Original title: "Messari Report: 2020 Q3 Public Chain War Heats Up, Ethereum Dominates"
Original Source: The Way of DeFi
Note: The original text is from Messari.
In the third quarter of this year, decentralized finance (DeFi) will undoubtedly It has become the focus, and it has further consolidated the status of Ethereum's encrypted financial center, and this largest smart contract platform will continue to absorb most of the new users, liquidity and developers' thinking in the industry.
Why not? Almost all relevant DeFi tokens run on the Ethereum platform, which fulfills the most popular use case in the cryptocurrency market (speculation). It also has a multi-year head start in developing tools and money middleware, which spurs innovation and puts Ethereum ahead of other technologically superior competitors.
Source: Messari, CoinDesk with multiple blogs
Ethereum platform even has nearly 1.5 billion dollars worth of bitcoin anchor tokens Coins, the number of such tokens has grown parabolicly (9x) over the past three months. Not surprisingly, Ethereum has the potential to become the dominant settlement layer for decentralized financial systems.
But you still can’t forget the "but", because Ethereum is the third The increase in quarterly activity comes at a price, and this price is the gas cost. The boom in DeFi, and later NFTs, has driven Ethereum network fees to an all-time high, making them too expensive for retail investors and wreaking havoc on non-financial applications. This “gas crisis” has created a perfect storm for so-called Ethereum killers, who can flex their low-fee environment and better scaling technology to attract those looking for an alternative.
Of course, there was no mass migration in the third quarter. Even if they do happen, these actions will take time. Ethereum developers have been quick to track efforts to address its scaling issues, as evidenced by the recent Optimism OVM testnet and Vitalik’s proposed rollup-centric roadmap for the Ethereum network. However, there is no mature silver bullet expansion solution yet, and it will still take several years for Ethereum 2.0 to fully land. There is still a glimmer of hope for other networks to take a piece of the smart contract market.
Q3 sets the stage for the smart contract platform race, with nearly all High-profile Ethereum competitors have all launched or will launch by the end of the year. How these projects position themselves in the community in a crowded market, and whether fees are always disruptive, will determine whether new talent and liquidity will move away from Ethereum. So far, no public chain has proven irreplaceable, and even Ethereum is not immune to competition.
Source: Messari, CoinGecko
< p align="justify" line="UXFY">Q3 is like turning back the clock and breathing new life into public token sales. After the token boom of 2017, new sales on Layer-1 platforms have all but stalled, with only six projects opening crowdfunding campaigns to non-accredited investors outside the US between early 2019 and July 2020.
In the third quarter, that number nearly doubled, Five smart contract platforms, including Flow's October public auction, are looking to capitalize on the token revival sparked by DeFi's breakout year, with sales raising a combined roughly $138 million in late July, with Polkadot and Avalanche Two rounds of over $40 million raised by Avalanche took center stage.

p>
Source: Messari, CoinList and multiple blogs
I have to say that the timing is very good. Several smart contract platforms that were once dormant have benefited from fundraising and launching when market optimism was at its peak. These projects are able to maximize their fundraising goals while achieving favorable valuations once the tokens start trading.

Source: Messari, CoinList and multiple blogs
Most early-stage tokens are in stark contrast to newly-funded tokens. The market punished tokens on public chains like Algorand and Blockstack, while Solana raised just $1.76 million because the team chose to hold their token sale the week after Black Thursday. The message was clear: Timing is everything when it comes to raising capital.
Whether the timing is right or not, these crowdfunding benefits for projects Not just money. A public sale is essential to distribute network ownership to insiders and VC backers. They also ask participants to make a pre-purchase decision, which often creates a stronger psychological connection between the investor and the stock he or she holds. A fair token distribution, coupled with a strong belief in financial upside, is an ideal way to optimize long-term community engagement. Ethereum was able to succeed because it made early investors rich. And it thrives because of the sizeable number of early contributors.
At the expense of the community, internal personnel (team, founders and VC firms) would put themselves at a disadvantage by distributing tokens. Rebalancing the ratio of insider versus community network ownership post-launch is a daunting task, and it can be even more difficult for proof-of-stake (PoS) networks. This last point is important because, outside of the Kadena and Nervos networks, every competing Ethereum network launched in the last two years uses Proof of Stake (PoS), and not every chain takes this consequence into account.
Investors should pay attention to how projects are divided between insiders and the public Token. For example, Placeholder prefers agreements where only 20%-30% of the token supply goes to founders, investors, team members or advisors. According to Chris Burniske, any project with more than a 30% allocation will lose some opportunity as we try to allocate capital and power better than the existing shareholder-driven system.

Source: Messari, CoinList and various blogs
Placeholder’s target scope may be too restrictive for a new smart contract platform, some recently launched For smart contract platforms, their insider ownership is around 43%, with only two networks (Kadena and Edgeware) below the 30% threshold. In contrast, some older and better-known projects are often split 80:20, which favors the general public. Times have changed, and ideal ratios have changed, but larger projects will need to devote more resources to optimizing transparency and community-focused incentives to offset any concerns about centralization.
However, not all VCs are inherently bad , project backers often not only bring in revenue, they can also help design key network components and fund supplementary services to provide solutions to protocol-specific problems. For example, Paradigm has funded some projects that are only marginally related to Ethereum (Optimism and Gauntlet), but they provide potential key solutions to the bottlenecks of the Ethereum network (scalability and network security).
Although any project would benefit from an influential supporters, but Layer-1 will benefit greatly from these types of VCs due to the difficulty required to migrate new networks from zero to DeFi.

Source: Messari
The road to success in the smart contract market is far more complicated than raising and hoarding large amounts of funds. Projects may be "successful" in the short term as they ride the latest market craze. But without a huge user base, they would never have thrived like Ethereum.
Ironically, the likes of Polkadot, Cosmos and Tezos While older projects gained an edge thanks to massive ICO fundraising, with some big investors turning devout supporters, more recent smart contract platforms must gain by bootstrapping actual utility (e.g., FTX-backed Serum). this level of support.
  ;
Ethereum is the main base of DeFi, and this situation is unlikely to change in the short term. However, it is inevitable that the popularity of DeFi will inevitably spread to other platforms in the end. Over the past few quarters, a number of networks have capitalized on the DeFi boom, supporting a small but growing number of financial applications that could form the basis of the first DeFi ecosystem outside of Ethereum .
As we have observed this summer, Cosmos appears to be the first A competing network that gained significant traction, Cosmos soon amassed applications like Band Protocol, Kava, Terra, and THORChain, which represent the critical infrastructure needed to build a decentralized financial ecosystem.
This list is far from exhaustive, there are over 50 other projects built on top of the Cosmos SDK, many of which revolve around financial applications. Some Ethereum-based applications have also found a way to enter the Cosmos ecosystem. For example, Aragon plans to be established on the Ethermint Cosmos zone, and Chainlink provides price feed data for the Kava decentralized lending agreement.
Cosmos’ DeFi plans don’t stop there, its community has taken initial Step, add an AMM module to the Cosmos Hub, which will enable the Hub to act as a cross-chain DEX. This upgrade has a great opportunity to improve the DeFi capabilities of the Cosmos ecosystem, while also improving the utility of the Cosmos Hub (ATOM by default). It is reported that the first iteration of this Cosmos Hub may be launched as soon as the first quarter of 2021, depending on the successful and timely Stargate upgrade.
At the same time, another well-known public chain project Polkadot )’s DeFi ecology has also begun to show some vitality.
5 different Polkadots in the past two months DeFi projects have completed financing, and they have raised a total of more than 18.5 million US dollars. Although the funds obtained by the top Ethereum DeFi protocol cannot be compared, this also shows that Polkadot has an emerging DeFi community worth paying attention to .

p>
Source: Messari and various blogs
Cosmos and Polkadot are not alone, with FTX-backed decentralized exchange Serum launching on Solana and Uniswap clone Dexter finally launching on Tezos in the past quarter. If a smart contract platform doesn’t have a DEX or stablecoin solution yet, it’s 100% in the works.
DeFi will continue to expand beyond Ethereum, however, project parties And investors should note that copying and pasting an Ethereum application does not guarantee success. These networks can fork and borrow existing code, but not user base or liquidity. The possibility of success is likely to come from building new applications beyond the scope of Ethereum's current capabilities.
For example, cross-chain exchanges like THORChain require Cosmos SDK’s Flexibility to start an independent, application-specific network. Once launched, it will unlock an otherwise untapped market, allowing holders of idle cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin to earn yield without tokenizing on Ethereum or turning to centralized custodians.
Another example is Serum, as of now, CLOB on Ethereum has been clumsy and struggled to gain significant traction, eventually ceding control of the DEX market to AMMs. In contrast, Solana’s design prioritizes scalability over low verification costs, which allows Serum to have a user experience more similar to a centralized exchange.
If DeFi on Ethereum has just learned how to run, then DeFi on other platforms hasn’t started crawling yet. As the hype surrounding DeFi emerges, Ethereum's competitors will also begin to empty their token pools to establish a parallel DeFi ecosystem. These new networks are still miles behind Ethereum in terms of developer firepower, but they can take advantage of the technical characteristics of the underlying chain by supporting entirely different solutions.
This tweet by Arjun Balaji shows that transaction fees are Duality:
As users push ethereum to its limits and set records for gas costs, it's leading some to question whether the network's fee-based design is a strength or a fatal flaw.
From a security standpoint, Ethereum is thriving: Third In the quarter, the activity on the Ethereum chain and the demand for block space were very strong, and the gas fee accounted for more than 50% of the mining revenue, which was the highest ratio in the 5-year history of Ethereum.
Although the income of miners did not exceed the historical high in 2018, due to the increase in gas prices, the block rewards suddenly soared, causing a large amount of computing power to flood the Ethereum network. In the third quarter, the hashrate of the Ethereum network grew by 35%, the highest in two years.
Because of Ethereum's ability to facilitate and encourage on-chain activity, transaction fees are likely to continue to be an important source of income for miners. If this fee environment persists, one might argue that Ethereum has achieved a more sustainable proof-of-work (PoW) system than BTC.
However, not all news is good news.
Increased transaction costs are not only a by-product of network congestion, but also A consequence of high transaction fees to increase the chances of their transactions being included in a block. Fees paid to miners are one potential source of miner-extractable value (MEV), which represents the profit that miners can extract from transactions during the ordering process. As demonstrated in the Flash Boys 2.0 paper, MEV can expose the network to consensus attacks and pose a greater threat as the percentage of block rewards attributed to MEV increases. While higher fees do not guarantee sufficient MEV, it can be assumed that growing DEX volumes (as seen in Q3) will lead to increased activity such as front-running.
Another obvious concern is that rising transaction costs may Keeping non-financial apps and retail users away also deters those on the sidelines. High fees can turn DeFi into a rich man's game, as illustrated in a recent article by Nic Carter: "As fees rise, users become reluctant to make smaller transactions" unless absolutely necessary On-chain activity and DEX liquidity adversely affected. Only speculators with deep pockets and knowledge will reduce trading profits to an uneconomical level. In short, "Without retail investors, there is no party."
Many new Layer-1 and Layer-2 platforms are being built on the premise that users and non-financial applications will tire of Ethereum's fee markets. There is nothing wrong with their strategy, and those affected by continued high costs will inevitably explore alternative platforms. Nobody wants to stay in one place out of some irrational sense of loyalty foolishly. But in fact, the conclusion that all on-chain activity will jump to the low-fee network is wrong,
There are two reasons:
The fee is only for users to engage in transactions or other on-chain activities ( Another variable that needs to be considered when considering yield farming, for example. As long as the transaction is properly sized, rational users should not be put off by losing a relatively insignificant percentage point in transaction costs. The diversified development of the Ethereum DeFi ecosystem provides an ample environment for profit opportunities, which can offset excessive fees; Ethereum seems to follow Nic Carter's fee space oscillation model, which shows that the relationship between on-chain activity and transaction fees There is a semi-predictable relationship. The point is that high fees are usually temporary and tend to decrease when the number of transactions decreases. Ethereum users don’t have to jump to other networks when gas prices spike, they just have to be patient.

Based on both views, high fees may not be as disruptive as was first thought, further clouding the outlook for ethereum's competitors. A Layer-1 network that has struggled to find its own niche may end up being a glorious sidechain for Ethereum. The activity and liquidity of the sidechain will be affected by the unpredictable conditions of the underlying blockchain and offloaded to other chains for similar purposes. This decentralization of activity can lead to undervalued networks that reward stakers with transaction fees.
In this case, the winners are the users and developers who It is possible to temporarily transfer to another network in the event of a gas crisis. Ethereum will also benefit from every blockchain linked to it. While some liquidity will leave, more will come in, and Ethereum ends up looking more like a cross-chain hub than Cosmos.
And Layer-1 want to expand Ethereum into a side chain, This will be a head-to-head confrontation with Ethereum's Layer-2 expansion plan. They will all be fighting to win the love of the same set of apps, developers and users. The recent proliferation of collaborations between Layer-2 networks and well-known DeFi applications (such as Optimism and Synthetix, or zkSync and Curve) suggests that the market share up for grabs can shrink quickly, as once one domino falls, the rest are likely to fall. Will follow soon.
Of course, the ultimate goal is not to tout Ethereum’s current market share , but for the growth of the entire market. While Ethereum is unlikely to lose much of its existing economy to another "fee crisis," in its current state it may not be able to support a large influx of new users. For new layer-1 networks, the real opportunity is to take a different approach and break into new markets. And trying to copy Ethereum and its applications will inevitably become a side chain of Ethereum.
< /p>
The next twelve months may define the smart contract platform wars, with nearly every high-profile Ethereum competitor going live before the end of the year, Ethereum Ethereum leaders have been strongly advocating for moving the Ethereum network to a Rollup-centric future. The timing is impeccable, at least until Ethereum 2.0 is fully implemented (at least 1-2 years), both solutions are now at a critical juncture to determine who may become the future infrastructure of the crypto-financial economy.
Most Layer-2 projects will start from the close Well-known DeFi applications won’t be too far away from Ethereum, and may also appear in some version of Rollup if they are completely separated from the base layer. This is also evidenced by Optimism's existing and potential partnerships.
Having said that, there are still plenty of opportunities beyond Ethereum, New Layer-1 networks can be developed by targeting niche areas (such as Flow and gaming) and bringing about radically different designs (the unrivaled flexibility offered by modular frameworks like Polkadot and Cosmos, or the private computing enabled by the Secret network). stand out.
As for which approach will prevail, only time will tell. But prioritizing community is critical, as is differentiation. The secret of success is the combination of both.
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia