header-langage
简体中文
English
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

The Dilemma of Encrypted Games and the Road to Breakthrough

Read this article in 23 Minutes
Maybe gamers shouldn't spend $1,000 to play a game.
Original title: "Crypto Gaming is Broken. How Do We Fix It?"
Original author: Nat Eliason
Original compilation: Captain Hiro


In the past year, I have been immersed in the world of encryption games. This is where I am most interested in the field and where I feel most qualified to speak.


Fortunately, I have seen crypto games from more angles than most people. I'm a big fan of games like Runescape, World of Warcraft, Diablo 3, and DOTA 2, all of which showcased early experiments in what we now call crypto gaming. These experiments include the gray market for in-game currency in World of Warcraft, "NFTs" for rare items in Runescape and DOTA 2, and a brief attempt at a real-money auction house in Diablo 3.


I have experimented fairly extensively with past, present and upcoming crypto games, spending at least raised $100,000 in funding. Over the past few months, I've started writing more crypto game-related analysis on this site.


I also helped build a crypto game economy. I am an advisor to Crypto Raiders and I assist with game economics and token economics. By building a crypto game economy myself, and seeing it work online, I've tested a few different theories. Over the course of the last few months, I've also been exposed to these ideas more in practice through economic collaborations with other games.


Crypto games are brand new, and almost no one has more than a year or two of experience in this area. So while I'm still very new to all of this, I still feel qualified to present some of the problems I'm seeing in the field right now, and some of the ways we might improve them.


I am very bullish on crypto games. It's something I've wanted for over a decade, even though I didn't learn its name until recently. I believe gaming will eventually grow into a trillion dollar industry in cryptocurrency. So while this article is currently critical of the field, don't take that to mean I don't believe in the industry. Quite the contrary, I deeply believe in its potential and want to help make it the best it can be.


Accordingly, this article is not definitive for all games. It's more of a list of problems, and possible solutions or experiments. I share my views on crypto games as much as possible within the limited content, and hope that more crypto game teams can actually practice some of the ideas in this article, iterate on them, and hopefully make this field stronger .


Not much to say, let us analyze it in depth. If you have any thoughts after reading this post, I'd love to hear your feedback on Twitter.


Current problems in encrypted games


There are some common problems in encrypted games at present , in no particular order:


- NFT sets a bad precedent for gaming

- DeFi  Sets a bad precedent for the game

- Earnings in most crypto games are unsustainable

- The cost of playing the game is too high for the lifetime of the game

- A lot of content is nonsense

- People with money (capital) have much more power than people with leisure (time)

- "Play to Earn (P2 E)" sets wrong expectations for players


NFT sets a bad precedent for games

< p>

The NFT wave kicked off in early 2021. It started with art, then moved to profile pictures, and started creeping into games.


What I need to emphasize here is that the popularity of NFT started with artwork and collectibles with rarity and fixed supply. The strategy for investing in these collectibles is really to simply buy and hold them. If you pick the right one, the price of the NFTs in your hand will go up, making you money once you sell them to the next buyer.


This standard of NFT investment sets a bad precedent for gaming. Creating NFT characters in the game that players can speculate on will move the game in the same direction, which is to wait for the price of NFT to increase. At the same time, the idea that you can buy a basic account of a game, hold on to it and expect it to become more valuable is absurd.


Nevertheless, in the NFT game, people pay great attention to the "floor price", that is, the cheapest purchase price of NFT. A game whose floor price keeps falling is seen as dying, even if it means that the barrier to entry for new players is getting lower and lower.


When crypto games start with 10,000 NFTs worth thousands of dollars, it is very difficult to build an economically sound game and a happy community. You need to lower the price of the NFT significantly so that a larger number of players can enter the game. And if the game starts with high-value assets, it will attract more speculators than players, which is very different from the people the game party hopes to appear in the early game community.


DeFi sets a bad precedent for gaming


First wave of crypto games It is essentially a combination of NFT and DeFi. These games take the Ponzi scheme that exists in DeFi (buy in-game tokens, trade them for more tokens, sell the tokens you earn, and hope you get a return on your investment before everything crashes!), just adding additional steps. The breeding loop that exists in many NFT games is essentially the same as DeFi mining, except that the way in the game is to attach colorful characters to it.


Furthermore, DeFi yield and staking set players’ expectations of what tokens should do. People expect that they can buy a game token and get passive income from it without playing the game. Therefore, introducing this passive gain ends up destroying the in-game economy.


Crypto games need to move away from NFT and DeFi expectations. Copying these paradigms helped a new game get off the ground in ways that are now hurting it in very obvious ways.


Most earnings in crypto games are unsustainable


If a game With all the nascent resources increasing the income of game participants, the game's economy must eventually collapse. You can't keep increasing everyone's earning potential without massively inflating the reward currency, which would eventually cause the value of the reward currency to collapse.


A simple way to test this question is to ask what the main tokens are and what impact they have on the economy when they are used. The game is not sustainable if all major nascent resources increase people's earning power. The game may have a sustainable economy if major nascent resources don't increase revenue. It is necessary, but not sufficient.


This is my main criticism of STEPN. While the game is fun and has a better economic design than most games out there right now, most of the new resources in the game right now increase the player's earnings, so unless they can alleviate that, it's going to have to end up in some way Way to crash.


The game cost is too high for the game life cycle


A good game can How long does it last? two years? five years? Very few games last more than 10 years. Therefore, we must take into account the short lifespan of most games when assessing the value of game assets.


There are currently basically three ways to judge the value of an item:


- Intrinsic non- Monetary value (status, happiness, etc.)

- Cash flow (it earns you money)

- Appreciation (guess you can sell it for a higher price)

p>

The Boring Ape Yacht Club (BAYC) Metaverse Otherside has 100,000 pieces of land. The floor price of these lands is $6,000 now, and it will become more and more expensive in the future.


Assuming that the average price of all 100,000 lots in the future is $10,000 per lot, the market value of Otherside is about $1 billion. If we assume very optimistically that the BAYC metaverse will be popular for 10 years, assuming you're not happy to spend $10,000 just to play with no promise of something in return, then you have to ask if you can achieve it at least in your land during that time break even.


The only way you will get a return is if you can sell your land to someone else for a higher price or you can generate good cash flow from the land . But selling it to others for more profit is traditional Ponzi economics that we are used to and want to get rid of.


Maybe you can quickly see the problem here. Assuming you want your BAYC land to generate at least 10% cash flow per year, the entire ecosystem needs to pay the landowner $100 million per year. Assuming BAYC can match the popularity of Fortnite, which generates about $5 billion a year in revenue. The question is can BAYC give 2% of its income to landowners?


It's not impossible, but we have to weigh whether BAYC can build a game as popular as Fortnite, and then use the This popularity lasted for ten years.


Is it possible? Yes, but that's not the direction I'm willing to bet on. I think we have to admit that most of the value of these assets is that people expect it to appreciate. People hold the asset with the expectation that its value will go up, and when that fantasy is defeated, they get very sad. Yes, it must end eventually, no game lasts forever.


Many "play" and earn jobs are bullshit


In an ideal game With the earned version, you'll be able to cash in some of the value you've accumulated from playing a fun game. Alternatively, you could get paid for making some meaningful financial contribution to the game, such as designing a popular skin for other players to buy.


The "earning" of most crypto games is not like this. Most crypto games earn money by doing some form of pointless work, usually a series of button clicks. To be fair, this is a very common situation in games, especially online games: mining copper in Runescape is kind of boring. But if your income comes from logging into the game every few hours, clicking a few buttons, not experiencing the gameplay but just doing basic operations, then you're just creating a weird job.


Some farming cycle and land management games are common examples of this. To be blunt, I'm not saying that's necessarily a bad thing, but if the majority of your game's revenue comes from logging in every few hours and clicking something, you haven't really built a game that's fun and that people make money from. Unless you can complicate land management to the level of SimCity, or compete in some way. I do think it would be interesting to create a Web3 sim city game where you can create trade agreements to share resources between different cities.


He who owns the capital has instant power


Now, the big players in the P&E game Part of the power is immediately available to those with substantial capital. They can buy large amounts of resources, run the economic cycle faster, and gain significant control of the market quickly.


This is a blow to the real players as they may have more time than capital. The highest earning potential should go to those who put the most time and effort into the game, and the extent to which some players can approach this by deploying large amounts of capital should be limited.


Assuming those who have a lot of money to put into a game do so to extract revenue, not to play it, they plan the game accordingly. If the game can be mined, then these people will mine all the value to the greatest extent, and the losers will be those who are actually playing the game.


"Play and Earn" sets wrong expectations


A game is going to last development, then players can't immediately start getting a good ROI on their investment in the game. And the easier the math of how to achieve ROI, the easier it is for the game to be exploited by people with a lot of money.


This is where the "play and earn" term is quite lovable. The gameplay of most crypto games should not be a meaningless job of pretending, it should have actual gameplay. And the benefits of the game should be difficult to calculate, especially for new players.


Finally, the income of the game should be irregular, and there should be large bonuses in the game instead of a steady income. The more difficult it is for players to predict the steady income of the game, the more you can build the game around the actual gameplay of the game instead of the DeFi loop.


Okay, these are what I think are most of the problems with crypto games. Now let's see how we can solve these problems.


How can we fix the current problem with encrypted games?


As I said in the introduction, I am not writing this article as a comprehensive analysis but rather one that I think crypto games should try List of ideas and things. This field is still in a very early stage and we are all experimenting and feeling our way.


- Significantly lower cost of entry

- Limits the power of new capital

- Prioritize reward games over Not clicks

- unstaking

- build a fun game first

- separate external and internal economies as much as possible

- Masking ROI

- Recalibrating expectations for P&E

- Unlimiting games


Significantly Lower cost of entry


It's stupid to pay $10,000 to play a game. Now almost everyone knows that if you don’t have spare cash, don’t touch crypto games. The only reason people are acknowledging crypto games right now is because we're all excited about NFTs and copying those patterns.


However, the idea of a game party creating an account that costs $10,000 to start the game is absurd, and it turns away a lot of players who might be tempted to try you game, but can't afford to invest in a decent used car.


This also puts a lot of pressure on the in-game economy, as the game's revenue has to justify this huge start-up cost. If you want to try to break even within 3 months, you need to make $3333 per month from your startup account. So either someone else needs to put $3333 a month into the ecosystem for you to make money from it, or you have to benefit from the Ponzi, which is almost certainly the latter.


It should be free for people to join a crypto game, or cost as much as a regular game (less than $60). I'm partial to a free-to-play mode, and some teams are doing interesting experiments in this direction (eg Genopets and Sunflower Land).


This will greatly reduce the income people can make from the game at the beginning, but this is a good thing, there will be less pressure on you to try to keep the token price high, This way people can make crazy money from the game. And that means expectations are much lower. They won't be jumping for a $10,000 investment, they can really enjoy the game.


If you've launched a game with a steep $10,000 threshold, what do you do? We tried to deliberately lower the price of characters in Crypto Raiders, but this didn't get very good feedback. People are biased against NFT, mainly because people are too concerned about the floor price of NFT. So while we're making progress on our goal of lowering the cost of access to games, many people are very upset that they hold an NFT and then can't be bought by someone else at a high price.


But I support doing something similar. I think if you can turn 1 $10k character over time into 10 $1000 characters, or even 100 $100 characters, then you've dramatically lowered the number of people getting into the game threshold without destroying any value for the original buyer. This may be your best bet.


Some would say that loans and scholarships are a solution here, but I don't like them. The point of crypto games is to own your own game assets, borrow from others or apply for scholarships, which is almost meaningless.


Runescape and WoW's economy works well when people keep creating new tier 1 accounts. Access should be free or very cheap, and income should be earned through enough work.


Limits on the power of capital


Someone with a lot of money should not raid And dominate the game or game economy.


One way this is happening now is by breeding. A person or guild with a lot of money can buy up many assets, start a breeding business, and have a huge impact on the market without actually playing the game.


Another area we might see is the game item market. If someone can come in and buy the rarest item in the game, they can immediately start winning games or generating the best rewards without putting in a lot of effort.


In terms of breeding and economic cycles, there should be some limit on how quickly someone can deploy capital. STEPN has an interesting hurdle built into the hierarchy of sneakers. Since sneakers have to be level 5 to be castable, and you can only forge one pair of sneakers at a time, and since breeding has a 48 hour cooldown, you'll really only be able to cast them once every 36 hours or so, no matter how much money you have. This is very different from breeding in other games, where you could theoretically buy 100 characters and breed 100 from them. And in STEPN's sneaker collection, there's no way to achieve that kind of multiplier.


Another way you can build control over this is through soul items. The best gear in the game should be picked up in bundles, so it can't be sold. It can be used to win games and generate low-tier sellable gear, but it cannot be sold itself. This ensures that the highest earning and competitive potential is in the hands of those actively playing the game and cannot be bought out by newcomers. Make people buy max 80-90% gear instead of the best gear.


Finally, you can make certain ROI-increasing activities non-transferable, such as investments in time-bound land upgrades.


One of my minor criticisms of Crypto Unicorns is that land upgrades are still transferable via sale, and new players can buy them outright. So you can buy a piece of land on  OpenSea , put some money down, and instantly compete financially with those who have been playing the game for a month. I don't think this is ideal. There should be some perks to a game you've been playing for a while.


Prioritize Rewarding Games over CTR


Make the game fun, Both have income, and income should come from activities that are closer to "playing" rather than repeated clicks.


This doesn't mean that breeding games are bad, just that they should have a decent layer of strategy and tactics attached to them. The game should have trade-offs, it should be hard for the player to make a spreadsheet and figure out the best way to play. And buying resources to click "breed" and selling new NFTs should definitely not be the main profit mechanism.


If breeding is the main monetization mechanism, it means that people are not paying money to play the game, they are paying money to play a breeding Ponzi scheme. A game is successful when people pay for premium gear, or extra land moves, or cosmetics. These are things that allow them to play the game more, or allow them to flex in the social context of the game.


Limiting the best rewards to PvP, end game content, challenges, leaderboards and other more competitive activities will help ensure this situation.


A metaphor I often refer to is that someone who signs up for a brand new Runescape account cannot expect to make an immediate impact on the big exchanges. Nor should a person who purchased an NFT character or signed up to your game receive an immediate financial reward.


Unstaking


Staking is often implemented in one of two ways, both None of it makes sense.


First, you use the governance token as a pledge to get more governance tokens. This is stupid because you are now rewarding rich DeFi miners instead of real gamers. And, aside from slowing down token sales, which is fine, it doesn't improve the game.


Or, you use the governance token as a pledge to get a share of the revenue in the game. It's also kind of stupid, because now you have to make the in-game economy even more loss-making, making it impossible for most players to actually earn anything in the game because you're paying rewards to speculators instead of real players. You can take a portion of the fee from the in-game marketplace, but then you're compromising your ability to generate revenue yourself.


I think it is more important to use Governance Token as the most valuable limited resource in the game and use it for the most influential upgrades to characters or accounts meaningful practice. This allows roles to accumulate value over time, as these upgrades are necessarily limited, and gives the token a reason to exist and be held. Rather than locking up supply by letting people stake it in a staking contract, lock up supply by letting people stake it in a game.


Build a fun game first


It may seem like a revolutionary idea, but I think for a crypto game to work, it first needs to be a really fun game.


If no one wants to play your game, when players aren't making money from it, they'll get off the first thing the market goes wrong and dump everything . If the game's internal economy cannot function without the influence of external token activity, then the game is in an unstable state to begin with, and it will be difficult to build up later.


This may seem like a stupid thing to do, but few people do it. Probably because launching tokens is an incredible way to raise funds, and games are expensive to produce. So you do have some challenges here. How do you wait to incorporate your token into your game until you build a fun game, and how do you build a fun game without using tokens as a fundraising mechanism?


Well, of course you can raise money the normal way. But I also think community members can be more patient than we assume. Illuvium is doing a good job of this right now. They have a token that has been out for a while, and they are now bringing people into the beta phase of their game, but there is no way to make money in the game yet. That is a future matter. They're focused on building a really fun game first, and then introducing money-making elements as it matures.


Separate internal and external economies


Try to balance the game around the external value of Token The cost in is tempting, but it becomes a distraction and leads to a frustrating gaming experience for players.


These two economies should operate independently. The game should function the same whether 1 gold coin in the game is worth $0.001 or $1. There will be periods of spikes in interest in the game, where people will flock to the game and drive up the token price, and there will be low tides where the token price will drop. During these times, the player's experience playing the game should remain consistent. Otherwise, you'll be constantly changing the economy of the game to chase token prices, which will make the whole thing rather confusing.


An example of this not being done right, at least in my opinion, is STEPN's recent decision to base minting costs on the relative price of their tokens.


Crypto Game Dilemma: Seven Questions


This makes one of the game's core loops extremely unpredictable on a day-to-day basis, and makes coin minting an annoying mathematical operation. Maybe that's the point, it makes minting less fun for players and more of it a transactional experience. The main benefit of this approach is that it helps increase the price of their governance token while potentially making the game more affordable in the short term by driving down the price of GST.


In any case, people should not look at Coingecko to decide or know what to do in your game.


Masking ROI


Again we assume that any economic cycle that is easy to plot will be exploited , we should make the ROI of a game hard to calculate.


Measuring ROI is important for many games today because of their high startup costs. You don't want to spend $10,000 on a character or a piece of land if you're not sure how to earn that money back. However, if the game has a low startup fee (which I think they should be), then this problem becomes less of a problem.


However, it's still worth thinking about here how you can blur the cost-benefit analysis of in-game activities. One way is through rewards with high variability.


Maybe the expected value of running a land in the game is $0.20. But 90% of the time, you only make $0.10, and 10% of the time, you make $1.10. This is a very simplified version, but you should be able to get my point across. You can know that a player should have some rough ROI over months or years of play, and they can't be easily calculated in-game due to the variability of outcomes.


This is already a common design standard in games with loot boxes, rare items, and other mechanics, but it's odd that we haven't done this yet in "playing with Seeing so many in earning may be because a lot of earning is based on "work" rather than "games".


Reframe expectations around P&E


This will be the hardest, but also the most important. As an industry, we need to move expectations away from the P&E game being something you can dig a quick profit at, to a really fun game where you happen to cash in some of your work.


At present, "DOTA2" is a very good model. You wouldn't think of it as a P&E game, because there is no cryptocurrency involved, and no "job"-like activities that allow you to earn any value. But in-game assets do have value in the game market, so if you get something you don't want from a loot box, you can sell it to someone else.


The vast majority of players end up spending more money than they earn on a game. Actually, I'm not sure anyone is netting money in this market, unless you have some very early very rare items. But it's a great example of how a game can have a market without it ruining the fun.


If a game takes a long time to play before it makes money, and once it does, it's hard for people to calculate the ROI, and it doesn't affect the game replayability, then you may have a more sustainable game economy.


Unrestricted game


I hope our last change is to create a game that does not require restrictions The player enjoys the P&E game of the game ability.


Energy, recharge, and other time-based limits are a great way to limit inflation in-game. But they do limit how much people can enjoy your game, and if you build a good game, you end up disappointing people who want to play it.


On the contrary, our goal should be to allow a lot of content in the game to be played freely without restrictions, and only allow capital-generating activities to be limited. Other games with developed economies in the past had very small restrictions on in-game economic activity. In Runescape or WoW, you can basically mine all the copper you want, and they turn out pretty well. But we can still limit activities that are extremely valuable, like ending game lands or harvesting the rarest resources, which may also tie into the concept of building a fun game in the first place. If the game provides a broad range of fun for the player, and then adds money-making content later, then the player will have a lot of things to do that are not tied to making money, and this may finally solve some problems.


Written at the end


This article is somewhat like a brain teaser, but I hope It is helpful for any team trying to build a "play and earn" game.


We all have an incredible opportunity to be the first to solve this problem. Build a game on the scale of World of Warcraft or Runescape this generation, but with a real-world economy.


I am very bullish on this field. This is the area of cryptocurrencies that interests me the most. So if you want to share work you're working on or other thoughts on similar topics, be sure to reach out to me on Twitter.


Original link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit