header-langage
简体中文
English
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Creator Economy: The Road to Change under the "Crisis of Legitimacy"

Read this article in 15 Minutes
Legitimacy comes from trust, and when this trust is eroded, legitimacy crises occur
Original title: "Creator Economy: The Road to Change under the "Crisis of Legitimacy""
Original author: Li Jin & Katie Parrot
Original compilation: Nan Wind, Unitimes


As historians write about the rise of the "creator economy", there are two moments (a decade apart) that are sure to occur. The first moment was in the spring of 2007, when YouTube began sharing advertising revenue with creators—a decision that arguably laid the foundation for what we know today as the “creator economy.” The second moment came in the spring of 2017, when the cracks in this foundation became impossible to ignore, and questions about the "legitimacy" (also translated as "legality") of the platform economy began to emerge.


Spring 2017 marked what creators are now widely dubbing the "Adpocalypse." YouTube is facing an exodus of advertisers as advertisers worry that their ads will appear next to objectionable content. As a result, the platform completely reformed its advertising policy. YouTube chose to conduct a more thorough review of the platform content, introduced increasingly stringent content terms and revenue mechanisms, and adjusted the video content classification and recommendation algorithms to ensure advertising delivery. of video content is "ad-friendly." As a result, thousands of creators have seen their views and revenue plummet — some by as much as 99%.


A YouTube creator told New York magazine at the time: "Almost everyone's views have been cut in half. So we're fighting this (YouTube's ) system and new algorithms, it’s like, how do people live on this now?”


For many YouTube creators, Adpocalypse  The event is a wake-up call. For the first time, they realize that their income — and in some cases, their entire livelihood — is attached. This is the first time creators have questioned the legitimacy of their deals with platforms.


But it won't be the last time. After the first Adpocalypse event in 2017, YouTube had its second, third, and fourth Adpocalypse events in 2018 and 2019. YouTube isn't the only platform with strained relationships with creators. Facebook faced a backlash in 2016 when it made changes to Instagram’s algorithm feed that affected creators’ engagement on the platform. When OnlyFans announced content policy changes in the summer of 2021, the creator backlash was so swift that the platform was forced to put the changes on hold almost immediately.


If the pattern sounds familiar - a group of people who object to the policies that govern them and demand better Conditions - this is no accident. What else can a change in the platform’s profit policy be, other than a form of taxation that has not received support from users? What is creator if not a new type of labor seeking protection for an emerging type of work that never existed before?


Like feudalism and the theocracy before it, the creator economy (at least in its current highly centralized form) is going through a crisis of legitimacy (legitimacy crisis). Creators are questioning the terms that govern their relationship with the platforms they regularly use, and the platform's right to set them in the first place. How the ecosystem responds—that is, what alternatives are proposed, who builds them, and how—will determine the next phase of the creator economy.


01. What is legitimacy? Where did it come from?


Legitimacy Like air quality, we don't usually think about it until something goes wrong. We all participate in various political, economic, and social institutions—governments, schools, workplaces—that govern our behaviour. When we think these systems are fair, we believe they are "orthodox". We think it's "unorthodox" when we think it's unfair and we deserve better.


Consequently, when enough people within the system question the fairness of the system, it threatens the ability of the system to continue to function, and it faces legitimacy Crisis (legitimacy crisis).


Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin wrote: "Orthodoxy is a higher order mode of acceptance. If people in a certain social background are widely Accepting and playing their part in crafting that outcome, and each doing so because they expect everyone else to do the same, the outcome is orthodox in a certain social context."

< p>

The term "crisis of legitimacy" was coined in the 1970s by sociologist Jurgen Habermas. But for centuries, philosophers and social thinkers have wondered about legitimacy—who owns it, where it comes from, and how it disappears.


For example, the ancient philosopher Aristotle suggested that political legitimacy rests on "reward legitimacy" - Under the system, each person gains according to his own virtue. Two millennia later, the political philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau argued that government legitimacy rests on the general will and the common good (as opposed to individual interests such as a monarch or a small elite). A century after Rousseau, German sociologist Max Weber identified three basic sources of legitimacy:


Traditional legitimacy— Essentially, rule by the status quo. "Follow me, because it's always been done that way."


Charismatic legitimacy—in other words, the reign of a cult of personality. "Follow me because I'm charismatic and persuasive." (The rise to power of many authoritarian leaders has followed this pattern.)


Rational-Legal legitimacy—in other words, rule by reason. "Follow me, because the rules and legal system I established are clear and objectively make society run better."


At the end of the day, legitimacy comes from trust: Trust that governing order is just, trust that the actors who create and enforce it do so in the interest of the majority. When this trust is eroded, a crisis of legitimacy occurs—when the ruled no longer believe that those in power exercise power for the collective good.


The concept of legitimacy is not limited to political institutions. Economic systems and power can also have legitimacy or lose it. In Europe, for example, when laborers – made scarce and therefore valuable due to the devastation of the Black Death – gained greater bargaining power and used this to ensure greater individual autonomy and (Eventually) greater economic freedom, feudalism lost its legitimacy as an economic system. This eventually led to urbanization and the creation of a merchant class. The Industrial Revolution and the subsequent Gilded Age led to a crisis of legitimacy among factories and workers who demanded better working conditions, child labor laws and weekends, and the American middle class was born.


Our understanding of legitimacy and the sources of legitimacy are constantly changing. In fact, shifts in orthodoxy are often the impetus for a crisis of legitimacy: 400 years ago it was more or less believed that the legitimacy of government arose from the birthright of the sovereign; The notion that all power should come from the consent of the governed" became popular during the Enlightenment, when democracy replaced the monarchy as the only orthodox government structure in much of the world.


All of this brings us to the current conflict in the platform economy. More and more creators no longer trust that the decision-making of the platform is based on the collective interests, and no longer trust that the results of the platform's decision-making will make all participants get a fair return.


Not so long ago, the orthodoxy of these platforms—their centrality to creators and the attention economy, their role as the primary intermediaries of 21st century commerce Characters - still largely unchallenged. Understanding how these platforms gained legitimacy—and how they lost it—is important for understanding what needs to happen in order to resolve this crisis of legitimacy.


02. How did the platform gain orthodoxy and then lose it?


Originally, the legitimacy of these platforms came from the three sources Max Weber listed above: charismatic legitimacy, traditional legitimacy and rational-legal legitimacy.


In the early days, platform orthodoxy was largely charismatic orthodoxy: people like Mark Zuckerberg (Facebook founder) and Jeff Founders like Bezos (Amazon founder) have cast themselves as kings of tech geniuses and philosophers by painting compelling visions of the future that their creations might achieve. Platform orthodoxy also has a strong legacy bias: platforms are free to build and manage products as they see fit, since they are private companies, usually with founders controlling the board, and traditionally, private companies are structured as they see fit and the right to administer its own domain was unchallenged.


However, most of these platforms establish their legitimacy through "reasonable-legal" means - that is, through rules and regulations that everyone understands and agrees to. legal system to gain legitimacy. Through terms of service and content moderation policies, “objective” algorithms, and “impartial” oversight boards, platform creators have built what amounts to their own legal system. These systems are built to protect everyone and maintain the best community possible for all.


But over time, the flaws in the social contract between platforms and creators began to show. Changes in platform policies similar to those enacted during YouTube’s Adpocalypse reveal the extent to which platform policies and practices are designed to protect and advance the platform’s interests, regardless of their impact on creators.


Algorithms can be tuned so that platforms can give or receive content based on whether the content keeps viewers engaged and generates a steady stream of revenue for the platform. Take traffic away from creators. Data ownership policies lock creators and their audiences into a specific platform, making the platform a middleman and regulator of the relationship between the two, and the platform has the right to unilaterally determine the fees.


The result is that platforms exercise almost authoritarian control over the creators who frequent their platforms. YouTube can ban well-known creators at will; TikTok can ban its biggest stars indefinitely; Apple can decide who can be featured in its App Store, and OnlyFans can decide the ethics of its creators to appease their paying partners and investments By.


As creators begin to define themselves as a distinct category and gain recognition—as skilled professionals, as craftsmen, as Partners who regularly use the platform to provide value – they are increasingly asking themselves questions about the domain they work in and coming to the conclusion that the system is not being built in their favor. Each subsequent monetization change or policy failure has further eroded creators’ trust in the platform — not dissimilar to the series of colonial-era parliamentary acts that ended with the US Declaration of Independence.


This brings us to today, and the current state of the social contract between platforms, creators, and platform ecosystems. Today, platform legitimacy is largely dependent on traditional legitimacy—arguably the weakest of the three aforementioned sources of legitimacy, and the most easily abused. That is, platforms make their own rules, and thus set the terms of the creator economy, because that’s how it’s always been done, and because no one has come up with meaningful alternatives to the status quo.


Fortunately, this is starting to change.


03. How can the crisis of legitimacy in the creator economy end


The crisis of legitimacy can It resolves itself in two ways: either, the regime reasserts legitimacy by aligning its rule with social interests and norms (as industrial-age factories did by enacting fairer work policies); or, the system Overthrown, a new system is put in place that better links values and incentives among people to relationships of power.


These platforms have used the first route in an effort to regain the recognition of creators by increasing the various monetization channels available on the platform. Both Twitter and YouTube have added tipping features to their sites. Facebook recently announced plans to pay creators $1 billion in "bonuses" by 2022. But these realignment efforts reveal the extent to which platforms are unable or unwilling to actually change their relationship with creators. For example, Facebook's bounties will only be available to select creators and will be tied to specific "milestones" related to product and growth goals set by Facebook.


It is clear that the second option will need to be adopted if the crisis of orthodoxy in the platform economy is to be resolved: the emergence of real, credible platform challengers, These platforms offer a more democratic and decentralized alternative to the platform economies currently built.


The first generation of such companies has already emerged. Products such as Patreon, Cameo, and Substack have gained traction over the past few years by offering creators a way to generate revenue directly from viewers by targeting traditional platforms’ monetization issues for creators, rather than relying solely on platform control advertising revenue.


But as we’ve seen, profitability is only one aspect of the crisis of platform legitimacy. It’s not just about money: it’s about agency and autonomy, and the opportunity to participate in decisions that directly affect your livelihood, and it’s about breaking down the unilateral power that platforms hold as centralized points of control in ecosystems.


Fortunately, the innovations that many of the founders are pursuing in Web3 are precisely the corrections needed to introduce the platform ecosystem to address the current crisis. Founders who want to drive the next generation of platform economies should focus on three areas in particular: data ownership and portability, participatory decision-making and collaborative business models, and decentralization through Crypto and open source protocols.


1) Data ownership and portability


In the current platform economy, One of the most important sources of conflict is how data is controlled and passed on. Platforms own the data created on their platforms—including identities, content, interactions, and engagement—and by extension, this enables platforms to control creator-viewer relationships. In this model, creators are essentially captive, unable to leave a platform without losing their users and business.


An important step in reshaping the social contract in the platform economy will be to change this dynamic, giving creators the ability to own and transfer the data relevant to their business.


Next-generation platforms are already moving to a more data-portable model. For example, Substack gives authors full ownership over their readers, allowing them to take their subscribers' email lists with them if they decide to leave the platform; furthermore, authors use their own Stripe accounts, which means subscription relationships are not Bound to the Substack platform. More and more creators are turning to building their own independent properties, making money directly from users through tools like Stripe and Venmo.


In contrast to the current closed paradigm of building consumer platforms, decentralized networks (encrypted networks) are built on open data (stored on public blockchains) ) to give the user transparency and control over what's going on. For example, creators can mint NFTs (Non-Fungible Tokens)   and sell them through many different platforms, and there is no single market that "owns" that NFT. This dynamic means creators can operate outside of a particular platform and move to other networks and services that better suit their needs and values. True creator consent and legitimacy occurs when creators are able to participate in the system from a place of their free choice (rather than a data-driven lock-in).


2) Decentralized construction through open source development


Open source protocols are in the early stages of development network infrastructure, including e-mail, played a key role. Over time, open source was largely crowded out by a more proprietary model, as companies built centralized networks that far outstripped the capabilities of open source protocols (compare Facebook to email). As the current crisis of legitimacy resolves itself and the platform economy shifts towards a more democratic and representative model, open source protocols will once again play a central role.


The platform's proprietary product development is a major reason they are able to maintain control over their ecosystem. Platform owners and internal teams decide what features are developed, what integrations are available, to whom they can be made available, and under what terms creators must accept if they want to participate in the platform. This in turn has the effect of locking creators into specific platforms and prioritizing platform monetization over creator autonomy and empowerment.


Through open source development, this dynamic can be broken. Platform features will be chosen based on what makes the most sense to the community as a whole, not based on unlocking more advertising revenue or preventing users from leaving the platform.


3) Participatory Decision Making & Collaborative Business Model


I have written before , I believe true creator empowerment includes more than data ownership. In a platform economy that truly empowers creators, creators will own the platform itself.


From this perspective, encrypted tokens represent one of the most promising innovations, enabling ownership to be distributed and transferred over the Internet as easily as information.


Encrypted networks are decentralized networks that use encrypted Tokens to motivate and reward users for participation; Bitcoin and Ethereum are early examples of encrypted networks, which reward Participants start with their native Token (representing ownership in the network). DAO (Decentralized Autonomous Organization) is an online community owned and operated by its members through Token. I've compared DAOs to "crypto-native cooperatives" before. In a DAO, decisions about the direction of a community are made by its members. It’s conceivable that in the future, decisions about monetization, algorithmic prioritization, and other things that platforms have made unilaterally in the past will be made by creators and users themselves.


An example of this model is Mirror, a crypto-native content distribution platform. On Mirror, WRITEToken will allow users to become members of the Mirror DAO, who will collectively decide how to allocate their treasury funds and product development.


While cryptographic tokens provide the strongest form of distributing ownership to the community, smaller-scale As a result, this will also give creators the opportunity to actively participate in decisions affecting the platform and better align incentives between creators and the platform. One example is Airbnb's Host Advisory Board, a group of 18 hosts who meet regularly with company leadership.


04. Towards a bright future of the platform economy


A few years ago, when I first Once I was interested in Passion Economy (Passion Economy, that is, creators produce certain content and products through their own enthusiasm and preferences, and fans pay for their output) , what attracted me was that these platforms seemed Promises a new, more personal and self-directed way of earning a living outside of the traditional workplace for creators.


The more time I spend in this ecosystem, the more time I spend talking to creators, watching the dynamics between them and the platforms they use, The more I realized there was a lot of work to be done to deliver on that promise. The current platform economy—highly centralized, highly intermediary, with a few people making key decisions—has the potential to replicate the same problems in the traditional economy that have led to widespread burnout and financial instability among workers in the traditional economy and the erosion of workers' rights.


Throughout history, crises of legitimacy have often been resolved with new, more collectively representative forms of governance. That's the opportunity I see in today's platform economy. However, this is not a given: As with all change, the outcome depends on who takes the lead and the choices they make. But if the next generation of networks can optimize creator ownership and autonomy, and more representative decision-making, we will be closer to realizing the promise of a future of truly free work.


**This article only represents the views of the original author and does not constitute any investment opinion or suggestion.


Original link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit