Original title: "Open Source versus Survival? LibreOffice Community Protests commercialization of Projects"
Source: Open Source China
Note: The open source software development team is always in a very contradictory environment. On the one hand, they hope that the open source and free products can provide convenience for more developers and technology enthusiasts. On the other hand, the pressure from survival is a mountain in front of "freedom". Open source does not create utopias, and developers need to consider reality. How to measure freedom and survival is a problem for most open source teams. In the cryptographic community, open source projects are often recognized by the market, and teams often consider whether to promote tokens or other means to keep the team growing after open source. In the field of Internet open source, how to satisfy open source and maintain the project is still a problem faced by many teams or companies.
The inclusion of commercial exploration in the latest 7.0 release of LibreOffice has raised hackles in the community, with several senior LibreOffice community participants saying it will hinder the spread of the free and open source software. & have spent
The "personal version" slogan raised questions
It started with an error report on the LibreOffice community mailing list earlier this month from a user who noticed that the newly installed LibreOffice 7.0 RC was now marked "Personal" and stated in the About dialog that "this personal edition is supported by volunteers and is for personal use only."

In the discussion below the mailing list, many expressed dissatisfaction with the change. Some users believe that the "personal version" is often reminiscent of the simplified version of some commercial software, offering limited free versions for non-corporate users. Does this mean that LibreOffice will launch a more powerful corporate paid version? There were also concerns that terms such as "personal use version" and "private use version" might restrict free access to LibreOffice in nonprofit organizations such as education.
The community's uneasy speculation soon caught the attention of the Documentation Foundation (TDF), which manages the project, and TDF's board was quick to issue a statement on the matter. The statement began with an apology, saying, "&Nbsp; our short working hours resulted in the slogan appearing on THE RC without community discussion, and we are deeply sorry that some of our users thought we implemented the change unilaterally. Please rest assured that negotiations with the community are ongoing." It also said that any changes would not affect LibreOffice's original open source license, software availability, or functional differences. "LibreOffice will remain open source and free, and nothing will change for end users, developers, and community members."
So what exactly is the "personal version"?
TDF explained in the following statement that "this' personal edition 'slogan is part of a broader' five-year marketing plan 'it is preparing to differentiate the currently free, community-supported LibreOffice from a set of paid products and services offered by LibreOffice Enterprise." & have spent
That said, TDF is indeed trying to commercialise LibreOffice, with the aim of enabling Eco-Partners to offer paid products with the "LibreOffice Enterprise" label.
It's worth noting that the board's statement defines this as "a marketing plan in the works and under discussion," but a detailed public PPT on TDF's board mailing list; The plan, which Italo Vignoli, TDF's head of media relations and marketing, has been in the works for a long time and will begin on August 5, according to Italo Vignoli, does not appear to be "unplanned due to the short working hours," according to the statement.
LibreOffice's business plan
Putting that aside, we found Vignoli's proposal included the LibreOffice Enterprise edition and detailed reasons for the commercialisation proposal. We've learned a lot about LiberOffice's business since it came out of the OpenOffice project in 2010.

Vignoli divides LiberOffice users into two groups in his proposal, which are somewhat opposite:
Community users: Contributors and ordinary users in the LibreOffice open source community hope that the project will remain free and open source throughout the project, with complete functions. Eco-partners: Companies that want to do business with the LibreOffice project and hope to profit from it. & have spent
Since building the community, LibreOffice has been supported by a number of so-called "eco-partners" who provide TDF directly with money or people to fund its day-to-day operations. At the same time, some resources come from the contributions and donations of volunteers and users to the community. Of this, approximately 68% of the source code contributions came from ecological partners. An example of an ecological partnership is NBSP; in Cambridge, England; Collabora The company that USES LibreOffice as part of its commercial products. & have spent
The number of full-time employees working in LibreOffice rose to 60 between 2010 and 2014, according to data compiled by Vignoli, but dropped to 40 three years later as some companies withdrew support. Although the situation has stabilized, "ecosystems are not growing as fast as communities," Vignoli said. & have spent He also referred to "friction" in the community due to tensions between business members and community project members, noting that "it's not healthy for the project." & have spent
As for the withdrawal of enterprise partners, Vignoli pointed out that this is also the dilemma facing many open source projects today. "The global open source ecosystem has been developing for many years and there has been a long discussion about the business model between OSS [open source software] and the enterprise, but at the moment the feedback from the project community is still very limited." He added: "The number of businesses using the free version of LibreOffice without paying or reporting any money has been growing for the past 10 years, causing problems for the project's business model." & have spent
The solution proposed by the board was to "improve support for commercial products". So in early May, Vignoli drafted the marketing plan. Vignoli's idea is to improve LibreOffice's financing model by "finding the right balance between free products and enterprise-supported products." Reference is made to commercially supported versions of LibreOffice, such as the aforementioned Collabora Company release based on LibreOffice; Users of the software will pay €17 or $18 a year. & have spent
The first step in this idea is to use a new concept called "LibreOffice Engine" to describe the core project for both the personal and commercial versions. The concept is similar to the "Linux Kernel", in that the Kernel remains free and open source, and commercial companies such as RetHat can launch commercial distributions of Linux with extended functionality. The purpose is to distinguish LibreOffice Personal from LibreOffice Enterprise in user cognition. & have spent
Vignoli also noted problems with LibreOffice Online, the cloud version of the browser-based office suite. Community members want a "fully functional product that can be easily deployed by everyone," he said, while eco-partners want the bulk of the revenue from LibreOffice Online. & have spent Vignoli suggested separating the free version from the commercial version and delaying the release of the free version to satisfy both parties. & have spent
To open source, to survive
TDF and the LibreOffice team could have done a better job of communicating on the issue, but in the face of the open source community of open source enthusiasts from around the world, the statement "subconsciously" glossed over or watered down some of the information about the commercialization of the project, even though it was easily accessible to the more casual observer. This is also an awkward situation for many managers of large open source projects, who have to take care of their community members' enthusiasm for the free and open source concept, and seek funds for the survival and operation of the project. Balancing the viability and growth of an open source project with endless ethical concerns is a daunting task.
Also a rational user under the statement of TDF the message expressed support, "& have spent will" personal edition "changed to" community edition "might be better, I'm sure, because the LO is free and open source, so a lot of users will continue to use LO. Over the years, I have been a few euros per month on a support for TDF (donate), I would be happy to become a LO commercial supporters. But don't happen" community edition "behind the" enterprise "such a change, I think that most people cannot accept."
The user thought the LibreOffice team could learn from RedHat's business model. As one of the world's most successful open source commercial company, RedHat in enterprise users of Linux distributions of RHEL at the same time, also supports the construction of the community version Fedora Linux, and was the first to test the latest functions in Fedora, free of charge for users, with the power of the open source community to make new features stable again after update to provide paid in RHEL corporate clients. Then RedHat acquired the CentOS team and launched a more stable community version of CentOS. Finally, a virtuous development loop is formed between the community version and the enterprise version, which not only expands the market, but also gains a good reputation. & have spent

In fact, "open source software" has never been "free software," and there is nothing shameful about commercializing open source projects. RMS, the father of the free software movement, participated in the drafting of NBSP; In the GPL 2.0 agreement, it is mentioned that "if you can provide maintenance service for software users, you can charge maintenance premium". And companies like RedHat that do business around open source projects make reasonable profits by providing additional value-added services to open source project users. & have spent
Of course, whichever way the LibreOffice team ultimately commercializes the project, Mike Saunders, spokesman for the TDF board, is adamant that "NBSP;LibreOffice will always be foss; NBSP; and NBSP; .
The original address: https://my.oschina.net/editorial-story/blog/4341422
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia