header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Coinbase Monthly Outlook: ETH’s DeFi central position is difficult to replace, and there is still potential for growth in the future

Read this article in 16 Minutes
1. ETH's long-term market positioning is strong: Despite ETH's poor performance year-to-date, its market positioning remains strong in the long run, with unique expansion roadmap advantages and continued demand momentum. 2. ETH benefits from dual narratives: ETH has historically benefited from the dual narratives of "value storage" and "technology tokens", with a high correlation with BTC, but will decouple when BTC prices rise, showing the characteristics of a technology-oriented cryptocurrency. 3. Potential approval of spot ETH ETF: After the United States approved the BTC spot ETF, the potential approval of the ETH spot ETF has become a key issue, which may bring new capital inflows to ETH, despite the current regulatory challenges. 4. ETH fights the challenge of alternative L1s: Despite competition from alternative L1 networks such as Solana, ETH maintains its market position with its mature developer ecosystem, EVM platform popularity, and DeFi staking practicality. 5. ETH technological innovation and tokenization potential: ETH's technological innovation, especially in L2 expansion and EVM compatibility, as well as the increase in tokenization projects and global regulatory clarity, may benefit ETH first and promote its advantages in public blockchains.
Original translation: Monthly Outlook: Expectations on Ethereum
Original author: David Han, Coinbase
Original translation: TechFlow


The multiple role classifications for ETH raise questions about its position in the portfolio, and this article will clarify some of these statements, as well as potential positive factors for the asset in the coming months.


Article Summary


· Despite ETH's poor performance year-to-date, we believe its market positioning remains strong in the long term.


· We believe that ETH has the potential to bring unexpected gains in the late cycle. We also believe that ETH has the strongest sustained demand momentum in the crypto market and maintains its unique expansion roadmap advantages.


· ETH's historical trading pattern shows that it benefits from the dual narratives of "value storage" and "technology token".


Main text


The approval of a BTC spot ETF in the U.S. strengthens BTC’s store of value narrative and its position as a macro asset.On the other hand, questions remain to be answered around ETH’s fundamental positioning in the crypto space. Competing layer-1 networks such as Solana have weakened ETH’s position as the preferred network for decentralized application (dApp) deployment. ETH’s L2 expansion and reduced ETH burns also appear to be affecting the asset’s value accumulation mechanism at a high level.


Nevertheless,we continue to believe that ETH’s long-term positioning remains strong, and it has important advantages that other smart contract networks do not have.These advantages include the maturity of the Solidity developer ecosystem, the popularity of its EVM platform, ETH’s utility as DeFi collateral, and the decentralization and security of its mainnet. In addition, we believe that advances in tokenization may have a more positive impact on ETH relative to other layer-1 networks in the short term.


We find that ETH's ability to capture both the "store of value" and "tech token" narratives is reflected in its historical trading patterns. ETH has a high correlation with BTC, showing behavior consistent with BTC's store of value model. At the same time, it also decouples from BTC during long-term BTC price increases, behaving more like a technology-oriented cryptocurrency like other altcoins. We believe ETH will continue to play these roles and is expected to outperform in the second half of 2024 despite its poor performance year-to-date.


Response to the ETH Controversy


ETH has been categorized in many ways, from being considered an “ultrasonic currency” named for its supply reduction mechanism to being called “internet bonds” for the non-inflationary nature of its staking returns. With the development of the second layer network (L2s) and the addition of re-staking functions, new descriptions such as “settlement layer assets” or more complex “universal objective work tokens” have emerged. However, we believe that these descriptions do not fully reflect the vitality of Ethereum. In fact, as Ethereum’s application scenarios continue to enrich and complicate, it has become increasingly difficult to fully evaluate its value through a single value indicator. More importantly, these different descriptions may conflict with each other, thereby generating negative effects, as they may offset each other-distracting market participants from the positive drivers of the token.


Spot ETH ETF


Spot ETFs are extremely important to BTC because they provide regulatory clarity and a path for new capital inflows. These ETFs structurally change the industry and challenge the previous model of capital circulation, which was from BTC to ETH to higher beta altcoins. There is a barrier between the capital allocated to ETFs and that allocated to centralized exchanges (CEXs), which only have access to the broader cryptoasset space. The potential approval of a spot ETH ETF would remove this barrier, allowing ETH to access the same pool of capital currently only enjoyed by BTC. In our view, this may be the biggest outstanding question for ETH in the near term, especially given the current challenging regulatory environment.


While the SEC's silence on issuers makes timely approval uncertain, we believe that the existence of a US spot ETH ETF is a matter of when, not if. In fact, the main reason for approving a spot BTC ETF also applies to a spot ETH ETF. That is, the correlation between the CME futures product and the spot rate is high enough that "CME's monitoring can reasonably be expected to detect improper behavior in the spot market." The correlation study period in the spot BTC approval notice began in March 2021, one month after the launch of CME ETH futures. We believe this evaluation period was deliberately chosen in order to apply similar logic to the ETH market. In fact, analysis previously presented by Coinbase and Grayscale suggests that spot and futures correlations in the ETH market are similar to BTC.


Assuming this correlation analysis holds, the remaining possible reasons for disapproval may stem from the fundamental differences between ETH and BTC. In the past, we have discussed some of the differences in the size and depth of the ETH and BTC futures markets, which may have been a factor in the SEC's decision. But among other fundamental differences between ETH and BTC, we believe the most relevant approval issue is ETH's Proof of Stake (PoS) mechanism.


With no clear regulatory guidance on the treatment of staking assets, we believe it is unlikely that a spot ETH ETF that supports staking will be approved in the near term. Potentially ambiguous fee structures from third-party staking providers, differences between validator clients, the complexity of slashing conditions, and the liquidity risks of unstaking (and exit queue congestion) are materially different from BTC. (It is worth noting that some European ETH ETFs include staking, but generally, European exchange-traded products differ from those offered in the United States.) Nonetheless, we believe this should not affect the status of unstaking ETH.


We believe this decision may bring surprises. Polymarket predicts a 16% chance of approval on May 31, 2024, while Grayscale Ethereum Trust (ETHE) trades at a 24% discount to net asset value (NAV). We believe the odds of approval are closer to 30-40%. As crypto becomes an election issue, we are also unsure if the SEC is willing to invest the necessary political capital to support a decision to reject crypto. Even if the first deadline of May 23, 2024 is rejected, we think the chances of overturning the decision through litigation are high. It is worth noting that not all applications for spot ETH ETFs must be approved at the same time. In fact, Commissioner Uyeda’s approval statement on the spot BTC ETF criticized the disguised “motivation to accelerate the approval of applications, namely to prevent the emergence of a first-mover advantage”.


Challenges of Alternative L1s


At the adoption level, highly scalable integration links, especially Solana, appear to be eroding ETH’s market share. High throughput and low fee transactions have shifted the center of trading activity away from the ETH mainnet. Notably, the Solana ecosystem has grown from only 2% of decentralized exchange (DEX) volume to 21% today over the past year.



We believe that alternative L1s also offer more meaningful differentiation now than during the last bull run. The move away from the ETH Virtual Machine (EVM) and redesigning dApps from the ground up has resulted in unique user experiences (UX) across different ecosystems. Additionally, the integrated/monolithic approach to scaling enhances composability across applications, avoiding issues with bridging UX and liquidity fragmentation.


While these value propositions are important, we believe it is premature to use incentivized activity metrics as confirmation of success. For example, the number of transacting users on some ETH L2s dropped by over 80% from the peak of the airdrop. Meanwhile, Solana’s share of total DEX volume grew from 6% to 17% between Jupiter’s airdrop announcement on November 16, 2023, and the first claim date on January 31, 2024. (Jupiter is the leading DEX aggregator on Solana.) Jupiter has three airdrops left to complete, so we expect activity on the Solana DEX to continue for some time. In the interim, assumptions about long-term activity retention remain speculative.


That said, trading activity on leading ETH L2s like Arbitrum, Optimism, and Base now accounts for 17% of total DEX volume (combined with ETH’s 33%). This may provide a more appropriate comparison of ETH demand drivers to alternative L1 solutions, as ETH is used as the native fuel token for these three L2s. Other additional demand drivers for ETH are untapped across these networks, which provides room for future demand catalysts. We believe this is a more equivalent comparison of integrated vs. modular scaling approaches in terms of DEX activity.


Another, more “sticky” measure of adoption is stablecoin supply. Stablecoin distribution tends to change more slowly due to frictions in bridging and issuance/redemption. (See Exhibit 2. The color scheme and arrangement are the same as Exhibit 1, with Thorchain replaced by Tron.) Activity is still dominated by ETH as measured by stablecoin issuance. In our view, this is because the trust assumptions and reliability of many new chains are not yet strong enough to support large amounts of capital, especially capital locked in smart contracts. Large capital holders are generally indifferent to ETH’s higher transaction costs (relative to scale), and prefer to reduce risk by reducing liquidity pause times and minimizing bridge trust assumptions.


Even so, among high-throughput chains, ETH L2s are growing stablecoin supply faster than Solana. Arbitrum’s stablecoin supply has surpassed Solana’s at the beginning of 2024 (currently $3.6 billion vs. $3.2 billion, respectively), while Base’s stablecoin supply has grown from $160 million at the beginning of the year to $2.4 billion. While the final verdict on the scaling debate is still unclear, early signs of stablecoin growth may actually favor ETH L2s over alternative L1s.



The growth of L2s has raised concerns about the actual threat they may pose to ETH - they reduce the demand for L1 block space (and therefore reduce transaction fee burns) and may support non-ETH gas tokens in their ecosystems (further reducing ETH burns). In fact, ETH is experiencing its highest annualized inflation rate since its switch to a proof-of-stake (PoS) mechanism in 2022. While inflation is often understood as a structurally important component of BTC supply, we do not believe this applies to ETH. All ETH issuance is owned by stakers, and stakers’ collective balances far exceed cumulative ETH issuance since the merger (see Figure 4). This is in stark contrast to BTC’s proof-of-work (PoW) miner economics, where the competitive hashrate environment means miners need to sell a large portion of newly issued BTC to fund operations. While miners’ BTC holdings are tracked at various cycles to account for their inevitable selling, ETH’s staking operation has minimal operational costs, meaning that stakers can continue to increase their holdings. In fact, staking has become a convergence point for ETH liquidity—the growth of ETH in stake has exceeded ETH issuance (even excluding burns) by 20x.



L2s themselves are also a significant demand driver for ETH. Over 3.5 million ETH has been moved to the L2 ecosystem, becoming another liquidity convergence point for ETH. Furthermore, even if the ETH moved to L2s is not directly destroyed, the remaining balance of native tokens held by new wallets to pay transaction fees constitutes a soft lock-up of a growing portion of ETH tokens.



Additionally, we believe that some core activity will always remain on the ETH mainnet even as their L2s scale. Things like EigenLayer’s re-staking activity or governance actions for major protocols like Aave, Maker, and Uniswap remain firmly rooted in L1. Users with the highest security concerns (typically those with the largest capital) may also keep funds on L1 until fully decentralized sorters and permissionless fraud proofs are deployed and tested — a process that could take years. Even as L2s innovate in different directions, ETH will always be a component of their treasury (used to pay L1 “rent”) and native unit of account. We firmly believe that the growth of L2s is not only good for the ETH ecosystem, but also for ETH as an asset.


ETH’s Strengths


Beyond the commonly covered metric-based narratives, we believe ETH has other, harder to quantify but equally important strengths. These may not be short-term tradable narratives, but rather represent a set of long-term strengths that can sustain its current dominance.


Original Collateral and Units of Account


One of the most important uses of ETH in DeFi is as collateral. ETH is able to be leveraged with minimal counterparty risk in the ETH and its L2 ecosystem. It serves as a type of collateral in money markets like Maker and Aave, and is also the base trading unit for many on-chain DEX pairings. The expansion of DeFi on ETH and its L2s has led to additional liquidity pooling on ETH.


While BTC remains the primary store of value asset more broadly, the use of wrapped BTC on ETH introduces cross-chain bridges and trust assumptions. We do not believe WBTC will replace ETH for DeFi-based ETH usage — WBTC supply has remained flat for over a year and is over 40% below its previous high. Instead, ETH can benefit from the diversity of its L2 ecosystem.


Continued Innovation & Decentralization


An often overlooked component of the ETH community is its ability to continue to innovate even as it decentralizes. ETH has been criticized for its extended release timeline and development delays, but few acknowledge the complexity of balancing the goals and objectives of diverse stakeholders to achieve technological progress. Developers of more than five execution clients and more than four consensus clients need to coordinate to design, test, and deploy changes without causing disruptions to mainnet execution.


Since BTC’s last major Taproot upgrade in November 2021, ETH has enabled dynamic transaction burning (August 2021), transitioned to PoS (September 2022), enabled staking withdrawals (March 2023), and created blob storage for L2 scaling (March 2024), among a host of other ETH Improvement Proposals (EIPs). While many other L1s appear capable of moving faster, their single clients make them more fragile and centralized. The path toward decentralization inevitably leads to a degree of rigidity, and it is unclear whether other ecosystems will be able to create similarly effective development processes if and when they begin this process.


Rapid Innovation in L2


This is not to say that ETH is innovating slower than other ecosystems. On the contrary, we believe that ETH’s innovation around execution environments and developer tooling is actually outpacing its competitors. ETH benefits from the rapid, centralized development of L2s, all of which pay settlement fees to L1. The ability to create diverse platforms with different execution environments (such as Web Assembly, Move, or the Solana Virtual Machine) or other features (such as privacy or enhanced staking rewards) means that the slow development timeline of L1 does not prevent ETH from gaining acceptance in more technically complex use cases.


At the same time, the ETH community’s efforts to define different trust assumptions and definitions around sidechains, Validium, Rollups, etc. have led to greater transparency in the space. For example, similar efforts in the BTC L2 ecosystem (such as L2Beat) have yet to emerge, where L2 trust assumptions vary widely and are generally not well communicated or understood by the broader community.


The Popularity of the EVM


Innovation around new execution environments does not mean that Solidity and the EVM will become obsolete in the near future. On the contrary, the EVM has been widely adopted by other chains. For example, many BTC L2s have adopted research results from ETH L2. Some of Solidity's shortcomings (such as the ease of introducing reentrancy vulnerabilities) now have static tool checkers to prevent basic vulnerabilities. In addition, the popularity of the language has also created a mature audit sector, a large number of open source code samples, and detailed best practice guides. All of these are essential to building a large development talent pool.


While the use of the EVM does not directly lead to demand for ETH, changes to the EVM are rooted in ETH’s development process. These changes are then adopted by other chains to maintain compatibility with the EVM. We believe that it is likely that core innovations in the EVM will remain rooted in ETH — or quickly preempted by L2 — which will focus developer attention and thus foster new protocols within the ETH ecosystem.


Tokenization and the Lindy Effect


The push for tokenized projects and increased global regulatory clarity may also benefit ETH (among public blockchains) first. In our view, financial products are often more focused on technical risk mitigation than optimization and feature richness, and ETH has the advantage of being the longest-running smart contract platform. We believe that higher transaction fees (dollars instead of cents) and longer confirmation times (seconds instead of milliseconds) are secondary issues for many large tokenized projects.


In addition, for more traditional companies looking to scale on-chain, recruiting enough developer talent becomes a key factor. Here, Solidity becomes the obvious choice as it constitutes the largest subset of smart contract developers, which echoes the previous point about the popularity of the EVM. Blackrock's BUIDL fund on ETH and JPM's proposed ERC-20 compatible Onyx Digital Assets Fungible Asset Contract (ODA-FACT) token standard are early signs of the importance of this talent pool.


Structural Supply Mechanisms


The evolution of active ETH supply differs significantly from BTC. Despite the price increase since Q4 2023, ETH's three-month circulating supply has not increased significantly. In contrast, we observe an increase of nearly 75% in active BTC supply over the same time frame. Unlike what we saw in the 2021/22 cycle when ETH was still running on Proof-of-Work (PoW), long-term ETH holders are not leading to an increase in circulating supply, but rather the growing ETH supply is being staked. This reaffirms our view that staking is a key liquidity convergence point for ETH, minimizing structural sell-side pressure on the asset.



Evolving Trading Regimes


Historically, ETH has traded more in line with BTC than any other altcoin. At the same time, it has also decoupled from BTC during bull market peaks or specific ecosystem events - a similar pattern observed in other altcoins, albeit to a lesser extent. We believe this trading behavior reflects the market's relative valuation of ETH as a store of value token and a technical utility token.



Throughout 2023, ETH’s correlation with BTC has been inversely related to changes in BTC price. That is, as BTC value increases, ETH’s correlation with it decreases, and vice versa. In fact, changes in BTC price appear to be a leading indicator of changes in ETH’s correlation. We believe this is a reflection of market enthusiasm led by BTC price in altcoins, which in turn drives their speculative performance in bull markets (i.e. altcoins trade differently in bull markets than they do in bear markets relative to BTC).


However, this trend has weakened following the approval of the US spot BTC ETF. We believe this highlights the structural impact of ETF-based inflows, where an entirely new capital base has only exposure to BTC. New markets, such as registered investment advisors (RIAs), wealth management advisors, and securities firms, may view BTC in their portfolios differently than many crypto-native or retail traders. While BTC is the least volatile asset in a pure crypto portfolio, it is often viewed as a small diversifier in more traditional fixed income and equity portfolios. We believe this shift in BTC’s utility has impacted its trading patterns relative to ETH, and that ETH could see a similar shift (and a recalibration of trading patterns) if a US spot ETH ETF is approved.



Summary


We believe that ETH may still have upside potential in the coming months. ETH does not appear to be under significant supply-side pressures such as token unlocking or miner selling pressure. Instead, the growth of staking and L2 has proven to be a meaningful and growing convergence point for ETH liquidity. We believe that ETH's position as the center of DeFi is unlikely to be replaced due to the widespread adoption of EVM and its L2 innovation.


In addition, the importance of a potential US spot ETH ETF cannot be ignored. We believe the market may be underestimating the timing and likelihood of potential approval, which provides upside. In the meantime, we believe ETH's structural demand drivers and technological innovation within its ecosystem will enable it to continue to juggle multiple narratives.


Original link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit