原文标题:《Cryptocurrency、DecentralizedFinance and the Evolution of Exchange:A Transaction Costs Approach 》
原文作者: James Caton and Cameron Harwick
Ye Jian, Fintech Research Institute, Renmin University of China
Based on the perspective of transaction cost, the author provides a theoretically unified process of transaction evolution, and the current evolutionary frontier is cryptocurrency and decentralized finance. The authors show that with each new development of money, the new form or medium of exchange must reduce transaction costs relative to the related alternatives. The development of blockchains and cryptocurrencies reduces the cost of transferring money, eliminating the need to provide trusted third parties to intermediate funds, while also providing the benefits of anonymity/pseudonyms.
Similarly, decentralized financing does not require a third party to make intermediate savings and investments and can provide occasional anonymity to borrowers. These innovations can significantly reduce transaction costs and attract investment from economically advanced countries. The fintech Research Institute of Renmin University of China has compiled the core of the report.
In the typical form of money and its emergence, the adoption of a medium of exchange through a network of exchanges aims to reduce transaction costs: search costs, storage costs, transportation costs, and costs resulting from the lack of divisibility of the goods exchanged. As long as it is believed that the adoption of a commodity as a generally accepted medium of exchange can successfully reduce transaction costs and enable economic actors to obtain the resources needed for economic activity or survival, there will be a tendency to adopt a generally accepted medium of exchange.
Though seemingly unhistorically relevant, Menger's cause-genetic narrative of monetary evolution is a valuable starting point for two reasons. First, it recognises the importance of piecemeal change, guided by profit discovery. Second, these profits are achieved by reducing transaction costs. Increasing profits incentivized participants to continue to make profits, and also transmitted to entrepreneurs to imitate and develop those who made relatively high profits.
The latest frontier in currency evolution includes the growing adoption of cryptocurrencies for transactions and, increasingly, for financing. What makes digital currencies unique is that neither direct payments nor financial intermediation requires a trusted third party to conduct an intermediary transaction. For a mature cryptocurrency and crypto finance system, removing or repositioning third parties to facilitate trading and financial intermediation can significantly reduce transaction costs.
In the past few decades, people have increasingly recognized that money can reduce transaction costs, and the evolutionary trajectory of money is closely related to the transaction costs it reduces. The evolutionary approach takes into account the importance of fixed costs, which may inhibit the adoption of monetary systems that reduce marginal transaction costs.
With the advent of money, there are four types of transaction costs, namely search costs, storage costs, transportation costs and divisible costs. As the transaction costs of barter rise rapidly with increasing size, producers are incentivized to incur fixed costs of currency exchange. Menger points out that people in business seek to obtain a tradable good in exchange. Attributes that promote sales include storability, divisibility, portability and scarcity. Historically, precious metals have been used as a commodity, effectively facilitating exchange, and the cost of bartering has been too high.
Robust financial markets, one of the hallmarks of a modern capitalist economy, enable idle capital to be transferred from owners to entrepreneurs. Developing one or a few commodities for intermediate exchange greatly reduces the transaction cost of loans. Loans no longer have to be physical. Instead, alternative wealth in the form of monetary goods can be lent out.
The transaction cost approach to currency evolution helps us understand the barriers to the development of cryptocurrencies and decentralized finance, as well as the potential impact of these technologies on economic organization. Blockchain technology can greatly reduce the cost of electronic transfers and loans.
While transferring money between users might seem like an obvious application of computing technology, the incentive to manipulate accounts in digital ledgers has been an obstacle in the years since the widespread adoption of the Internet. The problem is not as simple as debiting one agent's account and crediting another. Readers can do this through excel spreadsheets or by developing a program that systematically implements transactions. Two problems stand in the way of digital currencies:
1. Any person other than the account owner must be prevented from transferring funds from the account or granting other users the right to transfer a specified amount of funds.
2. Anyone accessing the account must be prevented from double committing funds from the account. For decades, these problems were thought to require a trusted third party to manage the ledger, and in fact such trusted ledger operators emerged early in the history of the Internet. But it wasn't until 2009, with the advent of Bitcoin, that a fully decentralized practical solution was developed and implemented.
The first problem can be addressed using encryption methods that are also used to support blockchain protocols. Secure your account by blocking access unless you provide the required password. The second problem can be summarized as the so-called Byzantine general problem, because it is difficult to sequence signals from multiple sources. This problem is harder to prevent fragmentation, especially when users want to remain anonymous.
Anonymity is also a factor in some transaction costs. Just as the development of new financial instruments in the second half of the 20th century helped investors avoid certain regulatory and tax costs, anonymity and a lack of third-party facilitators who could easily be subject to state regulation could help borrowers and lenders avoid similar costs.
For the purpose of diversifying financing, as long as the loan is repaid, and if the Prophet is supported by a trusted party, this information may convey the creditworthiness of the borrower to the lender without simultaneously revealing the identity of the borrower. Information can be obtained from the traditional financial sector. This haphazard anonymity allows decentralized financial applications to reduce transaction costs by providing only the information needed to indicate the soundness of a given loan.
While the information and enforcement costs are essentially unlimited in the case of complete anonymity, those costs are greatly reduced in the event of a default because Oracle automatically reveals identifying information to lenders. So if borrowers abscond with borrowed money, they cannot simply start over. The game changed from a game of limited repetition to one of infinite repetition, as in the case of identity as collateral, equity expanded from the borrower to lender relationship to any future interaction of the borrower with members and institutions of the financial system.
As a result, decentralised financing applications can simultaneously reduce costs for borrowers who wish to remain private, while centralised control of their funds will also reduce enforcement costs for lenders. As with the development of mobile money and cryptocurrency applications in African countries, borrowers who are at great risk due to institutional uncertainty will have a better chance of obtaining loans and ensuring that the wealth is not confiscated by domestic governments. Reducing enforcement costs for lenders increases the likelihood of repayment.
Mr Coase argues that companies exist because they reduce the cost of obtaining resources compared with markets. Innovation, he notes, could further reduce the cost of organizational resources within companies. Coase then continued this intuition, pointing out that positive transaction costs can have a negative impact on economic efficiency. In particular, the clear definition and effective enforcement of property rights have reduced transaction costs and increased the ability of entrepreneurs to form accurate expectations about future world conditions. Blockchain technologies, especially cryptocurrencies and decentralized finance, will improve economic performance in both areas.
As transaction costs fell, investments that were once completely unprofitable became profitable. This is true for every stage of economic development, including those outlined here. But the development of cryptocurrencies, blockchain technology and decentralized finance is unique in how it affects transaction costs. The impact of previous innovations has often been limited by the ability to accumulate new technologies and integrate them into local economies managed by existing institutional frameworks. Cryptocurrencies and decentralized finance are emerging in a world where the modern communications technologies they require are already being adopted by many developing countries.
In short, cryptocurrencies and crypto finance have the potential to usher in an era of international financial integration undreamed of half a century ago. The new technology is the latest iteration of cost-cutting technology that promises to have the most dramatic impact on areas that have traditionally suffered from financial exclusion. There is much to be said about blockchain's impact on economic development and organizations more broadly in the form of supply chain integration, as well as the changing nature of enterprises, but this is beyond the focus of the authors' discussion.
The authors say we are seeing the first signs of the impact cryptocurrencies and decentralized finance will have on economic organization. The transaction cost framework illustrates the importance of this development and puts forward the future development trajectory.
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia