header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

CZ reposts 6-year-old article: Dislikes large-scale ICO projects, obtaining a large amount of funds at once may not be correct.

Read this article in 7 Minutes
CZ believes that the focus should shift from large-scale ICOs to a mindset of long-term growth.
Original Title: "I Don't Like Big ICOs"
Original Source: czbinance
Original Translation: TechFlow Deep Tide


On July 24th, Binance founder CZ tweeted an article he wrote 6 years ago titled "I Don't Like Big ICOs". The article mentioned a large ICO that aimed to raise $100 million, but now the project's market value is less than $1 million.


CZ represents a group of good people, but they may be distracted by too much money. Start with small things and then move on to bigger things, rather than the other way around.


In the article, CZ explained in detail that it is not a good thing for a cryptocurrency project to raise a large amount of funds with a high valuation at the beginning in the long term, although this is often considered an achievement for the founder. Binance also does not like such projects, and CZ's thinking on the selection of coins on Binance can be seen from the article, which continues to this day.


For entrepreneurs who aspire to make a mark in the world of encryption, this article may be worth a read.


The following is the full text:


I am the CEO of https://www.binance.com, CZ. This is my first article published on Steemit, and it is a highly subjective piece.


Last night, I was at a party in Tokyo with several cryptocurrency enthusiasts. The host wanted to conduct an ICO. Although the team was small, they were powerful. They had developed and released a product with a decent user base. Everything sounded good until I asked how much money they planned to raise in the ICO. The answer was $100 million.


My expression is "I don't like it." Afterwards, a discussion took place and I believe it would be beneficial to share the content of this discussion with anyone interested in conducting an ICO or listing on Binance.com.


At least in theory, large-scale ICOs have many benefits. It can become headline news, increase the project's visibility and credibility, make people in awe of your greatness, and enhance confidence. $100 million should be able to meet all the funding needs of the project for a long time! With sufficient funds, the project team can do whatever they want, actively building it into a huge empire, and all of this seems to be a happy and beautiful thing...


But I don't like it. The reasons are as follows:


Firstly, do you really need 100 million US dollars for your project?


Yesterday, a team member gave me their first answer, "Yes, we will establish the entire ecosystem, acquire companies..." and I interrupted them. I like to see startup teams focus only on one task. This is just my personal preference. However, my personal preference did indeed affect Binance.


You need all your funds now?


One misconception is that ICO is a one-time event. You must have all the necessary funds now! This is incorrect. There are many ways to build a token economy and obtain all the funds needed for a project over time, without requiring all investors to bear significant risks in the initial stage. Details will be discussed later.


Hunger


I'm worried that a small team with $100 million may no longer feel hungry. Indeed, the most motivated teams should have intrinsic motivation, hoping to change the world, and so on. Indeed, some people can maintain this hunger even if they have money, but not everyone can. I still hope to see teams with hunger. I like to occasionally see code submitted to GitHub at 3am.


Setting aside these issues, the key question is token economics.


ICO Maximization = Bad


I don't like to see projects achieve maximum value during ICO. In the long run, this is often harmful to these projects. This is counterintuitive for many ICO entrepreneurs, including many who were present yesterday.


The most valuable ICO coins will only fall in price once they enter the exchange. This will bring various problems, which most people did not consider during the ICO stage. However, as an exchange operator, I often see this situation, fortunately mainly on other exchanges.


Assuming your project is worth $200 million today, and you sold 50% of it in an ICO for $100 million. One day later, your coin is traded on Binance. Setting aside hype and market overreaction, unless you increase the value of your project within a day, the price on the exchange will not rise further. If the price does not rise, it will fall. A certain number of people (short-term traders) will sell it in exchange for coins that rise faster. This selling will cause the price to fall, and when the price falls, more people (uncertain people) will also sell, causing a spiral decline.


Now, people are losing money on your currency. Some will complain and speak ill of you, calling you a scam and spreading their conspiracy theories on various social channels that you cannot even monitor. Your reputation has been damaged and you have to spend all your energy managing negative PR instead of writing code.


Due to the negative news impact, your new user acquisition rate has decreased. Recruitment has also become extremely difficult. People in the office have started arguing about where the problem lies and blaming each other. If this continues...


You also have to immediately take on the responsibility of increasing the project's valuation from 200 million US dollars to 400 million US dollars, which is not an easy task for most new projects.


Another option


Now let's compare this to another scenario. Suppose your project is currently valued at $200 million (or any value you believe), but you set the ICO valuation at $30 million and sell 50% for $15 million. (These were the actual numbers for Binance during their ICO. I think, from our commitment, this is a very good number from any perspective).


But you might say, "Holy crap, this is so stupid. I lost 85 million dollars in ICO funding and valuation." If you think this way, please keep reading.


Of course, now due to the undervaluation, everyone wants a piece of your ICO. It has been fully oversubscribed. Everyone is asking for more allocation from you, but you say, "Sorry buddy, you have to buy later on the exchange."


Your ICO is completed within 38 seconds (the real record of the last ICO on Binance). One day later, your coin starts trading and people flock to it. No one wants to sell, and the price soars. More traders are attracted to you than to other coins.


Now, you have become a hot topic. Everyone is discussing your project, making YouTube videos and analyzing how good your coin is. With these free positive reports, the speed at which users register for your service is beyond your imagination. In about a month, you have entered the top ten in the world rankings. With the growth of users, your project is now worth $300 million, and your 49% stake is worth $150 million.


Now, most of your investors have made a lot of money, with a 10x increase in just 2 months. You have a user base, product, and positive community support, and are ready to grow at an even faster pace. Over time, you can gradually sell your shares at a valuation of $300 million or higher.


Of course, if you still feel stingy, you can also adjust/reduce the ICO ratio by 50%. But I strongly recommend an ICO ratio of 50% or higher. The whole point of an ICO is to make money with your investors and build momentum together!


From the perspective of exchanges, there is one simple mathematical problem to consider. If your coin has a circulation of $30 million, with 80% held by long-term holders, you only need to attract buyers with an additional $12 million in funds to double your valuation. If your project has a circulating supply of $300 million, then you need to attract $120 million. Looking at the trading volume of the top ten exchanges currently, it is easy to see that squeezing out $12 million from other coins is easy, while $120 million requires some effort.


Therefore, if you can prove that your coin can bring in $120 million in new funds and users to our exchange, we would be happy to list it. Otherwise, we will have to carefully consider whether to list your $300 million market value coin, especially if it is a new coin with no trading history.


Last night, when I explained these issues in detail, there was a feeling of "Oh, that makes sense, I didn't think of it that way" in the room. I think I successfully shifted the mindset of most people present from "big and comprehensive ICOs" to "long-term growth". I hope I can do the same, which will make it easier for us to list your token.


Original Link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit