Original title: " When EIP-1559 goes online, pour a little cold water 》
Original source: Shenchao TechFlow

August 5th, Ethereum London hard fork The upgrade is complete, and EIP-1559 is officially launched.
Ethereum has ushered in an unprecedented highlight moment. It seems that everyone is discussing and waiting for the reversal moment-Ethereum surpasses Bitcoin.
Goldman Sachs issued a report saying that Ethereum is the blockchain with the most "practical use potential", and its market value is expected to surpass Bitcoin.
BitMEX founder Arthur Hayes wrote an article discussing the possibility of Ethereum surpassing Bitcoin in market value.
The two principals of Bankless, Ryan Sean Adams and David Hoffman, as the number one milk king of Ethereum, have output such as "Ethereum is the most capitalized Efficient assets", "It is inevitable that Ethereum surpasses Bitcoin"...etc.
It is worth mentioning that since the Chinese encryption world often translates and spreads Bankless articles, the Chinese-speaking world is also filled with a reversal of Ethereum The Mysterious Confidence of Bitcoin. ...
The atmosphere group is all in place, the founder of Ethereum, V God, also bravely said in an interview with CNN, Ethereum is expected to surpass Bitcoin in market capitalization.
How does Ethereum surpass Bitcoin?
EIP-1559 is undoubtedly everyone's hope. In all discussions about Ethereum surpassing Bitcoin, EIP-1559 will be mentioned: implement EIP After -1559, the basic fee will be burned, and Ethereum will reverse the inflation trend and become a deflationary asset. As for the price, of course To the Moon.
For example, Pantera Capital founder Dan Morehead said in an interview that the upcoming London upgrade will help Ethereum catch up with Bitcoin, making Ethereum More like a fixed asset.
The anticipation of the deflation of Ethereum has also evolved into a MEME symbol, and the encrypted big Vs put bats and voices next to their Twitter names
p>
But the more I tout Ethereum like this, the more dangerous I feel.
People always tend to overestimate the short-term impact of an event, but greatly underestimate its long-term impact. It is very appropriate to describe EIP 1559.
This impact may be positive or negative, although most people regard it as a great benefit.
First, we have to understand a real EIP-1559.
The core of EIP-1559 is to change the way users pay for transactions on the Ethereum chain.
In the past, transactions on the Ethereum chain used the first-price auction model, which is well understood, and the highest price wins.
The miners choose the packaged blocks according to the user's bid, and get the handling fee paid by the user, which also leads to a serious problem - involution.
Just like taking a Didi car or ordering takeout on a rainy day, the driver only accepts the order according to the price, which leads to only " The rich" can enjoy the service first, and others have to increase their quotations, which virtually increases the average cost.
Originally 20 yuan can be used for a taxi, but in the end everyone has to pay 50 yuan to take a taxi, which is too expensive.
How to solve it?
There is EIP-1559, abandoning the first price auction, adopting the uniform price auction mode, and setting a basic fee.
This is like in order to deal with the problem of expensive and difficult taxis. The price is high or low to choose passengers, but directly use the price set by the Internet company. This fee will change according to the real-time supply and demand situation.
In addition, in order to meet the needs of some users, in order to speed up transactions during congestion, you can also tip miners by way of rewards .
So, will the miners themselves send a large number of transactions to raise the basic fee, left handed and right handed?
So, in order to prevent this, the most ruthless trick of EIP-1559 appeared, miners do not get the basic fee, directly destroy , which is also the most controversial point of the entire EIP-1559.
If it is not destroyed, it is like a taxi or takeaway platform in the Internet ecology to set dynamic prices uniformly, and tip prices increase during peak hours, Once the destruction policy is introduced, it changes the monetary policy of ETH.
Initially, the purpose of EIP-1559 was to reduce the transaction fee, but now everyone is more concerned about whether EIP-1559 can make Ethereum Square into deflation, the price is TO THE MOON.
In the Bitcoin mechanism, the system only provides one payment channel, and the user pays directly to the miners who provide accounting services , which is equivalent to a service fee.
After EIP-1559, the fees that were originally paid directly to the miners were deprived and destroyed by the "central", which is equivalent to becoming a kind of tax.
Taxes are never only levied on producers, but also on consumers. By increasing taxes and reducing the income of service providers Lower transaction fees? To make an analogy, can real estate developers be taxed heavily and lower real estate developers’ income lower housing prices?
It seems that it does not make sense from the basic economic principles, so there is a big question mark here, at least from the current situation From the point of view, there is no performance of reducing the handling fee.
So why do most currency holders applaud such a "tax policy"?
There is nothing else, which is good for the price of ETH.
In the eyes of most people, all measures that are conducive to the rise of currency prices should be supported. This tax is distributed to all currency holders in the form of burning, which is a feat of mining miners to share gasoline.
If the Internet platform takes away most of the driver's basic expenses, then it will definitely be denounced as "capital blood sucking", sympathy Miners, but if this fee benefits all stock holders, then everyone will feel that this policy is justified.
As for the miners, in the face of V God and the strong voice of the Ethereum Foundation, it seems that they can only swallow their anger.
Compared with Bitcoin miners, Ethereum miners have always been relatively weak.
From the perspective of the algorithm mechanism, the miner should be the master of the blockchain, at least a partner, but since 2015 When the difficulty bomb started, Ethereum miners were destined to be temporary workers, and they did not receive the "respect" they deserved.
ETH2.0 is destined to split when it comes, and EIP-1559 will preview the contradiction again. Now it seems that V God and Ethereum Foundation The meeting appeared to have won, but the consensus was broken, and the miners' counterattack may be on the way.
A big fork will come sooner or later.
In our previous article "Ethereum's True Competitive Advantage: Ideology", we pointed out that the biggest competitiveness of Ethereum is the ideology of decentralization.
DeFi is also an ideological choice, such as some purists or top DeFi protocols refusing to operate outside of Ethereum The development of any application on the network, this persistence has greatly widened the moat of the Ethereum network.
All new public chains trying to challenge Ethereum must realize that technological progress is actually the easiest, and ideological transcendence is the easiest hard.
Correspondingly, the biggest danger of Ethereum is also the degeneration of ideology, from a creative and united community to a A company controlled by Vitalik and the Ethereum Foundation.
• EIP-1559
• Layer2
• ETH2.0
This is the "three small things" that V God and the Ethereum Foundation have been committed to promoting. Look, no one seems to be able to stop its pace, and all non-technical problems are not a problem.
Miners can be sacrificed and abandoned at any time. This is the price on the road to growth. Who will be the next price?
Since EIP-1559, the power structure of the Ethereum system has changed. Banknotes, the right-hand tax, resemble a national system.
In 2019, Lane Rettig of the EWASM team, the core developer of Ethereum, complained on Twitter: "Ethereum's governance has failed and is effectively expert rule: a small group of technical experts has the final say on protocol updates."
Compared with the Bitcoin network that also adopts off-chain governance, Ethereum's "Satoshi Nakamoto" has not retired yet. Although V God himself is not a dictator, his Words and deeds can often affect other people's minds and decisions, especially the Ethereum Foundation has no opinions and is afraid to express opinions and make decisions.
But the magic is that it is precisely in the one or two years when the Ethereum Foundation has no sense of existence (such as 2019, 2020), the entire Ethereum DeFi ecosystem has exploded.
Throughout history, many great prosperity have come from bottom-up savage growth, inaction and self-interest, And many tragic tragedies often come from the noble and grand dreams and wishful thinking of certain individuals and organizations.
Although the media and the community are shouting "Ethereum is invincible" and "Ethereum is about to surpass Ethereum" , but today's Ethereum is far from "victory", there are many problems, and there is a long way to go.
I wish Ethereum better and better.
< blockquote>Note: The author holds an ETH position, and the market value of the position occupies the first place.
Original link< /a>
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia