Defi's Way Lose Billions of Dollars After Turning Off Burn Mechanism, Algorithm Stablecoin's Future Uncertain
Original source: Babbitt
On the morning of April 8, Beijing time, Fei Labs founder Joey Santoro decided to shut down the controversial burn mechanism when the algorithm stablecoin project FEI was caught in a huge controversy. He released an announcement saying:
"We have heard your comments and we are focused on achieving stability and building on that.We have closed Burn and Rewards to address the vulnerability disclosed yesterday.The community has more than $1 billion in PCV funding available to support Fei and Tribe. Turning off the burn incentive will also release selling pressure on FEI and use the PCV to help restore anchoring. Other proposals could further leverage the PCV to achieve this goal. This process will help build a community dedicated to TRIBE. This week, our top priorities are to deploy the necessary fixes for incentive contracts and to responsibly disclose technical issues. We will also develop a proposal to expedite the process of resuming anchor pricing using PCV. Going forward, we will support proposals to reward Tribe's holders, and we expect Tribe to be consistent with the long-term success of the agreement..."
Last night, after ETH dropped below $2,000, FEI's listed price on Uniswap dropped below $0.90. Under the burn mechanism, selling FEI on Uniswap meant that users would lose all of their moneyIn the secondary market,FEI , trading at around $0.73, and panic sets in.FEI The community spread, which also forced.FEI The team eventually turned off the burn mechanism.
Rekt also wrote about the performance of the recent FEI agreement, starting with:
FEI's launch was achievedAndreessen Horowitz, Framework, CoinbaseBut in the Defi space, getting the support of the big players doesn't mean much, and it's hard to see the project as a success.
FEI failed to maintain its $1 anchor rate, and the Agreed Governance Token Tribe has fallen about 30% since its launch.
FEI's mechanics design guidelines forced its users into incarceration, and the project was widely seen as a disaster.
What is the future of FEI and what is the future of algorithmic stablecoins?
In 2014, researchers published two academic papers detailing the two main concepts on which most current algorithmic stabilization algorithms are based.
Ferdinando M Ametrano's paper "Hayek Money" proposed a rebase model in which the aggregate supply of money varies with demand. The seigniorage joint-stock system proposed by Robert Sams is a dual token mechanism, that is, stable assets themselves and fluctuating "seigniorage shares", whose owners benefit or are punished according to the supply and demand of stable assets.
These two seminal papers laid the foundation for many subsequent attempts to build decentralized non-volatility crypto assets such as ESD, BASIS, RSR, FRAX, and now FEI.
Most stablecoins that are considered "successful" are based on collateral reserve types, and these models work well, but the problem with decentralized versions is that they are capital inefficient and put collateral assets at risk. The use of these stablecoins is also limited by the amount of excess collateral required.
Ampleforth and the Empty Set Dollar (ESD) try to create sovereign stable money without relying on any collateral, however, the money they create is not stable at all.
Arguably the most successful decentralized stablecoin protocol is still Maker (DAI), which relies on user-owned collateral to create non-volatile decentralized assets. However, it is not perfect and cannot perform closed-loop arbitrage on DAI, so its price is not completely stable, and the protocol faces capacity expansion issues.

Together with concepts such as ESD 1.5 and Frax, FEI represents a second wave of algorithmic stablecoins. While FEI's launch is far from perfect and raises questions about the future success of the project, it's easy to see why people are still struggling to conceive of a "perfect stablecoin".
FEI uses a joint curve and a "direct incentive" token model to maintain a liquid market, with the aim of allowing the ETH/FEI price to trade close to the ETH/USD market price.

In FEI's founding token offering, which took place a few days ago, users could earn discounted FEI by depositing ETH and receive additional governance token airdrops, which seemed like an attractive opportunity and ultimately led to more than 17,000 separate addresses participating in the event.
Existence conditions of the discount is, however, only in the less than $250 million of the ETH case, the founding stage of FEI, just can have discount, but at the last stage, a total of $1.3 billion worth of ETH participated in the founding stage, which means that the discount has been cancelled, and the ETH irreversible to the PCV contract the address of the project, the first will be used to establish Uniswap liquidity pools.
At one point after the launch, the liquidity of the Uniswap FEI/ETH pool exceeded US $2.6 billion, which was created by the ETH raised during the founding phase.
These numbers did not help the FEI project, however, as FEI soon moved away from anchor pricing and its reputation took a tumble.

The initial de-anchoring was mainly due to a large amount of selling pressure for the TRIBE, and the FEI Protocol punished those who sold FEI and rewarded participants who bought FEI underwater, while participants faced penalties to convert the TRIBE into ETH.
To make matters worse, despite CondenSys Diligence and Open Zeppelin's audit of the FEI Protocol contract, there was a flaw in FEI's incentive calculations, which forced the team to close the coinage award for buying FEI underwater, with an official statement saying:
"Reweight will continue to occur without coinage."
In response, @Bantg has documented the impact of FEI reweight with the chart below.

As Emin Gun Sirer (Avalanche founder) commented on Twitter:
"Let's take a look at FEI. The core idea is this: Why stable currency price will be lower than its anchor? Because people are selling, so, let's punish those who sell FEI, underwater! The price is lower, so the greater the penalties, if you are below the anchoring exchange rate under the condition of sale of FEI, the person receiving the FEI is less than you transfer, FEI, a team of people think that this mechanism should be able to raise the price of FEI. But now, let's look forward a bit, rather than just doing the obvious logic step (" when below anchor currency, let's punishment transfer "). Every transaction has a buyer and seller, If you penalize the seller, you penalize the buyer. The FEI penalize not only the supply, but also the demand. It penalizes both sides, thereby reducing the range of feasibility for the coin.

When one of the FEI Protocol founders proposed assigning part of the PCV to Yearn, the idea was criticized on Twitter, with Karoo joking:
"Our project is not going as planned, so why don't we make some money from the ETH you give us?"
Banteg told a public panel:
"Personally, I strongly hope that they rip up the money and refund some of it to their users, even if it means that no more than 50% of TVL will be deployed to Yearn." "We don't decide who uses the agreement. After all, neutrality is what we have been fighting for."
However, Julien Bouteloup may disagree, as he has publicly published a "blacklist" of FEI holders, suggesting that future airdrops should not accept these addresses.
The FEI project is a disaster of overfunding, with both proponents and critics offering extreme opinions. Many call it a failed experiment, while others say "all ETH should be refunded." Others simply reiterate their faith in the project, such as Compound founder R. Leshner, who tweeted:
"I'm still offering $0.70 and I'll buy whatever you can get me."
Perhaps the wisest position would be slightly less extreme.
So far, the experiment hasn't been a success, and on the other hand, it's completely unnecessary to raise so much money, as Fiskantes said on Twitter:
"The most crowded investment opportunity is never the best."
Will we continue to see this level of financing for future financial experiments, or are we reaching an inflection point?
The original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia
