header-langage
简体中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Steem warning: will the exchange misappropriate user assets, control public chain governance?

Read this article in 8 Minutes
Users' assets may have left the exchange and been locked up without their knowledge, which clearly does not meet the exchange's standards for asset management and has no risk controls to speak of.

Original title: "Steem warning: will the exchange misappropriate user assets, control public chain governance?"

Source: daily planet



On February 15, 2020, TRON officially announced the acquisition of Steem, a decentralized content community. However, sun yuchen, who always stands at the forefront of the storm, did not quietly complete the acquisition, but started the public opinion debate of "Steem network controlled by the stock exchange".
The "Steem takeover" ended briefly with the end of voting rights announced by enn and ewing, but it also sparked a deeper debate about whether exchanges that are both DPoS/PoS nodes and store large amounts of user assets might be able to divert flowing tokens to manipulate public governance.

Taking Steem as an example, voting requires upgrading Steem tokens to SP lock-up voting and then downgrading the retrieval. In other words, all transactions may be in the user's knowledge of the situation, misappropriation of the user's assets to lock up the vote. And whether that actually happens, we don't know.


Reverse Steem soft fork, sun yuchen stock exchange strong "power grab"

After the wave field completed the acquisition of Steem, members of the Steem community were concerned that the wave field was a retaliatory acquisition and could not bring long-term stable development to Steem.
So on February 24, the Steem community including witnesses, developers and stakeholders jointly wrote a statement saying that to ensure the security of Steem block chain, the community updated a temporary protection agreement (soft fork 22.2 upgrade) to maintain the current status and long-term development of Steemit shares.

Some analysts say the Steem community developers made the soft split to limit sun's voting influence. Given sun's move to acquire Steemit, it is thought that he will use the tokens he holds to push Steemit in a particular direction, with soft bifurcations preventing certain account-held STEEM from voting on who should manage the network and from participating in ways that might see it seize control.

But when STEEMIT witness people prepared to exercise their rights, began to soft bifurcate STEEM was a voice, Sun Yuchen joint currency, COINS and mainstream Poloniex these exchanges fire, soft bifurcation of a strong reversal STEEM community, use the mainstream users vote, hard power bifurcation and targeted to freeze a few opponents of the account, to recall its voting rights, this process is completely confirmed by the people all the time of "DPoS over-centralisation" problem.

The Steem community accused sun of bribing mainstream exchanges like yuan 'an to use their voting influence to re-elect the new TOP 20 witnesses and immediately update the 22.5 soft fork upgrade.

Thus, sun yuchen established his own "centralized" control in the Steem network, and the original witnesses were completely ineffective.




Sun yuchen said he briefly took control of the Steem network after being attacked by hackers

At around noon on March 3, sun yuchen tweeted that he had admitted to controlling the Steem network, explaining that the hackers had frozen the Steem of core developers, and finally reassuring everyone that "Steem has successfully defeated malicious hackers and all funds are safe".
On February 22, some malicious hackers froze 65 million Steem legally owned by Steemit, the Steem core developer. At the time of discovery, the hackers had frozen the STEEM and threatened to invalidate existing STEEM tokens in STEEM's network. "Disrupting the Steem network would put everyone who holds Steem at risk, so it would be necessary to take control of the Steem network for a short period of time.

Sun yuchen stressed to the outside world that the control of the network in a short time is a "no choice", it has no intention to control or affect the entire Steem blockchain network, without community discussion and unity, Steem blockchain and wave field blockchain will not be merged.

"We are committed to withdrawing our votes as soon as it is determined that malicious hackers are no longer sabotaging STEEM and that voting rights are returned to the community. "Sun wrote on twitter.




Sun Yuchen statement in the twitter, "those who claim that the wave field through the cooperation and exchange hostile takeover rumors Steemit is wrong, our purpose is not to take over the network, more than the wave field and Steem former TOP 20 witness all parties vote will be cancelled. We just want to protect everyone's private property, from hackers."

However, this explanation did not convince the Steem community. Netizens said sun did not explain the purpose of the stock exchange and the role of the exchange, and even questioned whether it was taking advantage of people's fear to give the "wok" to the hackers.


DPoS was questioned by V god, currency fire currency to cancel the right to vote

Sun yuchen's approach was also questioned by ethereum founder V god.




After the Steem incident, twitter user Luke Stokes tweeted that users' Steem tokens in the centralized exchange were used by large exchanges such as sun yuchen to control the Steem area network. "It is clear that Steem's voting system has been taken over by the large exchanges that participated in his DPOS process. This seems to be the first real case of a" vote-buying attack "under the DPOS consensus mechanism," V replied.




Under the pressure of V god and public opinion, yuan 'an CEO zhao changpeng tweeted yesterday afternoon to explain the "Steem struggle for power", and yuan 'an has withdrawn its vote. Zhao changpeng once again explained that this incident is his negligence, mistake this upgrade as a routine upgrade. And in the end to emphasize that the currency on the chain governance is not interested in, always remain neutral, later will continue to support regular upgrades and hard bifurcation.

Following the abolition of voting rights, huoyuan posted a letter to the Steem community on Medium on the evening of March 3, announcing the cancellation of the vote.

Firecoin said in a "letter to the Steem community" that Steemit and Tron had come to us for support before the problems with the Steem network. We were informed that the Steem network was at risk of an attack, which directly affected the assets of our users. We therefore collaborated with Steemit and Tron to better understand the situation and carefully assess the existing risks. Based on the information we have obtained, and out of caution, we believe that helping Steemit and Tron is in the best interests of our users and the network as a whole. But we've always intended to give the right to vote back to the community so that they can determine the needs of the network. Therefore, we canceled the vote and will always support the user's decision.

Thus, sun yuchen lost two "Allies" in the process of "Steem seizing power".


Should exchanges vote for their users?

Exchanges may not be interested in participating in governance, but the possibility of exchanges easily controlling public chain governance still makes users uneasy. After all, "do you want to do evil" and "can you do evil" are two things.
When we look at Steem's governance mechanisms, this "unease" makes sense.

Steem is governed by Steem Power, and Steem token holders can optionally Power UP Steem held in their hands into SP (super node) and then vote to govern Steem network.




Consensus on standards, a senior analyst at Li Zipeng Odaily daily planet said, "from the operating level, the user in the exchange the Steem coin is laid in the exchange address, Steem actual manager is exchange, exchange, is the ability to do the user exists in the hands of their Steem to escalate to SP, and then vote on the Power Down after the completion of downgraded to Steem COINS."

"But it only means that the operation is feasible. In fact, it is difficult to judge whether the exchange has done so or not. It still needs to be verified by lawyers."

If the exchange really does Power UP to exchange SP, it is essentially misappropriating user assets, and the Steem token after Power UP is to lock UP the position. Let's say that the big exchanges actually do this, which means that if the user were to go to these exchanges at the moment and withdraw money, there would be no money to withdraw.

If a user's assets have unknowingly left the exchange and been locked up, it clearly does not meet the exchange's standards for asset management and there is no risk control to speak of.

More discussed is whether the DPoS design is seriously flawed, given the ease with which exchanges have the right to control corporate governance. And, since the exchanges holding assets on behalf of users have become PoS/DPoS nodes, can they exercise governance rights on behalf of users, and have their authorization and consent?


According to user feedback, most exchanges currently do not set up the page and function for users to authorize the exchange to vote on their behalf, and users simply do not know whether their tokens have been voted by the exchange.

Users put the currency in the exchange, does not represent the right to participate in the governance of the exchange. Unless the user chooses to give his or her currency Stake to the exchange, the move amounts to a pledge of the currency to the exchange's pool, which exercises the voting rights on behalf of the user and rewards the user with interest earned from the reserve.

So, are the PoS/XPoS tokens not involved in Staking actually sitting in the wallet of the exchange, or have they been diverted to use it? We don't know. Just as there was no way of knowing that many assets had been moved long before the FCoin storm.

"Participate in the chain of governance", "exercise of the right to vote", many retail investors hear similar terms will feel headache, and never participate in.

But what is happening now should alarm all asset holders that your rights, which you don't care about, could make the difference between the project's survival and your tokens' demise.

The Odaily planet also called on exchanges as nodes to provide better and clearer choices and guidelines in product design, allowing users to clarify their choices or guide them to exercise their rights.



The original link: https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/obKdCLji7zhzE7Pyl70OzQ





Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit