header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Will productive DeFi assets like Sushiswap and Compound have higher returns?

Read this article in 7 Minutes
It may not matter whether an asset is productive or not. What matters most is the underlying product and its growth.

It may not matter whether an asset is productive or not. What matters most is the underlying product and its growth.


Title: The Defi Way: Are Productive Defi Assets Worth Holding? The Data Tell Us

By Lucas Campbell, Bankless 
Last night's porridge, Babbitt


Today, there are two main categories of DeFi tokens: productive and unproductive.


The non-productive DEFI token is the classic "worthless" governance token that we all know and love, and tokens like UNI and COMP are perfect examples, although they have generated hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue since their birth, these tokens only represent the right to participate in governance, not the cash flow right.


On the other hand, we've also seen the emergence of productive Defi tokens like Sushi and Aave. These are the holy grail of crypto capital assets because they represent both governance and on-chain cash flow rights. Unlike unproductive tokens, they allow holders to receive a return of passive income in the form of an agreement fee (and in some cases an inflation bonus).


For AVE, holders can pledge their money in a security module, and their funds will be used as collateral of last resort. In return, they receive rewards from ecosystem reserves and agreement fees. Similarly, Sushi holders have the option to pledge their tokens and acquire XSushi for 16.6% of all fees incurred by Sushiswap.


We intuitively assume that productive assets are superior -- that is, that they are always a better bet for investors. But that may not be the case. Ultimately, what matters most in investing is market performance.


As with traditional finance, the most important thing may not be whether the token has cash flow rights. Instead, valuation is driven by growth in fundamentals, such as volume, revenue, users, etc.


This article uses some quantitative evidence to support this claim, so we will use two similar sets of protocols, one with productive assets and the other with unproductive assets.


The two sets of protocols are (1) Uniswap and Sushiswap and (2) Compound and AVE.


A horizontal comparison


1. Uniswap and Sushiswap


Of course, the key metric to understanding any Dex token, such as Sushi and Uni, is trading volume. This is a basic measure of the adoption and success of decentralized exchanges, and higher trading volumes mean more fee income from the protocol, which drives the value of these DEFI tokens.


While in terms of volume, Uniswap is in the ascendant.According to Token Terminal's data, the average daily volume of Uniswap at the beginning of 2021 was around $733 million, with the launch of Uniswap V3 last month, Uniswap's average daily trading volume has grown to $1.4 billion, double what it was at the start of the year. By contrast, Sushiswap, which started the year with an average daily trading volume of just under $400 million, has grown to $560 million, up a modest 42 percent over the past six months.


生产性 DeFi 资产更值得持有吗?以头部 DeFi 协议为例分析


Volume and fees are directly related, so it is not surprising that the daily revenue chart looks the same as the volume chart above. But there is a key difference in what these revenues mean for the two deals. As mentioned earlier, Sushi holders can pledge their tokens and get XSushi, which in effect represents a 16% right to all revenue generated by the agreement. UNI, on the other hand, has no such income and the income generated by the agreement goes to the liquidity provider (LP).


In addition, Uniswap's revenue has grown 72% year-to-date, with LP racking up $3.3 million in daily revenue. By contrast, Sushiswap's revenues are up only 42% this year, and LP is making $1.6 million a day. (XSushi holders are getting about $250,000 a day.)


生产性 DeFi 资产更值得持有吗?以头部 DeFi 协议为例分析


Note: If Uniswap followed the same scheme as Sushiswap, the "Xuni Holder" could earn more than $220 million in fees this year! If the pledge rate is the same as Sushiswap's, that means the UNI pledge will receive an annualized return of 7.55%, which is almost the same as Sushiswap's.


Ultimately, there is only one metric that matters to investors: price performance. Every investor wants to bet on the fastest horse, and the market is the final judge of that. Although UNI does not have cash flow rights, and even though it is a relatively static governance ecosystem, it still outperforms Sushi.


After a bit of digging, we can see that this makes sense. Uni overtook Sushi in the key area of driving the valuation of Dex (transaction volume and revenue). However, we should also highlight one important aspect that could directly affect the performance of both this year: the token supply schedule.


Sushiswap experienced a massive Sushi token unlock in late March, while it continued to offer LPs liquid mining rewards on a weekly basis. Uniswap, on the other hand, has no plans to release tokens to the market, and a large number of tokens are in the hands of teams and investment institutions, which may have been a key factor in Sushi's decline in March-April.


That said, both have had good years, with Sushi up more than 189% so far this year and UNI up 378%.


The winner: "worthless" governance token


生产性 DeFi 资产更值得持有吗?以头部 DeFi 协议为例分析


2. The Compound and Aave


Compound and AVE have a similar contrast with Uniswap and Sushiswap. Compound represents the slow progress of lending agreements backed by US VCs, as opposed to AVE, where the team and community took a "fast move" approach and gave AVE token cash flow rights through the introduction of Aavenomics.


But what's the comparison? Like DEX and trading volumes, a key concern for lending agreements is the growth of lending volumes.


The greater volume of lending translates into better interest rates for the LP, which in turn attracts more capital and thus increases the lending capacity of the agreement. Although Compound has long held a leading position, it has been overtaken since the launch of the AVE Liquid Mining Program in May 2021.


The launch of AVE's liquidity mining program led to a surge in borrowing demand for the agreement. To put this into context, AVE had only $500 million in outstanding debt at the start of 2021, a small amount compared to the Compound at the time (which had more than $1.7 billion in data).


Since the start of the year, AVE has seen its lending increase by 1,700% to more than $10 billion, while Compound has seen its lending increase by more than 200% to $5.3 billion.


生产性 DeFi 资产更值得持有吗?以头部 DeFi 协议为例分析


Thanks to the surge in borrowing, AVE has also taken the lead in terms of daily revenues, which is good news for AVE holders.


Currently, AAVE makes less than $1 million a day, most of which goes to LP. Meanwhile, Compound generates just $550,000 a day in LP revenue.


Interestingly, the AVE's revenue is up more than 360% this year, while the Compound's growth rate is flat at 2% after recent cutbacks.


生产性 DeFi 资产更值得持有吗?以头部 DeFi 协议为例分析


I'll repeat: Ultimately, what matters to investors is the performance of the app. Investors want to see the numbers go up.


With AVE's explosive growth this year, it's no surprise that it's outperforming Compound. Overall, both assets grew more than 123% this year, but AVE won with an annual growth rate of 255%.


Winners: Productive Defi tokens


生产性 DeFi 资产更值得持有吗?以头部 DeFi 协议为例分析


conclusion


Although Uniswap(UNI) is an unproductive asset, it outperforms the productive asset, while AVE outperforms its unproductive rival Compound as a productive asset. So what does that mean? It may not matter whether an asset is productive or not. What matters most is the underlying product and its growth.


If the fundamentals exist and it is growing, the market will react to them regardless of whether the token has a value accumulation mechanism or not.


No offense to UNI holders (I am one of them), but let me point out that it has no cash flow rights and very little governance to speak of (I admit there has been more governance recently).


But guess what? Uniswap is still the dominant force in the Dex space, and no other agreement comes close to the volume and fees it generates, as demonstrated by its 60% + market share and year-to-date triple-digit growth.


生产性 DeFi 资产更值得持有吗?以头部 DeFi 协议为例分析


The same is true for AVE, which has borrowed more and earned more than its rivals and has outgrown Compound this year, thanks to a well-timed liquidity mining program. I bet this would be true if the AVE were an unproductive, unprofitable governance token. The productive nature of AVE is just icing on the cake.


My argument is that it doesn't really matter whether the token is productive or unproductive. What matters is that the product fits the market and the rate at which the product grows. So yes, while having a value accumulation mechanism that the holder can rely on and point to is a nice addition, in the end it doesn't guarantee that the number will go up, nor does it mean that it will be better than a similar protocol with unproductive tokens.


We have seen that this applies to traditional finance as well. Amazon and other high-tech growth stocks have never paid a dividend, and I've never met anyone really involved in shareholder governance.


But how many things did you order from Amazon this month?


The original link



Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit