header-langage
简体中文
English
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Why NFT Leasing is Indispensable in the Metaverse

Read this article in 22 Minutes
Leasing is a new type of economic primitive in the Metaverse, which can further enrich various economic relationships in the virtual space.
Original title: "Economic Primitives of the Metaverse 1: Renting and Lending"
Original source: BlockchainColumbia
Original compilation: Rhythm Research Institute-NFT Labs
< p>

After the explosion of the metaverse, people think that DeFi is the economic system of the metaverse, and NFT is the asset of the metaverse, which is like currency and commodity when mapped to the real world. , a close relationship needs to be established between the two.


In the real world, leasing has become more and more common. From housing to electronic equipment to transportation, we can use a small amount of money to obtain the right to use it for a short period of time after paying a deposit. In the metaverse, this behavior is the lease of NFT.


Nowadays, NFT is also endowed with different functions by various project parties. In addition to collection attributes, practicality has also become a consideration for people to buy NFT, and As the unit price of some NFTs is getting higher and higher, the threshold for people to buy NFTs is also increasing, and the demand for "renting NFTs" was born. However, due to technical and other reasons, NFT leasing does not yet have a complete solution, and because it is an emerging demand, it has not yet received much attention. However, some pioneers are also exploring this.


This article is an article published on the Mirror platform by BlockchainColumbia, a student organization of Columbia University. With the advantages and disadvantages of the solution, and imagined the future development and usage scenarios of NFT leasing, Rhythm BlockBeats translated the full text as follows.


Recently, the big event of Facebook’s name change has made everyone’s eyes focus on the Metaverse. Venture capital is now more interested in blockchain games than ever, and some game companies have also begun to deploy in the NFT field. However, if we want the metaverse to develop into "Avalanche", "Ready Player One", and "Sword Art Online", if we want our vision to come into reality, some of the most basic components must be built and put into use.



In this series of articles, we hope to introduce this building block, the economic primitive of the metaverse, and show you how indispensable it is. We want to pay special attention to those practical ways that have not yet gained widespread attention and adoption, so this article on fragmentation and NFT mortgages will not go into details, leaving readers to explore on their own.


We will first briefly introduce the definition of the metaverse, and clarify again the role of NFT in protecting digital property rights. Afterwards, we provide an overview of the basic limitations of smart contracts and introduce different implementations of leasing that are currently live.


If you liked this article, please follow us on Twitter: @0xtaetaehoho and @0xcesare.


If you are already familiar with the concept of the metaverse and the role of Crypto in protecting digital property rights, we recommend skipping directly to the third part of the article. In the first two parts of the article, we directly cite existing literature and provide readers with links to the original articles, which explain the concepts far more clearly than we can.


Disclosure: @0xtaetaehoho purchased an NFT issued by reNFT during the writing of this article.


Table of Contents


1. What is the Metaverse (quick review)

< p>2. The role of Crypto in the metaverse (super quick review)

3. Economic primitives in the metaverse

4. Leasing

5. Contract inheritance model

6. Mortgage model

7. Unmortgage/project party integration model

8. What will happen in the future

>9. Acknowledgments


What is the Metaverse?


In the words of Matthew Ball, the Metaverse is:


"A massive, An interoperable, real-time rendered network of 3D virtual worlds that can be simultaneously and continuously experienced by real and infinite users, with persistence of data such as identities, histories, interests, objects, communications, and payments."

< p>

To illustrate this more visually, watch this clip from Ready Player One:


Video link: https://youtu.be/3DFzWmBVNbU


Many thinkers (including Mark Zuckerberg) believe that the Metaverse will be the place where we live and digitize the human network The only way.


"The Metaverse is our next great milestone as an online species." - Piers Kicks


If you want to read more articles about the Metaverse, we recommend the following articles:


https://www.matthewball.vc/all/forwardtothemetaverseprimer

https://futuristspeaker.com/future-trends/the-history-of- the-metaverse/

https://editorial.superrare.com/2021/09/10/into-the-metaverse-a-short-history/


Crypto's role in the Metaverse


For a deeper understanding, we recommend reading "< a href="https://metaversed.net/263f1ff8c13c455ea472f5689e01acaa" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">the Void: Where Crypto Meets the Metaverse":


“What NFTs enable for the first time is a decentralized, universal layer of digital representation and ownership through which scarcity, uniqueness, and authenticity can be transparently managed.


In order for the economic part of the metaverse to flourish, it is first necessary to introduce shared standards and protocols, which must be adopted in the issuance and circulation of virtual goods widely accepted.


In general, the metaverse is imagined by people as a fully immersive shared virtual space, the pinnacle of network and digital development. NFT protects digital property rights in this ecosystem, allowing us to artificially create digital scarcity, which will become the basis of the virtual economy and Create unprecedented economic value on the Internet.



This is a simple spiritual transition from the real world to the digital world Mapping, in the metaverse, the objects we own and interact with are NFTs, our currency is cryptocurrency, and the contract that determines the flow of the two is a smart contract.


Economic Primitives


At present, the main obstacle we face in realizing the above vision is that NFT Not yet rich enough to replicate the complex economic relationships we rely on in the real world.


This is due to inherent differences between smart contracts and real-world agreements. In the real world, the state is responsible for arbitrating and enforcing the agreement, the parties involved are well known, and because the agreement can be renegotiated and canceled, it also has a certain degree of flexibility, so the agreement does not need to consider all possibilities at the outset. Only when problems arise can safety be guaranteed. Usually, both parties to the agreement will perform in good faith, and the unconsidered issue will be resolved by the judicial system.


This is not the case for smart contracts. Most of the time, we don't know who our adversary is, and the presence of one bad actor compromises the protocol (hackers). Smart contracts have limited flexibility in terms of renegotiation and termination, especially when user growth scales, and smart contracts must take into account all possible scenarios. You can't rely on ordinary regulations and the larger judicial system to arbitrate these unforeseen issues (we're not sure how UETA/E-SIGN would apply here). This is a fundamental limitation in the realization of the complex economic relationships we see in the real world today, and it also explains why the first innovations in smart contracts appeared in defi, because conditional logic can cover much more, and all the required information is already exist on the chain.


However, the vast majority of things we interact with are unforgeable, and the most important protocols for the Metaverse will be those that allow us to A protocol for bringing experienced, hard-to-replicate experiences into the virtual space of the future.


The Economic Primitives of the Metaverse is a series of articles that are being serialized. We hope to introduce the protocols built on these primitives in the articles, We will see the big explosion that has happened in the DeFi world. We will start by discussing the importance of leasing, then explore 3 existing solutions, understand their technical implementation details, and how they can work in a more convenient way. We then wish to introduce future applications and potential use cases of these protocols.


The Importance of Leasing


Q1 2019, S&P 500 companies have more than $503 billion in operating lease liabilities and more than $69 billion in finance lease liabilities on their balance sheets. This includes office space, land, industrial machinery, data centers, network equipment, vehicles, laboratory equipment, restaurant and hotel equipment, construction equipment... and more. Even a pure software product company like Facebook (Meta), balance sheet also has $11 billion in operating lease liabilities.


If my school is close to home, I would wake up in the rented apartment every day, and then go to school on a rented shared bicycle. I've rented cameras, Airbnb cabins, surfboards, motorcycles, video games, DVDs, U-hauls, storage space, and more. Here are the numbers for reference: Tenants in the U.S. paid $512 billion in rent in 2019 and $4.5 trillion in rent over the past decade.


Leasing is a sharing economy Basics (Airbnb, Uber, Turo, Rover... conservatively estimated market capitalization is about 1.5 trillion US dollars)


Extended reading: Weird Things You Can Rent


In daily life, we may or may not notice that non-homogeneous leasing and related services are the most commonly used economic structures in our lives One, as the examples above show, most of the things we interact with in this world are non-homogeneous.


However, there are few existing implementations of this economic primitive. This is mainly because of the limitations of smart contracts mentioned earlier. NFTs are "owned" by a wallet at any one time (unless fragmented). In reality, it is easy to realize that the owner, user/tenant, bank... all have different rights to the relevant assets. Once the owner has only one address, it is difficult to perform other operations.


In the next section, we describe three existing and ongoing implementations on this issue. There are several protocols that we are watching closely and we hope to report on when their contracts are open-sourced in the future.


Contract Inheritance Model (EIP-2615)


April 2020, Kohshi Shiba proposed "EIP-2615: NFT with Mortgage and Leasing Functions” draft, the first concrete attempt to implement a trustless leasing solution for NFT. The project initially received strong support, with the Blockchain Game Alliance forming a working group with support from Yield Guild Games, Delphi Digital, and others. While the project ended up falling in the initial implementation phase, it was still rewarding to educate people about the challenges unique to this problem and see how the proposed solution evolved.


One of the main challenges of implementing leasing functionality with the ERC-721 standard is that it only defines the owner role and limits the complexity and scope of its functionality . At best, an approved address can transfer this role, but no other available role would have different permissions on the said NFT.


EIP-2615 proposes the ERC-2615 standard, which extends the ERC721 token standard and supports leasing and mortgage functions by defining additional roles: lien Holders, Owners and Users. These three roles enable more complex relationships, such as allowing tenants to list rented items and giving holders a lien. By making ERC2615 backwards compatible with ERC721, ERC2615 NFTs will still be compatible with protocols that interact with standard ERC721.


Note: The right to continue to occupy a person's property until the debt owed to him has been paid. (In mortgages, this is what banks do)


Let's take a deeper look at ERC2615 and the features it unlocks. As we mentioned, the standard proposes three roles: Lienholder, Owner, and User.


1. The lien holder has the right to transfer owner and user roles.

2. The owner has the right to transfer owner and user roles

3. The user has the right to transfer user roles.



If this diagram is too complicated , which we'll try to fill in below with more understandable terms.


All leasing and mortgage logic can be expressed in terms of these three roles and their respective rights, plus a small addition: executor; Another smart contract that sets the conditions for the agreement between different parties (such as the renter and the rentee) and is responsible for handling the change of roles, the transfer of tokens, and enforcing the consequences when one of the parties violates the agreement. The draft intentionally does not implement this part, but instead lets developers work on top of this standard.


Using EIP-2615 for leasing


In order to make everyone understand more clearly, let us Show the leasing process of an ERC2615 token. We will assume that a lease contract has been deployed to handle the lease logic and enforce the lease agreement.


1. Suppose Alice wants to lend an NFT she owns. Alice will create a listing on the rental contract and approve the same contract to set the tenant (user) role.


2. Bob wants to rent Alice's NFT. So Bob will fill out the lease request and the role of the tenant (user) is set to Bob.


3. Alice cannot transfer the tenant role now.


4. Bob is to pay rent during the lease agreement; this will be handled by the lease contract (the executor).


5. If Bob violates the lease agreement, the lease contract will revoke Bob's tenant role and reset him to Alice.


6. If instead, at the end of the lease, the tenant's role will be transferred back to Alice, and both parties will leave satisfied.


With ERC2615, NFT will not just be "exclusively owned" by one person. Imagine mapping NFTs to addresses in a ledger in the sky, we now have mappings not only for property owners, but also for tenants, lien holders, and related lease contracts. When a project needs to know who is the current "user" of the NFT, it can read whether the renter exists. If the renter is different from the owner, the project recognizes the renter as the effective "owner" - a wallet with access to the NFT, and defaults to the owner if not.


Example of setting an address as the executor address:


< p style="text-align: center;">< /p>


A smart contract implementing ERC2615 was deployed on Github in October 2020, however, the draft has not progressed since then. We guess that this is because the logic required to implement these three roles and who has the authority to transfer these three roles is very complicated, and the gas efficiency is too low.


On the positive side, the EIP-2615 NFT is self-custodial by the owner, reducing concerns about smart contract risks, This is present in the next two solutions.


Collateral solution (reNFT)


A gas-saving way to solve the lending problem is A staking solution for reNFTs. reNFT is a protocol born out of the Chainlink 2020 Spring Hackathon and the Avalanche Money Dance Hackathon.


List your NFT for rent (mortgage scheme)


The lender is in the reNFT smart contract Place an NFT inside, set a specified collateral and the daily rental fee required to rent the NFT. Then, the leaser provides the corresponding collateral and pays the rent in advance within the predetermined period to borrow the above-mentioned NFT. Once they return the NFT, all payments are delivered to the parties.



For curious readers, We attach a high-level technical overview of the leasing and lending implementation of the reNFT staking solution below. You can also skip this chapter and read "Unsecured Project Party Integration" directly. reNFT supports batch lending of multiple ERC721 and ERC1155, but we will assume that we want to lend or borrow a single NFT.


Technology implementation directory


1. List NFT for rent

2. Leasing NFT

3. Returning the leased NFT

4. Unsecured solution


Alice is going to lend an NFT.


-In order to lend her NFT, Alice selected the total rental period, daily rental price, Required collateral and payment tokens. These inputs are passed as arguments to the lending function.



- This function first creates A structure to summarize the input information. Then call handlelend.

-Handlelend creates and stores information on the blockchain about outstanding loans, including information about each lender - their address, loan amount, their specified maximum rental period, daily rental price , payment tokens and required collateral.



-Finally, the NFT was Sent to the reNFT contract.



You look on the platform The received NFT is held by the reNFT contract. Of course, this means that if the reNFT contract is compromised, it is possible to lose any outstanding loans. The team is aware of this problem, so other solutions have been built, which we will expand on in the future once they are live.


Lending UI


Bob borrows an NFT from Alice.


- Bob selects Alice's NFT and specifies a rental period. After approving payment of tokens, he calls the rent function.

- Similar to lend, this first creates a structure to store information including the lend ID (a nonce specifying how many times the contract was invoked - atm 241), the lease duration and the associated NFT. Then we call handlerent.



-Handlerent also in the district Information about this unpaid rent is created and stored on the blockchain, storing information about the address of the renter, the duration of the rent, and the time when the rent was enforced. Every pair of lending and lending is stored in the same place (a mapping of the hash of the information to the lending structure).



-Then the collateral And the total rent (daily rent * number of days rented) is sent to the contract escrow. The thing to note here is that the payment when renting is made at the beginning. These payments are distributed upon completion, but leases require locking up not just the collateral, but the total lease fee.


- Finally, the contract transfers the NFT from itself to the tenant.


Rent UI


Return NFT


Once Bob kills Elvarg with a borrowed dragon hunter crossbow, shows off his CSGO skin, and cashes in on the metaverse land, he'll be in the lender's place. Return the NFT by terminating the lease before the end of the specified maximum allowable lease period.


After restitution, all monies will be allocated to the parties concerned at that time. The renter only needs to pay according to the total time he actually rented the NFT, and get back the collateral. The amount received by the lender is calculated based on the daily rent price * the total time the NFT loan has been outstanding. From this total value that can be transferred to the lender, the agreement charges a small fee. Currently, this fee is set to zero.


Finally, it deletes the lease record and returns the NFT to the reNFT contract, from which Alice can retrieve her NFT.


One limitation of this implementation is that if the price of the NFT is higher than the price of the collateral, Bob has no incentive to return the NFT. Therefore, the protocol encourages setting a very short maximum lease term and very high collateralization. In the highly volatile NFT market, this is a dangerous element of mortgage leasing for potential lenders and a sub-optimal user experience for potential renters.


If you want to know more about how Alice takes the collateral if Bob fails to return the NFT in time, and the various functions we mentioned above For details, we strongly recommend that you check out reNFT's Github.


Unsecured project integration (unsecured reNFT)


Ideally, as in DeFi, unsecured and trustless is the gold standard for leasing. As we have seen, the ERC721 standard itself is not sophisticated enough to support these primitives. Although a new standard has been introduced, namely EIP-2615, which has more functions and seems to be the most thorough solution, it will also incur high conversion costs, which makes it not yet available on the mainnet. to build, and its complexity is uncontrollable.


In order to solve this problem under the current paradigm, reNFT has developed a registration smart contract, by hosting the lender's NFT and conducting the registration of the person who rents the NFT Track to apply leasing logic.


To rent an NFT in escrow on this contract, the renter only needs to call the handleRent function to create a log in the registry to record the renter's address, lease amount, lease period, and timestamp when leased.



The contract is also responsible for processing the payment of the lease (no collateral), and these payments will also be escrowed in the contract for subsequent distribution. It is worth noting that NFTs exist in the registration smart contract until the lender decides to redeem it; the registry can only show whether an item is currently on loan, and by whom at a certain point in time.


Compared to the scheme that requires collateral, the advantage of this method is that NFT is always in the contract, so that we can improve the efficiency of Gas , because the borrower no longer has to retrieve or return the corresponding NFT.


In addition, the logic in the smart contract will also guarantee the interest of the renter, if he is currently renting the NFT, the lender will not be able to redeem it from the escrow . Similarly, under this logic, the lender's ownership of the NFT will not be affected in any way, and if the NFT is not rented, they can choose to redeem it from the smart contract. In the unsecured scheme, even if the NFT becomes very valuable during the lease period, the lender does not have to worry about the tenant not returning their NFT, but in the scheme that requires collateral, this risk still exists.


However, unsecured solutions need to introduce a new element: project party integration. If the lender has escrowed the NFT to a registry, the ERC721 contract will assign the owner to the registry smart contract. If the NFT is currently in the lending state, the NFT project party needs to first check whether the NFT is still being rented out, and then who borrowed the NFT to determine who the "owner" of the NFT is in each time period .


In order to ensure the smooth progress of the project, the reNFT team built an SDK that the project team can use to locate the latest "owner" in the registry smart contract. In order to achieve unsecured leasing, the project only needs to check the ERC721 owner. If the owner is a smart contract, the project team can use the SDK to obtain relevant information about whether the NFT is being rented and the identity of the renter.


Unsecured Animetas rental service provided by reNFT


We did not provide a more in-depth registration contract technical specification because it is related to the mortgage Loan contracts are very similar. If you want to know more, check here re for more information about the registration contract or here re Learn more about the SDK.


Native integrated non-collateralized lending


As we mentioned above, reNFT two One of the biggest security risks comes from token collateral and custody NFTs, which are stored in its smart contracts. That unsecured lending solution we're talking about still requires the NFT to be escrowed to work. In order to eliminate these two major risks, reNFT wants to further expand the ERC721 and ERC1155 token standards to enrich the functions that users can adopt when using NFT. This solution is still being worked on, and we will finish writing this and a similar solution including wrappers as soon as possible.


NFTs and the Future of Leasing


reNFT recently closed a $1.5M strategic seed round , led by Animoca Brands, with participation from MetaCartel, Scalar, Play, Lattice, Gabby Dizon (founder of Yield Guild), Sebastien Borget (founder of The Sandbox), and Eric Aresealt (Rarible).



In the near future, They plan to build lending and leasing infrastructure for NFT games. Today, a large percentage of players in the Axie ecosystem are scholarship students. Managers "lend" their accounts to scholars, providing them with the email address, PW, and QR code of the Ronin account, each of which has three axies for getting started with the game. The process is entirely manual and relies on mutual trust. Scholars need to trust that administrators will pay them, and administrators must also trust that academics will not violate Axie's terms of service, because violations will face account bans.


If reNFT is integrated with Ronin, Axie owners are now free to manage scholarships without trust - Axie owners can lend their Axie in exchange for A certain rental price (student share of the scholarship) is offered to others for a maximum period of rental. Scholarships Students can receive scholarships on the open market for a better price discovery process.


Their work with YGG, Animoca Games, The Sandbox and Rarible shows that the team is taking a short-term strategic approach. Also, they are already in talks with multiple NFT games for integration at a later date.


In the long run, the team is working towards becoming a plug-and-play economic primitive for the Metaverse.


reNFT is working hard to become the underlying protocol for all the following activities, including hosting parties on Embersword or Decentraland leased land (scene as a service), using you to buy Unforgettable best weapons for raids, access to exclusive airdrops, participation in community events with NFT thresholds, and royalties from 3LAU's latest album, rental of intellectual property for biotech research.



Even in the distant future , whether it is paying rent for a residence in the metaverse, vacationing in a metaverse wooden house on Airbnb, or using rented industrial equipment (metaverse operating lease?) in the metaverse to create native art, music, NFT (Similar to Metaverse Factory?), reNFT hopes to provide development momentum for these complex economic relationships.



Other possible uses of NFT Approach


People can already short NFT futures through staking solutions. If the renter believes that the price of the listed NFT will drop during the lease period, they can borrow the NFT and sell it by setting collateral and paying the funding rate (daily rental fee), and buy it back at the end of the lease period. return.


In addition, in the original EIP721 standard, NFT can represent a class of "negative value" assets, such as loans, liabilities, or some other liability. For example, if there is an NFT lease or ERC20 LP, a corresponding NFT will be minted (similar to LP tokens). reNFTs enable bundled loans on top of these NFTs, creating the possibility for other securitized products.


Another interesting idea is that when we rent big-ticket commodities in reality, such as cars, houses, etc., they will be subject to credit constraints, and the lender will cooperate with The renter signs a contract to prevent his interests from being infringed, and restricts some behaviors of the renter. But if we borrow some small items, such as pencils for exams and tools from neighbors, we will not encounter these constraints. The lease is entirely based on trust.


I remember reading something like this a few years ago:


"An ordinary Your hand drill may only be used for 10 minutes during its lifetime, but more than half of all American households have one.”


But more noteworthy Yes, how many times have you rather bought another pair of scissors, stapler, pencil, or camera, guitar, etc., than borrow it from a friend? Perhaps with trustless leasing, we will greatly reduce the waste of resources, because in the future metaverse, because we can easily borrow items we want from others.


As EIP721 - "We have imagined that NFT can represent a variety of different types of assets, and we believe that you will come up with more possibilities."


Obligatory sunpunk-esque image -- actually one from a game I once played City


Summary


Leasing is a new type of economic primitive in the metaverse, which can further enrich various economic relationships in the virtual space.



If the metaverse is a singularity, its arrival will make our lives in the virtual world better than our real world Lives matter more and make the total value of virtual goods exceed the total value of physical goods. Then, by then, the total economic value guaranteed by virtual goods will exceed the "real" GDP. But to realize this vision, we need to accelerate the innovation of smart contracts, so that we can easily replicate the complex economic relationships in reality. In general, many related protocols are currently being built, and we are very excited about this, because they are laying a solid foundation for that future, and I also hope that they will be launched on the main network or layer1 and layer2 as soon as possible. We will also publish papers describing these protocols.


Original link




Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit