use proof of interest and there is no sharding before the upgrade, how does scalability look so far?


To put it bluntly, the combined block time will drop from 13.5 seconds to 12 seconds on average, but the Gas fee limit will remain the same. As a result, scalability will increase by 10% when a merge occurs, and it's up to you to accept it or not.


While this is not as scalable as we might think, extensible, more complex consensus mechanisms that lead to more consensus are actually hard to build into work certificates. There have been previous attempts to do things like shards with proof of work protocols, but they have all ended up simulating proof of interest under the guise of proof of work. So I would say proof of interest is a necessary foundation for future scalability upgrades.


There is also an extensibility path parallel to Merge that leverages L2 Rollup. At the same time, people are starting to adopt online pathways that can provide 10-100 times more scalability without changing the existing Ethereum, which will be complemented by future L1 scalability upgrades. Therefore, with L1 we aim to improve security and sustainability, and with L2 we can achieve scalability. In the future, we can continue to expand L1 to complement (see Part 2 of our talk).


If you are relying on L2 solutions to achieve a certain degree of extensibility, what security considerations should there be?


First, building low-security L2 is really not that hard. In our opinion, the most general security constructs are these Rollup 例 句 Optimism and zero knowledge (ZK). One of the key components is publishing transaction data or some kind of state transition data on the chain and certain ZK constructs are therefore able to take advantage of the data availability of the chain, which really limits the ultimate scalability.


Sometimes people look at this and say, "Well, let's not do that, we can just build a Rollup and not publish the data, and we can do a side build." So, for a while, it was possible to scale back the L2 architecture for greater scalability. So in the case of L2, it's a difficult tradeoff between security and extensibility: if you build an architecturally complete L2, it's guaranteed security; But if you build an L2 Rollup to take a shortcut, there are plenty of security issues.


I think it's hard for consumers to tell the difference between the L2s and see that one is many times safer than the other, especially when the language is unclear and it's hard to see what's really going on.L2BeatWorking as an independent third party to put this information together so that we can better understand the various trade-offs involved here. But for all that, the reality may not be the same as they describe it.


As for complexity, L1 carries some risks in terms of the types of bugs that can be introduced, the complexity of the software, and so on. When you build L2, you introduce a derivative system, which inevitably has its own set of security risks and increased complexity.


Not only that, but we also need to make sure that these L2-derived systems can be upgraded and enhanced over time, with the potential for security risks in the process. So specifically, what upgrade modes can we have? Signed by three people or approved by the DAO? Is it safe? Is it upgradable immediately, or does it take a year to prepare? There will be a lot of design involved, and in theory a perfect L2 should inherit Ethereum's security.


"I believe there will be an order of magnitude more validators than miners in the future, and that has to be a good thing."


MEV, Liquidity Pledge, and the evolving Ethereum ecosystem


In your opinion, what new players or types of projects will emerge as we move to proof of equity and adjust infrastructure and incentives with consolidation?


On the participant side, there will surely be more verifiers coming in and miners leaving. I believe there will be an order of magnitude more validators than miners in the future, and that has to be a good thing.


Meanwhile, in the last few years, there have been a number of different players in the MEV (Miners' extractable value or maximum extractable value) space, but not as a result of mergers. Some of these participants specialize in block search and try to find the best configuration of blocks. Some intermediaries are combining search tools into blocks and selling them to miners or verifiers.


So far, it seems that many players have joined the MEV structure to take advantage of the high risk. However, we can also perform some operations at the L1 layer to make the entire MEV architecture more secure.


Derivative collateral is very interesting, and there are many different ways of doing it, but they all involve some element of risk, whether it's someone else pledging it for you or you pledging it yourself. And for the underlying pledged asset, you can use it for trading, or bring it into areas like smart contracts or DeFi.


I know thatLIDOIs the best-known of its kind, and others are popping up. Accordingly, many participants have joined in -- DeFi participants,


Daos, consortia, etc., have all come to this interesting area.


There has been some discussion about LIDO, which pledges large amounts of ETH on beacon chains on behalf of users, but does this practice benefit decentralized networks to the greatest extent?


I wrote an article called "Risk Analysis of Liquidity-Pledged Derivatives" in which I also mentioned LIDO. Some argue that one can find ways of building to avoid the centralisation problem, by denying certain key thresholds to a single operator. But I don't think that's the case, and there are substantial risks. And because of the nature of derivatives, we all know these risks differently. As a result, it is possible for market behaviour to exceed these thresholds.


Therefore, it is in the best interest of the pledged derivative, the DAO, or the controller to stay below the threshold to avoid the risk to the protocol and users of exceeding the threshold. But this may not be in the best interest of users, and while the benefits of taking part in the pledge of highly liquid derivatives are particularly good, the risks may ultimately outweigh those benefits. So my claim is that we can ignore the risks and pay more attention to the benefits, and the market will become more sensible.


[Editor's note: In June 2022, LIDO holders voted down a governance proposal that would have placed a cap on the number of ETH pledged on the platform.]


In my view, part of the security gains will include increased decentralization, as participation becomes easier -- you can participate not only through pledge, but also through non-block production nodes. So specifically, how much of the security gain is due to increased user engagement, and how much is due to other factors?


First, decentralization is likely to increase, as the collateral required for proof of equity is easier to obtain than for proof of work, and ETH can be purchased entirely on the open market. As a result, all types of players have the same advantages when it comes to accessing capital. In a work ID, the required capital is highly specialized machine components, such as ASics or Gpus.


In short, the rise in decentralization is all due to the new type of Crypto economic capital that promotes equity while weakening economies of scale.


In practice, the agreements are structured in much the same way as some of my propositions: in the work certificate, the rewards are very clear and we earn money if we do well; Even if attacked, it won't hurt much. And in proof of equity, again, you can make money doing well. But if you don't do it well, you lose some money; Even if we create a data recombination or two different chains, we may incur large losses, depending on how well we are detected.


We can destroy the ETH assets pledged in the protocol, which is somewhat similar: in the event of a blockchain attack, we can't destroy its mines, but we can destroy the ETH pledged. Not only can we get rewards, but we can also get penalties, so the safety factor of the pledged capital can be very high.


At the same time, decentralization, access to required assets and reduced economies of scale are also very favourable factors.


"There are so many things happening on Ethereum every day that we believe it will continue to grow."


Synchronous update


The upgrade process has not affected the normal flow of transactions, and Ethereum.org notes that "there has been no downtime at Ethereum." Why do we do this? Why not just take a day, send notice in advance, and upgrade?


First of all, it doesn't make the upgrade any less complicated, and at the end of the day, we still have a lot of coordination to do, and we need more than one day.


If you really want to do that -- to shut down and let everyone upgrade their nodes and then restart them, we need at least three days, maybe a week. Even if you give people time to prepare, it will take two or three days to complete, and one day is definitely not enough.


Here's the thing: once the shutdown happens, a lot of problems will arise, and DeFi participants are bound to be very angry. Ethereum is a system that works well, with a lot happening every day, and we have every reason to believe that it will continue to grow.


The complexity could be reduced by 20% if the upgrades were not synchronized, but considering the cost of a three-day shutdown, it's not worth it. Also, WE HAVE a very clear approach to synchronous UPGRADES, AND as long as there are no massive miner attacks, the complexity will not increase much.


The original link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit