header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Binance hit with a $4 billion fine, was SEC the mastermind behind it?

Read this article in 9 Minutes
The US Department of Justice is seeking over $4 billion in fines from Binance as part of a proposed settlement for its years-long investigation.

Author: Jaleel, Jack, BlockBeats

Editor: Jack, BlockBeats.


This is another formal attack by US regulators on Binance, and a $4 billion fine is finally coming.


On November 21st, according to sources cited by Bloomberg, the US Department of Justice is seeking over $4 billion in fines from Binance as part of a proposed settlement to end a years-long investigation.


Binance has not responded to multiple requests for comment via email and phone. The US Department of Justice has also declined to comment. According to sources familiar with the matter, the announcement may be released as early as the end of this month, although the situation remains uncertain. These individuals have requested anonymity to discuss confidential matters.


A "hefty fine" of 4 billion yuan, such a large amount of fines, can be said to be one of the largest-scale investigations conducted by the US Department of Justice against cryptocurrency companies. If Binance and the US Department of Justice agree to a deferred prosecution agreement, the Department of Justice will bring criminal charges against the company. As long as the company meets the specified conditions, including paying a large amount of fines and agreeing to a detailed statement of its improper behavior, the United States will not continue to prosecute. A program will be established to monitor the company's compliance.


Insiders revealed that official news may be released as early as the end of this month, but it is still uncertain. The specific time, structure, and cost of the proposed resolution are unclear. The agreement aims to achieve a balance that allows Binance to continue operating without risking collapse, thereby reducing the negative impact on the market and cryptocurrency holders.


June SEC Lawsuit Against Binance


On June 5th of this year, Binance Holdings Limited (hereinafter referred to as "Binance"), a cryptocurrency trading platform, and its CEO Zhao Changpeng (hereinafter referred to as "CZ"), were sued by the US Securities and Exchange Commission (hereinafter referred to as "SEC" or "Commission") for allegedly violating securities trading rules. This is the second time that Binance and its CEO CZ have been sued by US regulators, following a lawsuit filed by the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) on March 28th for allegedly violating trading and derivatives rules, which caused a significant fluctuation in the cryptocurrency market.


SEC accuses Binance Holdings Limited, BAM Trading Services Inc. (referred to as "BAM Trading" below), BAM Management USA LLC (referred to as "BAM Management" below), and CZ of violating federal securities laws and disregarding investor protection. The defendants are accused of illegally promoting cryptographic asset securities to US investors and issuing and selling cryptographic asset securities and other investment plans multiple times on the unregistered online trading platforms of Binance.com and Binance.US. The defendants are said to have made billions of dollars in profits through this method, while putting investors' assets at significant risk.


Related reading: "SEC sues Binance, key details in original document".


Early the next morning, Binance responded to a series of accusations made by the SEC and emphasized the safety of assets on the Binance platform. The response expressed dissatisfaction with the SEC's "tough regulation" and pointed out that the SEC's actions were aimed at gaining an advantage in the tug-of-war with other regulatory agencies, rather than protecting investors. In the official response announcement, Binance stated:


"Although we take the SEC's allegations seriously, Binance should not be the subject of SEC enforcement actions, let alone in an emergency situation. We strive to fully defend the Binance platform. Unfortunately, the US SEC has refused to engage in productive dialogue with Binance, which is just another example of the SEC being misled and subconsciously refusing to provide much-needed clarity and guidance for the digital asset industry."


Today's action is another example in a series, like other encrypted projects facing similar lawsuits, the SEC has decided to use the blunt weapons of law enforcement and litigation for regulation, rather than taking a more thoughtful and meticulous approach. Unilaterally designating certain tokens and services as securities - even those that other US authorities have claimed jurisdiction over - will only make these issues more complex.


Perhaps the most surprising thing is that the SEC's actions have weakened the United States' position as a global center for financial innovation and leadership. In most parts of the world, digital asset laws are still largely undeveloped, and enforcement is not the best way forward. An effective regulatory framework requires cooperation, transparency, and thoughtful policy engagement - a road that the SEC has abandoned.」


Related reading: "Binance responds to SEC allegations: platform funds are safe, SEC's tough regulation will make the situation more complex".


On June 14th, the federal judge overseeing the Binance and BinanceUS cases, responsible for supervising the US Securities and Exchange Commission, refused to issue a temporary restraining order freezing the assets of the US trading platform. Judge Amy Berman Jackson of the District of Columbia District Court said that "there is absolutely no need" for a restraining order. At the same time, the judge ordered BinanceUS to provide the court with a list of its business expenses and ordered both parties to continue negotiations.


Earlier in the day, the judge hinted that she may be inclined to impose some form of restriction on Binance's access to BinanceUS assets, but not a complete injunction, ordering the company to coordinate their proposed restrictions and ordering the SEC to use the company's proposal instead of the injunction itself. SEC lawyer Jennifer Farrel told the judge on Tuesday, "We are open to continuing to operate the business."


BinanceUS representatives stated that they mainly hope to obtain normal operating expenses, and they "do not want to accept the death penalty represented by asset freezing." According to SEC lawyers, BinanceUS also told the US Securities and Exchange Commission that it may stop operating in the United States, which prompted the need for an emergency freeze order. BinanceUS lawyers stated that the exchange needs to have the ability to pay normal business expenses, such as rent, salaries, suppliers, and software licenses. "The area that surprises us is asset freezing, which will be misunderstood by banks," the judge agreed. "Completely shutting it down will not only have a significant impact on the company, but also on the entire digital asset market," she said at the hearing.


Judge Jackson said that ultimately the differences between the two sides are not significant. If they can reach an agreement, it will give all parties time to properly organize the details of the case. She referred them to a local judge to reach a settlement agreement. The judge stated that if an agreement is reached, she will no longer need to make a ruling on the SEC's temporary restraining order request.


Binance has proposed a compromise solution in response to the asset freeze request from the SEC, which includes transferring the cryptocurrency assets of US customers to a new wallet with new private keys that will be controlled separately by BinanceUS's US staff. The US Securities and Exchange Commission has requested in a compromise proposal submitted to the court that Binance repatriate customer assets to the US, where these assets will be controlled by entities beyond CZ's control and can be used to process redemptions for customers.


Related reading: "Binance Hearing: Judge Refuses to Freeze Assets, Will Discuss Securities Definition with SEC".


SEC investigates Binance for what reason?


In the previous confrontation between SEC and Binance, although a Washington DC judge encouraged Binance to cooperate with SEC and provide more information on how Binance.US handles customer assets, Binance.US holding company BAM stated that SEC's requirements for the documents are "too broad and burdensome", implying that it is difficult to cooperate.


According to a court document dated September 18th, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has launched an attack on Binance.US's asset custody "instability", urging the Washington DC court to approve an inspection of Binance.US and reiterating that the company's pledge, settlement, and brokerage services violate federal securities regulations and that Binance.US is not cooperating with the SEC's investigation.


The negotiations between the Ministry of Justice and Binance this time include an agreement that its founder CZ may face criminal charges in the United States to resolve an investigation into suspected money laundering, bank fraud, and violation of sanctions. The investigation is jointly led by the Money Laundering and Asset Recovery Section of the Criminal Justice Department, the National Security Division, and the US Attorney's Office in Seattle.


























Regulatory fines are becoming more expensive?


Compared to this, Coinbase's previous $100 million fine seems insignificant.


According to BlockBeats, on January 4th, cryptocurrency trading platform Coinbase announced a settlement agreement with the New York State Department of Financial Services. They agreed to pay a $50 million fine and committed to investing $50 million to strengthen their compliance program, which aims to prevent potential violators from opening accounts in New York State.


Previously, the New York State Department of Financial Services found that Coinbase allowed customers to open accounts without conducting sufficient background checks, which the department claimed violated anti-money laundering laws. According to the Department of Financial Services, as of the end of 2021, Coinbase had a backlog of over 100,000 alerts about potentially suspicious customer transactions that were not properly reviewed. Regulators also found that Coinbase only conducted basic "KYC" checks on individuals before allowing them to open accounts, and criticized the trading platform for treating customer background checks as a "simple checkbox exercise".


The amount of the $4 billion fine that Binance received is only comparable to the settlement amount with the bankrupt cryptocurrency lending platform Celsius Network.


According to BlockBeats, on July 13th, the bankrupt cryptocurrency lending platform Celsius Network was banned from trading by the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and fined $4.7 billion. Celsius and its affiliates agreed to the judgment. Celsius stated that the $4.7 billion settlement agreement reached with the FTC will not affect its restructuring or the recovery of assets for its customers.


Related reading: "Will Binance settle with SEC? Take a look at the well-known projects that have been fined by SEC in history."


Although Binance is facing a $4 billion fine, optimistically speaking, this is also a way for regulators to offer a settlement.


According to most insiders, the agreement between regulators and Binance aims to achieve a balance that allows Binance to continue operating without risking a potential market and cryptocurrency holder negative impact or causing a collapse. The founding partner of Castle Island Ventures also stated that "reaching a settlement with the US Department of Justice that includes regulatory terms may be a compromise that protects investors and allows Binance to move towards a more institutionalized and compliant future direction."


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit