Tesla founder Elon Musk, a Bitcoin supporter, tweeted in the early hours of the morning that his company would stop using bitcoin as a means of payment because it uses too much energy, uses too much non-renewable energy and has a negative environmental impact.
Bitcoin fell 15% in response, with more than $2 billion worth of bitcoin sold online. Wake up leek people a face Meng circle, what happened this night?
The community is on the attack. How did Bitcoin's energy use come up again?
Musk was quick to cite the CCFA data to back it up. But there are a lot of misconceptions about bitcoin's energy use.

Image credit: CCFA
As a top VC and researcher in cryptographic circles, Nic Carter has recently devoted a lot of time and energy to educating users inside and outside the circles on the issue of bitcoin energy consumption. This article, How Much Energy Does Bitcoin Actually Consume? The analysis is very thorough.
How much energy should an industry consume? At present, organizations around the world face limits on the consumption of non-renewable energy and limits on carbon emissions. But how much is too much is a tricky thing to determine, and it has to do with the way a society prioritises different things. After all, which goods and services are "worth" and how many resources are spent is all about value. As cryptocurrencies, and Bitcoin in particular, have grown in importance, the discussion of energy use has become a question of just who benefits.
On the face of it, the question of energy use is a fair one. Bitcoin currently consumes about 110 terawatt hours of electricity a year, according to Cambridge's Centre for Alternative Finance (CCAF), or 0.55 per cent of global electricity generation, roughly equal to the annual energy consumption of a small country such as Malaysia or Sweden. Of course, that does sound like a lot of consumption. But how much energy does it make sense for a monetary system to consume?
Your answer may depend more on how you feel about bitcoin. If you think bitcoin is just a vehicle for a Ponzi scheme or money laundering, then any energy that bitcoin consumes is a waste. But if you're one of the thousands of people in the world who use bitcoin as a tool to avoid currency suppression, inflation, or capital controls, then you're likely to think the energy cost is well worth it. The amount of social resources you think bitcoin should consume comes down to how much value you think bitcoin can create for society.
If this debate is to continue, the least we can do is be clear about how bitcoin actually consumes energy. Understanding bitcoin's energy consumption may not answer questions about its usefulness, but it can help shed light on its impact on the environment. In particular, we need to clarify some very serious misunderstandings.
First, there is a big difference between the amount of energy a system consumes and its carbon emissions. While it's pretty straightforward in terms of energy consumption, you don't know the different carbon emissions for different combinations of energy consumption -- specifically, computers that mine for bitcoin use different energy components. For example, each unit of hydropower energy has a much smaller impact on the environment than the same unit of coal energy.
Estimating bitcoin's energy consumption isn't really hard: You can make an educated guess at the energy demands of the hardware used by miners by looking at its hashing rate (the amount of energy used to mine bitcoin and process transactions). But its carbon emissions are harder to estimate. Mining is a highly competitive business and miners pay little attention to operational details. CCAF has come up with an assessment of the best geographic location for energy production (from which energy allocation can be inferred). CCAF has worked with major mining pools to aggregate anonymized data on miners' locations.
Based on this data, CCAF predicts the energy used by miners by country (or province). But their data set doesn't include all mining pools, nor is it up to date, leaving us largely unclear about bitcoin's actual energy consumption structure. In addition, many of the analyses provide an overview of the energy mix at the national level, leading to inaccurate descriptions of countries with extremely diverse energy patterns, such as China.
As a result, estimates of the percentage of bitcoin mining using renewable energy vary widely. In December 2019, a report suggested that 73 percent of bitcoin mining's energy consumption is carbon neutral, mainly due to hydroelectric mining in places like Southwest China and Scandinavia. However, CCAF estimated in September 2020 that this figure had dropped to 39%. But while that number has fallen, it's still twice the size of the U.S. power grid, suggesting that energy consumption alone isn't a reliable way to determine bitcoin's carbon footprint.
Another key factor that makes bitcoin's energy consumption different from most other industries is that bitcoin mining can take place anywhere. Almost all of the world's produced energy use has to take into account its distance from its end user, but Bitcoin has no such restriction, allowing miners to use energy that most other industries cannot.
Hydropower is the most typical example. Large amounts of renewable water energy are wasted each year during the rainy season in Sichuan and Yunnan. In these areas, productivity far exceeds local demand, and the lack of battery technology makes it unworthwhile to store and transport energy to cities. These regions are probably the largest energy islands on the planet, so it's no coincidence that these provinces are the heartland of China's mining industry, accounting for nearly 10 percent of global bitcoin mining during dry seasons and 50 percent during wet seasons.
Another carbon-neutral mining option is flare gas. Today, the process of extracting oil releases large amounts of natural gas byproducts, which pollute the environment rather than use the power grid. Confined to the remote location of oil mines, most traditional industries have not been able to use this energy efficiently. But Bitcoin miners from North Dakota to Siberia are already taking advantage of this wasted resource opportunity, and some companies are even exploring more controlled ways to burn natural gas to further reduce emissions. Of course, it's still not critical in today's bitcoin mining world, but the calculations suggest that there's enough natural gas in the U.S. and Canada alone to keep the entire network running.
To be fair, bitcoin mining with excess natural gas does still produce emissions, and some argue that it even subsidizes the fossil fuel industry, giving energy companies an incentive to invest more in oil extraction. But bitcoin miners make peanuts compared with other industries that rely on fossil fuels, and their demand for fuel isn't likely to disappear anytime soon. Given that oil will continue to be extracted in the foreseeable short term, expanding the use of natural gas byproducts will have a positive impact (and perhaps even a reduced environmental impact).
Interestingly, the aluminum smelting industry bears a striking resemblance to Bitcoin mining. The process of converting natural bauxite into usable aluminum is very energy intensive, and aluminum is usually inexpensive to transport, so many countries with energy surpluses have built smelters to use their surplus resources. Places with more capacity than they can consume, such as Iceland, Sichuan and Yunnan, are net energy exporters through aluminium. Today, these regions have inherent advantages that make them the first choice for bitcoin mining. Many former aluminum smelters have even started bitcoin mining.
Energy generation is only a small part of the equation. But another area of widespread misunderstanding is how bitcoin consumes energy and how it changes over time.
A lot of journalists and academics talk about how high bitcoin's "energy cost per transaction" is, but it's a misleading metric. The vast majority of bitcoin's energy consumption occurs during mining. Once a bitcoin has been minted, the energy required to verify the transaction is minimal. So it doesn't make sense to just look at the total energy consumed by bitcoin to date and divide it by the number of transactions. Most of the energy is used to mint bitcoin, not to transfer transactions. This leads to our final big misconception: the energy costs associated with bitcoin mining will continue to grow exponentially.
Because of how fast bitcoin's energy consumption is growing, people sometimes think it will eventually take over the entire energy network. A recent study cited by the New York Times claimed, shockingly, that Bitcoin could warm the planet by 2 degrees Celsius. Yet there are good reasons to believe this will not happen.
First, as in many other industries, Bitcoin's energy-hungry structure is becoming less and less carbon dependent each year. In the US, a growing number of listed, ESG-dominated miners have taken a big share of the market, while China recently banned coal mining in Inner Mongolia, one of the largest regions in existence. At the same time, a number of organizations in the mining industry have launched a "crypto climate agreement" similar to the Paris climate agreement to advocate and commit to reducing Bitcoin's carbon footprint. Of course, as renewable energy sources like solar become more efficient, there will be more ways to mine, and Bitcoin mining could end up being an important driver of the construction of these emerging technologies.
Moreover, miners are unlikely to continue expanding their operations at the current rate indefinitely. The Bitcoin protocol provides subsidies for mining, but those subsidies already have built-in checks on its growth. Miners now receive a small transaction fee (about 10 per cent of their income) for verifying their trades, as well as the bitcoins they mine for profit.
However, the agreement is set up to cut miners' income from newly minted bitcoins in half every four years, so unless the price of bitcoins doubles permanently every four years (which economics considers largely impossible for any currency), miners' income from minting shares will eventually fade to zero. In terms of transaction fees, Bitcoin's natural limits on the number of transactions it can process (less than a million per day) and its users' ability to pay for them ultimately limit its growth potential as a source of income for miners. Some miners can be expected to operate on transaction fees alone, but in practice, if margins fall, there will be less economic incentive to invest in mining.
Of course, there are a myriad of factors that can influence Bitcoin's impact on the environment, but the nature of all of them is a question that is hard to quantify numerically: Is Bitcoin worth it? On top of that, many environmental issues have been overstated, as well as misunderstandings and false assumptions about how the Bitcoin protocol works.
This means that when we ask "Is Bitcoin worthy of its environmental impact?" the actual negative impact is likely to be much less than you think. But there is no denying that Bitcoin (like any other product that adds value to society) does consume social resources. Like all other energy-guzzling industries, the crypto community must acknowledge and address these environmental issues, work to reduce Bitcoin's carbon footprint, and ultimately demonstrate that Bitcoin provides far more social value than it requires.

Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia