header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

FTX founders: Development and bottlenecks of DeFi in terms of trust, centralization and availability

Read this article in 5 Minutes
This is the second in a series of articles about DeFi by the founders of FTX

原文来源: FTX 创始人& CEO Sam Bankman Fried

0×33, rhythmically BlockBeats


This article is the founder & AMP of FTX, an encrypted derivatives trading platform. CEO Sam Bankman Fried is the second in his opinion series on DeFi. The first article"SBF, FOUNDER of FTX: DeFi is facing a "life and death decision" because of the "bubble" created by liquidity mining"The second examines DeFi in terms of trust, centralization, and availability.


以下为 Sam Bankman Fried的第二篇观点全文,为了更加方便读者阅读,律动BlockBeats在翻译时对部分语句进行了通俗化处理。


The core of DeFi should be decentralized and ideally trustless. But centralization is usually efficient, and for many DeFi projects, cost decentralization results in a poor product (usability or experience).




So why is that, and what are the trade-offs?


First, before you can do anything, the premise is that you must trust the blockchain in use: trust that its miners, stakeholders, or nodes are trying to build the longest chain, and that there is no other incentive to fork the chain. (I'll save the discussion of the different blockchains for next time.)


In doing so, the trust blockchain aims to:

A) Don't trust anyone and assume everyone is selfish and incompetent

B) Create quality products of great value


Let's start with something that's doing well in the DeFi industry right now: atomic exchange.


You can exchange two ERC20 tokens with each other in a trust-free and efficient manner. How do you get there? Use smart contracts. A centralised smart contract can check whether there is money in both parties' accounts.Both parties put the money into a smart contract that automatically sends the purchase to the appropriate person once they both agree to trade. Users can now do this through pre-programmed smart contracts without a middleman. At this point, intelligent contract can fully meet the needs of users.


What else works in DeFi? Borrowing/lending can mostly be done on demand; See Compound, Aave, etc. But the risks go far beyond that, and the quality of the product deteriorates rapidly. For example, use stability COINS.


Let's start with the stability coin in CeFi, which is basically the simplest product in CeFi. Users use ERC20 tokens, then use DOLLARS in their bank accounts, and then map them 1:1 to creation and redemption. There are few thorny issues (other than the need to have a bank account to withdraw dollars).


But in DeFi, the stabilizers are a complete mess. In fact, the problem is that the stability coin is worth $1, and the dollar is not on the blockchain. In their centralized bank accounts. So if you only have blockchain, you can't exchange it for a dollar. But what makes it stable?


Throughout DeFi, complex attempts are being made to solve this problem. For example, Curve and mStable are constructed around the entire DEX coin. CeFi users, on the other hand, can use USDC: TUSD 1:1 for transactions without charge, and can complete the exchange by using a variety of wallets (SBF lists their own).


But these require Banks, and if you're not allowed to use centralized elements, then basically what's left is the atomic exchange of THE TUSD with the USDC, depending on some external mechanism to stay consistent and provide liquidity. But worse, if you really hate centralization, you may not like the fact that the value of your stable assets depends on your bank account. What if these assets are frozen, or the creation/redemption mechanism is closed?


So let's think about what could be worth a dollar, but not depend on the bank?


So we end up with a stability coin like Dai in DeFi. But Dai is such a mess. Dai doesn't really have the dollar behind it. That means users can't exchange it directly for dollars. But what makes Dai "worth" $1 is that users usually can't redeem it at all?


In practice, users cannot create Dai, and can only borrow from it. So Dai has a soft peg. And he supports leveraged positions, so holdings of the stability currency could be liquidated if something happens to the market.


To sum up: no creation, no redemption, but liquidation.One conclusion should be drawn: Dai really does not sound very stable.



& have spent

Therefore, users who do not want to trust the centralized redemption of the USDC want to be able to stabilize the stability coin to $1. What choice is left? - mStable and Curve, and many other attempts to build hybrid products.


The stabilizers are just one example. The tradeoff between centralization and availability is everywhere.


Many DeFi projects require pricing; So they use Oracle, which usually extracts prices from Coinbase (or platforms such as Coinbase). That is fine, including the fact that FTX futures itself does the same. But it's not very decentralized; It is prone to centralized failures or API problems. (See BitMEX and Deribit futures prices in the event of crashes such as Bitstamp.)


Also, if a user wants to trade BTC on Ethereum, most attempts will end up with a group of people overseeing the BTC trade. One way to make blockchain faster and cheaper is to centralize it (regardless of other needs, just what can be done to make transactions faster). This is where you start to get into the whole area of encryption, especially DeFi.


So what are we doing now?


Many of the answers are not obvious. But that doesn't mean it's hopeless. There are powerful programs that can create cross-chain behavior without trust. There are blockchains that can increase speed without sacrificing security.


There are ways to get the stabilizers into a perfect state that, while not ideal, are at least better than DAI and less centralized than USDC. For DeFi to evolve, a compelling reason must be made that the need for no trust is justifiably "troublesome." This means finding the best Pareto optimal scheme (Pareto is also known as the 80-20 rule, Pareto optimal is an ideal state of resource allocation, in order to achieve a certain goal, it needs to make a certain sacrifice to save greater interests). , and continue to look for ways to enhance the functionality of the DeFi ecosystem without sacrificing its core principles.





Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit