Original Title: "The Next Frontier in Digital Privacy"
Author: Mads Pedersen
Translated by: Lynn, Mars Finance
TL;DR version:
Zero-knowledge proofs (ZKP) are obviously useful for improving scalability and privacy in web3, but they are hindered by their reliance on third-party processing of unencrypted data.
Fully Homomorphic Encryption (FHE) has brought a breakthrough, allowing for the sharing of both collective and individual private states without the need for third-party trust requirements.
FHE can directly perform calculations on encrypted data, thus supporting applications such as dark pool AMM and private lending pools, where the global state information of these applications will never be leaked.
The benefits include trustless operations and on-chain state transitions without the need for permission to encrypt data. The challenges lie in computing latency and integrity.
The main participants in the emerging FHE cryptocurrency field are focused on developing private smart contracts and specialized hardware acceleration for scalability.
The future FHE encryption architecture has the potential to directly integrate FHE rollups on Ethereum.
"One of the biggest remaining challenges in the Ethereum ecosystem is privacy (…). Using a full suite of Ethereum applications involves exposing a large part of your life to be viewed and analyzed by anyone." - Vitalik
For at least the past year, zero-knowledge proofs (ZKP) have been the darling of the cryptography industry, but they also have their limitations. They are valuable for privacy, proving knowledge of information without revealing it, and scalability, especially in zk-rollups. However, they currently face at least some major limitations:
(1) Hidden information is usually stored and computed off-chain by trusted third parties, limiting the permissionless composability that other applications require to access this off-chain data. This server-side proof is similar to systems like web2 cloud computing.
(2) State transitions must be completed in plaintext, which means that users must trust third-party verifiers who possess unencrypted data.
(3) ZKP is not suitable for applications that require knowledge of shared private states to generate proofs related to local private states.
However, any multi-party use case (such as dark pool AMM, private lending pool) requires on-chain sharing of private state, which means that using ZK requires some kind of centralized/off-chain coordinator to achieve shared private state, making it cumbersome and introducing trust assumptions.
Fully Homomorphic Encryption (FHE) is an encryption scheme that allows computations to be performed on data without the need for prior decryption. It enables users to encrypt plaintext into ciphertext and send it to a third party for processing without the need for decryption.
What does this mean? End-to-end encryption. FHE allows for sharing private states.
For example, in AMM, decentralized liquidity provider accounts interact with each transaction, but do not belong to any individual user. When someone exchanges token A for token B, they must understand the existing amounts of both tokens in the shared liquidity provider account to generate a valid proof of exchange details. However, if the global state is hidden through a ZKP scheme, generating such proof will no longer be feasible. Instead, if the global state information is publicly accessible, other users can infer details about individual exchanges.
Using FHE, it is theoretically possible to hide shared and personal states, as it can be proven through encrypted data calculations.
除了 FHE 之外,实现隐私圣杯的另一个关键技术是多方计算(MPC),它解决了对私有输入进行计算的问题,并且仅公开这些计算的结果,同时保留了输入的机密性。但是,我们将其留待另一次讨论。我们这里的重点是 FHE——它的优点和缺点、当前市场和用例。
Translation:Aside from FHE, another key technology for achieving the holy grail of privacy is multi-party computation (MPC), which solves the problem of computing private inputs and only reveals the results of these computations while preserving the confidentiality of the inputs. However, we will leave this for another discussion. Our focus here is on FHE - its advantages and disadvantages, current market and use cases.
It is worth noting that FHE is still in the early stages of development. This is not a tribal issue between FHE and ZKP or FHE and MPC, but rather an additional feature unlocked when combined with currently available technologies. For example, privacy-focused blockchains can use FHE to enable confidential smart contracts, use MPC to distribute decryption key shards among validators, and use ZKP to verify the integrity of FHE computations.
At this time, the benefits of FHE include:
1. No third-party trust requirements. Data can be kept secure and private in an untrusted environment.
2. Through the composability of shared private states.
3. Data availability while maintaining data privacy.
4. (Ring) Quantum resistance of LWE.
5. Can perform on-chain state transitions on encrypted data without permission.
6. No need for hardware and centralized supply chain that are vulnerable to side-channel attacks like Intel SGX.
7. In the context of fully homomorphic EVM (fhEVM), there is no need to learn how to perform repetitive mathematical multiplication (such as multi-scalar multiplication) or use unfamiliar ZK tools.
At the same time, any developer who wants to get their hands dirty or earn money through bounty hunting can try Fherma's FHE Challenge and win several four-figure bounties.
Acknowledgements: Many thanks to Gurgen Arakelov (Founder of Yasha Labs/Fherma), Rand Hindi (Founder of Zama), Remi Gai (Founder of Inco Network), and Hiroki Kotabe (Head of Research at Inception Capital) for their contributions to this article.
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia