header-langage
简体中文
English
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

When the NFT art collection meets Double Eleven, is the seven-day unreasonable return still applicable?

Read this article in 9 Minutes
What factors need to be considered when judging whether an NFT art collection is suitable for seven-day no-reason return?
Original title: "Can NFT art collections be returned without reason within seven days?" "
Original source: Babbitt


Say it first


We believe that NFT art collections are an umbrella concept, and whether it is applicable to seven-day unreasonable return needs to be analyzed according to the specific type of collection.


Under the premise that there is no technical obstacle that cannot be returned, when the NFT art collection is not "Consumer Rights Protection of the People's Republic of China The Law and the "Interim Measures for the Seven-Day Unreasonable Return of Online Purchased Goods" stipulate that if the seven-day unreasonable return is not applicable or may not be applicable to the goods, consumers have the right to seven-day unreasonable return.


It cannot be because NFT art collections are emerging digital commodities, and operators only add "this product does not apply" to the user agreement Seven-day no-reason return” method can circumvent the relevant regulations of seven-day no-reason return.



With NFT The concept of NFT is gradually being understood by more and more people, and more merchants have begun to use the concept of NFT to promote and sell their products. Along with the popularity of Double Eleven, Taobao also launched the "Metaverse Art Exhibition". Although it is called an art exhibition, it is more of a way for merchants to attract more consumers to buy products by selling goods and giving away NFT art collections.


(Taobao Yuan Universe Art Exhibition promotional image)< /blockquote>


Whether it is an NFT art collection sold directly or an NFT art collection sold together with physical goods. The emergence of consumption scenes is often accompanied by consumption disputes. The reason for the dispute of consumption may be that the seller's goods are not right, or it may be the change of the buyer's willingness to consume.


So for NFT art collections sold on online platforms, is it also the same as our daily online shopping, and can the relevant provisions of seven-day no-reason return apply?


Related regulations on returns without reason within one or seven days


Article 25 of the "Consumer Protection Law of the People's Republic of China" and "Interim Measures for Seven-day Unreasonable Return of Online Purchases" It stipulates that consumers have the right to return goods sold online within seven days from the date of receipt of the goods without explaining the reason. At the same time, the following provisions are made for goods that are not applicable or can be returned without reason within seven days :



Second, the relevant agreements and regulations of domestic mainstream NFT art collection trading platforms


( 1) A screenshot of part of the content of the user agreement on the AntChain Vermicelli platform is as follows:



< /p>

(2) A screenshot of part of the purchase page in the Magic Core APP is as follows:



Judging from the current policies of the two major distribution platforms of NFT art collections in China, none of them support seven-day unreasonable returns.


3. Can NFT art collections be returned without reason within seven days?


When judging whether an NFT art collection is suitable for seven-day no-reason return, the following points need to be considered Factors:


(1) Legislative intent of seven-day no-reason return


Seven-day no The purpose of reason return is to balance the information asymmetry that exists in online sales. When consumers shop online, they often cannot understand the nature of the goods in detail like offline shopping. If the consumer misunderstands the nature of the product due to information asymmetry and makes a purchase mistake, the seven-day unreasonable return gives the consumer the right to repent, thereby protecting the consumer's right to know, right to choose and fair trade.


However, the rights given to consumers by seven-day no-reason return are not unlimited. It will ossify the vitality of the operators, and will deal a blow to the enthusiasm of the market. If things go on like this, the interests of consumers will also be damaged.


NFT art collections are usually only digital commodities, and there are often not necessarily exact corresponding offline physical commodities. However, the absence of physical goods does not mean that there is no information asymmetry between online sales and physical goods. The information asymmetry here, the author thinks, should be understood as the content asymmetry between the online product sales information and the actual goods received, rather than necessarily limited to the concept that physical goods must be received.


(2) Will the value connotation of NFT art collections affect the seven-day unreasonable return


Article 2 of the "Consumer Rights Protection Law": "Consumers' rights and interests are protected by this law when they purchase, use goods or receive services for life consumption needs; Relevant laws and regulations protect." "Interim Measures for Seven-day Unreasonable Return of Online Purchased Products" Article 2: Consumers who need to purchase products online for daily consumption must comply with the "Consumer Rights Protection Law" within seven days from the date of receipt of the products. Article 25 of the "Return of goods" shall apply to these Measures.


What is the need for living consumption? Is the purchase of NFT art collections a living consumption need? The author believes that the consumption needs of life not only refer to the material needs that people need to meet in their daily lives, but also include people's spiritual and cultural needs.


The Ant Platform has renamed NFT artworks as digital collections some time ago. On the one hand, the Ant platform may be for legal compliance considerations, but on the other hand, it is understood that the NFT artwork named digital "collection" actually always adheres to the nature of its collection. The author believes that collectibles are also the consumption objects of consumers when they meet their own spiritual and cultural needs, and cannot be included in the scope of commodities that are not applicable or can be returned without reason within seven days.


However, there are also views on the value of NFT art collections at present, which tend to belong to a kind of virtual rights and interests, which are different from traditional physical collections. That is, after purchasing an NFT art collection, the rights and interests contained in it have been enjoyed and used by the buyer. In addition, the platform agreement will also indicate in advance that the NFT art collection does not apply to the seven-day no-reason return clause. Therefore, when the virtual rights have been enjoyed and used, it will affect the application of the seven-day no-reason return rule for NFT art collections.


The author believes that whether NFT art collections are completely equivalent to virtual rights, and whether the rights are enjoyed and used after purchase, needs to be determined according to different types of NFT art collections. Analysis, rather than a single general evaluation.


(3) Are the sellers of NFT art collections all operators stipulated in the Consumer Law?


NFT art collections are different from general online sales. The sales of NFT art collections have the following situations: individual artists, after NFTizing their works, sell them to the outside world through the platform as a medium. The NFT art collections of individual artists have short-term and unstable characteristics. They are different from online commodity operators, and may only upload a few of their own works in a short period of time, rather than making long-term profits through NFT works of art.


From this point of view, if an individual artist sells his NFT art collection sporadically in a short period of time, it cannot be regarded as "Consumer Law" As stipulated by the operator, the seven-day no reason return is not applicable. However, if there is an identical work that is sold in hundreds or more copies, it is a different matter.


Therefore, not all NFT art collection sellers are operators stipulated in the "Consumer Law". If it does not belong to the operator, it is difficult to apply the seven-day no-reason return policy.


(4) Whether the NFT art collection is not applicable or can be returned for seven days without reason

< p>

The types of NFT art collections are roughly divided into: calligraphy and painting (including emoticons, etc.), hand-made models, photographic works, musical works, film and television works, and written works etc. Therefore, it is necessary to judge whether it is a product that is not applicable or can be returned without reason within seven days according to the specific type of NFT art collection.


For example, if NFT art collections such as music and video are sold by platform operators, the detailed content can only be experienced after consumers purchase them. After experiencing such rights and interests, it is not appropriate to claim that there is no reason to return the product within seven days. Of course, if the nature of collection of this type of NFT art collection is much higher than the nature of equity experience, there will be different judgments.


For another example, if the platform operator sells blind box NFT art collections, consumers will be eligible to open the blind box after purchasing the collection. After it is turned on, it is claimed that there is no reason to return the product within seven days, so the author thinks it will not be supported.


For another example, if it is an NFT art work of calligraphy, painting, and hand-made models, if there is no so-called exhaustion of rights and interests after purchase, the author believes that , should fall within the protection scope of seven-day no-reason return.


Based on the above discussion, in the absence of obstacles that cannot be returned at the technical level, the author is more inclined to apply the relevant provisions of the seven-day unreasonable return of NFT art collections. Of course, it is necessary to comprehensively analyze whether the specific types of NFT art collections are included in the scope of non-applicable or non-applicable seven-day unreasonable returns stipulated by laws and regulations.


Fourth, the lawyer's point of view


< p>

If the ultimate destination of NFT art collections is to be embedded in the metaverse, then the relevant regulatory policies for NFT assets will always accompany the issuance environment and technology Iteration requires constant revision of changes. Today, when new things are constantly emerging, it is necessary to analyze the specific connotation of the new things themselves, such as NFT art collections, and cannot blindly narrow or expand their legitimate rights and interests that should be protected by laws and regulations.


Even though there may be differences in cognitive viewpoints now, leading to differences in outcomes. However, as the application of NFT continues to expand, there will always be special policies to regulate it after it covers more types. Of course, with the improvement of technology level, the information asymmetry of consumers' online shopping in the future will be gradually smoothed out.


Consumers’ right to know, right to choose and right to fair trade are no longer different from offline shopping due to the development of technology, and relevant regulations will be constantly updated . But the most important thing is always that the rights and interests of consumers (not only buyers of NFT art collections, but also participants in larger emerging consumption scenarios in the future) must take into account efficiency, experience, choice and fairness.


Original link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit