header-langage
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Tiếng Việt
Scan to Download the APP
Partnered With:

Bitcoin protocol comparison: Counterparty vs RGB/Taro

Read this article in 10 Minutes
Compare Counterparty with these new Bitcoin 2.0 Token protocols, what are they new?
Original title: "Counterparty vs. RGB and Taro"
Original author: Mandel duck


I recently attended an antique NFT festival (Historical NFT festival). What is an "antique NFT"? Simply put, it is an NFT that appeared before NFT became popular culture. At this event, the Counterparty protocol seemed to be in focus, probably because it was actually the first NFT platform on Bitcoin, dating back to 2014 (there were other protocols before it, but Counterparty was the first to be used To mint what we now call NFT works of art instead of finance Token agreement).


Fast forward to 2022, and two new protocols have appeared on the Bitcoin network, called "RGB" and "Taro" (both somewhat resemblance).


RGB and Taro are largely the same thing (TRAO used to use the name "CMYK", which is a play on RGB), and they are also Not my area of expertise, so I won't compare the two in too much detail. Instead, I want to compare Counterparty with these new Bitcoin 2.0 Token Protocols, what's so new about them?


Counterparty Summary


Counterparty launched in 2014 with other Token Protocols such as Coloredcoin and Mastercoin (now called "omni"). Colored coins appear to be designed to "put a share of gold on the blockchain Token created". Mastercoin is very commercial, and it is very difficult to use without the help of the company behind Mastercoin. Counterparty was launched as an open standard, and it's an easy-to-use wallet that everyone can nurture, allowing it to be adopted by the community in casual Bitcoin.


Counterparty's founders designed it with financial services in mind, for example, you can use Token To represent the equity of a company, however, there are many legal issues and collateral effects, so in the end they abandoned this project and established a more commercial organization (symbiont.io). This put Counterparty in the hands of the community, who started using it for "community projects" like RAREPEPE, art collectibles, and more.


How does Counterparty work?


< p>Dyeing currency will track UTXO (Translator's Note: The original text is "Satoshi", which is the smallest unit of Bitcoin, and Bitcoin exists in the form of UTXO). Counterparty is different, it is an a data layer.


Another way of explaining: dyed coins mean "this bitcoin (UTXO) represents a certain gold bar"; if Alice wants this gold bar To transfer to Bob, just send the bitcoins to Bob (technically not that simple, but for a medium post, this is enough).


However, if you want to buy a cup of coffee and accidentally send bitcoins representing gold bars to Charlie the barista, then Charlie will get the gold (At least Bitcoin, which represents some gold).


This means that you have to be very careful when using dyed coins, because you can easily accidentally put Token Send it to a recipient who never had such an expectation, and even TA may not see that the money has other value, and cannot transfer it back to you.


Conversely, in Counterparty you have to forfeit a special Counterparty transaction in order to transfer Token ownership of. The Counterparty node will analyze the data of this transaction outside the chain, and then update a ledger/database placed in the Counterparty node.


This is done using OP_RETURN , which is a way to store arbitrary data in a bitcoin transaction (thus making it possible to put data into the bitcoin blockchain) Methods.


The loaded OP_RETURN data needs to indicate this:


Send 1 RAREPEPE to address X


You need to put this OP_RETURN into a bitcoin transaction, as long as you use the current holding RAREPEPE Token The private key of the address to sign the transaction, Token will transfer to the new address specified by the OP_RETURN data.


One advantage of using OP_RETURN is that full nodes that are not interested in the Counterparty protocol neither need to store nor verify these data, and can transfer these data from node is deleted.


Why create RGB/Taro if we already have Counterparty?


Good question. Because from today, Counterparty seems to have more features than RGB and Taro, and it has been running since 2014. So why do we need to make new protocols?


I think there may be several reasons why developers tend to make a new protocol from scratch rather than build on an existing protocol.


Motivation


I think a big reason is that these developers just want Create your own project, have your own "children". People are always more motivated to develop their own ideas than to maintain and enhance existing projects.


Technology


From scratch, you can use the latest learning outcomes and technologies; Inserting new paradigms into existing code can be cumbersome. Many developers who saw the Counterparty code thought it was bad. Especially in light of today's standards and new technologies in cryptography.


Scalability


Because RGB/Taro uses client-side authentication technology (below we will explanation), which is inherently easier to scale because not every user needs to store all Token the entire history of .


Ignorance


Many developers either don't know about Counterparty or think the project is dead .


Counterparty Token


I think this is also an important factor. Bitcoin enthusiasts basically dislike developing a set of their own Token The protocol, and the Counterparty protocol, is called "XCP". I feel Token The release stained the project forever, and in hindsight it would have been better not to have released it Token .


However, I also want to say that this Token unlike other protocols Token , because


a) you don't need it


you only need to use BTC You can make Counterparty transactions, issue assets, and use decentralized trading platforms, regardless of XCP


b) It is issued fairly


Unlike other protocols that have held ICOs and finally made the founders rich, XCP is distributed through  burn proof , which means that you can only get XCP by burning bitcoins . This means that founders can only burn their own coins to get XCP, so they cannot get rich by pre-issuing.


What is XCP good for?


Although you don't need to have XCP to use Counterparty, you will need it if you want to issue assets with custom names. Counterparty property names are unique, similar to URLs (website domain names), so you have the same problem as domain squatting, where someone buys a domain with a buzzword in it ahead of time.


In Counterparty, to mitigate this, you must hold XCP to issue assets under custom names, such as SATOSHI coins and FREEDOM coins.


Another scenario that requires a small amount of XCP is using Counterparty DeX (Decentralized Exchange). DeX allows peer-to-peer, non-custodial transactions of Counterparty assets, meaning, I can place a sell order, propose to use 1 RAREPEPE to exchange 1 SATOSHICARD, and then broadcast this order to the Bitcoin network, if someone places a sell order, use 1SATOSHICARD Exchange 1 RAREPEPE, the two order orders are automatically matched, and the assets are transferred.


So if a user just wants to take a Token exchange for another Token , there is no need to use XCP. However, when assets are not exchanged directly, but bought and sold through a more liquid currency, transactions are smoother. Ideally, BTC should be used, but technically speaking, it is impossible, because there is no Bitcoin in the Counterparty protocol, only Counterparty assets, so everyone's idea is that you can sell the assets into XCP, and then go to the trading platform Sell XCP for BTC. (Ultimately, the underlying asset is PEPECASE, not XCP!)


How is RGB/Taro better than Counterparty?


Except because RGB/Taro doesn't have its own Token Therefore, in addition to giving people a more "clean" impression, there are many technological innovations that make RGB/Taro stand out.


In my opinion, the biggest technical advantage is the way they store data.


As mentioned earlier, Counterparty uses the OP_RETURN output to store Counterparty messages on the Bitcoin blockchain that can update its ledger/state. Because it uses OP_RETURN, regular Bitcoin nodes neither need to parse nor store this data; however, if you are a Counterparty node, you have to store a large ledger containing the state of all Counterparty transactions.


And RGB/Taro uses client-side authentication.


This means that the ledger or the state of the network is not stored on the Bitcoin blockchain, but each user who needs to store these data puts the data stored in its own database.


A hash/proof of this data will be stored on the Bitcoin blockchain; and, through the skillful use of Merkle trees, you only Need to store what you want to interact with Token The data.


For example, in Counterparty, I am Alice, I want to send 1 RAREPEPE to Bob, and then Charlie wants to send 1 SATOSHICARD to Daid, I have to store Charlie and records of the status of the Davids, even though they have absolutely nothing to do with my transactions. Charlie and David can also see the transaction I sent to Bob, so it will be less private.


And in RGB/Taro, I can ignore all the data related to the Charlie-David transaction. If David later sends me (Alice) the SATOSHICARD, I can store and verify the data at that time.


Ultimately what makes RGB/Taro more private is that third parties will not be able to know the contents of my transactions unless I proactively expose them. It also means I can store less data. This hash/evidence is indistinguishable from a regular bitcoin signature included in a tapscript (taproot script), so RGB/Taro transactions look just like regular bitcoin transactions. Counterparty transactions are transparent because they use OP_RETURN and thus can be (and were) censored by nodes and miners.


(Note: It seems that RGB also allows you to use OP_RETURN (not tapscript) to store hash values, however, it is a generic hash value , indistinguishable from other hash-based OP_RETURN protocols such as opentimestamps.)


RGB/Taro is a new project (with venture capital backing ) may also incentivize and fund more developers to develop the protocol, ultimately creating better tools, smoother wallets, etc.


Many companies that started to fund and develop Counterparty from 2014 later went bankrupt, or migrated to other chains (such as Ethereum), so that the development speed becomes faster Slow growth, because the entire ecology relies heavily on donations from the community.


(However, after the explosion of NFT in 2012, a lot of funds were recovered for the development of Counterparty, and many developers became "full-time" developers of the project , and some new companies have joined in)


What is Counterparty better than RGB/Taro?


One downside of RGB/Taro's client-side authentication feature is that if I lose my data and no one else has a backup , then I can no longer initiate transactions, so I actually lose my assets.


In Counterparty, the state can be re-parsed and calculated from the Bitcoin blockchain at any time.


Subjectively speaking, I also think that the unique property of asset names makes Counterparty more suitable for "collectibles/NFT".


In terms of functionality, Counterparty is also ahead of RGB/Taro, which allows users to issue assets, transfer assets, receive assets, and trade on decentralized trading platforms , dividends, batch sending, creating vending machines, and more.


Counterparty also has a ready-made ecology, which the community has been developing for many years.


Where did RGB, Taro and Counterparty not do well?


In my personal opinion, the problem with all of these protocols is that they require on-chain transactions to transfer ownership of non-fungible and fungible assets. Technically, you can use a homogeneous Token (such as stable currency) to build a Lightning Network on them. However, when it comes to NFT, I don't think the useful scenarios people envision can be realized.


An example is gambling with NFT. Popular games execute thousands or even millions of transactions per second. If each transaction needs to initiate a bitcoin transaction on the chain, it will not be scalable at all, which will result in only a few users being able to play Play the game, but also pay a high fee. I witnessed something like this in 2017, when I played Counterparty, players had to pay a $10 fee for trading in-game items worth $1, and had to wait a few days to see the transaction confirmation.


In this regard, RGB and Taro have not changed much, RGB supports batch transactions (Counterparty can too). But I hope these protocols find a better place to live on the Bitcoin sidechain projects that may appear in the future.


Original link


Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia

举报 Correction/Report
Choose Library
Add Library
Cancel
Finish
Add Library
Visible to myself only
Public
Save
Correction/Report
Submit