Original title: "Token Value Accrual"
Original source: Vader Research
Original compilation: Kxp, BlockBeats

The basic business is in the growth stage and continues to generate income. Now we need Questions to consider include—how should we create value for the Token entity, so that Token holders can share the existing or future benefits of related businesses? And, what are the different value accumulation mechanisms we can use, and what are their pros and cons?
We will answer all these questions in this article. At Vader Research, we have a three-step method for token value accumulation:
Step 1: Clear the Token inflow channel
Step 2: Determine Token Inflow Payment Currency
Step 3: Develop a Value Accumulation Mechanism
The main content of this article includes:
·Value and Value Creation
·Step 1: Clear Token Inflow Channel
· Step 2: Determine the payment currency for Token inflow
· Step 3: Develop a value accumulation mechanism
· The correct timing for value accumulation
p>
We have already talked about value accumulation in the previous article on the distribution of the Token upper limit table, which includes both existing value and future value.
In other words, when assets flow into the ecosystem, value is created. These inflows can be in any currency (Stablecoins, L1 blockchains, native tokens) and can accrue to the protocol 100% (main NFT sales, upgrade fees, etc.) or after deducting a percentage of royalty fees.
For example, Crypto Vnicorns sold 100 primary NFTs for $1 million. Assuming all proceeds from the transaction go to the token entity, the token entity will generate $1 million worth of inflows regardless of the currency used in the sale (could be USDC, ETH, or the native Crypto Vnicorns Token).
For example, Gambler A buys $100,000 worth of Gigidaiku NFT from Gambler B , Gigidaiku creator Kimit Break charges a 10% royalty fee on all secondary transactions. Assuming all proceeds from the transaction go to the equity entity, Kimit Break will generate $10,000 worth of inflows regardless of the currency used in the sale.
As to whether these asset inflows should be recognized as income (subject to the time period in which the value is generated or the payment Currency impact) is an issue that accountants need to consider. We should focus on how to design a sustainable NFT economy, how to effectively allocate resources, and how to evaluate business decisions.
In actual operation, the inflow of cash and the recognition of income are often two concepts. For example, if Adam pays Netflix an annual fee of $120, Netflix needs to recognize $10 of actual revenue per month, and that $120 is the first month's cash inflow. Additionally, payments in the protocol's native currency may not be recognized as revenue.
For modeling purposes, we prefer to use inflows rather than income, Because inflows are closer to traditional accounting cash flow inflows (cash flow statement) than income (income statement). However, we will also include non-Stablecoin capital flows, such as non-Stablecoin inflows and native Token or non-native currency (NFT, etc.) outflows, into the adjusted inflow statement.
The traditional three financial statements, valuation method (DCF), key performance indicators (retention rate, DAU, LTV, CAC) are not directly applicable to web3. They are only adjusted to more accurately reflect the financial health and performance of the web3 protocol. At Vader Research, we've been working on proprietary reports and metrics to better illustrate value creation and accumulation.
p>
We have explained the inflow of Token above, now let us look at some common inflow channels and examples in web3. In the game, the channels of capital inflow mainly include:
In-game characters, items/weapons or One-time NFT sales of land
· Ongoing primary NFT sales (cultivation/minting/crafting).
·Upgrade/Repair/Energy Fee
·Battle Pass
·Stake/Tournament Buy-In
Although the game gives players a sense of control by allowing them to "cast" or "cultivate" NFTs, the actual price is still Set by the developer (or DAO), all funds also flow directly to the protocol. Some of these NFTs are permanent NFTs, while others are consumable NFTs. Consumable NFTs are likely to experience frequent sales, generating more sustainable and recurring inflows.
Axie Infinity:
1. Primary NFT sales
2. Primary land transfer
3. Cultivation fee, which is considered a continuous primary NFT sale. The breeding fee is the upper limit of the NFT price, so as long as the NFT price in the secondary market is higher than the breeding fee, anyone has an arbitrage opportunity and can breed/mint new NFT
4. Royalty Fee - Level 2 Market Transaction Fee
Skyweaver:
1. Challenge entry fee
2. Royalty fee
3. Primary non-card NFT sales (hero skin, etc.)
Splinterlands:
1. Junior card NFT loot box sales
2. Card NFT upgrade fee
3. Royalty fee
4. Tournament organizer fee
p>
STEPN:
1. Primary NFT Sales
2. Minting fee
3. Maintenance/upgrade fee
4. Royalty fee
Ethereum:
1. On-chain transaction gas fee
< /p>
We should define one or more payment currencies for each inflow channel, i.e. the end user can choose one currency among all options, or only one choice. The decision-making process should consider end-user experience, diversification of capital inflows, accumulation of value, and legal/regulatory issues.
There are currently three common payment currency options:
1.Stablecoin (USDC, USDT, USD, EUR, etc.)
For end users, Stablecoin is the most convenient choice, because users do not need to deal with additional friction points (friction point) when using Stablecoin, such as they do not need to Exchange Stablecoin for another currency on a decentralized or centralized exchange.
Additionally, the Moonpay Funding Tool enables end users to pay directly by credit card with no setup or connection required Metamask wallet. This is critical as a sizable percentage of users across the payment funnel drop out due to additional points of friction. The fewer points of friction, the lower the exit rate.
In other words, Stablecoin payments may cause legal problems, and regulations in some regions do not Players are encouraged to use Stablecoins for payment.
For users, the underlying blockchain Token is the second most convenient choice. Since users need to hold the underlying blockchain Token to pay the Gas fee for transactions on the chain, users generally keep at least a part of the Token. Additionally, most centralized exchanges allow users to deposit/withdraw blockchain currencies to non-custodial wallets such as Metamask.
Users can also choose to use the protocol's native currency, but additional friction points must be dealt with, so compared to For other tokens it is not so convenient. Still, it gives the token a concrete utility and increases user perception of token purchases (there is no scientific basis for this claim).
We can use one or two native tokens for payment, for example, the cultivation cost of Axie is AXS and SLP can be used to pay, so players must hold a sufficient amount of both Tokens to complete the transaction. Transactions related to the payment protocol using the native Token can make the Token truly have the property of "currency".
p>
After completing the previous two steps, we can now select the value accumulation mechanism. Keep in mind that not all capital inflows need to be accumulated in Token entities, and some developers instead want to accumulate value in equity entities, other Token entities, and various types of NFTs.

p>
Axie's cultivation costs are accumulated among multiple entities, and it has two main sources of funds: marketing costs and cultivation costs. All market fees are accumulated in the wallet address controlled by the AXS Token entity. X% of the cultivation fee is paid by SLP - accumulating value to the SLP Token entity; 1-X% of the cultivation fee is paid in AXS and accumulated to the wallet address controlled by the AXS Token entity.
Axie NFT owners can earn SLP through games, while Land NFT owners can Earn AXS. In other words, the value of SLP will be accumulated indirectly on Axie NFT, and the value of AXS will be accumulated indirectly on Land NFT. In addition, there are many other parameters, such as how much of the AXS pledge reward is reserved for Land NFT, how much the cultivation fee should be set, the respective proportions of SLP and AXS in the cultivation cost, and whether Axie NFT is a permanent asset .
Here are the value accumulation options for each incoming currency:
< br>
1. Stablecoin or blockchain Token capital inflow
A. Repurchase native Token
Token repurchase Much like stock repurchases, token entities purchase native tokens from the open market through centralized or decentralized exchanges. As the supply of circulating tokens decreases, value will accrue to token holders in proportion.
The repurchase can be executed at fixed time intervals and ratios, such as taking out Stablecoin inflows every month 70% of the original Token will be bought back. Alternatively, we can execute buybacks on an aperiod basis for more flexibility in asset management.
B. Distribution to usersStablecoin Or blockchain Token
The inflow of funds will be used for marketing/participation expenses, and then flow back into the economy through repurchase to Incentivize specific behaviors with the goal of driving growth, increasing retention, encouraging monetization, and creating long-term value. Unlike Scenario 1, in the short term, value will accrue to active protocol participants rather than token holders, which will bring greater benefits to token holders in the long run.
C. AssignStablecoin to Stakeholders (similar to dividends)
Staking rewards are very similar to dividends, the Token entity will airdrop Stablecoins or district tokens to Token holders Blockchain Token. Since Token holders will have more currency assets after receiving staking rewards, the value will be accumulated to the pledged Token holders in proportion. This model can also be further optimized, such as allocating a higher proportion of Tokens to Token holders who have pledged for a longer period of time.
We can combine the above approaches: execute a small Or blockchain Token rewards are distributed to users who are eligible for rewards due to protocol activity and native Token ownership, which may be an effective way to distribute rewards.
A. Burn the original Token
We can reduce the maximum supply of Tokens by permanently burning some of the Tokens in circulation. This link can be done automatically when funds come in, or at a fixed time every month/week, or at any time according to the decision of the developer/DAO. Due to the reduction in the maximum supply of tokens, the token value of all token holders has been accumulated.
B. Recycle native Token for users
p>
Inflows are used for marketing/engagement spend and then flowed back into the economy via buybacks to incentivize specific behaviors with the goal of boosting growth, improving retention, Encourage monetization and create long-term value. Unlike Scenario 1, in the short term, value will accrue to active protocol participants rather than token holders, which will bring greater benefits to token holders in the long run.
If cash incentives are provided in the form of native tokens to users with high loyalty and participation , then it may be a better reward currency than Stablecoin or Blockchain Token. Because in this mode, for those users who are willing to obtain native Tokens, they will not need to exchange native Tokens in centralized or decentralized exchanges, so that their native Token yields will be higher than those of non-native Tokens after exchange native Token yield.
Additional friction points when selling native tokens will reduce users’ willingness to sell native tokens, the same reason , the additional friction points when purchasing native tokens will also reduce users' willingness to purchase native tokens.
C. Issue native tokens as pledge rewards
Staking rewards are very similar to dividends. Token entities will airdrop Stablecoins or blockchain tokens to Token holders. Since Token holders will have more currency assets after receiving staking rewards, the value will be accumulated to the pledged Token holders in proportion.
D. Long-term holding of original Token
p>
Instead of burning tokens immediately or redistributing them to users/stakers, it is better to store tokens in a vault and make value accumulation decisions later. Burning native tokens can give retail investors more trust that there is a tangible and measurable token burning mechanism in the system than just holding native tokens in the vault.

< /p>
The listed company has generated income and accumulated After cash, these funds can be used in three ways:
1. Reinvest in growth/marketing/operations
2. Pay dividends to shareholders
3. Buy back stock
If management Believing that the business is mature enough and does not see any attractive opportunities for business investment, such as hiring new employees, establishing a new service line, or marketing a brand, management can distribute excess cash as dividends to shareholders.
Typically, early-stage or fast-growing startups do not offer their shareholders Instead of paying dividends, they would rather reinvest the proceeds back into the business through user incentives, subsidies, or marketing spend. Facebook was founded in 2004, became profitable in 2009, and went public in 2012, all while never paying a dividend. The same goes for Amazon, which was founded in 1994, went public in 1997, and became profitable in 2001. It has never paid a dividend in the past few years.

< /p>
Compared to established companies in the oil, gas or industrial sectors, these companies are still in a stage of rapid growth. Executives at Facebook and Amazon would rather use the excess cash to expand into new business areas than return it to shareholders, because the former would have a greater opportunity for value creation than the latter.
The timing of short-term Token value accumulation decisions, such as pledge rewards, repurchase of native Tokens or burning Tokens Etc. are all crucial. Token incentive rewards (whether native tokens or other currencies) are one of the channels for user acquisition and engagement. In addition, other strategies include: performance marketing, influencer marketing, tournaments, etc. Web2 startups typically hire a growth/marketing executive who tracks CAC and LTV metrics for each acquisition channel to determine the best marketing or reward distribution model.
For example:
· The cost of acquiring users through Facebook advertising is At $20 per user, the return is an LTV of $5.
· The cost of user acquisition through influencer marketing is $10 per user, and the return is an LTV of $12.
In this comparison, online celebrity marketing is definitely the best choice. The same method is also applicable to Token incentives, but the difference is that in addition to being used for user acquisition, it can also encourage participation and improve retention rates, so more care should be taken when designing Token incentive schemes.

Uber has designed a dynamic revenue incentive model for drivers-the pickup revenue in designated areas will be higher, and this This revenue model is constantly changing based on traffic conditions in the area, time of day, number of idle Uber cars, and existing/projected rider demand. With this approach, Uber hopes to minimize wait times, which often lead riders to use other apps instead.
Therefore, for early or even fast-growing Crypto start-up companies, burning Token or allocating Staking rewards may not even be an efficient resource allocation. In the previous article, we explored the reasons for extending the token lock-up period.
If Token incentives cannot bring long-term benefits to the protocol, then we should reduce the amount of Token incentives Scale, and convert Token into legal currency/Stablecoin for other marketing/participation/operation activities.
< /p>
Whenever assets flow into the ecosystem, value will be generated, and developers/ The task of DAO is to determine the cumulative value of tradable assets. The selection of the Token value accumulation mechanism will depend on whether the incoming funds belong to the native Token or other currencies. In addition, the timing of value accumulation is also very important.
Original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia