header-langage
简体中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Tents, coin tosses, distributed backups: How does Coinbase store private keys internally?

Read this article in 7 Minutes
Go through the whole process.

Coinbase was recently "stalked" by the New York Times.


December 8, The New York Times Tech journalist Nathaniel Popper on Twitter posted that he was told by people familiar with the matter that four of the seven people who could hold the private key were among the employees who left Coinbase this fall. Therefore, he was very curious whether Coinbase was How to ensure the safety of the user's assets (he was told that there are about 30 billion US dollars).



Screenshot from Twitter


This is another serious question for Coinbase.


You know, 11 days ago, on November 27, Popper just wrote a report on discrimination against black people within Coinbase, and the New York Times published The previous "notification" forced Coinbase to respond to this in advance in order to cause adverse effects. This time, Coinbase responded quickly to reporters’ questions. Half an hour later, Coinbase Security Director Philip Martin (Philip Martin) came out to respond quickly.


According to Philip Martin, the security and availability of Coinbase's cryptocurrency storage system does not depend on any one or a few people in the company - it is managed by several teams , Redundancy is set up in terms of both personnel and systems. To explain this principle more specifically, he also attached an article "Why You Need a Physical Vault to Secure a Virtual Currency" that he interviewed in 2018.

 


Screenshot from Twitter


Because of this article, we also have a glimpse of how Coinbase, the top encryption trading platform, preserves the platform's tens of billions of dollars worth of cryptocurrency. Different from OKEx, Huobi and other trading platforms that use multi-person multi-signature methods to store private keys, Coinbase decomposes private keys and The paper holding the private key is stored in a closed physical vault - very old and traditional way.


This article comes from Wired, authored by Tom Simonite, Rhythm has organized it without changing the original meaning, and the original text can be found at the link at the end of the article.


As the Coinbase employee closed the dreary, silver-curtained tent, I was stunned by the sudden drop in cell signal strength. The fabric walls enclose a cubical space about 8 feet wide, and the grid inside acts as a "Faraday cage." The escape of the electromagnetic field, to avoid information being stolen by hackers), can block electromagnetic radiation.


When the tent is closed, I am completely cut off from the outside world. This also means that the visit has officially begun.


You may have heard that Bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies claiming to advocate monetary freedom can be traded for as little as 0.25 cents, or as large, without the need for banks. Transfers up to $250 million can also be made irrevocably in exchange for cash. But cryptocurrencies also have their own physical constraints, such as mining, which consumes huge amounts of energy, and the safest way to store cryptocurrencies is actually on an offline computer.


In order to keep users' bitcoins safely offline, Coinbase has carefully designed a process: After storing the cryptocurrency in the cold wallet, they will store the password The key is printed on paper, which is then placed in a specially designed "vault". (Sounds simple, but the reality is more complicated.)



Coinbase generates keys that can control user assets in a tent that can shield electromagnetic signals from prying eyes


Company flash (can disassembled) The open tent and what happens inside is critical to keeping the keys safe.


Earlier this year (2018), the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) said regulators were considering making "institutional investors The rule that assets are handed over to a "qualified custodian" applies to the cryptocurrency field. Coinbase founder Brian Armstrong (Brian Armstrong) hopes that his company will be ready. "A lot of institutional funds are interested in the cryptocurrency field." "They need a qualified institution to act as a custodian."

< p align="justify" line="FSKu" style="user-select: auto;">

The shielding process is the core of ensuring security. Owning control of Bitcoin or another cryptocurrency boils down to holding an encryption key, a combination of characters like this: 1A1zP1eP5QGefi2DMPTfTL5SLmv7DivfNa. From time to time, Coinbase will randomly choose a safe location in San Francisco, place such a "safe house", generate and print out thousands of keys. “It’s going to take a whole day, and we’re going to be in there until the job is done,” revealed Philip Martin, Coinbase’s head of security. After generating new accounts, customers transfer their assets to at this new address.


Martin's team isn't the only one trying to lure Wall Street's crypto assets. For example, some institutions will send their bitcoins to a small financial company called Kingdom Trust in Murray, Kentucky, which has long provided cryptocurrency custody services.



Philip Martin uses metal mesh to seal the tent



The power supply in the tent is designed to to shield against power fluctuations that could reveal information

 

After setting up the tent, the team members also installed a shielded power supply inside that can eliminate power fluctuations, and then, the printer placed on the foldable table started Work.


The process starts with a coin issued by the United States Mint. After that, all processes will be recorded on video for subsequent audit. The person in charge flipped a coin to decide which of two brand new laptops from which the hard drive and Wi-Fi SD card had been removed would be used to generate the key.


The staff first uses the USB driver to boot a Linux-based operating system on the selected laptop, and then the customized software generates the key that can control the customer's assets, and then these The key is split into encrypted pieces, which are then encoded into a series of QR codes.


After completing the complex and logical process above, the staff did an "extra" step: the QR code was transferred to an Apple laptop. what is the reason? “(Because) it’s so much easier to print from a Mac,” explained Zak Blacher, a member of the security team who led the process.


At this point, the laptop used to generate the key has completed its mission-in order to prevent the possibility of leakage, this device will be completely destroyed.


The printed paper with the QR code will be placed in a folder and placed in a secure facility somewhere in San Francisco - In theory, hackers can't get it, and the backup files are scattered on USB and hard drives located all over the world, just in case. Martin said, "[The probability of an accident is like] an asteroid hitting San Francisco."


For storing billions of dollars in just a pile of paper Confused, Martin called it for safety — an evolution of bank vaults, not a regression. "The security risk of cryptocurrencies is completely different from the previous model," he said. "We are taking the lessons of the past about physical security and combining them with cryptography."


Users can request to withdraw cash at any time, but it usually takes a day or two to get the funds, so Coinbase is not suitable for depositing and withdrawing back and forth (Coinbase has a service for institutional investors ). Here's how the process works: First, a customer logs into the Coinbase website using a USB dongle and requests a transfer.



Similar to this


Once Coinbase receives the request, it is handed over to a team to review the specifics and during the process, The platform will require a video call with the user to avoid someone or software from imitating the voice of the customer. "We want to see real people and interact (for identification)," Martin said.


The staff of this team are called "sagas" (Rhythm note: inspired by the action-adventure game "The Legend of Zelda" released in 2013 7 sage characters who sealed the entrance to the dark world in the age of sealing wars) to verify user requests. If all the information is true, they will use their own private key to notify the "librarians" who have access to the storage key file, and they will need to scan multiple QR codes to reassemble the key that controls the customer's funds. In the end, the corresponding funds can be circulated.



The 7 Wise Characters from The Legend of Zelda


For cryptocurrency companies and Attorney Alex Lindgren of Investor Services expects custodial services like Coinbase to bring billions of dollars to the crypto space in the coming years because they allow Institutional investors are more comfortable with the crypto market.


The process of using and storing bitcoin can be a bit complicated today, but that doesn’t mean it always will be. Lindgren said: "For a while after (the car) came out, horse-drawn carriages and horses were still much more efficient than cars, but as time went on, it became more and more obvious which was better."


Original link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit