Original author: Peter (@pet3rpan_)
Original translation: Deep Tide TechFlow
Creating a sustainable token network involves multiple aspects and requires coordination and operation among participants. However, as most founders are only proficient in technical aspects, it is difficult to achieve this coordination and operation, resulting in the sustainability of the token network being affected. In this article, 1kx partner Peter 'pet3rpan' will focus on these issues and provide some solutions to address them.
The operation of most token networks can be summarized into three main aspects:
Generate supply; create demand; allocate resources.
Network construction is difficult. Every network needs to solve the same problems. Here are some observations and thoughts to address these issues:

We can model most token networks as markets composed of participants (supply and demand) who coordinate to produce the final market, which cannot be achieved by an individual alone, whether it is a product, service, economy, or platform (serving suppliers and consumers).
Most problems arise from a lack of practical experience in how decentralized participant networks can coordinate on a large scale. This is a skill that most founders typically do not focus on too much in the early stages (instead focusing more on product development).
The network needs better or cheaper supply than alternatives to generate demand. Without demand or incentives to participate, supply will not appear. You need to incentivize and spend based on guiding such a network.
Most problems can be debugged from this perspective, and most of the key challenges in network construction also arise in these areas:
1. Don't be too naive about the coordination of the network;
2. Poor resource allocation and governance control;
3. Unsustainable network participation fit.
Product development and network construction are fundamentally different fields. Many founders are skilled in technology, but few are skilled in network coordination, which requires a shift in mindset.
Before decentralization, centralized companies were usually responsible for generating most of the supply and demand for projects. However, when you launch a network, it is the participants who drive the supply and demand from that point forward, not the core team.
Many teams launch tokens with the mentality of "build a network, issue tokens, and users will come", without actually considering how to utilize their network to grow in a more scalable way that the team cannot achieve.
Many teams' token incentive models ultimately do not meaningfully expand network growth - well...because they have never seriously considered how to encourage network participants to contribute to network goals.
Therefore, they spend funds on poorly designed participation plans, which often leads to certain growth in supply or demand due to token incentives, but the overall unit economics is unsustainable.
In many cases, the growth efficiency is much lower and the value unit is negative compared to every dollar spent on centralized teams. TLDR; It is best to stay centralized.
The team needs to consider how to properly coordinate network participants before launching tokens and launching the network.
This means that a coordination framework needs to be implemented, which can replace the work of labor force generated by supply or demand previously driven by the core team.
Whether it is through human-based coordination or engineering programmatic methods to replace the work and processes of the core team to motivate contributions, it takes a long time to effectively establish such a participant network.
There are too many teams that are too naive, thinking that launching a token is the ultimate goal, when in fact it is only the beginning. In fact, at the moment you launch the token - you have just opened the faucet of funds that quickly flow out of your network.
Suddenly, you encounter a funding problem that needs to be solved within a few months, and you are trying to build a solution that actually takes at least 2 years to properly cultivate. This ultimately leads to network losses, inability to grow, and inability to gain market share.
If there is no operational framework to explain how token holders should make decisions and spend money, most networks will irresponsibly continue to produce, causing the purchasing power of tokens to decline over time.
In an ideal scenario, every token or capital spent at a rate of 1 USD/eth would result in an increase of one unit in supply or demand. We should measure the output of our expenses and ideally increase it over time.
In many DAOs, annual budgets are established for different functional departments' expenses - in my opinion, this is a terrible way of capital expenditure, and we don't need to market just for the sake of marketing.
We should support growth, not just work for the sake of working.
Only when you start measuring output can you identify and eliminate incompetence within the contributor network. This is a popular disease that has already affected most DAOs, with the worst being decisions made through political means rather than objective ones.
When there are token rewards or subsidies for participants, it is easy to mistake network participation in this situation for a truly sustainable supply/demand.
Although token incentives are very powerful in guiding initial participation or as a means of long-term retention for participants in the encryption industry, they often give the network a sense of security that they have established a sustainable network - especially during a bull market, which is incorrect.
Network participation fit: refers to the natural economic incentives for participants to join the network without any subsidies or incentives when the network is created.
What does it look like? It may resemble a community-operated NFT loan underwriter DAO that brings together knowledge, capital, and strategy to generate profits on NFT lending platforms.
It may look like KRPDM, an art collection DAO, driving art collection trading volume on fxhash, while generating profits by collecting and selling its own works. Or like Ribbon Finance's insurance vault, bringing trading volume to Opyn's options protocol.
All of the key points of these relationships revolve around a symbiotic relationship between participants and the network itself, where each person has a natural economic incentive to participate in the network/protocol.
Original Link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia