header-langage
简体中文
English
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Coinbase report: The real "Ethereum killer" may be Ethereum itself

Read this article in 9 Minutes
If Ethereum 2.0 replaces the current Ethereum network with faster, cheaper alternatives, how much value will those L1 alternatives still have?
Original title: "Is ETH2.0 the real "ETH Killer" ? "
Original author: David Duong, Director of Coinbase Institutional Research Department
Original compilation: Odaily Planet Daily


Content Overview


- Layer 1 (L1) alternatives are gaining popularity mainly due to high gas fees on the Ethereum network making  DeFi  related transactions becoming more and more expensive;

- Ethereum is trying to solve the network scalability problem through Layer 2 solutions, and moving to the proof-of-stake consensus model and sharding;

- While this doesn't necessarily mean L1 will become irrelevant, the value of L1 may depend on how long it takes the Ethereum network to scale.


Gas fees on the Ethereum network have been one of the biggest barriers to mass adoption of ETH, and smart contract platforms in general, including Solana ( SOL), Avalanche  (AVAX) and Terra (LUNA) are the main reasons why Layer 1 alternatives are getting a lot of attention in 2021. However, the majority of active application development on the L1 network still appears to be happening on the Ethereum blockchain, which currently has $156 billion in total lockup across 214 projects — almost the top 100 in lockup. Twice the sum of the locked positions of the 2-11 blockchains. In this case, a question arises, namely: if Ethereum 2.0 can replace the current Ethereum network with faster and cheaper alternatives, those L1 replacements - the so-called "Ethereum killers" How much more worth it?


In our opinion, there is still room for some L1 blockchains in the crypto space for at least a couple of reasons, and could also compete with Ethereum coexist. First of all, although the official Ethereum 2.0 implementation schedule has been advanced to 2023 (sharding will be completed), during this transition period, the L1 network will still intervene in the network, aiming to solve the long transaction processing time and excessive transaction costs of Ethereum. high question. That said, at least for now, ETH-centric Layer 2 (L2)  solutions can play a huge role in improving throughput and reducing transaction fees.


Secondly, scalability is only one issue affecting the Ethereum network. Issues such as maximum extractable value (MEV) may not be of concern to users or investors at the moment, but as these ecosystems continue to develop, related issues may change the governance mechanism of the L1 blockchain.  Also, more complex bridging algorithms and interoperability improvements may facilitate greater composability between different L1 networks in the future.


For some L1 alternatives, we can still see the Ethereum mainnet until the Ethereum mainnet merges with the beacon chain Occupy a certain advantage, so Ethereum 2.0 will not crowd out other network development opportunities. That said, we believe that the performance of the Ethereum mainnet in the first half of 2022 will likely be largely influenced by monetary policy—in particular, ETH issued to miners (and thus ETH sales to miners) will gradually decrease due to the transition to a proof-of-stake mechanism. reduce. In our opinion, these changes will have no impact on the viability or cost-efficiency of blockchain.


However, we do believe that L2 scaling solutions, merging with the beacon chain, and sharding upgrades may limit the current development of the L1 network. For example, as the scalability of Ethereum improves, DApp users may stop looking for faster and cheaper alternatives to Ethereum. Nonetheless, we believe there is still room for multi-chain coexistence in the near term, driven by cross-chain interoperability and the possible need for alternative consensus mechanisms.


Misunderstanding: Ethereum 2.0 Timeline


In essence, Ethereum 2.0 is actually is "a set of interconnected upgrades" on the Ethereum network that allows for network scalability without significantly sacrificing decentralization or security. Considering the speed of development of decentralized applications (dapps) on the Ethereum blockchain and the rapid growth of the entire ecosystem, we believe that if Ethereum 2.0 can provide lower fees and better network performance, then it must have Potential to disrupt L1 networks.


But many market participants tend to confuse the upcoming ethereum mainnet merger with the beacon chain with the actual deployment of ethereum 2.0 itself, which is an important misunderstanding. The reality is that the merger of the Ethereum mainnet and the beacon chain will only change Ethereum from a proof-of-work (PoW) to a proof-of-stake (PoS) consensus mechanism, but in itself, it is very important for achieving higher transaction processing speed and improving transaction efficiency. Throughput, and support for lower gas costs are negligible. In fact, Ethereum network fees are primarily driven by the demand for block space, so if activity on the network picks up after the Ethereum mainnet merges with the beacon chain, then the underlying network (i.e. Ethereum mainnet) fees will actually remain the same. It is possible to continue to rise.


Monetary policy. Although there are some problems, the merger of the Ethereum mainnet and the beacon chain does not mean that the update is meaningless, because the change of the consensus mechanism may also bring about related efficiency improvements, especially in terms of monetary policy. As an example, the merger of the Ethereum mainnet with the beacon chain could mean more ETH is staked and less ETH is created (taking into account the shift from miners to validators), reducing supply on exchanges and thus From the perspective of supply and demand, prices can be pushed upward.


It should be noted that the speed of ETH issuance is also an important factor, because in the past miners often had to sell ETH to obtain funds to pay for their equipment operating costs . Thus, by our estimates, using (fewer) validators could reduce the issuance of ETH by as much as 90%, and also reduce the amount of ETH sold on exchanges by at least 30-50%, since the same as Proof-of-Work ( Compared with the PoW) mechanism, the Ethereum network after the merger of the Ethereum mainnet and the beacon chain requires less computing power (ie: lower operating expenses mean less mandatory ETH sales). This situation is especially evident after the launch of EIP-1559 in early August. As can be seen from the figure below, the flow of funds from Ethereum miners seems to be more directional.


Coinbase report: The real 'Ethereum killer' may be It's Ethereum itself

Figure 1: Net ETH inflow/outflow of Ethereum miners' wallets, source: Coinbase Analytics


However, although the merger of the Ethereum mainnet and the beacon chain can be ETH /USD sets a higher low price, but it is unlikely to improve much in performance indicators such as network transaction speed, scale or cost. So, how to solve these problems? The answer may be to split the beacon chain. Sharding, sharding is actually an upgrade that the Ethereum network plans to implement before the merger of the Ethereum mainnet and the beacon chain, but it was finally postponed to 2023 for various reasons, one of which is that the ETH-centric L2 solution has achieved good results. However, now, L2 has become the main focus of the expansion of the Ethereum network.


L2: the key to the expansion of the Ethereum network


L2: the key to the expansion of the Ethereum network


At the moment, in our opinion, the long-term viability of the Ethereum blockchain depends more on L2 scaling solutions than upgrading the underlying network. That is , in terms of attracting developers and capital, and hosting smart contract platforms, we believe that the growth and adoption of L2 solutions may be the key to determining whether these so-called "ETH killers" can challenge Ethereum's dominance.


Historically, blockchain scaling solutions have typically opted for larger blocks and/or shards, but with the advent of L2, It was discovered that there was a faster and more economical method of transaction processing. Chief among these are Optimistic and Zero-knowledge (ZK) Rollups, solutions that bundle transactions together and process execution in a new environment (i.e. off-chain), and then send updated transaction data back to Ethereum. Coinbase has discussed these solutions in depth before, and you can check them out.


Rollups can significantly reduce transaction fees, but if Ethereum implements a sharding upgrade in 2023, it may be possible by allowing Rollups to take advantage of more blocks on Ethereum Space to enhance the impact on transaction execution speed. In the long run, this is critical to the ethereum network's goal of scaling to billions of users and processing tens of thousands of transactions per second.


Coinbase report: The real 'Ethereum killer' may be It's Ethereum itself

Figure 2: Average monthly fees on the Ethereum chain, source: Coinbase Analytics


However, in our view, L2 is still in its early stages and they It may not be ready for the golden age, which is actually why they can continue to proliferate as they are regarded as "L1 replacements". For example, when transferring funds between Rollup and the base layer of Ethereum and scanning for fraud, users may wait a long time on Optimistic rollup, in some cases, it may even need to wait a week, for institutional investors Said that this situation may bring greater potential risks. On the other hand, ZK Rollups also has certain limitations in terms of supported transaction types.  


Living in a multi-chain world


With the scalability of Ethereum Challenges persist, and we believe the attractiveness of L1 alternatives in the market will largely depend on how quickly Ethereum 2.0 and L2 solutions emerge. That said, we may see continued growth in these so-called “L1 alternative networks” and cross-chain bridges in the first half of 2022. However, the window of opportunity for L1 alternatives may start to shrink significantly in the second half of 2022, as we expect ZK proof technology to improve and Rollups to gain wider adoption.


However, this does not mean that L1 alternatives will disappear anytime soon. The multi-chain world is a very real existence, because we believe that solving the scalability trilemma (scalability trilemma) is only the first step in the development of smart contract platform blockchain. First of all, as far as the trilemma is concerned, users may pay more attention to transaction speed, security and decentralization issues, and choose L1 based on these factors.


Secondly, other issues in the crypto industry have also begun to emerge gradually, such as maximum extractable value (MEV) and priority gas auction bots. MEV refers to the profit that miners and validators can extract from others due to their ability to include, exclude, order, and reorder transactions in blocks, which has the potential to create some problems for proof-of-work and proof-of-stake networks. Problems like this may favor blockchains that use other consensus mechanisms, such as proof-of-history (PoH), that do not rely on mempools and thus may be more insulated from MEV.


Third, we are moving away from the concept of facilitating composability by locking into one specific network. With the development of L1 cross-chain bridges, and   L1-L2 cross-chain bridges, assets are allowed to move across the network in search of higher yields or different liquidity pools. As interoperability and more complex bridges become more common, we could see the L1 ecosystem growing as some DApp developers may not want to compete in a crowded market. In fact, we may even see the emergence of certain L1 blockchains that focus on specific use cases, such as gaming or social media.   


Original link

a>


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit