Original title: "We need to rethink Airdrops next cycle..."
Original author: cpt n3m0, Hashed
Original compilation: Bob, BlockBeats
The airdrop helps to decentralize the supply of the project's Token to the public and may make it part of a large-scale marketing plan to increase awareness of the project's core product or new product awareness.
Users typically earn these tokens without spending any money, subject to certain stated eligibility criteria, and can usually receive them when the protocol is about to launch , or claim them retroactively after using the protocol.
This paper examines The performance of 31 different Token airdrops within one and a half years, from Uniswap in September 2020 (UNI) to Evmos (EVMOS) by April 2022.
This is not an exhaustive list of all airdrops in the last 1.5 years, but an attempt to include as many airdrops as possible that meet the following parameters:
· Token and Genesis airdrop are launched at the same time (that is, the airdrop is not carried out after TGE)
· The project There is some form of roadmap based on Gitbook/Public Docs
The project indicates that the intent of the airdrop is to reward existing users/further market their product/decentralize the token Supply Ownership
Tokens have been around long enough to provide meaningful data points
First, let's look at the distribution of the token supply percentage allocated for the airdrop by each project:
< img src="https://image.blockbeats.cn/upload/2022-06-24/6b98ece23eabdd3f09ca65ea9ff437d698c7eb79.png?x-oss-process=image/quality,q_50/format,webp">
On average, projects spend 7.5% of their token supply on airdrops - by using median calculations to avoid outliers.
Most projects allocate less than 10% of the total token supply for airdrops; 26% of the projects airdrop 10-20% of the total supply; 23 % of projects accounted for more than 20% of total airdrops.

In contrast, project parties tend to be investors About 10% is allocated, and about 15% is allocated to team members (based on data here), so decisions are made For airdrop projects, setting aside 7.5% of Token supply is an important ratio.
Token airdrop has multiple benefits for the project:
· If the product is about to go live, the founder may want to expand marketing and awareness. A successful airdrop would be an effective way to gain more followers in a short amount of time while giving users time to research the project's legitimacy. (eg: APE, EVMOS, LOOKS)
· If a project has been live for a while, airdrops are a great way to reward early adopters and contributing community members , while incorporating the Token mechanism into daily protocol operations. (Example: COW, DYDX, ORCA)
< /p>
While airdrop strategies may achieve the above intentions in the short term (eg, increased DAU, increased TVL, new wallet interactions), long-term incentives for native tokens may not always be consistent.
Let’s take a look at the performance of each Token after the genesis airdrop:

At first glance, this looks like a crowded diagram.
Prices above have been normalized to 1.0 (y-axis) and scaled to days since respective genesis airdrops (x-axis).
If the price of an item is 1.0 on day 1, we want to know how it performs compared to the price on day 100. This chart shows that after 100 days, 74% of projects are trading at a lower price for their native token than on day 1.
There are only 7 projects whose transaction price is higher than the price of their airdrop on the day, and the outstanding performance is 4.8 times that of ORCA (DEX on Solana) The price of the day of airdrop, RAIDER (a utility-based NFT RPG game) is 2.4 times the price of the day of airdrop.
Other projects - GTC, 1INCH, JUNO, OSMO and UNI - are trading at less than 2x the price of the day of the airdrop.
The chart below goes on to detail that over time: (i) average price performance deteriorates, and (ii) a growing number of Item is below its Day 1 price.

· On day 5, the average airdrop median price was 0.99 (-1% difference from day 1), and 55% of people have already traded below the airdrop price< /p>
· On day 50, the average airdrop median price is 0.87 (similar to day 1 day difference -13%), 70% of the transaction price is lower than the price on the day of the airdrop
· to 100 days, The average airdrop average price is 0.64 (value depreciation -36% from day 1), and 74% of transactions are below the price on the day of the airdrop
When counting these figures in a longer time span (airdrop The results were no different when the market price performance after 200 days was completed).
The chart below shows the long-term trend of price decline, with the median airdrop price dropping from 0.99 on day 5 to 200 0.44 of the day.

The performance of most projects (72%) Still below its airdrop day price, although some noteworthy projects are doing well for token holders.
UNI was launched in September 2020, and by the second quarter of 2021 (day 200), it has become the most Major DEXs.
· Token holders can participate in governance proposals, macro conditions are a favorable catalyst for price performance after the airdrop
· Although not shown in the chart, UNI continues to stay above the airdrop price today (nearly 2 years after launch), trading at slightly more than 1.5 times the price on the day of the airdrop.
RAIDER took an unconventional approach to distribution in August 2021 - the team completed a successful NFT sale and published it on Polygon a few weeks later An original P2E RPG game.
· By Q1 2022 (Day 200), they have built a strong community and broad active player base which will help to gain $6M funding round co-led by Delphi, DeFiance, 3AC and Polygon.
· This explains the strong performance of more than 6.5 times the price on the day of the airdrop.
· However, the unfriendly macro conditions hit the crypto game industry the hardest, resulting in a decline in user indicators and poor performance of Token prices - the result of the price on the day of its airdrop 0.44 times.
While UNI and RAIDER have shown that airdrop tokens have the potential to perform well over longer time spans, overall samples suggest that airdrops generally do not The best boost to the long-term price of the project Token.
As a founder, you want the token to be in the hands of community members who support the project, participate in governance, stake it, or use it.
According to the initial parameters or according to the indicator to retroactively airdrop to the user, it will reduce the possibility of the ideal situation mentioned above. Especially if there are rumors of an imminent airdrop, as this would attract disloyal witch hunters (like Paraswap, Hop Protocol , Optimism).
The chart below shows the composite median normalized price per token over a 200-day period.

According to historical median data, within 200 days Within the range, there were only two days in which the median airdrop outperformed the airdrop's intraday price - day 4 (+1%) and day 18 (+4%).
This shows that the best time for users to sell airdrops is as early as possible, preferably between day 1 and day 5 (red shaded area) period, as prices fluctuate very little during this period.
If the user has no plan to continue participating in the project, or does not like the Token economic model of the protocol, then it seems to be a good idea to sell the airdrop as soon as possible better strategy.
However, in some cases, teams airdrop tokens when they have ample opportunity. It could be the case that users decide to sell on the day of the airdrop, but later realize they want to participate in the project and hold shares of the protocol as token holders.
The best time window to do this is 5th to 6th month (green shaded area) where the median airdrop price is at least 0.33x (i.e. 67% less than launch day price).
For example, if you bought UNI and OSMO on the 150th day after the airdrop and sold them on the 200th day, then Netting +42% and +59%, respectively.
This strategy can be applied to projects that have proven their worth a few months after the initial airdrop, indicators include their activeness in participating in the community, and ecological Connections to system infrastructure (e.g. Ethereum, Cosmos) and how quickly they are delivering and meeting product roadmap milestones.
If you are a developer /Project Founder: Please consider diversifying token supply or increasing product awareness in a different way than airdrops.
Airdrops have historically proven to be detrimental to token long-term price action. This study did not explore the effectiveness of airdrops on other project parameters, such as growing user metrics, new wallet interactions, increased TVL, etc. - but even if airdrops were effective in these respects,would you want to achieve this? One goal, and sacrifice the vast majority of retail investors to sell early?
Other practical airdrop methods:
Release airdrops according to time (can be unlocked every week for 3 months)
Release airdrops according to task completion (can be claimed after completing certain operations)
< p>Release the airdrop according to the combination of time and task completion (according to the frequency and degree of interaction between the user and the agreement in the past, it can be claimed within a certain period of time)
< p>If you are an individual holder receiving an airdrop, your decision tree should look like this:
· Do I need a token to interact with this protocol? If yes, HODL.
· Would selling now make a big difference to me? If not, HODL.
If you can continue to use the protocol without Token (for example: Paraswap, DEX aggregator), and airdrop when selling There is still significant value (eg: dYdX airdrop) , you may need to sell the airdrop as soon as you claim it!
Original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia