header-langage
简体中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Deribit Insights: Token is an important incentive mechanism for projects to break through the bottleneck of network effects

Read this article in 10 Minutes
It has become increasingly difficult for new blockchain networks to build a network effect moat.
Original title: " Why I have changed my mind on tokens "
Original author:  Deribit Insights Cryptographer Hasu

Rhythm BlockBeats news, on December 24, Hasu, an encryption researcher of Deribit Insights, published an article titled "Why I Changed My View on Tokens" on his official account, in which he explained his views on tokens (Token) The change of view, from the previous belief that the responsibility of the role of tokens should be minimized, to the later change of view, that tokens are the key to triggering network effects, and also the incentive mechanism for projects to break through the bottleneck of network effects.


Governance tokens (I actually prefer the term equity tokens) are usually awarded to holders of a portion of project fees and Some voting power in its governance.


Take SUSHI as an example, SUSHI is the native token for sushiswap transactions. When a staker stakes on the Sushibar contract, he will get a commission of 0.05% of the total transaction volume. They also received “Sushipowah”, which represents voting rights in Sushiswap’s off-chain governance system.


Tokens like SUSHI have been one of the hottest topics of discussion over the past few Fans and researchers split into two camps.


The first camp believes that the role and responsibility of tokens need to be minimized, and people in this camp often ask " Why does XYZ project need a token?”. I used to be firmly in the first camp, but now find myself leaning more and more towards the second camp, which sees tokens as a necessity and an important incentive mechanism.


Let me explain how I changed my mind of.


I will start with the arguments of the first camp and refute them one by one. There are three main ones:


1. Governance itself is an attack vector as it allows bad actors to change the rules of the protocol, worst case It is able to steal user deposits. This defeats the original purpose of using smart contracts.

2. Our goal in the encryption field is to replace rent-seeking companies and institutions with open and fair protocols. Extracting rent from users is a step backwards and goes against this core value.

3. Since the protocol is open source, anyone can fork, so the equilibrium rent is always zero. It’s just a matter of time, sooner or later we’ll reach that balance, and then the value of governance tokens will similarly collapse to zero. That's why anyone selling tokens today must be a scammer.


Governance and Security


Just to clarify one thing, I find the first argument to be very reasonable. Much of the value of encrypted networks and applications is because they are difficult to change. This allows users to trust that the app will do what it says it will, and developers can build on top of it without platform risk.


Attach governance to a system that does not need governance and it subverts that logic. When we allow humans to change a system in a top-down fashion, we lose the aforementioned guarantees. Since some possible changes are very bad for users, we need to pay these managers to bribe them to prefer honest behavior to malicious behavior. In other words, the application's security model changed from encrypted to economical (secured by economic incentives), which is very bad.


This debate goes back to Bitcoin itself. Some critics point out that we pay miners a lot of money to protect the network, but the only people who can attack the network are the miners themselves! So, are we really going to pay these thugs protection money?


If we can get rid of the miners, save this money money, that would be very desirable. But, alas, we need to "human-type" bitcoins for transactions and block transactions. Therefore, we need to pay human workers enough money to incentivize good behavior.


Need manpower input->Need motivation->Need fee

< p line="iGnJ">

In the current iteration of Defi, this argument applies to many systems. Neither Compound nor Maker can work without human input, and therefore cannot work without fees. This is because the risks posed by change are not isolated. Someone needs to control the increase in collateral, because one bad collateral can bring down the entire system.


The situation is different with Uniswap or Sushiswap. Each pool is an independent entity. If a pool dries up because one of its tokens goes to zero, the risk does not spread to other pools. Therefore, no governance is required to manage a pool that can exist.


Therefore, there are already some projects that require human input to run, and these projects are naturally not subject to charges being unethical and Fees will be affected by fork arguments, as it is impossible for similar projects to have no fees.


In fact, I will now make it clear that they should. Token maximization should not coincide with governance maximization just because developers feel the need to give their tokens additional functionality. Even if a project has a native token, governance minimalism is still king.


The ethics of rent


Note: This article The "rent" mentioned can be understood as the difference between the amount paid by a factor of production and the minimum amount that must be paid to obtain the use of that factor.   


(capital) Doctrine is the unification of the incentives of society as a whole with the incentives of individuals. It allows people to benefit society by serving each other while being selfish.


I think it is immoral to call people who serve others in exchange for some kind of compensation , which is also illogical  . I don't think it's surprising that DeFi is the most innovative market I've ever seen. Smart people are motivated to work there because they can make a fortune in the process.


I think it is immoral to call someone who provides a service to others (such as building an encryption app) " in exchange for some compensation is illogical. I think DeFi is the fastest innovative market I've ever seen. Smart people are motivated to work in DeFi because they can earn wealth in the process.


If we have a moral responsibility in this area, it should not be to get rid of (capital)ism by minimizing the rents we seek. Instead, we should make sure that the social standards we set for the space align with how people want to behave, and funnel those energies into a better world. Market mechanisms (competition, open source code, etc.) will ensure that over time this rent does not exceed necessary levels.


The problem of guidance


Token skeptics argue that since the protocol can be forked, the equilibrium rent will be zero. I think this is becoming more and more like a pipe dream for two reasons.


First of all, without rent, there is nothing worth spending""If you can't reward your early users, It's hard for you to compete with existing networks. These rewards need to be taken from somewhere.


At this point, supporters of the first camp now usually say that Bitcoin is achieved without rent . It is true that Bitcoin does not need rent to achieve this effect, but Bitcoin is not without tokens, and in many ways, it achieves the exact same purpose. So they buy and trade bitcoins, and in the process, increase bitcoin's liquidity and public image.



According to a German fable, Baron Munchhausen pulled himself up from the swamp by his hair.


If you were in the market shortly after Bitcoin launched, then once Bitcoin starts to take off, you can Get rich rewards. So there's a real incentive for users to experience it as early as possible. However, if you compare it with Uniswap, Ethereum’s largest DEX, such incentives completely disappear.


If you are an early Uniswap liquidity provider or trader, then your use process will be very bad: The user experience sucks, the market is illiquid, and there is no organic taker.


Of course, this does not mean that there are no early adopters, but Uniswap must immediately find a system that works for them , (this search process) was a huge limitation on early networks. Imagine if Bitcoin's price couldn't appreciate, the only people with a direct incentive to own it were those who needed it for instant transactions, leading to the fact that Bitcoin might not even exist today because none of these use cases were concreted enough to make sense Degree.


This is why for networks and two-sided markets, early adopters are rewarded with what they get from latecomers is so important.




This is why I think The promotion of the mining method pioneered by SynthetixCompound is important. The projects have found a breakthrough point to balance their respective benefit functions by pooling the benefits of future miners' dissemination to early adopters.


Attracting and Retaining Developers


The reason we talk about how capitalism works is because it is oriented toward people's self-interest. We need to be able to try to serve each other and outside the socialist ideal, which doesn't happen on a large scale when you exclude the ability to profit from your own work through some notion of fairness.


This is what tokens provide: they allow projects to raise funds, and hire developers staff, designers, and community managers, most of which are not free jobs.


There are two kinds of objections that people generally raise now because they are in different camps of the community.


Bitcoin supporters said: "But Bitcoin has no preconceptions, look at its current The situation.” Bitcoin has the ambition to solve one of the most fundamental problems in the world: hard currency (Rhythm note: Hard Money, also translated as hard currency, refers to a currency with good international credit, stable currency value, and a strong exchange rate)< /p>


This vision makes it attractive to volunteers who contribute their work for ideological rather than monetary reasons (Also, most BTC contributors today maintain their work through grants). But not every project can do this, nor should it. There are thousands of little problems that need to be solved, all of which together can equally change the world.


Ethereum will say that Uniswap was founded with funding from the Ethereum Foundation (which is true) . But Ethereum’s funding itself was prepared in advance, and if Uniswap hadn’t raised venture capital quickly to hire and retain more talent, it would never have achieved what it is today.


These investors did not give their money to Uniswap because they wanted to use Uniswap: planned from the beginning A token issuance arrangement, which is what makes the investment and Uniswap's success possible.


No project since Bitcoin has managed to achieve itself without rewarding early contributors Development, and not pure imitation, is to have its own development (so Litecoin is excluded). Even Monero, previously considered another public offering, has information that it is pre-mined.


Perhaps we should not condemn this practice, but we should admit that very few people are willing to To invest one's life in a highly speculative enterprise under certain circumstances.


The network effect is like a moat


here At one point, we've built protocols that reward early adopters by tokenizing the benefits generated by late adopters in a way that will likely outcompete protocols that rely solely on organic growth.

 

Now the final question is, if the first item in a field It's growing very quickly, can someone come along and fork it to remove its fees/tokens and socialize its benefits?


First, remember that a protocol that relies on human input can never eliminate spending, as this is necessary to incentivize miners/managers. This allows the project to run without any necessary manual work. These still have huge network effects that new forks have to overcome.


For example, the network effect of Maker and Synthetix exists in the form of synthetic tokens, any fork will be from zero Collateral lock-up and zero synthetic circulation begins.


If there is no immediate economic stimulus for both sides of the market to stop what they are doing and get into a new system together is very difficult. A new system, even if it is slightly cheaper to use, but its brand, liquidity, developer ecology, community, integration with other projects, etc. are all very weak.


In general, I think that when the project exceeds a certain scale, it can basically resist the fork However, it is just a question of whether the project can reach this scale.

 

Summary


Tradition Crypto is already at a disadvantage compared to companies because everything is open source, making it harder to monetize innovation. This is why all very successful crypto projects will rely on the network effects brought about by the superior properties of public blockchains (trusted neutrality, permissioned access, etc.) as their moats.


But the new network is extremely difficult to guide users to create such a moat. The emergence of tokens and liquidity mining is an excellent innovation to guide liquidity in two-sided markets, and cryptocurrencies urgently need to overcome the network effects of existing networks.


Let's not just ask "Why does XYZ need a token?", but also "How does XYZ support its token". Because if it can do both, especially the latter, its chances of success will be greatly increased.


Original link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit