Original author: Jameson Lopp
Translated by: Eric, Foresight News
In the past decade, the scale and complexity of the cryptocurrency ecosystem have exploded. Although the vast majority of projects can be said to be scams or have very bad ideas, one percent of projects have managed to innovate and find products that are suitable for the market.
Bitcoin maximalism has also undergone an evolution as a result, but with the emergence of forks, it has become more complex. Unfortunately, as I will explain throughout this article, certain aspects of the well-known "maximalist culture" are not conducive to the adoption of Bitcoin.
This article will discuss:
Bitcoin Maximalism: Milestone Events in History
Pros and cons of variations and misconduct of the supremacy of description.
Long before the "Bitcoin Twitter" community formed, the BitcoinTalk forum was the hub of Bitcoin discussion and culture. It was a simpler time, with hundreds of new networks launching and their creators regularly posting [ANN] threads on the altcoins board to promote them. Almost all of these projects were simple modifications of the Bitcoin codebase, with changes primarily focused on marketing and lacking substantial content. The term "shitcoin" also first appeared in the context of creating worthless Bitcoin clones:

Most of the counterfeit currencies are pumped up and sold, and with a large number of Bitcoin users being deceived and harmed by unfair economic models, a defensive culture has emerged. We agree that "pre-mining" tokens allocated to internal personnel is unethical, and many people believe that even if counterfeit currencies manage to innovate and create value, this innovation will eventually be absorbed by Bitcoin, so they may be seen as Bitcoin test networks and abandoned. Counterfeit currencies include scams and some meaningless attempts, and these currencies are all junk currencies that are not suitable as sound currencies or investments.
Extremism definitely existed in the early days, even though the term had not yet been coined. When faced with worthless altcoin projects, minimalists tend to firmly say "no, thank you". Many of us find it distasteful that some people believe they can get rich quick from Bitcoin copycats.

In the early days of protocol development in the Satoshi era, when Gavin Andresen was the project maintainer, there wasn't actually much organized development team. Everyone who contributed to the codebase was a volunteer - there was no money to fund development. Therefore, Bitcoin needed a developer culture. One way to attract and retain contributors is to describe altcoins as useless scams (which they are) to prevent people from joining other projects.
In the first few years, various aspects of the network were weak, so it was very important to avoid the vampire effect of counterfeit coins. Without the above methods, the development of Bitcoin may not have achieved self-guidance in the next few years. We have seen a significant improvement in the understanding of the advantages and disadvantages of the protocol by the talent pool.
By 2014, Bitcoin had a group of quite active technical contributors. After the release of the Sidechains Whitepaper, the future began to look bright: we finally found the answer to how people can innovate within the Bitcoin ecosystem without risking harm to Bitcoin itself. In 2015, the Lightning Network Whitepaper demonstrated further innovation in low-latency, high-volume transactions. Maximalists were pleased, as the super-bitcoinization was clearly underway.
Of course, just a few months later in 2015, we saw the launch of Ethereum, which introduced a completely new approach to cryptographic asset protocols. This marked a significant shift in the development of cryptographic asset protocols.
Mircea Popescu was a leading figure in the early days of Bitcoin maximalism, even before it became a term. He was a prolific writer who spread some ideas that have had a lasting impact. At least some of his followers from La Serenissima are still active today and have gained influential positions on social networks...
Mircea's followers, sometimes referred to as #bitcoin-assets residents (their space on IRC), have formed a unique culture. In their eyes, if you don't have a GPG key on the WoT (Bitcoin-OTC Trust Network), then you are not "one of us". If you do successfully join the WoT, then you need to engage in meaningful interactions and transactions to get recommended by other WoT users through positive feedback.
Popescu is the administrator of this IRC room. If you are not accustomed to their culture, do not understand their jargon, and have a low tolerance for prejudice, misogyny, and racism, you may feel uncomfortable. Mircea does not value his communication effectiveness and will make statements in an exaggerated and difficult-to-understand manner without caring about how others interpret them. For example, in his article opposing segregation witnesses, he decided to explain his point of view by offering a reward for assassinating a protocol developer. Although he did this to make an interesting point about verifiability, due to his shocking values and lack of detailed explanation, most readers did not notice this point.
The #bitcoin-assets team is strongly opposed to any changes to Bitcoin, so much so that they forked Bitcoin Core 0.5 and created the "real" Bitcoin Foundation, maintaining their own full node implementation.
Due to the high level of friction and inadequate external communication, this group remains quite niche. Although Mircea himself was unable to expand his influence beyond IRC rooms (he was banned from using Twitter for making death threats against Andreas Antonopoulos), some of his actions have been imitated by followers on other platforms...

Vitalik Buterin popularized the term "Bitcoin maximalism" in 2014:
"Recently, there has been a new idea that has attracted some attention in parts of the Bitcoin community, which I and others have described as 'Bitcoin maximalism' - essentially, this ideology believes that having a competitive environment of multiple cryptocurrencies is undesirable, and launching 'alternative tokens' is wrong, and that Bitcoin's monopoly position in the cryptocurrency field is legitimate and inevitable."
Although Buterin did not create this term (as you can see from his previous blog post), he did play a role in positioning Ethereum and its views on cryptocurrency as mainstream views at a time when "altcoins were considered immoral scams". The term maximalism is clearly intended to warn against a certain closed-mindedness or lack of imagination in the Bitcoin community, and can even be seen as anti-free market.
In the next few years, with the launch of countless projects, some Bitcoin maximalists have updated their views and become more nuanced in their stance, but still consider themselves Bitcoin maximalists because Bitcoin is clearly different from all other projects and has no real competition in the currency field. The views of other extremists have become even more extreme, as they believe that everything outside of Bitcoin is actually a scam and focus on shaping the narrative to support this view.
By 2015, we saw a large-scale migration from BitcoinTalk to Reddit forums, which had already accumulated over 150,000 subscribers (now nearly 5 million). Although BitcoinTalk did have administrators, it was also a forum composed of many sections for different topics, so you didn't need to be too restrained as long as you posted in the appropriate section. Reddit, on the other hand, is a platform with moderators and rules for different sections, and content visibility can be modified through voting. I see Reddit as a platform for incentivizing group thinking and emotional feedback rather than rational speculation. The end result is that large sections inevitably become "echo chambers," and if you try to discuss a conflicting idea, your post will be downgraded and forgotten without much discussion.
Due to the increasing debate surrounding how to promote Bitcoin scalability, the moderators of /r/bitcoin have decided to ban discussions on the proposed hard fork. The "technological maximalism" (where everything will become a Bitcoin sidechain) has become a turning point as it imposes its views on mainstream discussions. Why? Because the r/bitcoin moderators are influenced by Theymos and are immersed in technical discussions on the development mailing list. Therefore, they have simply brought their standards to more followers on Reddit.
Naturally, the decision by /r/bitcoin mods to ban discussion of certain topics has sparked strong opposition and prompted many to migrate to the /r/btc board. Now, 7 years later, /r/btc users are still "howling" over losing the scaling war due to the "censorship regime". If you want to delve deeper into their dissatisfaction, you can check out "A History of Censorship in /r/Bitcoin". Personally, considering that discussions about Bitcoin scaling are taking place on various platforms that are not run by Bitcoin supporters, such as Twitter, I think it's foolish to dwell on this. The point is: anyone who cares about the scaling debate is well aware of both sides' positions.
The history of redefining derogatory terms through culture is long-standing. I believe this also applies to Bitcoin maximalism, as we are talking about ideological differences: what many find repulsive, others find highly desirable. I also believe that while minimalism is one way to navigate the crypto ecosystem, it is also an ideal. Please remember that Vitalik's use of this term was for "maximizing dominance," meaning that the crypto ecosystem would be dominated by Bitcoin. Although Bitcoin undoubtedly still dominates 14 years later, it is not as desired by many minimalists as they had hoped.
During the scaling war and the 2017 ICO frenzy, the use of the term "Bitcoin maximalism" regained its significance. It seems that in mid-2018, the use of the term "toxic" Bitcoin maximalism as a descriptor began to truly resurface. It is worth noting that Bitcoin maximalists were later vindicated when it was discovered that 80% of ICOs were scams.

In the scaling debate, we saw Samson Mow start producing hats as a new form of social signaling. The first hat was "Make Bitcoin Great Again" and "Make Ethereum Immutable" (mocking The DAO fork event).

The hat manufacturer Mow has sold more than 10 styles in the next few years; at the end of 2019, we saw Samson Mow wearing a "toxic extremist" hat because this word was used more frequently - this is a social signal that indicates which camp you belong to, using only Bitcoin or using multiple tokens.

Fairly speaking, the redefinition of extremism around 2017 was a resurgence of the ideology. This was a response, partly due to the fact that the promise of innovation explosion related to Bitcoin through sidechains by technical extremism did not materialize. However, compared to the stagnation of sidechains, Ethereum and other protocols have seen an increase in adoption and iteration of new features. As the argument of technical extremism gradually becomes untenable, people need a new narrative that can succeed without sidechains. This is the resonance provided by Mircea's adoption of his style by #bitcoin-assets users and its imposition on the discussion.
By redefining this pejorative term, Bitcoin holders use it as a social signaling mechanism. We can also see extremists sending similar signals when expressing the view that "Bitcoin is not a cryptocurrency." While technically inaccurate, it implies a deeper significance of the differences between Bitcoin and all other cryptographic asset protocols.
In 2018 and 2019, we saw the emergence of the prototype of becoming the cornerstone of the next round of typical Bitcoin maximalism. The Bitcoin standard was released, and countless new memes were created and entered people's vision.
The Bitcoin scaling war did not end with a bang, but rather with a whimper over the course of several years. By 2020, it was clear that the numerous large-block Bitcoin forks did not have strong appeal. Many OGs who were once actively involved in the scaling debate grew tired, but this provided an opportunity for newcomers to fill the void. Soon after, the COVID-19 pandemic presented an opportunity as many authoritarian regimes came under fire and the printing presses went into overdrive.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, we have witnessed the accelerated development of extreme lifestyles, which are attributed to the strengthening of certain extreme cultures (such as "laser eyes" and political populism).
It should be noted that I myself have also participated in some of the aforementioned activities, which is not a judgment on any of the aforementioned topics.
The COVID-19 pandemic has greatly accelerated the evolution of Bitcoin maximalist ideology, shifting from traditional face-to-face activities to new media forms such as virtual reality. The chaos caused by the pandemic has made it crucial to explore alternative content distribution channels, with those who participate through social media being the main beneficiaries. A large number of newcomers with limited knowledge of Bitcoin have taken the lead in these new arenas, while other Bitcoin enthusiasts seek information and entertainment on these platforms. Due to the borderless nature of Bitcoin interest groups, Bitcoin enthusiasts have gained the upper hand in this new era of network interaction. Early Bitcoin users were often smart and unconventional thinkers who enjoyed discussing authoritarianism related to the pandemic and constantly innovating.
The travel restrictions during the pandemic have also played an important role in directing people's attention towards the United States. This helps to enhance the image of Americans who are less affected by the lockdown, making the narrative after 2020 largely inclined towards digital gold. This statement is not new for Bitcoin (it has always been dominant), but logically, it is more attractive to first-world people who can use modern financial infrastructure and those who need to pay US taxes.
During this period, I also observed the accelerating trend of "thought leaders". I saw educators and builders being overwhelmed by those who seemed to be artists and performers. Despite only providing superficial content, those who are good at "growth hacking" have accumulated a large audience. This situation had already appeared before the epidemic, but now it is even more serious.
The problem is (and still remains) that the lessons from the "scaling war" are very complex and not easily understood. If you want to increase your engagement and influence on social media networks, this content may not be suitable for you.
What happened after
?
The new platform focuses on storytelling. Some "old-timers" have started telling "great war stories" to naive newcomers. Later, the newcomers begin to participate in oral storytelling, recounting the traditions of the previous generation. However, they lack first-hand information, so their perspectives lack any innovation and are like copies.
These platforms (Clubhouse, Spaces) are designed with an economics model for lengthy monologues, thus their participation mechanisms will only further stimulate this behavior.
The mainstream Bitcoin culture is such that the expression of ideas (as seen in the 2017 debate) has degenerated into a rehashing of old stories. The old enemies have been replaced by new enemies that better fit the current trend, but we have retained the "Bitcoin players vs the world" mentality of the past, which has led many newcomers to excessively defend their beliefs. It is worth noting that this is a recurring cycle, as in 2017 people talked about how great the 2014 discussion was, while in 2014 people reminisced about the 2011 discussion. This is a natural phenomenon that occurs as a community transitions from being niche to mainstream.
translates to
The extremism of toxic extremists makes many moderate supremacists uncomfortable. Those extremists who dare to speak their minds have accumulated a large audience, and they must make a decision: continue to talk about what they find interesting and accept insults, or self-censor and limit themselves to the echo chamber of Bitcoin? From a cultural perspective, this is somewhat regrettable, and when some public figures succumb to the captives of the audience, it is bound to have a cicada effect.
Some moderate extremists have turned into provocateurs of extreme factions, known as "Antima," who enjoy pointing out the weaknesses/hypocrisy/disgusting behavior of even more extreme extremists and using any means possible to provoke them. Today, this includes "using" Bitcoin (such as Bitcoin NFTs) in ways that pure extremists would hate.

Source Link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia