Original author: Lao Bai
Today I will talk about the issue of Sequencer decentralization, including consensus and Token.
As mentioned in the previous post, Sequencer's ability to do evil is not to print money out of thin air or submit fake transactions, but to hide transactions or change the order of transactions during a relatively short window (a few minutes to 10 minutes) when the data has not been submitted to L1.
Isn't it really a question of censorship and Mev?
清楚了这一点,我们再来看 Sequencer 的去中心化,该用什么共识,就清楚多了 首先,不能用什么共识机制?
Basically most Layer1 consensus mechanisms don't work! Since you are a Layer2, not a Layer1, and your purpose is to improve the efficiency and TPS of Layer1 in a disguised way, your own use of Layer1 consensus completely loses the meaning of Layer2.
What does Layer1's consensus mechanism look like? Originally it was Everybody-talks-to-everybody (each node communicates with each other to agree on something) + Everybody-sends-everyone-else-everything (each node sends all data to the other node - broadcast). Because it's Everybody, it's slow.
Then came Solana, which pursued the ultimate performance, and tried to change some of the "Everybody" to "Somebody". In this way, it would take less time to reach a consensus, and less things would be transferred, so TPS would go up!
Layer2 should be a little more extreme than Solana, because there is no need for a true "consensus" on Layer2, just to prevent the centralized Sequencer from having the ability to censor and MEV. At the same time, the performance of Sequencer must be better, because it will deal with a large number of transactions. Therefore, the decentralization of Sequencer must be a "semi-centralized" state of a small number of high-performance nodes, with the messages that need to be synchronized between them as few and as fast as possible.
There are two consensus ideas.
1. Find several powerful nodes and make blocks in turn, no matter by following or drawing lots, it is just a Style of Sequencer small groups making blocks together and supervising each other. At present, the only Layer2-Metis who has decentralized Sequencer basically did this. However, if you want to join this small group, you need to apply for + official approval, so it is similar to semi-centralized, or alliance chain Style.
2. ETH Layer1 is working on the memory pool encryption technology. If all transactions are encrypted, the packaging node is faced with encrypted data. But exactly how to do that is completely open. I think it can be implemented at both protocol level and App level, just like PBS, which does not have protocol level for the time being, Flashbot has made an App level to use first.
In theory, Layer2 is more suitable for this technology, because with this, even the small Sequencer team does not need it anymore, instead, it just uses an ultra-high performance server to solve the problem! Add hot spare, load balancing and other Web2 server redundancy technologies at best.
If there is a consensus, there must be a Token (well there is no consensus Layer2 will have a Token...) What the Token on Layer2 should be used for has been a point of debate. As a whole, it can be selected from the following three functions.
1. POS - is equivalent to simulating the POS of Layer1, which is mainly used by Layer2 itself as DA. ZK-sync's Zk-Porter and Starknet's Validium will probably do this.
2. Gas - The simplest technology, the most straightforward power, and yet the most opposed. For a Layer2 you do not use ETH as Gas, instead you use your own Token, ideologically and politically incorrect...
3. Governance - This is what OP is doing at the moment, but it's really lame, like Uni, what about Token value capture? ! This is it?? ?
我倒是相对认同 Fuel Labs 创始人提出的第四种功能,那就是 Layer2 的Token,应该仅被用作领导者选举(说白了就是出块的权利或者概率),适配上面共识思路的第一种 比如有 20 台 Sequencer,是「真去中心化」+permissionless,某个 Sequncer 手里有 2% 的币,那他就有 2% 的时间出块,10% 的币就给你 10% 的时间出块……
However, there is still a question mark on this "only", because the ideal Sequencer should be few and refined, unlike Layer1, which spreads out the comprehensive decentralization, so only a few nodes will grab these hundreds of millions of tokens then?? I think it's a little weird... Therefore, this fourth point can be used as a function combined with one of the previous three, the feeling will be good.
So much for Layer2 decentralization, the next post is OP vs. ZK, a showdown that promises to drag on for years.
Link to original article
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia