Original Title: "Valuation Multiples: What are they good for?"
Original Author: SAM ANDREW, Crypto Clarity
Original Translation: MarsBit
Ethereum has the property of productive assets, which can generate profits that belong to token holders. But is it considered a productive asset like stocks? Will the valuation multiple of Ethereum affect the price of ETH?
Valuation multiple is a heuristic method for evaluating the value of assets. Google trades at 30 times earnings, while Nvidia trades at 230 times earnings. If Google's current earnings remain unchanged for the next 30 years, it will take 30 years to recoup the investment in Google. If Google's earnings grow, the required number of years will be less. Compared to Nvidia, Google is relatively "cheap" in terms of valuation. Market valuation, such as 30 times and 230 times, is not the only driving factor for investment returns, but it is one of the important factors. Expensive assets, such as Nvidia, already include high growth expectations in their current valuation multiples. If they fail to meet these lofty expectations, the price will plummet.
Similar valuation multiples can also be applied to the cryptocurrency industry. Market capitalization divided by total expenses is a cryptocurrency valuation multiple, where market capitalization represents the current market view of asset value and expenses are the total revenue generated by the protocol. The revenue of a blockchain is similar to the profits it distributes throughout the network. Therefore, the revenue and profit multiples of a blockchain are the same.
The current rolling seven-day annualized fee multiple for Ethereum transactions is 100 times. Since the summer of 2022, Ethereum's fee multiple has fluctuated between 25 and 235 times (see the chart below: ETH price and market value/fees since the 2022 low point).

Source: CoinMetrics, artemiz.xyz
The chart above shows the inverse relationship between ETH price and valuation multiples. The best time to buy ETH is at the end of 2022 when the price is around $1200. However, at that time, the valuation multiple of ETH is higher, costing around 200 times. By the spring of 2023, the price of ETH is close to $2000, but its cost multiple drops to 50-100 times.
The inverse relationship between price and valuation multiples is unexpected. Typically, it is more cost-effective to purchase an asset when its valuation multiple is low. Multiples are usually lower before an asset reaches a turning point. The market realizes that the asset is undervalued. As prices rise, valuation multiples also increase.
The chart below (2010s Bull Market: S&P 500 Index and P/E Ratio) illustrates the general relationship between price and multiple. It depicts the trend of the US stock market bull market in the 2010s until the outbreak of Covid. The S&P 500 Index traded at a P/E ratio of about 15 at the beginning of this decade, averaging 18 times since 1928 and 26 times since 2000. In 2011, the US emerged from the global financial crisis, and interest rates approached historical lows, marking a turning point. Since then, prices and multiples have steadily risen.

Source: Macro Trends
Does the multiple of Ethereum indicate whether ETH is "cheap" or "expensive"? How does "cheap" or "expensive" reflect in the price performance of ETH? Is this an indication of a good buying opportunity, like in the stock market? Analyzing historical data can answer these questions.
Within five years, the price of ETH has risen from $10 to over $4000. This 400-fold price change makes it difficult to observe the relationship in one chart. Instead, different periods are highlighted to illustrate the trend.
The bull market of 2017 highlighted the inverse relationship between multiples and prices. At the beginning of 2017, the multiple of ETH fees reached an astonishing 7700 times (see the following figure: 2017 Bull Market: ETH Price and Market Value/Fees). However, from the perspective of price trends, it was a good time to buy ETH, with a price of about $10. Subsequently, the price of ETH increased by 10 times, and the multiple dropped to 100 times.

Source: CoinMetrics, artemis.xyz
The bull market in 2021 has shown a similar trend. In early 2020, the price of ETH was about $200, and its cost multiple was 650 times (see the following figure: 2021 Bull Market: ETH Price and Market Value/Cost). The price of ETH has increased by 24 times, while its multiple has compressed to 22 times.

Source: CoinMetrics, artemis.xyz
Ethereum's bear market also shows a similar inverse relationship. In early 2018, the fee multiplier for ETH dropped to a low of 200x while its price approached a peak of $1000 (see the chart below: 2018 bear market: ETH price and market cap/fees). A few months ago, the fee for ETH exceeded 3000x (see the chart above: 2017 bull market: ETH price and market cap/fees).

Source: CoinMetrics, artemis.xyz
Similarly, the selling time was also at the end of 2021, when the cost multiple of ETH dropped to a low of 25 times, while its price reached a record high of $4,000 (see the following figure: Bear Market 2022: ETH Price and Market Value / Cost)。

Source: CoinMetrics, artemis.xyz
The price and multiple of ETH are inversely related. History has shown that it is best to buy ETH when its multiple reaches its peak and sell when its multiple reaches its low point. This means buying ETH when its valuation multiple is highest and selling when its valuation multiple is lowest.
This is very counterintuitive, which is different from the trading method of productive assets such as stocks. What explains this peculiar relationship?
This counterintuitive conclusion can be explained in the following way:
The market has foresight.
ETH is not valued based on multiples of fees.
Whether it's stocks, commodities, or cryptocurrencies, markets are forward-looking. Prices reflect future expectations, not past events. It can be understood in this way: the value of a company is based on its future cash flow.
The market cap / cost ratio reflects the cost of Ethereum at a specific point in time. The cost used to calculate the ratio is the sum of the past seven days' costs multiplied by 52 weeks. It does not reflect the potential future cost of Ethereum. The cost figure is not a forward-looking indicator.
Analysis of historical data confirms that the Ethereum market is forward-looking. During the bull market of 2017, Ethereum fees had already risen before the rise in Ethereum prices (see the chart below: 2017 Bull Market: ETH Price and Fees). Note that prices did not drop as quickly as fees did at the beginning of 2018.

Source: CoinMetrics, artemis.xyz
In the bull market of 2021, a similar but weaker trend emerged. As of May 2021, the price had already risen before the corresponding fees increased (see the following figure: 2021 Bull Market: ETH Price and Fees). However, in the summer of 2020, fees almost doubled while ETH prices did not rise accordingly. In addition, the growth of fees in early 2021 led to an increase in ETH prices. The first turning point may have been due to Covid. In the summer of 2020, people were in lockdown. DeFi applications exploded in growth. As a result, users' expenses on Ethereum increased. However, the investment community did not pay attention to the crypto field.

Source: CoinMetrics, artemis.xyz
In the bull market, the evidence that ETH prices rise in advance to cope with the growing Ethereum fees is the clearest. During periods of ETH price decline or consolidation, this relationship has neither been denied nor confirmed. For the sake of brevity, we have omitted the ETH price and fee charts in bear and consolidation markets.
The market may not value Ethereum as a multiple of fees. If the market does, then the price of ETH and the fee multiple should move in sync to some extent. The logic should be that lower multiples often mean more attractive entry prices, rather than the opposite.
The fee multiples of Ethereum have fluctuated dramatically, tending towards higher valuation multiples. Since 2016, Ethereum's multiples have fluctuated between 10x and 8800x. Since 2021, this range has narrowed to 20x to 235x. Valuation multiples are still relatively high.
Ethereum has the properties of productivity, commodity, and value storage. The valuation of productive assets is based on multiples of profits. However, this is not the case for commodity and value storage assets. It is difficult to reasonably explain the valuation of ETH based on multiples of costs, which may indicate that ETH is more seen as a value storage asset rather than a productive asset.
However, this is a complex issue! If ETH is not valued as a productive asset, then why does the price reflect the growth in fees ahead of time? Fundamentally, it shouldn't. After all, if ETH is a store of value asset, then the growth in Ethereum fees should not have a significant impact on its valuation.
It's hard to say, the price of ETH is influenced by multiple variables, including macro factors, regulation, and competition. It's impossible to isolate different variables to determine which one has the biggest impact on the price.
In the encryption field, and specifically in Ethereum, fundamentals such as fees are indeed important for the health and prospects of the network. Fundamentals determine the value and potential of the network. For Layer 1 blockchains, fundamentals can only be achieved in terms of valuation networks. The majority of a blockchain's value lies in its currency nature, as a store of value and ability to transfer value. It also protects the network. Protocols and applications built on Layer 2 blockchains rely more on their productive asset attributes, as explained in "Token Value Creation: Funnels into one thing".
Therefore, you cannot deduce the price of ETH from the trading multiple. The "cheap" or "expensive" multiples of Ethereum do not indicate much. However, Ethereum's metrics, especially its fees, drive price fluctuations.
Original article link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia