header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Let’s start with the OP’s “upper and lower houses”: one coin one vote, one person one vote, and a combination of the two

Read this article in 6 Minutes
A new way out for "on-chain governance".
Original source: @0xTodd, Partner of Nothing Research  


To be honest, the OP governance mechanism is becoming more and more attractive to me. It’s not that there is a bullish vibe, but it is very similar to what I have been thinking about recently.


In the past, there were only two routes for "on-chain governance":


1. One coin, one vote (with Ve or coin age)

2. One person, one vote (public chain BFT node or some PFP)

OP once again proposed route 3, which is its OP Collective, which combines 1 and 2.

 

OP This new system is a design of "upper and lower houses".


Originally, OP was a user who delegated his vote to a representative. This part is the traditional "one coin, one vote". Whoever has a large number of node stakes + votes has greater power. Many DeFi protocols are similar.


In OP's new plan, the idea is to add one person, one vote on the basis of the original one coin, one vote.


OP likes a concept called public good. The traditional one coin, one vote is sometimes difficult to achieve. The purpose of the whale is often difficult to describe. The short-sighted behavior of sacrificing long-term interests for the sake of currency price increases is not excessive. There are more serious ones, such as Luna's attempt to manipulate Curve.


Let's talk about the problem of one coin, one vote first.


I think that the issue of Token governance not only comes from the projection of the real world, but also originates from the consensus of the public chain in the early years. In the early days, various chains attached so much importance to how to "reach a consensus" that they spent a lot of energy on consensus design. Participants in the 17-year market should have a deep impression.


In this round of 21 years, the competition for consensus has come to an end, and basically only PoW, PoS and BFT are left. Then, the PoS mechanism of voting by coin has been inherited by DeFi due to its low threshold and relatively decentralized nature. Of course, projects like Curve have also created the VE idea, which is also an extension of PoS.


However, the public chain has a single business, so voting by coin is fine; but when it comes to DeFi, its business is too diverse, so simple PoS is no longer effective. To give an inappropriate example, LFG once controlled a large number of CRV/CVX votes, and the UST pool is about to receive a huge amount of CRV rewards. If it survives that crash, more LPs who are unaware of the truth will be coaxed into the so-called new 4pool (high rewards), then Luna’s victims will at least double.


Although OP is also a chain, its consensus layer is actually ETH L1, which does not need consensus itself, so its governance should refer to DeFi, and it cannot be hijacked by scammers.

Having talked about the issue of one coin, one vote, let’s talk about one person, one vote next.


This problem was actually discussed by Satoshi Nakamoto at the earliest. If in a purely distributed system, 1 person 1 vote is too easy to be attacked by witches. Many friends on Twitter are particularly keen on airdrops, and should be familiar with this term.


 

OP is also a master of anti-witch. Therefore, OP's "one person one vote" is actually an elite one person one vote system, and a "90-member committee" will be formed. This is the second time OP has done this. The first time was to form a 22-member committee. This time, the 90 people are 14 people from the old committee + 14 newcomers nominated by the 14 people + developers using OP Stack + community + official appointments to form a new committee.


What are the backgrounds of the 14 members of the old committee? I did a quick DD. There are science fiction writers, founders of DeFi projects on OP, official members of OP, artists, Gitcoin and Paradiam Core, community KOLs. In short, it seems that the diversity is quite good.


As we all know, OP has a huge amount of unlocked tokens and a huge FDV (which is also a reason that prevents me from holding more hhh). How are these tokens distributed?


A large part of them will be allocated to projects within the ecosystem. Isn’t it very similar to Curve, but the task of dividing the money is given to the 22 members of the old committee.


These committee members gave a round of points to projects such as EtherJSJ, and finally allocated $1 million in rewards to these projects based on the weighted results of 22 people.


 

The tricky point is that there is a mismatch between personal interests and project interests. If you let the OP's vote representatives vote, the money will probably be distributed to the projects with the best relationships.


Then you may ask, will the committee members not vote? Of course it is possible, but it is undoubtedly a relief. Voting is based on money, while elite representatives are based on reputation. It is difficult to get a seat, so they often cherish their feathers more.


Especially when the number of seats on this committee continues to expand, its fault tolerance will increase. Therefore, this time, OP started the second round of money-sharing plan (Retro2), so it is reasonable to introduce a 90-member committee. Of course, this system is definitely not perfect, and no system is perfect. Each system is a better solution to the current problem and an improvement on the previous system, and there are new problems after the improvement.


If it is applied to the modern political system, such as the political system of the United States. The US Congress is the House of Representatives + the Senate. The House of Representatives directly allocates quotas to each state according to population, and only works for 2 years, similar to civilian representatives. The House of Representatives is more like the Senate, with only 2 people in each state, who can work for 6 years and are more elite.


Of course, let's assume that the United States also has a virtual "Money House", such as Wall Street, which represents money. I am not a proponent of conspiracy theories, but there is no doubt that capital is implicitly driving American politics.


Many current projects have turned this into a popular school of thought and a criterion, relying solely on this virtual "Money House" to resolve proposals, which is certainly not a good solution.


OP introduced elite representatives this time, allowing its "Senate" and "Money House" to merge their work and check and balance each other, which seems to be a good attempt.


And I personally have a feeling that OP particularly likes the "golden mean", and the OP Stack that I analyzed for you before also has this idea, a highly unified and highly customized compromise, or fusion innovation, which makes people feel less extreme and very gentle.


This kind of moderate philosophy really makes me more and more optimistic about OP (NFA).


Original link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit