header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

OpenSea bans Banksy imitators, says NFT trading platform should be 'decentralized'

Read this article in 7 Minutes
As the topic of NFT has become more and more hot in recent years, more and more people want to enter the market, and a huge market value of crypto art has been born. Yet it seems that beneath the surface of prosperity lurks chaos.
Original source: Cyber funkers


OpenSea: Is it wrong to delete accounts on a decentralized platform?

When you are blinded by the "facts.
Perhaps both sides have their own agendas


As the first crypto art trading platform, OpenSea has for years billed itself as a "decentroalized" platform for digital art trading. However, recently, under the pressure of public opinion, the artist's account "Pest Supply" has been banned. The account has been selling Banksy-style creations, and its account name is just one word short of Banksy's official Pest Control.

 

  (Photo courtesy of the Internet)

 

In the opinion of OpenSea, the account is "impersonated", and the action of banning is to avoid traders being "fooled". However, this incident has caused an uproar in the crypto art world. For crypto art lovers, OpenSea's move is a betrayal -- what about decentralization? Why was it so easy to use the "power" to ban artists?

 

Unfortunately, OpenSea didn't give its side of the story when it was still in the making, but took a long time to come forward. PEST Supply also took advantage of the opportunity and did enough publicity for itself. First, it donated part of the auction proceeds to "Save the Children" foundation. After re-entering the trading platform of Rarible, a competitor of OpenSea, it mocked OpenSea as "not understanding art history" :

 

Blocked by decentralized OpenSea as they have no idea who Elaine Sturtevant, Marcel Duchamp, Maurizio Cattelan is and know nothing about art history.

 

This is art history in making, you are part of the art.

 

"Laugh now, but one day no-one will be in charge."

Or, am I?

 

So rebellious, so Banksy, so fan sucker.


After that, they released a number of games that mocked OpenSea and once again gained market recognition:


                 

Title: Centralization in Disguise (33ETH)
       

Title: Closed Sea Red Edition (0.88eth)

 

Apparently, the rebel crypto enthusiasts are already on the opposite side of OpenSea.

 

The NFT art market battle isn't exactly a new topic. The essence of the PEST Supply vs. OpenSea event is to discuss an ever-changing controversy: whether the works of PEST Supply are fake and shitty for sensationality or true art with a core? Thanks to the art world's ambiguity, the answer to that question is invisibly in the hands of the public.


The art market is a perpetual struggle for discourse power

To win the hearts of the people,
Get a say.


Throughout the development of Western art, the decision of "plagiarism" or "appropriation of art" has always been a hot topic. From how early artists simulated nature and convinced people that this was the reproduction of the real scene, to contemporary art dominated by ideas, the definition of "imitation", "appropriation" and "plagiarism" in the whole art field seems to have lost more and more unified conclusion. As the standards of the art world become blurred, the power of life and death for artists is gradually taken over by the public.

 

Under the influence of Dada Art and Pop Art, the concept of "appropriation art" has been widely accepted by foreign art circles and the public. Take the artist Elaine Sturtevant of the early 1970s. Her own idea is to explore the boundaries of creation, plagiarism and imitation, and she never gets tired of it. In line with this concept, she reproduced the work of Roy Lichtenstein, Andy Warhol, Jasper Johns and Frank Stella, among others, using silkscreen or color techniques (known as raw techniques). Some even cost more than the original.


Title: Lichtenstein, Frighten Girl (1966)
  Artist: Elaine Sturtevant

                                 

Ttitle: Crying Girl (1963)
Artist: Roy Lichtenstein

                                                                     

  However, in China, due to the emergence of copyright awareness, the public tends to criticize the similarity of art in form, but lose their thinking about its core. Take a look at the "college professor plagiarizing Miffy Rabbit" incident, which was hot discussed on Weibo not long ago. Major media accounts have followed the trend, mocking Feng Feng, a professor at a Chinese university, for copying Miffy and being "a dead duck with a hard mouth".


(Photo courtesy of the Internet)

 

In fact, those who are familiar with "appropriation of art" will know that Feng Feng's "duck and rabbit" image explores the common memory of commercial symbols in contemporary society, which is a social study of artistic creation. "... all the familiar commercial symbols belong to public knowledge and information, are the vocabulary of artistic creation, and are also objects of study, study its path, study how it is immersed in our memory......"

 

Later, art professionals have also "sided" with Feng Feng, acknowledging that his works belong to the category of "embezzlement of art", and that there is no infringement or plagiarism in the public opinion.

 

Yet the voice of the arts is rarely heard by the public. Efforts by Feng and the professionals to explain the situation pale in the face of public opinion. Finally, Feng Feng will permanently stop using the image in future exhibitions.

 

When an artist's work is subjected to "one-sided" criticism in public, they are already in a passive position.


Art that is accepted by the public is true art. Right?

Decentralization,
Is it the authority of the art profession?


When art comes into the public eye, it is inevitable that it will be evaluated and discussed like a star idol in the spotlight. However, it is undeniable that there are many blind spots and prejudices in the public's judgment of things.

 

Please imagine with the author that if PEST Supply is changed to a middle-aged Chinese image in China, will it still be followed by young rebels? And what if Professor Feng turns into a young American, wearing a black mask and doing Banksy-style mysterious and exaggerated performance art? The public will probably see it differently.

 

Many question whether the crypto art market system will make art market-oriented. Indeed, when the blockchain-led decentralized world enters the Chinese art market, will artists, who already have a very weak voice, be placed in a more passive position?

 

We don't know yet. However, the art market should not only accept the review of the public opinion, but also accept the criticism and reflection of the professionals in the art world. Under such development, the art market seems more "healthy". Clearly, the crypto art market has a long way to go.


The art of disordered encryption needs to take the first step

Decentralized indicates a Lawless


The conflict between PEST Supply and OpenSea seems to be an accidental event, but in essence it is an "inevitable event" caused by the chaotic beginning of the NFT art market. In other words, even if there is no PEST Supply, there will be PEST X, ignite the conflict between "centralization" and "decentralization".

 

But the more such conflicts arise, the more they surface, and the more people in the industry will come forward to resolve them or find a balance. In the NFT art market, where standards and rules have not been established, it is necessary to have such a phenomenal national discussion to make rules for future generations. Exchange platforms should be clearer about how to abandon the traditional centralized operation model and leave more space for artists to create; At the same time, the reason of "speaking up for democracy" like PEST Supply can only be used once, and if PEST XX comes out later, will any trading platform follow the example of OpenSea? Will traders continue to stand by the PEST XX? The answer may be obvious.

 

With the rapid development of blockchain art, there will always be people who choose to abandon principles for profit, or go against the original intention of creation, or forget the "decentralized" nature of NFT. PEST Supply and OpenSea obviously have their own agendas. As a trading platform, OpenSea needs to protect the interests of traders, but gives up the principle of "decentralization"; Although PEST Supply adheres to the original intention of its own creation, it is suspected of "masking for profit" at the very beginning.

 

In the account of Raible platform, PEST Supply has also updated its statement, saying that only if the buyer indicates that the work is not the original work of Banksy in the introduction position of the home page, will it be verified: "We'd be happy to verify your account provided that at the very top of your Bio on Rarible, you clearly state this is not Banksy and that your work is based on Banksy's work."


The original link



Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit