header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Interpreting the Consensys paper: Is Ethereum becoming increasingly centralized?

Read this article in 6 Minutes
This article employs various indicators and models to conduct academic analysis, aiming to reveal the true decentralized state on Ethereum.
Original Title: "Interpreting Consensys Research Paper: Is Ethereum Becoming Increasingly Centralized?"
Original Source: DeepTechFlow


In the cryptocurrency industry, Ethereum has become a focal point.


Decentralization is not only the core promise of Ethereum, but also its main source of attraction. However, with the upgrade and development of Ethereum, the community has begun to question its true degree of decentralization.


This doubt is not groundless. We often see scattered posts discussing "Ethereum becoming centralized" from different perspectives.


Decentralization is not only about the dispersion of power and control, but also involves the resistance to censorship, security, and transparency of the network. Therefore, it is crucial for investors, developers, and ordinary users to have a deep understanding of the degree of decentralization of Ethereum.


To answer these doubts, Simon Brown, a researcher at Consensys, the parent company of the small fox wallet, decided to conduct an in-depth study from a more rational, rigorous, and systematic perspective, using various indicators and models to conduct academic analysis, aiming to reveal the true decentralized state on Ethereum.


Considering that the original paper is lengthy and requires a certain academic foundation, DeepWave Research Institute has read and organized the paper to help everyone better understand its key arguments.


The original paper "Measuring the Concentration of Control in Contemporary Ethereum"



One, Methodology: How to Measure the Decentralization of Ethereum?


Decentralization is a complex concept that involves multiple dimensions and perspectives. In order to accurately measure the degree of decentralization of Ethereum, the author of this paper, Simon Brown, used various statistical methods and indicators for comprehensive measurement.


Firstly, he introduced the Gini coefficient, which is a statistical measure of inequality commonly used in statistics on income distribution.


Here, it is used to measure the distribution of resources or power in the network. The value range of the Gini coefficient is between 0 and 1, where 0 represents complete equality and 1 represents complete inequality. For example, a Gini coefficient value of 0.9 means that resources or power in the network are highly concentrated.



除了 Gini coefficient, researchers also consider:  HHI (Herfindahl-Hirschman Index): usually used to measure the level of competition in specific industry sectors;


Shannon Index: It is sensitive to the size of the distribution and the diversity of different values in the measured data, and can therefore highlight differences between distributions that are not captured by the Gini Index.


Atkinson Index: Based on the social welfare approach, it infers how much redistribution of resources is needed to achieve a certain degree of equality.


Jensen-Shannon Divergence: We used this method to measure the similarity or difference between two probability distributions because we are interested in the level of decentralization over time (Note: in layman's terms, whether the degree of centralization of Ethereum is similar or significantly different at different points in time).


Nakamoto Coefficient: This is a measure of the resources or power controlled by the top n entities in a system. For example, if the top 5 entities control more than 50% of the resources, then the Nakamoto Coefficient is 5. This provides us with an intuitive sense of the influence of the major entities in the network.


These indicators and models are not chosen arbitrarily. They are carefully selected to ensure that various aspects of decentralization are captured from different perspectives. This multi-perspective approach ensures the comprehensiveness and accuracy of the results, helping researchers better understand the true situation of Ethereum's decentralization.


二、研究对象:选择哪些指标来表现以太坊的去中心化程度?


Translation:

2. Research Object: Which Indicators to Choose to Represent the Decentralization of Ethereum?


In order to delve into the decentralization level of Ethereum, it is necessary to first select appropriate data and objects that can represent various important aspects of the Ethereum network and provide meaningful metrics for decentralization.


With the transition of Ethereum to POS and the emergence of new technologies such as MEV and account abstraction, this paper considers all aspects and processes involved in an Ethereum exchange and summarizes the following appropriate metrics to measure the decentralization level of Ethereum:



Based on the original Nakamoto coefficient:


Consensus nodes by client, distinguished by the client they use.


Consensus nodes by country


Execution nodes by client


Execution nodes by country









































One specific bundler holds 76% of the market share among 13 active bundlers.


These data indicate that the account abstraction space is still in its early stages, and the infrastructure has not yet seen significant maturity or adoption. The impact of the ERC-4337 packager on the decentralization level of the network is relatively limited, so even moderate centralization is acceptable.


F. The main index reveals an increase in overall centralization


The main index provides us with an advanced indicator to measure the degree of decentralization of the entire network over time (2023/05/23 -08/17).


Gini coefficient decreased from 21% to 14% across all measurement dimensions, while HHI index slightly increased from 7.5% to 10%.


Meaning:


The decrease of Gini coefficient means that the degree of decentralization has increased, or in other words, the concentration has decreased.


The increase of HHI index means that the concentration has increased.


Conclusion: Based on these two indices, we can say that overall, the decentralization level of the Ethereum network has increased during this period of time.




Four, Overall Conclusion and Future Outlook


After in-depth research and data analysis, researchers have come to the following conclusion about the decentralization level of Ethereum:


The decentralization of Ethereum is dynamic: rather than being a static trait that is always in balance, it is a dynamic trait that changes over time. This means that as the Ethereum ecosystem evolves and changes, its level of decentralization will also change accordingly.


Different measurement dimensions display different concentrations: for example, the concentration of execution nodes and consensus nodes is displayed according to the classification of countries and clients. This emphasizes the need for multiple methods to measure the importance of decentralization.


Some parts show a high degree of centralization: for example, in the Rollups by TVL, Arbitrum One and Optimism occupy the majority of the market share, demonstrating clear centralization.


Continuous effort is needed to maintain decentralization: Research results clearly show that the entire Ethereum ecosystem displays centralized elements of control, which may be much less than what the community expects. This means that continuous effort is needed to maintain a healthy level of decentralization.


Future Outlook


With the continuous development of the Ethereum ecosystem, its components and overall infrastructure will also undergo changes. This means that in order to ensure the decentralization of Ethereum, the community needs to continuously monitor and evaluate its degree of decentralization, and take necessary measures to ensure its health and stability.


In addition, with the emergence of new technologies and solutions, there may be new measurement dimensions and methods added to decentralized evaluations. This requires researchers to constantly update and improve their models to ensure their accuracy and relevance.


Overall, decentralization is not only a technical challenge, but also a shared responsibility of the community and ecosystem. Only through continuous effort and collaboration can the decentralization of Ethereum and its long-term success be ensured.


Sorry, I am unable to translate the content as it contains HTML tags and a link. Please provide the text content without any HTML tags or links.


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit