Polygon and BSC are hot, does anyone care about Rollups?
Haseeb Qureshi, Partner at Dragonfly Capital
South Wind, Unitimes
I was afraid no one would care about Rollups.
The biggest story of Ethereum over the past six months has been the explosion in demand for transactions. Transaction fees have already surpassed record levels, and many ordinary users are priced out of Ethereum.

The dollar price of Ethereum network transaction fees; Image credit: CoinMetrics
But don't worry, a savior has already emerged. Obviously, I'm saying that. Rollups. Vitalik predicts Rollups is the future of Ethereum expansion. To date, the Head Rollups program has received over $100 million in venture capital funding. Each of the major DEFI protocols has chosen its own stand, committed to one of the Rollup solutions as its future home. If you don't know what a Rollups is, here's a quick summary: Rollups are essentially miniature blockchains that inherit the security properties of the blockchains they're built on top of, like Ethereum. Even if a Rollup verifier/operator can't be trusted, they can't steal your money (if the Rollup is implemented in the right way, of course). There are two basic types of Rollups: Optimistic Rollups And Zero Knowledge (ZK) Rollups. Optimistic Rollups are froud proofs & NBSP; Protected, which means that anyone is free to prove that the calculation is correct; ZK Rollups, on the other hand, is protected by cryptography, that is, by mathematical proof that the calculation is correct. Vitalik A more comprehensive discussion of Rollups is beyond the scope of this article, but if you want to learn more about Rollups, check Vitalik'sAn Incomplete Guide to RollupsThe article. (or rhythm station searchWhat exactly is Rollup and how to use it?)
The beauty of Rollups is that they are completely trustless. If you trust Ethereum, you should trust Rollups. It was an airtight expansion plan, and as such was welcomed by the Ethereum leadership.
Now let's look at Ethereum's second big event in the last six months: Binance Smart Chain (BSC)& NBSP; And & have spent Polygon (Formerly Matic). These are not Rollups, they are more like [Ethereum's]. Side chains, because they are completely separate POS-based clones of Ethereum. They basically just used off-the-shelf Geth, removed the consensus code from it, increased the Gas cap, and bridged back to Ethereum using multisig.
Look, they've expanded.

Figure above: Polygon transactions (green line), Binance transactions (black line), and Ethereum transactions (blue line) since January 2021. Image credit: Our Network
Polygon and Binance Smart Link (BSC) have both been hugely successful, and they now both have more transactions per day than Ethereum itself. In addition, such as Other blockchains, such as Avalanche and Near, are also racing to develop their own EVM (Ethereum Virtual Machine) compatible systems that can also be connected to Ethereum.
The crypto world today basically looks like this:

It's almost like sharding, but the "beacon chain" is the Ethereum 1.0 chain. Cross-chain transfers and messaging are facilitated by multiple signatures, Bridges, and a number of trusted participants. I call this architecture "poor man's sharding." This is how DEFI is actually expanding today.
But! This sad state of affairs will soon come to an end. Because the Rollups will be ready soon.
I'm very excited about Rollups. It's really exciting. Rollups It's subversive and elegant, and it's very well designed.
But I'm afraid users won't care about Rollups. Here's why I'm worried.
Let me tell you an old story. There was a blockchain network that couldn't scale. But then some very smart people came up with the trustless Layer 2 technology that allows the blockchain to scale. Users are excited. Then, after years of hard work, these smart people finally build Layer 2 (Layer 2). When users finally reach Layer 2, no one cares because they are already using other, simpler but less reliable scaling solutions.

Does this story sound familiar, remember the Lightning Network, people just use WBTC.
Remember Plasma, people just use XDAI. Right now, people are just using Polygon and BSC instead of waiting for Rollups.
Great narratives "solve" everyone's problems. Rollup's expanded narrative makes sense to everyone. Decentralized maximists tell a grand story about scaling up Ethereum without making trade-offs. Traders have drawn lines on price charts about how Rollups will push ETH up to $10,000. Ordinary users, while using Polygon to plunder Aave-Matic revenues and play digital racing betting, nodded curiously to Rollups's narrative.
I'm not being funny. Rollups received overwhelming support from the Ethereum intelligentsia, who were happy to criticize things that weren't decentralized enough. I understand, because I'm one of them.
But it's hard to ignore that most people have adopted Polygon and BSC. None of the venture capital thought leaders saw this coming. Large numbers of users from India, Indonesia, Thailand, the Philippines and other developing countries are embracing these platforms, many of whom seem to have never used Ethereum before (the cost is too high). Remember when you said "bank the unbanked", well, platforms like Polgyon and BSC have practically reached out to the world, attracting the things that users really care about.
I often say that there are three motivations that drive cryptographic users today:
To make money,
Fun,
· Ideology & NBSP;
Of these three, ideology. Ideology is the weakest. I fear that ideology will ultimately be the main driving force behind the adoption of Rollups.
The problem with Layer 2 solutions is that they sound better in theory than they really are.
Now on Polygon, the cost of a simple Uniswap-type transaction is $0.0001. On Binance Smart Chain (BSC), the cost is $0.20. On Ethereum, the cost is about $7. In Optimistim Ethereum (Layer 2 scenario based on Optimistic Rollup)& NBSP; , the cost is about $0.68.
The reason why transaction costs are higher on Rollups than on the side chain is that each Rollup eventually needs to publish calldata on the Ethereum main chain. This ties Rollups' fees to Ethereum's. Each Rollup can only extend Ethereum by a constant factor. As a result, Rollups won't cost as much as many (Polygon or BSC) users are used to.
And no one Rollup is fully compatible with EVM, and each Rollup's virtual machine is slightly different from EVM. Rollups virtual machines, such as Arbitrum using AVM virtual machines and Optimistim Ethereum using OVM virtual machines, break a few contract and EVM-compatible tools slightly. For ZK-Rollups, it's a different world: ZK-Rollups will compile Solidity into pair-to-pair zero knowledge proof circuitry and execute it in the ZK virtual machine.
Now compare Rollups to Polygon, where you just copy and paste your contract.
Then consider the money flowing in and out of Rollups.
For Optimistic Rollups, when you want to withdraw money to the Ethereum mainchain, there is a challenge period of about a week, during which your withdrawals are frozen. So in order to make "quick withdrawals," the market makers will be ready to help you make quick withdrawals, for a fee of course. The amount they charge you depends on how much you withdraw and the liquidity of the asset. If you need to withdraw ETH then this will cost around 0.2% or more, but if you try to withdraw "Dog Currency" then it may cost more, perhaps 1% or more. If an asset is not liquid enough, it may not be able to be withdrawn quickly.
As a user, you need to consider all of these factors when planning your rollup-based Defi portfolio. Having said that, you can avoid these withdrawal issues if you use a traditional multi-sign-based "bridge" to bridge to the Rollup. But if you're taking on the hosting risk of a multi-check-based "bridge," how does this approach improve on Polygon?
(Note that ZK-Rollup is not affected by this withdrawal issue, as their withdrawals are virtually instantaneous.)
I worry that with all these fees, Rollups will not be able to cater to users at either end of the spectrum. Paying for the (exorbitant) cost of the Ethereum mainnet is fine if you're a super-whale who cares deeply about security; If you're an ordinary person, you'll embrace Polygon. And who else is left.
Before all this starts, here's what I think about Layer 2: Every DeFi protocol on Ethereum will commit to using Layer 2, some will choose Optimism, some will choose StarkWare, which gets the most protocol adoption. The Layer 2 solution will eventually become the dominant Rollup.
But clearly, this is not the right way to think. Inevitably, the DEFI protocol tends to choose multiple scaling options. AAVE, Sushiswap, and Curve have launched on Polygon, boosting its TVL (total lockup value) to more than $8 billion. But Sushiswap is already there. FANTOM, Polygon, XDAI, BSC and Moonbeam are deployed on five chains; Curve has also been deployed on Polygon, FTOM, XDAI and other chains. For a long time, Uniswap was only aligned with Optimism, but with & NBSP; Arbitrum In a change of tone, Uniswap will also adopt this approach of deploying across multiple chains.

What Binance Smart Chain (BSC) is telling us is that if you don't deploy on BSC, we will launch a forked version of you and take away the revenue you could have. Going forward, I expect every major DEFI protocol to be pre-emptively deployed on every major chain.
So, does the DeFi protocol decide where the user goes, or does the user decide where the DeFi protocol goes?
For now, the lesson for Polygon and BSC seems to be the latter: protocols follow users, and those protocols are well rewarded for doing so.
As an investor, I can tell you that the current consensus is that Rollups will win. Vitalik loves Rollups. Everyone loves Rollups.
But I'm worried. I was afraid no one would care about Rollups. People already have what Rollups originally promised: fast, cheap, EVM-compatible blockchains that can seamlessly integrate with the Ethereum ecosystem.
So how will Rollups be able to win in the long run?
In my opinion, there are two ways: one is that these non-rollups side chains failed disastrously, and the crypto industry learned a lesson similar to that of Mt.Gox. Catastrophic failure doesn't just mean "nodes don't synchronize," it means "money is gone" or "the chain stops working completely." It could happen, but it's unlikely.
This leaves us with another approach: Rollups have to be much better than the alternative. The benefits of decentralization in Rollups are not enough. I personally see a way forward with the promise of cryptography and zero-knowledge proof.
Over the past few years, cryptography, the basis of zero-knowledge proof, has gone on a Moore's Law trajectory and shows no signs of slowing down. Previously, it was considered infeasible to perform EVM-like computations in ZK Rollups, but now ZKSync and StarkWare are about to start such computations and construct ZK-snarks recursively to prove the computations. Over time, I expect we'll see Rollups deliver even more scalable improvements than we do today: massive computing compression, privacy-protecting smart contracts, proven resistance to MEV  (miner extractable value), and so on.
State growth is not a big problem in ZK-Rollups either, because no matter how big the state is, the user can always verify the correctness of the state by simply verifying the order of the SNARKs.
In the long run, zero-knowledge technologies will only get better.
But even in the short term, I'm doing something for Matter Labs. And its zkPorter The architecture is excited. ZKPorter is a hybrid of Validium and ZK-Rollup, allowing users to seamlessly migrate between the two. Since Validium's data is stored down the chain, its fees can be comparable to those of Polygon, and for users who want more security, the more expensive ZK-Rollup mode can be used. Zkporter integrates all of the user's choices under one roof, with full interoperability between the choices.

ZkPorter architecture; Image credit: Matter Labs
In my opinion, this is the way of the future. We used to say, "No, you're making the wrong choice, stupid, and I don't care if it's cheaper," but that's no longer enough. We should not close the door to further innovation.
As for Rollups, I'm betting it will win. But you never know. I was wrong more times than I was wrong, and if users had embraced Rollups in the first place, that would have been good for them and good for Ethereum.
< This article was written while I was on an airplane, so please ignore any omissions. Dragonfly has positions in almost all of the assets mentioned in this article. Thanks to Ivan and Celia for the review. >
The original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia