header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

OpenSea's on-chain royalty tools are controversial, is it a monopoly in the name of royalties?

Read this article in 8 Minutes
Recently, some project parties have begun to use the forced royalty collection tool launched by OpenSea. After a huge gap in user product experience in the NFT community, extensive discussions on OpenSea's behavior have begun.

Original title: "Opensea's on-chain royalty tool sparks controversy, monopoly in the name of royalty"

Original source: Wuhai, PANews

On November 6, 2022, OpenSea announced that it will launch an on-chain enforcement royalty tool . Because it was only proposed at that time, the market did not have any response. As some project parties have recently begun to use the forced royalty collection tool launched by Opensea, after a huge gap in the product experience of users in the NFT community, extensive discussions on this behavior of Opensea have begun.  


The Opensea chain-enforced royalty tool stipulates that if the NFT project party wants to collect royalties normally on OpenSea, it must use OpenSea’s mandatory royalty contract, but This contract will block all platforms that launch custom royalties. If the NFT project party is unwilling to block other trading platforms, OpenSea officials will directly reduce all royalties generated by the project party on OpenSea to 0.


For example, the NFT Valentine series recently released by mobile game developer Homa, which has completed a financing of 165 million US dollars, was first launched on the trading market. For pending order transactions, buyers can also freely set royalties. But then OpenSea banned the contracts of other trading platforms, making it impossible for users to trade and place orders on other platforms. Therefore, Homa holders will reduce the price of Homa collections that have been listed on other platforms to 0 before being banned, silently resisting OpenSea's mandatory ban.



Why did OpenSea launch a royalty enforcement tool?   


Becoming a standard maker in the NFT field  


NFT Royalty It can be written at the code level, and the engineer can directly include the royalties into the transferFrom() function of the NFT. But this will make any transaction of NFT collections have to pay royalties. For example, you need to pay royalties when you transfer your NFT from one wallet to another, or give it to others. Therefore, the current NFT trading platform has been using its own off-chain system to track and pay royalties. The methods between platforms are not interoperable or unified, and there is no royalty standard.


But around royalties, some trading platforms began to make fuss. Since X2Y2 launched custom royalties, LooksRare no longer supports creator royalties but shares 25% of the income of the agreement with creators. SudoSwap adopts a zero-royalty strategy, and after Blur for professional users is officially launched, it also supports traders to customize royalties. In-depth users in the NFT community feel that there is no need to open OpenSea to trade. OpenSea's market share has gradually decreased from the previous dominance. According to data from NFTGo, a one-stop NFT analysis platform, OpenSea’s 30-day transaction volume accounted for 44.8% of the NFT market.



face With the threat of growing user groups and transaction volume in other trading markets, OpenSea hopes to launch mandatory royalties on the chain, using its current position that still occupies the main transaction volume in the market to force NFT project parties and creators to make choices. In order to obtain royalties, the project party has to choose Opensea's on-chain royalty tool and block other custom royalty platforms.


First-rate companies make standards, second-rate companies make brands, and third-rate companies make products. If things go on like this, OpenSea will have a new round of voice in the NFT field and become a company that sets standards for the industry.


Using the name of royalties to monopolize selfishness  


According to the official information of OpenSea , which hopes to invite more creators to enter the NFT field, and first implemented off-chain royalties. When other platforms launched custom royalties, OpenSea observed that the royalty payment rate was reduced to 20%, which could not support the creative motivation of creators, nor could creators control their royalty income off-chain.


OpenSea hopes to balance by giving creators more rights and equipping creators with the tools to control their business models, so it changes off-chain royalties to on-chain on royalties.


At first glance, OpenSea seems to be making changes for the development of the industry, but in the eyes of many project parties and community users, this is actually a The selfishness of fame monopoly. As mentioned above, if the project party or creator wants to use Opensea’s on-chain mandatory royalty tool, they must agree to OpenSea’s blocking of other trading platforms. The behavior of OpenSea is very similar to the behavior of e-commerce before Double Eleven that allows merchants to choose one of the two. And this kind of behavior is completely centralized, without any scruples about the open source spirit of Web3.


OpenSea keeps saying that the logic of simply serving NFT project parties or creators to control the business model is untenable, because the community agrees that Opensea's move is Because of the monopoly measures made after being threatened by the peers' first-class products and first-class services.


What is the impact of OpenSea's mandatory royalty tool?   


Other trading platforms have no choice but to compromise  


As mentioned above It is said that OpenSea's market share continues to decrease, but it still occupies the main market and the right to speak. NFT project parties and creators choose to stand in line with OpenSea, which reduces the asset targets of other NFT platforms. According to the data of NFTGO, a one-stop NFT analysis platform, since the launch of the mandatory royalty tool on the OpenSea chain, the daily transaction volume of the X2Y2 platform, which first launched custom royalties, has dropped from 1974ETH (data on November 1st) to the current 900ETH (data on November 19th). ).


As a result, other trading platforms have also compromised to the current market feedback one after another. X2Y2 officially tweeted that it was thought that the best way to deal with royalties was to give both creators and traders the right to choose. This is the rationale behind X2Y2’s custom royalty function. Since OpenSea released OperatorFilter (an on-chain royalty enforcement tool), most new projects support it. "Code is law", X2Y2 respects the law. X2Y2 removed the "custom royalty" setting for all newly listed NFTs using OperatorFilter.


Market liquidity has shrunk even further  


A summary of PANews experience in August Fees, royalties, platform features, etc. of existing mainstream NFT trading platforms. From the summary results, we can see that the transaction fee of Zora is 0, the transaction fee of X2Y2 and SudoSwap is 0.5%, and the other NFT trading platforms range from 2-10%, plus the 5-10% set by most current NFT project parties and creators. Royalties, the additional cost for users to transact a spend can be as high as 7-20%.   



Such a high transaction friction greatly reduces the user's transaction willingness and frequency. When the transaction willingness and frequency are greatly reduced, how can the NFT project party obtain more royalties. Moreover, the transaction frequency is also a process of community consensus exchange and expansion. In the long run, such high transaction costs are not conducive to the expansion of the NFT market from scenarios and users, to the precipitation of consensus and value, and are contrary to the overall vigorous development of the market.


It can be expected that one of the future development directions of the NFT trading market is to reduce user transaction costs. One is that the market evolution has forced the platform to reduce the handling fee. For example, platforms such as OpenSea charge users as much as 2.5% of the handling fee. One is the reduction of royalties for NFT collections. At present, most project parties set a royalty of about 10%, which makes many project parties extremely dependent on the path. PANews has written and compiled articles about NFT project parties and creators amplifying profitability by expanding business models and making the cake bigger.


Innovation in the NFT market will be suppressed  


< p>Before, OpenSea has been occupying user awareness because of its first-mover advantage, but the product has almost no optimization, which makes the NFT user experience poor. Later, other NFT trading platforms gradually occupied a certain market share through operation and improvement of product experience, and now NFT aggregation platforms have also won the favor of the market by integrating market liquidity.


Now, OpenSea has launched another monopoly tool to make NFT project parties and platforms compromise. This move will suppress the market's innovation and desire for innovation. When entrepreneurs who want to build better products for the NFT market enter the game, entrepreneurs will think about whether companies like OpenSea will be able to do so when the products they build have a climate. The crackdown is against the spirit of the industry, so that the NFT market cannot flourish.


As the X2Y2 official said, going online to force royalties is a simple decision and behavior. It has been less than two years since the NFT market really exploded, and too many tools and functions need to be built for the NFT space. But how much confidence does the industry have in innovation?


In this regard, dashuo, the founder of CreatorDAO, an NFT secondary creation community, said that the whitelist system will hinder innovation, and it will be difficult for new trading platforms to come out in the future. Because the filter of the on-chain mandatory royalty tool is completely controlled by OpenSea itself, OpenSea can completely block competitors for any other reason (politics, copyright protection, discrimination, etc.) in the future. The forced compromise of innovative platforms such as X2Y2 and Blur is just the beginning. Innovation will become more and more difficult in the future. When innovation is exhausted, the entire NFT field will enter a vicious circle.


Moreover, when the filter is controlled by OpenSea itself, once it is used and done evil, it can cause great harm. We have seen the consequences of eating the forbidden fruit.


Original link

a>


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit