Vitalik Buterin: Soul Binding
Vitalik Buterin
Block unicorn
One feature of World of Warcraft that is second nature to players but is mostly not discussed outside the gaming community is the concept of soulbound items, which once picked up cannot be transferred or sold to other players.

Most of the very powerful items in the game are soulbound and usually require completing complex quests or killing very powerful monsters, usually with the help of four to thirty-nine other players. Therefore, in order to get your character close to having the best weapons and armor, you have no choice but to participate in killing these extremely difficult monsters yourself.
The purpose of the mechanic is pretty clear: it keeps the game challenging and interesting by making sure you get the best items, and you have to really do the hard stuff and figure out how to kill dragons. You can't just kill pigs for ten hours a year, get a few thousand coins, and then buy epic magical armor from other dragon slaying players.
Of course, the system is far from perfect: you can pay a team of professionals to kill dragons with you, then let you collect loot, or even just buy a character on the secondary market without any of that -- game dollars, so you don't even have to kill a boar. But even so, it's a lot better than everything that always has a price.
NFT in its current form shares many of the same attributes as rare and epic items in massively multiplayer online games. They have social signaling value: people who own them can flaunt them, and there are a growing number of tools that help users do just that. Recently, Twitter began rolling out an integration that allows users to display their NFT in their photo profiles.
But what exactly are these NFT signals? Part of the answer, of course, is acquiring NFT and knowing which NFT skills to acquire. But because NFT is a tradable thing, another big part of the answer inevitably turns out to be a signal that NFT is about wealth.

CryptoPunks are now often sold for millions of dollars, and they're not even the most expensive NFT. The source of the image is here.
If someone shows you that they have an NFT that they can get by doing X, you can't tell if they did X themselves or if they just paid someone else to do X. Sometimes this is not a problem: for an NFT to support a charity, people who buy it from the secondary market are sacrificing their own funds for the cause, they are helping the charity by contributing to the motivation of others to buy an NFT, so there is no reason to discriminate against them. In fact, charitable NFT alone can do a lot of good. But what if the NFT we want to create isn't just about who has the most money, but actually tries to signal something else?
Probably the best example of a project trying to do this is the POAP, or "Proof of attendance Protocol." POAP is a standard by which a project can send an NFT that represents the idea that the recipient is personally involved in some event.

Part of my own POAP collection, most of which comes from events I have attended over the years.
POAP is a good example of NFT, and it works better if it can be spiritually bound. If someone is looking at your POAP, they are not interested in whether you paid people to attend certain events. They are interested in whether you personally attend the event. Proposals to chain certificates (such as driver's licenses, university degrees, proof of age) face a similar problem: if people who do not qualify themselves can buy certificates directly from those who do, their value will be greatly reduced.
While transferable NFT has its place and is very valuable for supporting artists and charities, there is a huge untapped design space for what non-transferable NFT might become.
Here are five more articles I've written over and over on this topic - Nathan Schneider on the Limits of crypto Economics, Beyond Token Voting Governance, Coordination, Good and Bad, On Collusion, Governance, Part 2: Plutocracy Still Sucks - but it still bears repeating: If governance is easy to do something really bad, if governance is easy to transfer. There are two main reasons for this:
- If the goal is to distribute governance broadly, then transferability is counterproductive, because concentrated interests are more likely to buy governance from others.
- Transferability is counterproductive if the goal is to give governance to competent people, because there is nothing to prevent governance from being acquired by determined but incompetent people.
If you take seriously the adage that "those who most want to rule are the least fit to do it," then you should be suspicious of transferability, precisely because transferability keeps governance away from meek human governance, which is most likely to provide valuable inputs, and power-hungry people, which is most likely to cause problems.
So what if we try to make governance non-transferable? What if we tried to create a CityDAO that would give more voting rights to the people who actually live in the city, or at least reliably democratic and avoid the undue influence of whales hoarding large numbers of citizen NFT? What if blockchain protocol DAO governance could somehow make governance power conditional on participation? Once again, a large and fruitful design space opened up that is difficult to access today.
The POAP has made a technical decision not to prevent the TRANSFERability of the POAP itself. For good reason: this user may have good reason to hope that all of its assets from a wallet to another wallet (for security reasons, for example), and "naive" on the implementation of the safety of the metastatic anyway is not very strong, because users can create a wrapper contains NFT account, and then sell its ownership.
In fact, there are many cases where POaps are often bought and sold when there is an economic reason to do so. Adidas recently released a free POAP to their fans that gives users priority access to merchandise sales. What happened? Well, of course, many POaps were quickly transferred to the highest bidder.

There are more transfers than items, and it's not the only time.
To address this issue, the POAP team recommends that developers concerned about non-transferability implement checks themselves: if the current owner has the same address as the original owner, they can check on the chain, and they can add more complex checks if deemed necessary over time. For now, this is a more forward-looking approach.
Perhaps the most powerful non-transferable NFT today is the human proof of proof. In theory, anyone could use a smart contract account with transferable ownership to create a human proof profile and then sell that account. But the certification of humanity agreement has a revocation function, allowing the original owner to make the video, request the deletion of personal details, and the Kleros court to decide whether the video is from the same person as the original creator. Once they have successfully deleted their profile, they can apply for a new profile. Therefore, if you purchase other people's documents, your property may be taken away from you very quickly, making transfer of ownership infeasible. Humans prove that archives are in fact soul bound, and the infrastructure built upon them allows items on the chain to be bound to specific humans in general.
Can we limit transferability, instead of going all the way, based on proof of humanity? It gets more difficult, but for some use cases, a medium-intensity approach might be good enough. Binding NFT to ENS names is an easy choice, if we assume that users care enough about their ENS names that they are unwilling to transfer them. For now, we're likely to see a range of approaches that limit portability, with different projects choosing different trade-offs between security and convenience.
The cryptographic privacy of transferable assets is fairly easy to understand: you take your coins, put them into Tornado. Cash or a similar platform, and withdraw them into a new account. But how do we add privacy to soulbound items if you can't transfer them to a new account or even a smart contract? If humans start to prove more adoptable, privacy becomes even more important, because the alternative is for all our activities to be mapped directly onto the face on the chain.
Fortunately, some fairly simple technical options are possible:
- Stores the item at an address that is (I) index, (ii) recipient address, and (iii) a secret hash that belongs to the recipient. You can reveal your secrets to an interface that will then scan all items that might belong to you, but people who don't have your secrets can't see which items are yours.
- Publish a hash of a bunch of items and give each recipient their Merkle (Merkle tree) branch.
- If the smart contract needs to check whether you own a certain type of item, you can offer ZK-SNark.
Transfers can be made on the chain; The simplest technique may simply be to invoke factory contracts to invalidate the old project and the new project to validate the transaction, using ZK-SNARK to prove that the operation is valid.
Privacy is an important part of what makes this ecosystem work well. In some cases, the underlying thing that the project represents is already public, so it doesn't make sense to try to add privacy. But in many other cases, users don't want to reveal everything they own. If someday in the future, vaccination become POAP, one of the worst things we can do is to create a system that POAP in the system will automatically release to everyone can see, everyone have no choice, only let their medical decisions they look cool things in certain social influence. Privacy as a core part of design can avoid these undesirable outcomes and increase our chances of creating great things.
A common criticism of the "Web3" Spaces that exist today is that everything is money-oriented, with people celebrating ownership and outright waste of vast wealth, which limits the attractiveness and long-term sustainability of the culture that emerges around these objects. Of course, even a financialised NFT can provide important benefits, such as funding for artists and charities, that would otherwise go unrecognised. However, this approach has limitations and many underexploited opportunities for trying to move beyond financialization. Making more "soul-bound" items in crypto space could be a pathway to an alternative, where NFT could represent more of who you are than just what you can afford.
However, there are technical challenges to doing so, and there is an uneasy "interface" between the desire to limit or prevent migration and the blockchain ecosystem, and so far all standards have been designed around maximum portability. Attaching projects to "identity objects" that users cannot (for example, using a proof-of-humanity profile) or do not want to exchange (for example, using the ENS name) seems to be the most promising approach, and there are still challenges in making this use easy to implement, privacy and security. We need to think harder and address these challenges. If it can, this will open the door for blockchain to become the center of a much broader ecosystem of collaboration and fun, not just money.
The original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia