Original author: Nic Carter
Original title: "Dry goods | Public chain fee cycle and negative feedback cycle (Part 1)"
Translator: Ethereum lover
In 1788, James Watt invented the centrifugal governor, a small device that made the industrial use of the steam engine possible. It applies the rotational force generated by the steam engine to the two heavy spherical cone pendulums. As the cone pendulums are rotated under force, the centrifugal force makes them rise up and pushes the lever connected to the valve. When the pendulum rotates faster, the valve closes. That's it, the governor is driven by the steam engine, and it mechanically adjusts the flow of steam, thereby adjusting the speed of the steam engine.
Translator’s Note: The general idea is that the pendulum itself rotates with the input of steam energy, but if the power of the steam engine is too large, the pendulum will reverse Turn off the energy input of the steam engine; increase the input when the speed is low, and turn off the input when the speed is high. Such negative feedback will stabilize the rotation of the pendulum cone at a certain speed.

This invention allowed the steam engine to be used in applications requiring stability and predictability speed of industrial equipment, such as mechanical textile machines. Its core idea is to design a negative feedback loop that will be generated with the input of system energy, so that it can in turn control the growth of system energy. For a steam engine, this is one of the great advantages of its design. As we have seen, a similar phenomenon exists in public chains, with more complex results.
After the 2017 boom subsided, I noticed that Bitcoin's transaction fees and transaction volume movements seemed to follow a cyclical pattern. As blocks are filled, transaction fees skyrocket, transaction volume drops, and then blocks are filled again. If I'm not mistaken, this cycle repeated 6 times in 2017.
- Chart is visible in Coin Metrics -
p>
Note that I have smoothed the average fees and volume with a 7-day moving average. Bitcoin’s “transaction fee crisis” in late 2017 is often thought of as an isolated event, but in fact, Bitcoin transaction fees have experienced at least 4 spikes, and 6 if you include periods with lower peaks. It’s just that most people calculate transaction fees in USD, not Bitcoin, so they only notice the spike in transaction fees that has been going on for a while when Bitcoin’s USD price spikes.

On average, about two weeks after volume peaks Within , transaction fees will also peak. The entire cycle takes two months to complete, but from the perspective of the whole year, this cycle is gradually shortening. As the utilization rate of block space increases, once there is a small peak in the transaction volume, the transaction fee will be pushed up to the point where traders are speechless. Of course, the transaction fee is only a sign, and the deep-seated problem lies in the block capacity.
By exploring the relationship between the block fullness of the block and the average transaction fee, we can see how transaction congestion occurs.

Through this method, we can see that As blocks get filled and stay that way, transaction fees start to rise. After the transaction fee peaked, users chose to reduce the transaction volume, and the utilization rate of the block space decreased, resulting in uneven block sizes. However, as transaction fees drop, idle block space re-attracts users, who flock to fill blocks again. Note the last transaction fee pump around January 2018, with months of full blocks and eye-watering transaction fees (whether denominated in Bitcoin or USD).
Don’t forget, SegWit (Segregated Witness) was officially launched on July 23, 2017. The block size breached the 1MB limit in the second half of 2017 due to SegWit increasing the block size (equivalent to allowing each block to hold up to 4MB of data). However, not all clients are using SegWit, so the average block size has not increased much.
Here is a flowchart describing the process of transaction fees and block space usage oscillating, like a sine wave. We can also think of it as a negative feedback loop, because when transaction fees reach a certain threshold, transaction volume is suppressed.

Just out of curiosity I pointed out this discovery , but generally found that this cycle is actually useless, and we have no way to predict the trading volume of the next week based on it. The lesson I learned from this was pretty straight forward: Once transaction fees exceed a certain threshold, users get frustrated and de-prioritize on-chain transactions, especially if transaction fees are too high relative to their transaction volume. SegWit and batching ease the situation a lot. From a certain point of view, transaction fees are self-adjusting, because it encourages large traders to be more frugal in block space consumption.
However, all of these make me more firm in my point of view, that is, expanding the throughput of Bitcoin requires a large number of delayed transaction systems, based on the trust model in Bit Transaction settlement is carried out on the currency blockchain. Another takeaway is that users have a defined transaction lifecycle, and when they experience significant transaction fee pressure, it takes a few weeks to return to their previous spending levels.
< br>
This year, when Ethereum transaction fees started to rise and surpass Bitcoin, I began to wonder whether Ethereum would repeat the same year as Bitcoin transaction fee and transaction volume cycle, and whether this cycle will have the same or even more serious impact on Ethereum, because there is a lot of liquidity on the chain (comparatively speaking, the transaction volume of centralized exchanges is basically " off the chain"). My guess is that we will see the same cycle, but the oscillations may be less violent, because the block space of Ethereum is not fixed and can expand with the increase of usage. But it turned out that the transaction fee pump was more damaging than I expected.

- Source: Coin Metrics -
Like Bitcoin in 2017, Ethereum saw a spike in block utilization in 2020 as transaction volume grew, gradually pushing up transaction fees. In mid-June, the launch of Compound’s governance tokens exacerbated this situation, putting upward pressure on transaction fees, and in mid-August, the launch of various tokens pushed transaction fees to new highs. A couple of events here are worth noting, especially when SushiSwap and UniSwap’s tokens went live and transaction fees were simply eye-watering. On September 2, the average fee per transaction on Ethereum was over $14. On that day, a total of $16.7 million worth of ether was used to pay transaction fees, far exceeding the newly minted ether ($5.98 million in total) (i.e. block rewards received by miners). Due to the increase in transaction fees, some users decided to delay transactions, causing transaction volume to start to drop. From mid-August, we entered a period of peak transaction fees, Ethereum's daily transaction volume began to decline steadily, and transaction fees peaked on the evening of September 2nd, but also began to decline.
Two days later, on September 4th, I predicted on the On The Brink podcast that high transaction fees will not only affect the usage of the Ethereum blockchain, It will also affect the liquidity of decentralized exchanges. Here's an excerpt I took from this podcast (starting at 36:30):
Nic: We saw this fee and volume oscillation in Bitcoin in 2017, and I expect the same to happen in Ethereum. Therefore, as the block usage rate rises, the transaction fee increases. After reaching a certain threshold, users will not be able to bear it, and then stop trading for a period of time because the transaction cost is too high. In this way, transaction volume and transaction fees are adjusted again, transaction fees become cheaper, people start trading again, and so on.
I think the sell-off in the market may also be caused by this. Retail investors are being forced out of the transaction fee race due to rising transaction fees. However, for smart traders, ill-informed retail investors are their favorite counterparties. In my opinion, this leads to lower liquidity.
Matt: Without retail investors, the game is not fun.
While the price dynamics of ether are hard to pin down, and I don't think ether's price volatility is the only cause of the oscillations, ether's dollar price After peaking on September 1st, it started to fall, while transaction fees remained high throughout the rest of the month.
So what happened? There are so many things. First, I think that Ethereum’s transaction fees and transaction volumes entered a major oscillation period for the first time. Transaction fees peaked three weeks after the transaction volume peaked, and then both began to decline at the same time. Even more interestingly, the average value of Ethereum transactions and the volume of several stablecoins spiked as transaction fees rose. There is a reason for this, users are more concerned about the ratio of transaction fees to transaction volume, and as transaction fees increase, they stop small transactions, and large transactions start to dominate.
This correlation is very close, which shows that users are very sensitive to transaction fees.

- Source: Coin Metrics -
This sensitivity to transaction fees is not unique to Ethereum transactions. As ethereum transaction fees increase, stablecoins like usdt see an uptick in transaction volume.

- Source: Coin Metrics -
The above can also be explained by introducing a third variable, such as the growth of liquidity mining, which both leads to blockchain congestion and attracts Big traders. This became even more clear to me after studying the composition of Ethereum transactions. Intuition tells me that small traders are discouraged by high transaction fees, but I didn't understand until I sorted out this picture:
p>

It may not be obvious at first glance, but this graph does show that as transaction fees increase, transaction volume decreases. More interesting is the dynamics of Ether and USDT transactions, which I divide in two at $500. We can see that the proportion of ETH transactions above $500 has grown steadily as transaction fees increase. We now remove the part of the contract call, and only focus on the two types of Ethereum transactions mentioned above:

- the red line is The proportion of transactions with a transfer amount of less than $500; the blue line is the average transaction fee denominated in ETH-
This is the hard evidence. Among non-contract call transactions, Ether transactions below $500 accounted for as high as 85% in June, but after the transaction fee soared, it suddenly fell to 40%. Finally, there is evidence that my hunch was right: high transaction fees discourage small transactions.
It is foreseeable that the same phenomenon can be traced in USDT, the largest ERC20 token. It can be clearly seen that as the average transaction fee climbed in mid-August, the volume of small USDT transactions began to decrease. The volume of large USDT transactions remained strong, but generally showed a downward trend, as transaction enthusiasm gradually cooled during the peak period of transaction fees.

So we have confirmed that in Bitcoin and Ethereum, the transaction fee is related to the block interval There is a clear negative feedback loop between usage rates. We already know that this cycle is about two months on Bitcoin, so what happens on Ethereum? In addition, traders obviously have a transaction fee threshold relative to transaction volume in mind, and small traders will avoid transaction peaks. This causes the average transaction value of Ether and other tokens to increase significantly during peak transaction fee periods.
But is there anything else besides these? Or is this just a repeat of Bitcoin’s 2017 cyclical swings? I bet there's something else going on here.
You must know that in 2017, Bitcoin transactions were all carried out on centralized exchanges, and the blockchain was only used for inter-exchange settlement and user access For money. The entire market is actually off-chain. Users can deposit fiat currency into an exchange account and then hold or sell bitcoin without actually using the blockchain. Therefore, when the transaction fee crisis occurs, although the Bitcoin economy has been affected to a certain extent, many users have funds on the exchange platform, or want to transfer funds in US dollars, and they can still continue to trade.
In 2020, by contrast, transactions on Ethereum (including those yield mining tokens) largely happen on-chain . While centralized exchanges are still crucial to price formation, trading volumes on decentralized exchanges like Uniswap can sometimes exceed even the largest centralized exchanges. Exchanges that use an automated market maker model do not require users to undergo KYC reviews, escrow tokens with third parties, or go through cumbersome onboarding processes, so they are much more convenient for users. The automated market maker model without the concept of an order book is also very easy to use. Additionally, certain asset and exposure types can only be traded on-chain, such as small DeFi tokens or participating in liquidity mining. As a result, the on-chain liquidity industry is booming. Since either Ethereum or Ethereum-based tokens are traded on these decentralized exchanges, transaction fees are charged for each transaction. Unlike centralized exchanges, every transaction on a decentralized exchange must be settled on-chain. Therefore, on-chain transaction fees are always on the minds of all traders.
So, instead of the cyclical oscillations that Bitcoin exhibited in 2017, we redraw a modified version to illustrate Ethereum's new 2020 dynamic.

Where does this second loop come from? Why single out the protocols with greater on-chain liquidity?
The first thing to understand is that, as Maya Zehavi stated, high transaction fees are a regressive tax on users. The so-called regressive means that the transaction fee has nothing to do with the transaction amount, regardless of whether the transfer value is 100 US dollars or 500 US dollars in ether, the transaction fee is similar (because the transaction fee is calculated based on the gas usage of the transaction, which is different from the US dollar amount of the transaction. value is irrelevant). This is similar to a sales tax that is regressive in nature. Consumption such as food accounts for a larger share of working-class income than the rich, so for the latter, the flat 5% sales tax is effectively a larger portion of their income.
For example, let’s play a game of poker, the opening commission is a fixed fee (in US dollars), not calculated as a percentage of the winnings pool . (The commission mentioned here is the operating fee charged by the casino). Players can pay a flat fee to play a certain hand, or choose to fold without paying. There was a mix of players at the table: a few pros, a few semi-pros, and a bunch of avid gamblers who didn't know much about the game. The opening commission can be set at will. To win money, you must not only beat your opponents in the game, but also consider the cost of the opening commission. That said, it's not enough just to win: you have to have a surplus after paying transaction costs.
If the opening commission is low, everyone will continue to play happily. However, once the casino becomes greedy and wants to increase the rake, players with low stacks will be more inclined to choose to fold. If a player has to pay more than 1/10 of their chip value to start a hand, they don't play (unless the hand has double aces). The general trend is that as the absolute value of the rake increases, more and more players quit the game, and the players with the least wagers are the first to quit.
When non-professional small players start to quit, the profits available to other players will also be greatly reduced. After all, semi-professionals make a living beating these smaller players. Every poker player knows that no one wants to play with semi-professionals and hard-working poker players on a Tuesday morning, but it's not the same as having a table with a bunch of rambunctious amateurs on a Friday night. You can watch them lose all their chips and crawl out of the bar.
Back to Ethereum, the transaction fee is the commission in the game. It took a lot of time. But when the transaction fee rises to an average of $14 (if it is a DeFi transaction such as buying DAI with Ethereum on Uniswap, the transaction fee will be much higher), for small retail investors, participating in transactions or liquidity mining Mining becomes unprofitable. Small retail investors had to withdraw from the market. Because retail investors are not so well-informed, they are the favorite counterparties of professional traders (leeks). If retail investors do not enter the market, the profits of the entire market will be much less, resulting in a decrease in overall liquidity and fewer trading opportunities.
Having said that, the above theories are difficult to verify empirically. Analyzing active wallets in the DeFi space according to different thresholds and responses to transaction fees, or comparing the spread to Ethereum transaction fees, may help to confirm the above conjecture. However, we can analyze several data points. First, the graph below, taken from Friedrik Haga's Dune Analytics, compares transaction volume on decentralized exchanges to average transaction fees on Ethereum.

We can see that volume and Transaction fees follow the same trend. This fits with speculation that high transaction fees would reduce usage, especially from a retail perspective.
The problem is that the causal relationship between them is difficult to infer. From this graph, it is easy to deduce that higher transaction volume on decentralized exchanges is the cause of transaction fees (and vice versa), rather than high transaction fees that reduce transaction volume. Even more interesting, the graph below shows the daily new addresses participating in various DeFi protocols compared to the average transaction fee on Ethereum (taken from Richard Chen's Dune Analytical report).

Except for the two surges before and after the issuance of SushiSwap and UNI tokens In addition, when Ethereum transaction fees rose to new levels in mid-August, DeFi no longer seemed to attract new users as it used to.
What we draw are only inferences. Clearly, small users defer transactions during periods of peak transaction fees, but the impact on on-chain liquidity is difficult to measure.
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia
