Original title: "A&T Talk: Why Classical VCs Changed the "Talk"——Talk about Web3 with Web2 VC"
Original Source: AnT Capital WeChat Official Account
Original Author: A&T Capital
The following is a transcript of the recent in-depth exchanges between A&T partners and two colleagues , we invited two senior investors from traditional institutions who are transitioning to Web3 investment, hereinafter referred to as Peter and David (both pseudonyms), to chat with them as investors with rich experience in traditional investment, the logic in the transition to Web3 investment and thinking.
Legal Disclaimer:
< /p>
The above content only represents the personal academic opinions of the guests, for industry learning and exchange, and does not represent the positions and opinions of the institution and the institutions where the guests work.
Peter:
It started when I participated in a Hackathon in 2016. During that time, Ethereum had just encountered the well-known DAO hack, but what I saw was that although ETH experienced a very big impact, at that time many developers just focused on building interesting things, rather than paying much attention to ETH. Prices go up and down.
Todd:
I believe in Web3 from January 2021. Although I have been involved in the Crypto world since 2018, I don't see Crypto as Web3, it's just more about blockchain, a new technology. Until I saw Mirror.xyz, which really brought something different and value to the industry. Compared to Zhihu or Medium of the Web2 platform, Mirror provides an option for content creators that can help them raise the funds they need during the creative process. And this is very difficult to achieve in Web2.
Peter:
From the perspective of user experience, I do agree with you about Mirror. To me, DeFi is also Web3, although they are not Web3 applications. Before Uniswap, there was a well-known DEX called DDEX. I was an active user of that application, because they did not monopolize your data rights, and I could fully control the movement of my assets between different applications.
Liam:
I started to believe in Web3 because I was involved in the cryptocurrency market. To me, Web3 means less licensing, ownership, transferable economic value, etc. In March 2020, I was still at Deutsche Bank, and it was also the first time I knew about Bitcoin as another asset. I believe Web3 will be a paradigm shift for the financial system, starting with money.
Peter:
From the perspective of user experience, Ownership is the most critical. Ownership is something we cannot have in the Web2 Internet world. That's why I'm so excited when the NFT bull market hits. Starting with NFTs, we can have a Metaverse where people spend more time and get entertained. In the long run, when everything is digitized, when there are more and more data, we can have more different things in the digital world.
Todd:
Totally agree with the idea of Ownership, but there are still many obstacles to make it happen. The only things we can really have right now are NFTs and FTs, but we may not be able to own data. This part will be discussed later.
David:
An open financial market is what I look forward to most. Because many friends came to ask, if they do not have overseas bank accounts, how to buy and sell Chinese stocks in the US market? The synthetic asset platform can indeed become an option for them to achieve the same goal, and the world on the chain will synthesize stock price fluctuations.
Peter:
The first is to use the threshold, if you want to enter the real Web3 world, you need to have a wallet Manage your private keys, which is a high barrier to entry for many people. I know that there are many projects that are trying to lower the barrier of wallets, but they still don't do it well enough.
The second is about privacy. The current data on the chain is very transparent, so basically every transaction of yours is under the nose of everyone. So we can see a lot of different types of applications coming into this public space trying to grab this data and give users a product that tells them what other people on the chain are doing right now. This does offer a lot of functionality, but we don't have any privacy in a place like this. I have seen many projects trying to solve this problem, such as Tornado Cash. These ideas allow users to manage their privacy. If you want to expose some transactions, you can open them to the public. If you want to have some privacy, you can still achieve it, so we will soon find a breakthrough in this area.
The last part is about decentralized storage. Right now, most things in the crypto world are still stored in centralized cloud storage. When it comes to ownership, we don’t really own it. Decentralized storage is what truly enables anyone to own data ownership.
Todd:
Low threshold and competitive in application scenarios, which one is more important for the expansion of Web3? Because you mentioned that there are many projects that are trying to modify the user experience.
Peter:
The first scenario will discuss serving users who are proficient in Crypto, or Crypto native users, the second The first scenario will discuss how to bring the masses into the Crypto world. From an investor's perspective, there are several ways to succeed. One is to serve those core users and use these core users to build the initial community, instead of expanding vigorously from the beginning, I think this will be a more practical approach.
However, I do see some other projects and they are creative enough to give them credit as well, I think they are Brave enough, for example, on the public chain side, Flow is doing a lot of work to accommodate non-crypto users. There is also a project, Stepn, which is very interesting, move to earn, they created a very simple user experience for non-crypto users from the beginning.
David:
I totally agree with what you discussed. And for me, it will be Crypto education. Most Web2 internet users don't know Web3 at all, they don't know how to use wallets, how to buy cryptocurrencies, or how to get involved in the community. Therefore, there needs to be some simple and intuitive way to get these people on board more quickly.
Liam:
Many people are not interested in DeFi, but if they want to participate in Web3, the first hurdle may be learning how to use Metamask . But I think they can start with hardware wallets, which are more secure and better suited to the Web2 user experience.
Peter:
Web2 companies need to change the way they think. Like needing to try to be open and collaborative instead of thinking everyone is my future competitor. They also need to try to use token incentives to attract users instead of buying users directly.
David:
This is hard for most Web2 companies. Because we are entering a new era, building is no longer a company or an enterprise, but more like a digital nation, they are doing the work of open source protocols, so the whole mentality of Web2 and Web3 builds is changing.
From the perspective of the community, to build a Web3 or Crypto project, you must have the mentality of building a community, and you need to There are some similarities in the process of building consensus among some of the great companies of the past, but the whole mentality is quite different.
David:
For Web3 companies, starting a business still needs to find some new application scenarios, and they want to keep up with Lending and Borrowing Comparing AAVE with Compound, it is actually very difficult to have a new opportunity, it is very difficult.
Peter:
In fact, we often encounter some problems, what should we do if Tencent and Ali do it, in fact, AAVE and Compound can also do these ToB things , and they are more convincing to some B-side users.
Todd:
Many things giants can do, but what each team is good at is limited. There will be no deep recognition of a new direction, but in fact not every team has such a deep understanding of an innovative point.
In fact, some new teams can have some innovations on some crowded tracks. For example, we voted for a Staking last year Reward, our investment logic at the time was that it was the CoinmarketCap of the Staking track, but in fact CoinmarketCap did not do this, and Stakingreward has been deeply involved in this track for a long time and has accumulated a lot of deep users.
Actually, I think AAVE has contributed a lot of innovative points to this market this year, so I also I think it is very reasonable. I need to jump out of a certain circle to get some new things.
Peter:
In fact, it is not yet the time for special introversion, such as Opensea and Uniswap, they have not done it on every chain , In fact, there are many opportunities for everyone, there are too many directions to do, and there are too many opportunities, such as Uniswap, which must be the largest traffic in Ethereum in terms of Dex, but Metamask did not make a swap because of its many users, but As an aggregate, it is connected to Uniswap, but Metamask’s swap charges a very high fee, so its Revenue is also very high, so there are many Marketplace and aggregator forms on NFT, so there are many things that can be done at the project level .
Liam:
In fact, there is no institutional monopoly in Web3, and users vote with their feet. Is it perfect? In fact, it is far from enough. In addition to the UniV2 and V3 forms, there are many other forms, such as some Orderbook forms, so the first mover has the first-mover advantage, but some innovations are still needed to attract users.
Peter:
VC is like a company, VC itself is a product of history, it is not static and will be changed, from the perspective of investment , VC invests a sum of money at a very early stage of the project and gets some equity or Token at a very low price. This is actually no essential difference from traditional VC. The difference lies in the form of financing and valuation Judgment, for example, the Token percentage in the early stage of the investment agreement actually has no further dilution, right? But if you invest in equity, after rounds of financing, your equity will only account for 1% or a few tenths of a percent, but the token has no dilution Yes, so you'll see some VCs at very, very low cost.
In addition, it is the background of the project. In traditional projects, you need to do financial background and legal background, but at present In this digital background, you don’t actually need to visit this company. You and the founder may chat remotely. Cryto actually brings a lot of good things. If the project goes online, many things can be clearly seen .
For anonymous projects, no matter what method is used to establish trust, what is his name, where is actually not It’s very important. In fact, I personally participated in some Fair launch projects. In fact, it’s a good way not to take money from institutions. It is still necessary for the organization to make a large investment in the early stage, and it is relatively difficult to fully implement the Fair launch.
Peter:
If we vote for a Fund, we may vote for the aesthetics of this Fund, but for Fair launch, it is more Most of them cater to the aesthetics of the entire market. But catering to the aesthetics of the market will fluctuate a lot, but if a Fund can be more open and transparent, such as in the form of a DAO, to disclose all investment trajectories, then I would prefer this form.
Todd:
In the Crypto field, some Funds are aware of a problem that the form of VC will change. For example, the Founder of Polychain sent a Push, he believes that VC in our industry will be subverted soon, and most of the organizational forms of VC will be subverted.
David:
Compared with Fair launch VC, there are still many advantages. The connection between projects, investors and investment institutions is still very useful. Institutions can provide some traditional post-investment services, including helping to recruit people, doing PR and connecting to some resources, including VCs such as KOLs and exchanges.
Todd:
In fact, we have been looking forward to the arrival of the bear market internally. In our understanding, the best time to sell Fund is in the bear market , because the competition and valuation faced by Funds in the bull market will not be so friendly. Compared with individuals, institutions will actually do more research. In fact, it is the money that a person realizes. Institutions are suitable for selling in bear markets, and counting money in bull markets is fine. .
Many traditional funds have been selling more frequently recently, and they will not be so afraid of high-valued projects. In fact, they are in a bear market We will maintain a shooting frequency. Going back to your question, every partner in our Fund has his own track. For myself, I will be more optimistic about the completion of some Web3 middleware, because in fact Several major pieces of Web3 have been seen, but something is needed to complete this middleware.
David:
We prefer overseas companies, we will divide Web3 into 4 layers, application layer, Tooling, middleware and infrastructure , the last layer is Protocol such as L1. Our focus is on middleware and Tooling, such as DAO tools, data analysis platforms, and NFT analysis platforms. We call Tooling layer, and the other is middleware and infrastructure, such as DID, data Middleware , and then nodes and Storage, these things are called Meddleware internally or because this part is an area we are very familiar with in Web2, the risk is controllable, but like the application layer, like Gaming and NFT investment, the risk is relative to us It's not so managable and takes less effort.
The last is the Protocol layer, we see less in L1 and Scaling solution, because we are currently in contact with good projects a bit less. In addition, cross-chain is also one of our key points.
Back to the issue of bull market and bear market, it is true that many traditional Web2 funds are very fomo investing in Web3 investment, and we are still very calm internally , it is more rational to look at a high valuation.
Peter:
For us, we will vote for an L1 or L2 Scaling or Privacy Protocol. Because I think the richness of the protocol level is relatively strong, there will be a lot of ecological economic activities, we have seen less about the application layer, and we have invested a lot in middleware and tooling, and we will continue to pay attention. From the perspective of valuation, everyone may prefer a bear market rather than bubbles with high valuations. When competition is fierce, many people will raise the valuation very high, and the end result is that everyone’s returns will be lower. . This is also a game. Everyone votes with their feet on the valuation. If everyone thinks the price is unreasonable or can get a more flexible price from the second level, then they will use their own methods to price the project, so everyone has their own valuation logic.
Peter:
The first one is the concept. Compared with the traditional equity market, the individual and community components of the Web3 market must be higher, so there will be some Fair launch practices. From another perspective, everyone's ideal is complete democratization, complete openness and transparency, but many people still rely on the judgment of institutions and KOLs, so for a long time, institutions still have a great influence.
About the valuation issue, from a broad perspective, we will judge which mechanism the project will use to exit, such as Coinbase’s Listing, such as Coinmarketcap being acquired by Binance, these are more traditional ways. We are more flexible about the exit mechanism.
David:
This mainly depends on whether the value of the project is in Token or equity.
Peter:
The most ideal situation must be that you can predict the cycle and direction well. Investing in NFT or in the last wave, investing in some large DeFi, this is definitely an ideal situation. If it is a less than ideal situation, there are some things that people don't know what is going to rise or what will rise. But we need to think about whether this thing is a wave or a long-term thing. If your perspective is the latter, from the perspective of an institution, then it is good for you to keep pace with the market. If you know that this thing has bubbles in the short term, but the long-term 10-5 years is a long-term growth thing, then believe this A little bit of sustainable investment. If you think this thing is a wave, then you may not be chasing hot spots. If you continue to be optimistic, you will continue to make arrangements.
Todd:
I would like to add that if the project exists for a relatively short period of time, you may go to the second level to pursue it if you are a second-level fund Such a short-term gain. We will have some considerations whether this project can really solve some problems in the market. It may face some troughs, but in the long run, the fund will also gain some value.
David:
This industry basically has some consensus, that is, the entire Crypto industry will continue to alternate between bulls and bears, but we are investing in projects I always hope that this project can survive in the next bull market and exit in the next bull market. If it is NFT or Gaming at the application layer, it will get a big return in a short time, but it will only be popular for a short time.
Todd:
Each specific track will have its valuation method. The simplest valuation method is that this project has similar Things that can be seen by the standards of his comparable companies. The other is that there are some projects that we think will have a place in the long run, and relatively speaking, they will have a better valuation. For example, Staking as a service, if you think crypto will become mainstream, it may later become something like AWS and Alibaba Cloud. Now let’s look at traditional equity companies. Their valuations in the market can also give us some references. For example, if you invest in a project, it may become such a large company in five years.
The valuation of this round of DeFi is because the hot spot of the market is not in this place, so the funds will go to higher returns Therefore, the second-level valuation will drop, but you can calculate the income of some blue-chip DeFi projects, so in fact, compared with the traditional financial industry, the PE of 20 times and 30 times is actually relatively reasonable . Therefore, for the valuation of some DeFi projects, as long as it is still the core player in a track for a long time, its price is also a fluctuation in the secondary market.
David:
Opensea’s benchmarking in the traditional Web2, in fact, the logic of this model is a bit like Taobao, and because its products are one and the other One is different, so its logic is more like that of Xianyu, let me add this question.
Peter:
Regarding the time perspective, the method of finding Comparable, as Todd said, may be the best way to use, to find a project similar to the project Where it is, of course, depends on the characteristics of the product. If it is a public chain project, it is not particularly accurate to use traditional valuation, but it is more reasonable to use traditional valuation for Defi projects. In addition, the current project subsidizes users. It is also very common, so there will be a situation of brushing volume, so to sum up, if you really want to calculate the valuation, you still have to believe that the long-term industry will return to a rational and average level. The industry is still very early, so in fact there is no very formulaic valuation method.
David:
Let me simply say that most of the time I rely on friends in the circle to communicate and recommend new projects, but there will also be In a small number of cases, some good projects can be found on Discord on Twitter.
Peter:
I won’t talk too much about friends’ recommendations. It’s actually quite useful to find some projects from Twitter or Discord. Friends from large domestic manufacturers will have a lot of regulatory considerations, so there will still be a process of changing their minds. In the long run, if they have a sense of identity with the industry after changing their minds, they will still turn to this matter later. This is A thing that takes time.
Todd:
I would like to add something that we will often do two things, the first thing is that we will invest in some portfolios, then we will The vote for them must be because of our recognition of this track, so I will chat with these founders to learn about the new development direction of these tracks, the latest good teams, and source some good projects from this channel.
In addition, everyone will have a bot to crawl some new projects. Sometimes it will have its own parameters or something.
David:
When I first came into contact with the Crypto market, I also thought about this question, because everyone’s code is open source, so how to maintain this competitiveness ? Then after I came into contact with Web3, I felt that a team still needs a strong marketing ability and operation ability. In addition, they need some of these fields and new relationship networks, such as some exchanges, public chains, KOLs, and the support of powerful investors. .
In addition, because the Web3 project is internationalized, it is necessary to operate an internationalized team with internationalized management capabilities and project execution The ability of the project is also very important. Another point is that someone in the team can have a strong understanding of the design of Tokenomics and make some innovations. Maybe the Tokenomics of defi does not have much new innovations, but gamefi and socialfi can have a strong understanding of the project. Some innovative designs of the token are also bonus points.
Todd:
Examples of Uniswap, Sushi, and Pancake, Uniswap still carries the largest amount of funds and the largest attention in the market. It is the innovation of the team. For example, Uniswap can make V2 V3, but Sushi and Pancake cannot. They can copy codes but cannot gain awareness and innovation. In addition, Pancake has also received strong support from Binance, and the other is the ecological support of BSC, so strong enough resources are very important, and the other is Sushi. Their team's community operation ability is relatively strong, so the team's ability in operation and community. So these three points basically cover our investment thinking.
Peter:
In fact, people are very important in the primary market, that is, whether the team can continue to innovate. In addition, the matter of open source does not mean that the track will become more involuntary. The competition is all-round. UniV3 actually modified an open source license. At the beginning, the time was set and it cannot be fully open source. , Slowly open source later, so open source is not a black and white thing.
Todd:
Thank you for joining our space, today's Twitter space is here, goodbye.
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia