Original title: " Bankless: Why is it said that DeFi will never die? "
Original author: Donovan Choy, Bankless
Original Compilation: Jordan, PANews
The last few months have seen the crypto industry take a hit like never before: billion-dollar crypto Currency banks are facing bankruptcy crisis, the largest hedge fund is selling NFT to deal with liquidation, and centralized encryption institutions are facing collapse... But what is surprising is that after this storm, DeFi is still standing. This also reflects the value proposition that the encryption community has been promoting - to create an open, public, and accessible financial ecosystem that is open to the world.
Because of this, DeFi will never die.
To design a strong economic system, we must first recognize this complex real world and accept the instinct of human greed and ignorance. In addition, you also need to understand that the resilience of the economic system has nothing to do with the performance of the bull market, and mainly depends on the ability to adapt to market changes without the intervention of regulators or giants.
Secondly, to judge whether an economic system can be resilient enough in the financial market, the following questions are also crucial:
1. Can the system effectively clear bad debts?
2. For unsustainable business models, does the system choose to eliminate or support them?
3. Can the above two points be achieved before systemic risks accumulate to a certain level?
4. When systemic risks arise, can the problem be solved by minimizing active management and negative spillover?
In fact, compared with the centralized financial system, the decentralized financial system is more closely related to the above goals, because no matter from the protocol Token economic system From the design point of view, or from the perspective of daily financial management and the health of the balance sheet, everything in the DeFi system is on the blockchain, and it is open and transparent. Anyone can observe and monitor it in real time. Individuals can clearly understand the investment trends and potential risks of giant whales.
We often see mainstream media describe DeFi as the "Wild West in the financial sector", but this analogy is not appropriate because DeFi's self-regulatory mechanism In fact, it is very perfect—
With Lido Finance and Solend as an example:
Since Lido stakes nearly one-third of the total ETH Centralization threat. Therefore, Lido launched a governance proposal vote to decide whether to limit the amount of ETH deposited into the liquid pledge agreement. As a result, the self-limiting governance proposal failed and 8 new validators were added to further decentralize the Lido validator set.
As the largest lending protocol on the Solana chain, Solend faces a more urgent situation. It was found that if the price of SOL continued to fall, liquidating a whale's margin position ($170 million) would be catastrophic and have serious impacts on the entire chain. To this end, Solend developers put forward a series of governance proposals to the community, such as taking over the accounts of giant whales and performing safe liquidation, but the final solution is to introduce a new rule-limiting the amount of borrowing within 50 million US dollars (the giant Whale borrowed $108 million).
Of course, although Lido and Solend may not be able to get out of the predicament after adopting relevant governance, the governance process of these two platforms alone can already feel What makes DeFi unique.
Thanks to the transparency of blockchain rules and activities on the chain, a community composed of internal and external stakeholders has the same goal and works together to solve the problem . In the two cases mentioned above, community members followed up in time after discovering danger signs, and finally gave solutions after in-depth technical discussions to prevent problems before they happen.
Conversely, if people turn a blind eye to these risky choices, the system will inevitably be attacked maliciously, and the consequences will be disastrous. So is there a general solution to this kind of problem? In this regard, TradFi (traditional finance) replied: "The government will solve it through laws", and DeFi's answer is very cool: "Everything is determined by the code."
Compared to DeFi’s active self-help, it has fallen like dominoes in the past month The encryption bank under the Internet is much more passive. In fact, the center of this storm is the most important hedge fund in the encryption field——Three Arrows Capital, whose liquidity problem was exposed as early as mid-June. $400 million.
Soon, the liquidation incident of Three Arrows Capital revealed other high-risk shadow trading problems of encrypted banks: embezzlement of depositor funds, such as BlockFi providing to Three Arrows Capital Voyager Digital provided approximately $670 million in loans. Although Voyager Digital's capital ratio is relatively safe (the loan rate is only 4.3%), due to a wrong decision, it provided concentrated loans more than twice its total capital to Three Arrows Capital, which eventually led to it also being in trouble. dilemma.
Of course, risky transactions in the financial sector are everywhere, not just in encrypted banks. The key to the problem is how the system governs and deals with risks when they come.
Unlike the way DeFi handles risk, since the balance sheets of crypto banks are centralized, the community cannot conduct independent investigations, and crypto banks these excessive Leveraged and risky deals can only be known to the outside world when the paper can't hold fire, and by this stage, it's too late. The biggest problem with this kind of "centralized" encrypted bank is that most of the transactions are closed-door bilateral off-exchange transactions, only insiders can know, and they will only disclose information after a liquidity crisis occurs, because this is in Legally the only condition for getting money back.
If For an in-depth look at the comparative advantages of DeFi, look at how centralized players conduct decentralized exchanges.
Let's look at three examples -
The Celsius problem was exposed for the first time because they had signs of insolvency in a series of on-chain loans, such as a 17,900 WBTC in the Maker vault Celsius’s pledge transaction could not be repaid, Celsius rushed to replenish funds to avoid liquidation of the collateral due to the drop in Bitcoin price (the loan was fully repaid on July 7), and soon Celsius’s other loan problems followed, Including a pledge of 458,000 stETH on the Avalanche chain, as well as loan pledges on Compound and Oasis.
In the beginning, the CEO of Celsius vowed that there would be no problems, but since the transactions of Maker, Avalanche and Compound on the blockchain are open and transparent Therefore, encrypted users quickly discovered potential risks and began to warn the community. Sure enough, Celsius soon announced the suspension of currency withdrawals. Although the alarm bell sounded a little late, if there is no public information about DeFi, more people may suffer losses and the problem will last longer.
Actually, the disaster of Terra was originally caused by DeFi Transparency was discovered because Terra's liquidity was rapidly drying up on the Curve protocol, "The UST exchange rate came under pressure for the first time on Sunday, May 7th, mainly due to an 85 million USTw-3CRV Curve fund pool The exchange of USD UST to USDC ... This large transaction has further shaken the public's confidence in the liquidity providers of the fund pool, and people have quickly withdrawn their 3CRV, resulting in the fund pool UST: 3CRV falling to 77% on May 8 : 23%."
I believe everyone already knows the story after that.
Millions of Terra investors began to panic, Do Know tweeted the famous statement that "more UST will be deployed", and the center behind Terra The Luna Foundation Guard, a virtualized entity, began to transfer $1.5 billion worth of Bitcoin to stabilize its algorithm Stablecoin. All these operations were not based on smart contract rules. As a result, when the "flood" of Anchor poured out, Terra crashed.
As far as Three Arrows Capital is concerned, many analysts We all know that their balance sheet is not healthy, because the on-chain data clearly proves that they lost $560 million in LUNA lockups in May of this year, and then delisted their stETH positions in July. The mystery of 3AC's bankruptcy is not complete, but a few fragments are enough to allow us to speculate on what went wrong.
In the end, you will see that these centralized players are quickly approaching bankruptcy. Why do they go to bankruptcy? Because the high-risk and leveraged closed-door bilateral transactions between CeFi platforms can only be resolved through legal means, which is their only choice, and they may be able to win a better result for themselves in court. In contrast, DeFi will not have similar problems, because under the premise of openness and transparency, you cannot argue with smart contracts.
The above three examples all prove one point: Celsius, Terra, and Three Arrows Capital are not real DeFi on the chain, and we only know it before the night comes It is indeed difficult to completely avoid and prevent such crises, but if they are real DeFi, perhaps the tragedy will not happen.
Greed and stupidity may be human nature, just like the Scottish Enlightenment philosopher David Hume said that a truly resilient political and economic system should be based on basic facts of human nature. He said this:
“.Everyone should Considered a scoundrel, who has no purpose in all his actions but personal gain. We must govern him through this interest, and though he remains insatiable and ambitious, will seek cooperation for the common good. ”
The advantage of DeFi is actually to take advantage of human nature, and then design a ruthless smart contract around this nature. In DeFi, the code is the liquidator, and the code is the settlement engine. So you will find that Celsius, Terra, and Sanjian Capital have fallen, while major DeFi protocols such as Aave, Compound, and Maker are functioning well. For example, in June 2022, Compound, Aave, and Maker successfully completed the "9-digit ”, among which the liquidation amount of Compound is about 9.9 million U.S. dollars, the liquidation amount of Aave is about 2.6 million U.S. dollars, and the liquidation amount of Maker is about 49 million U.S. dollars.
In DeFi, there are no closed-door negotiations, no delaying issues to the courts, and no lobbying regulators. Everyone only does one thing: abide by smart contracts, and Isn't that what a resilient economy should look like?
This is DeFi.
Original link a>
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia