header-langage
简体中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

How can community DAO achieve value capture through self-government?

Read this article in 8 Minutes
Social media is clearly a canary in Web 2.0 in terms of heralding the modern future of community DAOs.

Original title: "From the Bottom Up: An article to understand how community DAOs achieve value capture through autonomy"
Original source: Hugh Ragsdale, Messari    
Original compilation: Dongxun, Liantoutiao


Social media is clearly a canary in Web 2.0 in terms of heralding the modern future of community DAOs. Twitter and Facebook amplified the growth of digital tribes, but also extracted most of the value from those tribes. Moving to Web 3.0, digital communities are upgraded by introducing native units (tokens). The first instances of community tokens revolved around popular celebrities (e.g. EDM artist RAC). Whether it's an off-the-shelf social media platform or a well-known career, at first, digital communities need a central group to build upon.


As exciting as superfan clubs are, they're inherently one-way. Members can buy and sell their RAC tokens for profit. Perhaps token holders will retain exclusive non-monetary perks, such as stage passes or opportunities to collaborate with artists. Dapper Labs plans to improve the usefulness of TopShots clips by incorporating them into the fantasy sports game Hardcourt. But in the end, in most cases, one party creates and the rest follow. The next evolution of community tokens needs to be more generative and inclusive, weaving a symbiotic relationship between tokens, membership, and creation. Models should be bottom-up, not top-down.


Community DAO: A New Digital Organization


Community DAOs like BanklessDAO, PleasrDAO, and Friends with Benefits (FWB) flip the script. Community DAO does not allow the parent organization to determine the spirit of the community and acquire value, but self-organizes, formulates its own guiding principles, and generates/acquires its own value. Just as children grow into adults, so do digital communities.


The origin of community DAO is the further adaptation of human beings to cloud social life.


Community DAOs are usually initiated by netizens who share common passions, skills or values, and they are cultural Schelling points (or called focal points). Holding community DAO tokens represents loyalty to the digital tribe, and the status that comes with it. Holding community tokens represents something about their online holders. The members of BanklessDAO are very different netizens from the members of Friends with Benefits. The former is focused on advocating for DeFi growth and the Bankless mission, while the latter may seek curated cultural and offline networking opportunities.


To illustrate how current and potential members "value" online communities, we'll look at NFTs, and CryptoPunks in particular. CryptoPunks are public non-productive assets. These assets have neither cash flow nor sophisticated aesthetics, and they have outperformed Ethereum over the past 180 days. Using price as a proxy for desire, this digital community of 10,000 virtual avatars is hugely popular in the crypto space. Cryptopunk is a scarce symbol of identity and belonging, a digital passport issued by and belonging to crypto elites. Because punks have zero "production value," their value comes almost entirely from the desire to be part of that community. This is the community premium.


Community DAO: Independent Value Engine


In a community DAO environment, access is scarce resource. It is the fuel that runs the engine. The emphasis people place on access is both a cause and an effect of the power of communities. In short: the community drives the value of capture, which creates a need for inclusivity and further cements the size and strength of the community.


In decoding the specific correlation between community strength and access value, we can look at FWB's hierarchical progression model. Friends with Benefits (FWB) lives on Discord as both a provider of content and a hive of community. When the first season launched, members needed 50 FWB tokens to gain access to the discord. As the community grows in size, so do the barriers to access and associated perks. Season 3 kicked off a few weeks ago and requires 75 FWBs to get in.


Those who attend the third season of FWB can benefit from some additional benefits, such as a closed IRL (in real life) event, Premium substack content along with well curated city guides. One of those perks is undoubtedly exclusivity, as access gradually becomes more and more scarce.




BanklessDAO is an extension of the mission preached through the Bankless newsletter and podcast: financial freedom and sovereignty over your assets. Although BanklessDAO pursues a different goal than FWB, it employs a similar approach to access. Only after receiving 35,000 BANK tokens, members can fully enter the DAO's Discord. Once in, member benefits include corporate wellness programs and dedicated NFT giveaways.


Additionally, contributors are organized into specialized guilds within the DAO. Everyone is responsible for charting and completing goals in certain areas, such as finances or writing. A grants program subsidizes member projects that advance the interests of the DAO. BanklessDAO eventually launched an on-chain financial product called the BED Index, which consists of equal amounts of Bitcoin, Ethereum, and DeFi Pulse Index (another index product designed by Index Co-op).


How Tokens Enhance Network Effects


How Community DAOs Develop and Other Cryptoeconomic Protocols development in much the same way. They typically bootstrap themselves through subsidies and accelerate network growth by distributing tokens to individuals with some commitment to the network. This is similar to Web 2.0's "lightning scaling" strategy, or taking losses in the short term to foster long-term adoption.


DAO resource aggregators Forefront (FF) and FWB both distribute tokens to members who accomplish goals on behalf of the community. Goals range from short promotional blog posts to designing POAP (Proof of Attendance Protocol) badges for events to building Discord bots.


This one-time contribution may seem mundane, but these commitments add up over time. As community identities materialize and member benefits expand, the value of potential nodes as part of the community grows. Community tokens appreciate in value as demand for access to the DAO increases. As the token value rises, insiders are further incentivized to improve utility and content within the network to attract new members.


If members can effectively expand the social dynamics of the community DAO, outsiders will be attracted to the network and utility. Community DAO network effects may be stronger than Web2 network effects. The Web2 network extracts value from an otherwise potentially symbiotic growth ecosystem. These values are not reinvested, but are captured by the platform and exit the system. Token-based communities enhance the network effect of the ecosystem by distributing value from the platform to community members. DAOs governed by token holders are able to reap the fruits of their labor and continue to build the infrastructure needed for growth.


This reflexivity is widely understood as one of the main advantages of cryptoeconomic protocols. This effect may be even more pronounced in the context of community DAOs. In a less technical environment, such as a community DAO, a wider membership can contribute real value to the ecosystem, providing stronger support for the community token. Revisiting traditional club membership: The real-world counterpart of community tokens is an alternate reality where members of a particular club issue shares in the parent company. If a member can strengthen the club, making its visits and own shares more valuable.


Valuation of community tokens and DAO


The edge of community tokens such as FWB nature makes such tokens difficult to value. As communities grow or become "inorganic," the inherent value of exclusivity is diminished. To that end, while DeFi protocols like Compound seek institutional capital, the adoption of these community tokens by institutional investors is not necessarily a logical or desirable end state.


Even with access to a community's Discord, the nature of these digital communities can be elusive. How can an investor synthesize the thousands of threads in the community Discord into a discourse on the long-term growth and profitability potential of a community token? How to quantify the sum of creativity and productivity of the entire community? At this stage, discounted cash flow models are hardly applicable, and most traditional valuation indicators are not applicable.


But this is the case for most start-up for-profit organizations, web or otherwise. As community DAOs mature, they experiment with projects, some of which generate revenue. The Bankless BED Index currently charges a management fee. FWB can monetize its web3 ticketing app. Other community DAOs sell members' NFTs and transfer part of the proceeds to the treasury. Whether through in-house designed products or the sale of treasury assets, the coffers of successful communities swell.


For the token to hold value in the long run, these profits need to be distributed in some way. Community DAOs may avoid distributing profits directly to token holders in the near to medium term. From a regulatory perspective, it may be more palatable to have a programmatic token burn mechanism in place.


A potential path that is more beneficial to both parties is to return value to shareholders through implicit privileges. Communities can subsidize goods and services based on the number of tokens members own. Some of these digital guilds (communities) can start to provide services on par with existing institutions, making exclusive access very valuable. In any case, the Community DAO will be as decentralized as possible by collapsing the central functionality. By returning the ecosystem to its members, DAOs simultaneously reinforce community pride and reduce the likelihood of regulators marking their community tokens as securities.


If a community DAO can thrive in bull and bear markets, its native token may prove to be resilient too. As the industrial economy gives way to the knowledge economy, social capital takes on new importance. Influencers with social capital are already coming together, collaborating and growing their networks. Trying to value community tokens purely by future earnings is a simplification that doesn't take into account the community premium.


Original link



Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit