Original title: "We continue to find practical cases for DeFi: Let musicians advance their income from Spotify"
Original source: Chain News
The popular "industrial blockchain" is always tied to the alliance chain? No, we just want to tell you that it is also possible to empower the real industry by using decentralized finance (DeFi). Listen to how the founder of DeFi practitioner Paperchain achieved: Let musicians advance their income from Spotify.
Interview/Written by: LeftOfCenter
In 1997, glam rock musician David Bowie launched "Bowie Bonds", using the royalties from all his albums released before 1980 as collateral to issue bonds, which were later bought by Prudential Insurance Company for $55 million. The 10-year bond has an interest rate of 7.9%, which is about 1.5 percentage points higher than the market benchmark U.S. Treasury bond rate.
At the time, the deal was quite favorable to Bowie, because it allowed him to advance ten years of royalties and licensing fees without having to give up the ownership of his songs.

"Bowie Bond"
This is a bold financial experiment. Before this, the practice of packaging illiquid assets into bonds was only common in housing and car mortgages, but David Bowie used this method for the first time on music copyrights, pioneering the packaging of intellectual property rights into financial products. This move has won the praise of many financial experts because he truly understands the value of intellectual property rights.Today, streaming has become the mainstream mode of music consumption. According to the forecast released by the Consumer Technology Association, the US music streaming industry will reach a revenue scale of US$9 billion in 2020. However, this is not necessarily a good thing for musicians: first, the rise of streaming often causes a comprehensive impact on musicians' album sales and a sharp drop in income; what's more, due to the cumbersome income distribution process in the streaming supply chain, it takes musicians six months to get their income from streaming platforms such as Spotify.
Coincidentally, like the "Bowie Bonds", PaperChain, a startup from New York, wants to use a new financial means to advance income for musicians and labels with capital shortages, and release the liquidity and potential of these funds. The difference is that PaperChain chose blockchain, or more precisely, DeFi - a decentralized financial solution! The streaming music industry is huge, but musicians are not happyWhile consumers of streaming music can enjoy instant music and video consumption, content creators are complaining that their income payments are always infinitely delayed. People's media consumption methods have changed greatly. Just turn on your phone and you can listen to a large amount of music anytime and anywhere through streaming media. You can listen to Spotify streaming music and watch endless YouTube videos. All of these point to one keyword - immediacy. However, the creators of these media content cannot get income immediately. Compared with the immediacy of consumers getting music, the income of musicians is lagging. In fact, every time a user streams a stream, a "micro-transaction" income should be generated, and then this income will be distributed to the labels or musicians in the streaming music supply chain. Streaming music is currently in a period of rapid growth. According to data released by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), the revenue of streaming music platforms increased by 30% year-on-year in 2018, reaching US$7.4 billion. However, due to the cumbersome income distribution mechanism of the current major streaming platforms, it usually takes 3 months for the income to be distributed from streaming media such as Spotify to the label, and 6 months to the musicians.

In the streaming music consumption model, a series of processes must be experienced from the user's profit generated by playing to the final link that the creator obtains income
This problem is not just a problem in the United States, but a problem in the world. In essence, it is a problem of the entire industry structure, and this industrial structure problem is expected to be solved by blockchain and open finance.
PaperChain, a startup from New York, wants to solve this problem through the DeFi protocol. Their approach is to use data analysis to estimate the data generated by musicians on these streaming platforms, and then connect the revenue evaluation of these streaming media with efficient and low-cost sources of funds, which come from a series of permissionless borrowed crypto assets in decentralized financial protocols.
In the words of PaperChain CEO and co-founder Daniel Dewar: "We believe that decentralized finance can provide an efficient mechanism to access capital and issue low-cost loans."

PaperChain CEO and co-founder Daniel Dewar
This is not just talk, they have already put it into practice. At the 2019 London DeFi Summit, Paperchain successfully advanced $60,000 worth of stablecoin Dai to a client (an unnamed label) as Spotify revenue. Compared to the 90-day process, the entire process took less than 30 minutes and the transaction cost less than $3.
How did they do it?
So, how does PaperChain, which does not involve blockchain itself, let alone DeFi, help customers (music labels and musicians) solve the problem of instant payment?
PaperChain itself is a financial technology company that provides streaming platform data analysis services to musicians, and this is only one part of the entire solution process. From the perspective of the entire process, this is a typical case of using decentralized finance to solve supply chain finance. More specifically, it borrows funds from the DeFi lending agreement and distributes them to musicians whose income is deferred, thereby solving the supply chain finance problem in the streaming music industry.
This pilot was completed by PaperChain in conjunction with the Maker Foundation and the German supply chain blockchain project Centrifuge. This pilot took place on the Centrifuge platform and eventually integrated the Maker lending agreement to lend stablecoin DAI to the label.
As Chain News previously reported, "How to get DeFi out of the small circle game? Let's take a look at its application in the real industry". Centrifuge is a startup company that focuses on using DeFi to liberate the liquidity problem of assets in the supply chain finance link. It has been deeply involved in supply chain finance in the Internet field for many years. When it realized that the previous solution had reached the development limit of centralized supply chain finance, it turned to blockchain technology as a solution.
Specifically in this case, the Centrifuge solution process happened like this:
1. The streaming media revenue that can be obtained in the future achieves a certain value performance. This step can be achieved through the Centrifuge platform as NFT tokens.
2. Through the decentralized application called "Tinlake" developed by Centrifuge, over-collateralize NFT assets and lend CVT (collateral value tokens).
3. In various DeFi lending protocols that integrate Tinlake (such as Compound and Maker), lock CVT and lend stablecoin DAI.

The whole process of pilot operation
In this process, PaperChain, as a data analysis company, only participates in one link, fulfilling the role of underwriter and loan initiator. In other words, PaperChain will conduct credit assessment and guarantee the revenue of musicians and labels.
As an underwriter, the main responsibilities are to underwrite, evaluate and maintain asset balance of collateral, which mainly refers to the risk estimation of the future income of creators on the streaming platform, and then set the corresponding interest rate and mortgage rate, etc., to value the collateral NFT, which determines the final loan amount that the musician can withdraw. At the same time, PaperChain also performs the duties of a loan initiator on behalf of the customer and initiates the loan.
PaperChain has a set of algorithms and machine learning analysis models that can analyze musicians' future streaming income, thereby achieving accurate risk prediction and credit assessment.
Daniel Dewar said: "As more and more data is obtained, the accuracy will become higher."
In the whole process, the demand for funds is the musicians or labels. As the real borrowers, they will pay a certain cost (that is, interest rate) to obtain income in advance, and the lenders will obtain interest by lending funds. In this pilot, the lenders are the holders of MKR, the native token of the Maker lending protocol, and PaperChain, as a risk assessment and loan initiator, will extract a service fee of about 1%.
Daniel Dewar said: "For example, if a musician obtains Spotify income 60 days in advance, if the cost of funds is 8% annualized, then we will extract 1% from it."
Are independent musicians happy?
There was a popular joke called "I will sing for food" in the market, "So-called band members are: carrying $5,000 worth of instruments, driving a $500 car, driving 50 kilometers, and performing a show for only $5."
Although it is a microcosm of the offline music scene, it is enough to show how difficult the life of music creators, especially independent musicians, is.
In fact, it is very difficult for independent music creators to make music as a profession, and it is very difficult to make a living by music creation alone.

Music creators are really "southern"!
Online, streaming platforms are another important source of income for musicians, and the situation is not optimistic. Not to mention that streaming as a revenue model itself is questionable, there are also many problems in the income distribution cycle within streaming.
Daniel Dewar, founder of PaperChain, believes that the entire music industry has structural problems, that is, when streaming users enjoy instant music and video consumption, the income of music creators is delayed by half a year.
Streaming is currently a mainstream music consumption model, and the playback income is uniformly distributed to creators on music streaming platforms such as Spotify, Google, and Apple. As mentioned above, it usually takes 3 months for playback income to be distributed from streaming media such as Spotify to labels, and 6 months to reach the hands of musicians.

The process cycle of distributing playback income on major streaming platforms is different
This means that in the streaming music industry that has been ignored by the traditional financial market, there is a potential financial market that has yet to be explored. In fact, it is not accurate to say that it has been ignored, because Wall Street capital has entered this field. Unfortunately, it not only did not improve the income of musicians, but instead made them bear a huge interest of up to 45%.
In 2014, a startup called Sound Royalties was spread by word of mouth in the small circle of musicians. It was a business established by Novation Ventures, a structured fund company under York Fund, claiming to be "musician-friendly" and "a new generation of copyright financing that retains music versions and royalties."
Specifically, this company will provide musicians with quick advance payments, without complex credit checks, and without requiring musicians to give up their copyrights, so that they can obtain advance payments equivalent to loans at an interest rate of 4%.
However, in fact, they will increase the loan interest rate to 45% in disguise through a series of bad terms. Bloomberg learned through interviews with some industry insiders and information obtained from court documents that this method makes the actual interest rate paid by musicians much higher than the claimed 4%.
Generally speaking, the 4% they claim is only the rate for one year in advance, and sales staff will lobby musicians to sign longer contracts. Sound Royalties will estimate the artist's future income (for example, 3-7 years), minus about 10% of the upfront fee, and the musician must repay the advance payment with his own copyright or other income within the specified period. This money directly bypasses the settlement between the musician and Sound Royalties, resulting in the musician may need to pay more than 30% of the principal interest.
A legal document shows that record producer, songwriter and hip-hop singer Sean Garrett received $44,852 from Sound Royalties in August 2018, and he needs to repay $74,174 in the next three years.
Daniel Dewar said that long-term contracts are likely to put musicians in trouble. Although they can get income in advance, the cost is to eat up 35% or 40% of the interest. Not only that, they may also license the use of the master tape for this purpose. For a music creator, this is obviously a very unfavorable situation.
In contrast, in the pilot project conducted in conjunction with Centrifuge mentioned above, Paperchain advanced $60,000 worth of Dai Spotify revenue to an unnamed label at a cost of less than $3 (mainly used to pay Ethereum gas costs). The entire process took less than 30 minutes, and the annualized cost of funds that the label had to pay was 7%.
Daniel Dewar said that PaperChain can be said to be a provider of growth capital in the entire industry, allowing musicians and labels to obtain income immediately by accelerating the flow of funds in the music streaming supply chain. With these revenues, musicians and labels can use the money for touring, publicity, business growth and other matters, thereby bringing musicians the possibility of increasing income.
From the current role that PaperChain plays in the newly developed financial market, it can be said to be a provider of growth capital in the industry.
In addition to making revenue payments on time, Daniel Dewar also said, "We provide revenue data generated by streaming platforms so that musicians can directly participate in the market, and they don't even need to sign a label anymore." Because these musicians can directly access this data, there are many possibilities, such as selling revenue. Once the sale of revenue is combined with revenue analysis tools, revenue can be obtained in advance, and even a series of financial tools and products for (independent) musicians can be launched. The music industry is transforming PaperChain adopts a distributed office, and currently the team members are in Berlin, New York and India. As the financial infrastructure of the streaming industry, PaperChain not only represents the most forward-looking industry trend in the music industry, but also is a landing case that has nothing to do with cryptocurrency speculation, combining blockchain technology with specific business to become a real business. In February 2019, PaperChain was selected as one of the first 10 companies to be selected for the accelerator program of Techstars and Alchemist, a global blockchain consulting group. PaperChain currently has two major business models. The first is a streaming revenue pricing service based on data analysis, which charges a monthly subscription fee; the second is to integrate DeFi financing services, as a borrower and operating participant, to guarantee musicians and labels 60 days in advance to obtain revenue from streaming platforms such as Spotify, and PaperChain will extract a certain percentage of the issuance fee. The team is currently exploring other revenue models, including pricing API feeds that can be used by other companies to build services. This business strategy stems from the team's keen perception of the changing trend that the future music industry urgently needs to transform. Daniel Dewar told Lianwen that all members of the team have many years of music industry background. Among them, co-founder and CRO Dave Tomaselli launched his own independent label in 1998 and has been engaged in consulting work at the famous Mute Records for more than 20 years. Even the CTO has been a music industry practitioner for many years. He not only has rich industry resources, but also has a good understanding of the changing trends of the music scene. In Daniel Dewar's view, the entire music industry is now transforming into a musician/creator-oriented business model, which means that the relationship between musicians and labels in traditional labels will also change accordingly. Musicians are beginning to have their own teams. They work with agents to run labels. Since they can advance income in advance, musicians will be able to control their own IP and copyright of their works, and the transaction model of traditional record companies, where musicians rely on selling their IP to record companies in exchange for income to make a living, will gradually disappear. Next, record companies will focus on providing services and seeking to increase the value of musicians. Coincidentally, when David Bowie issued Bowie bonds, he also wanted to redeem the copyright of his own albums. He used the funds from the bond issuance to buy himself out from his agent at one time. After the bonds expired, he had exclusive ownership of all albums. PaperChain's target customers are these independent labels and independent musicians, rather than those large record companies that do not have an urgent need for cash flow. According to Daniel Dewar, as a business, a label must generate revenue, as little as $10,000 a year. As long as the revenue records can be tracked, these data can be used to advance revenue. PaperChain's main customers are cash-flow-positive independent labels, who usually seek quick advances of revenue to use in areas where they need funds urgently, with part of the funds used for cash flow management and the other part used to pay their musicians.Daniel Dewar told Chain News that many labels are interested in the model of "paying musicians every two weeks without disrupting existing cash flow." In addition, these labels and musicians are in urgent need of funds for music promotion and marketing.Not limited to the music industry, Daniel Dewar believes that this model can be replicated and applied to other media forms that generate rich data, such as streaming video, YouTube, Twitch, games, and applications, because as long as a large amount of data can be generated, underwriting and pricing models can be developed to create new financial products. After a long period of internal testing, PaperChain has just started to provide public services. Currently, there are 6 cooperating labels, and some labels are in negotiation. According to the data, the company currently tracks more than 78,000 pieces of music, and the number of musicians tracked is more than 13,600, with a total of 815,000 streaming auditions and a revenue scale of 4 million US dollars, and this number is still growing.

PaperChain business related data
From the perspective of cooperation platforms, PaperChain's current streaming partners are mainly Apple Music, Google Music, Deezer, Spotify, etc. Due to some requests from labels and musicians, PaperChain is currently working hard to integrate more streaming platforms. PaperChain itself is not a blockchain company, but a financial technology company that uses blockchain technology and DeFi protocols to solve practical problems. As Daniel Dewar said, blockchain is just a tool to solve problems. What is important is to really solve the problem, not which technology to use. If the blockchain industry wants to fade away the craze and bubble of currency speculation and enter the stage of moving from virtual to real, perhaps more companies like this are needed. References:
Wall Street capital Sound Royalties that makes musicians heavily in debt: [https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-04-02/hedge-fund-s-route-to-30-fees-cash-advances-to-hip-hop-artists]
The story of Bowie Bonds: [https://money.cnn.com/2016/01/11/media/bowie-bonds-royalties/]
RIAA Data report: [https://www.riaa.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/RIAA-2018-Year-End-Music-Industry-Revenue-Report.pdf]
US Consumer Technology Association report: [https://rainnews.com/cta-projects-9-billion-in-u-s-streaming-music-revenue-for-2020/]
Source link: weixin.qq.com
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia