The rapid development of NFT is amazing. Even though the market is no longer as good as it was at the peak a few months ago, the imagination that NFT has brought us and the ability to attract external users The ability is far beyond other fields in the industry. In addition to the applications we are already familiar with such as PFP and PASS, there are also some fields that maximize the ownership attributes of NFT, such as Metacask.
This is a whiskey barrel trading platform that makes NFT the ID of each barrel. In October last year, the Metacask platform successfully auctioned a 1991 Macallan whiskey barrel for $2.3 million. We contacted Metacask joint venture Nim Siriwardana to hear his understanding of the Metacask platform and his views on NFT.
Nim: In early 2021, I started collecting NFTs on the Tezos blockchain. But when I was the CTO of GSR, I have been paying attention to the development of the NFT field.
I've joined some artist groups who are selling 1/1 artwork and limited edition art collectibles as NFTs. They minted the scanned version of the painting into an NFT, and you just pay on Tezos. This is a fun and effective way to start a collection. I had never collected anything before this, but all of a sudden I could have a collectible in the NFT space.
I'm beginning to see the true power of the technology behind NFTs, and I'm inspired by the technology. I realized we could use it better than just artwork.
Nim: I chose a different path and met many traditional artists in this field. It all started with a collaboration with artist Trevor Jones who created a 1/1 art piece of art for a 1991 Macallan whiskey cask we auctioned last October as a cask digital labels. This is why I come in from collectibles, not PFP. Since then, I've joined a super interesting circle of artists in this field.
Nim: First of all, NFT has such a capability——Through the instant royalty payment configured in the Token contract, you can directly Reward creators.
There are already many artists who have transferred some of their works from the real world to the digital world. They can reach a new market and sell their work through a new communication channel. Thus, the gatekeepers these artists used to face in the real world are taken away, and they now have direct access to those interested in their work.
Secondly, and perhaps more importantly, NFT can prove ownership and preserve the source of physical assets, which is what we want at Metacask To be achieved.
It is very important to be able to record the historical ownership of a particular item. For example, a painting, in order to figure out who has owned it historically, we need to do a lot of research. And the entire circulation history of this painting is also part of its value. Now you can save all these things on the blockchain.
I think these two capabilities are the main strengths of NFTs and blockchains, and they are the reasons why I am extremely optimistic about what we can achieve with NFTs in the future.
Nim: I started my career at Goldman Sachs as a fresh graduate. It was an interesting experience,I was taught to do things with integrity and make sure they were done well - no shortcuts, the customer comes first. These values have deeply influenced me since the early days, and they are also very helpful for me to start a business now.
But the most interesting professional experience was at GSR, where I was introduced to encryption. I joined GSR in 2017, when our goal was to build GSR into a leading market maker in the encryption field. When I first joined, it was a small company of 6-10 people. By the time I left last year, GSR had more than 120 people. I have learned a lot from this process of growing up.
During the time I was at GSR, we were actually going through the encryption winter of 2018 and 2019. When the 20-year bull market came again, I saw the projects that continued to build in the bear market come to the fore. This is very important, people need to rely on the concept you are trying to sell. I've really learned two things: always do things with integrity, people need to trust what you're doing, and second, keep building so that when the market changes in your favor, you benefit from it .
Finally, it is worth emphasizing that don't build for the sake of building, but solve practical problems. A lot of people in the crypto space are only working on building infrastructure, but few people are actually building houses and solving real problems. At Metacask, we want to solve a real problem, and we use technology that others have already built to solve a real problem.
Nim: Let me start with some background on how Metacask was founded. Early last year, around the same time I was getting into NFTs, some whiskey brokers in the UK approached me and suggested I build a portfolio of whiskey casks.
Whiskey casks are also super interesting as assets - each cask is unique. No two casks made on the same day, hold the same liquid, and mature in the same way. Therefore, what we have is a physical asset that cannot be forged in the real world, so it is very reasonable to use NFT to represent this physical asset. The idea hit me a bit, so I went back to my broker and opened up and said, "I don't really want to buy these casks right now, but you guys want to work with me to create a blockchain-based marketplace to sell some wine Barrel?"
There are two ways to trade barrels traditionally, you can own a barrel. The first method is called a "delivery order". This is basically a letter, usually on paper, sent between the buyer, the seller and where the casks are actually stored. The warehouse where the barrels were stored wrote to the new owner saying, I admit that you own this barrel because Bob sold it to you. The warehouse will then create an account in your name and register the kegs to your account. Such paper-based transactions take weeks, sometimes even a month, to execute.
The second method is usually used to avoid the trouble of the first. The broker will give you a certificate saying you bought the barrel, but the broker keeps the barrel in their warehouse in their name. The advantage of this is that nothing changes in the repository, nor do they see the fact that ownership has changed. Instead you are now relying on the broker to keep a good track record proving that they have indeed sold you casks from someone else. You can think of situations where this could go wrong. For example if a broker goes bankrupt, you have to pray that they keep accurate records of who actually owns what casks.
NFT can solve the disadvantages of the above two methods. Because ownership of the NFT is valid ultimate truth, proving that you own the cask. Transactions on the blockchain can replace proof of title and delivery notes. It was this improvement in transactions from paper-based to blockchain-based that really struck me as an awareness of what improvements can be made in this industry. We showed this idea to brokers who have been operating in this space for about 11 years. They know the pain of transacting in the traditional way and see how blockchain technology can make life easier. So, they partnered with me to create Metacask.
Nim: First of all, we are dealing with physical assets, and NFT is actually a proof of ownership of physical assets. Whereas the physical assets we deal with are real spirits, whether it's a bottle or a barrel, it's spirits. We want to make sure they are not exposed to underage kids, make sure there is an age restriction before you buy these items.
Secondly, there is a practical aspect: HMRC requires warehouses to regularly report who actually owns the barrels in these bonded warehouses. We work hard to ensure our compliance by not allowing participation by citizens of certain sanctioned countries.
We use a solution called Civic Identity to perform authentication. When you authenticate, you just need to use an app on your phone. Civic will provide you with a KYC Token, which will be placed in your account. They are like a non-transferable NFT placed in your account, indicating that you have been verified. Metacask just checks for the existence of this token. If you own this KYC Token, you are allowed to participate. This means that we don't actually have to collect anyone's private data or log all of it. We just need to make sure participating users are authenticated.
Nim: We have just started, and we haven’t done a lot of advertising and marketing, but we already have a lot of users. We are always focused on improving the system, testing and improving the user experience. We are also planning our market strategy and plan to launch various initiatives in the next six months to one year.
Many people are interested in barrel NFT because it contains two interesting elements of whiskey and NFT. The organic combination of the two makes the barrel NFT more interesting. While owning a wine barrel is obviously not something most people would consider right now, Metacask presents such an interesting opportunity for them once they realize they can do so.
I think the tricky part is making sure people are comfortable buying and owning these things. Whiskey casks are not the same as bottled whiskey because when you are buying casks, you do not actually physically deliver them, the casks do not get shipped to your home. The barrels will be stored in the warehouse and matured gradually. When the time comes, it can be bottled at the owner's discretion. Of course, it can also be traded on the Metacask platform at any time in the form of NFT .
Nim: There is an interesting history in this too. We created the NFT in May last year and have been communicating with Bonhams Auction House, hoping that they will conduct the auction on their behalf. But in the end, they backed off, they felt it was too early to auction physical objects with NFTs. Later, we contacted Sotheby's and Christie's, and they also had similar opinions and did not agree to link NFT with real objects.
At the time, the platform we built on top of the Casper network wasn't ready, so we couldn't run auctions on Metacask itself. We ended up partnering with a platform called Origin Protocol, and they allowed us to efficiently execute a token auction on their platform for $2.3 million.
But about 2-3 weeks ago we just auctioned off a 30 year Genting whiskey cask on the Metacask platform. I think this is our most important auction on Metacask to date, selling for 225,000 of Casper Token.
Nim: The main plan in the short term is to increase the products on the platform. We are working on various partnerships, including with many independent producers and brokers. The advantage of brokers is that they have access to privately owned casks. So we work with a broker with the intention of listing these private barrels for sale on the platform.
The second goal we're trying to do with brokers is to have us cast the NFT, and transfer that NFT to customers who bought it in the real world. In this way, we began to effectively integrate NFTs with their existing sales mechanisms.
So, as a broker's client, if you buy a barrel, you not only get a paper document, you also get a representative NFT of this barrel. Eventually you won't need that piece of paper anymore, and by selling NFTs, you can achieve the same transaction. So, this is something we are very concerned about in our work - how to effectively tokenize the barrel inventory they are managing.
Similarly, we are also working with warehouses who want to do bottled and barreled items to effectively Token tokenize their inventory. As a warehouse, I will be able to track who owns the NFTs I store, and I will be able to effectively report to HMRC who owns the casks. If the barrel is transferred, the NFT will also be transferred. As distilleries and producers create NFTs for their casks, this opens up new sales opportunities for them to be listed on Metacask . So we're providing a very friendly environment: first on the logistics side, where we're using blockchain technology to record their inventory, and then on the marketplace side, where they're able to sell these casks on Metacask . That's what we're working towards.
Nim: NFT is obviously relatively new in terms of whiskey casks. In terms of the size of the whiskey cask trade, it's hard to measure because the trade in whiskey casks is opaque and there isn't enough market information. What we do know is that there is a huge demand for whiskey casks and there is currently not enough supply. There are some headline market statistics, such as Scotch whiskey exports are worth $5.5 billion in 2021, accounting for a staggering 22% of all UK food and drink exports.
As for the value of the barrel, you can take a look at the 1988 Macallan whiskey we are about to auction, that barrel can be kept for another 10 years to 20 years. Comparing that to the value of a 40 or 50 year old Macallan today might give an idea of what an 88 year old cask might be worth in the future. There is a lot of price information at the bottle level but very little at the cask level, mainly because it is in the hands of the brokers. We are trying to increase transparency in the industry with our solution by making this information available to the market by putting it on the blockchain.
The overall market size is growing. We found that there is a lot of demand coming from China. But interestingly, India also has a huge demand for high-quality whiskey. Britain is adjusting tariffs with India, and if the tariffs are removed, there will be high demand for high-quality whiskey in India. These two markets alone will put pressure on existing supply. Plus the U.S. has just announced lower tariffs on whiskey. Demand is increasing, but supply remains limited, and it will be interesting to see where the market goes.
Nim: Good usability is the Holy Grail of a PFP project.
The concept of utility is actually based on the idea of value transfer. How do you bring additional value to the person who owns this NFT? ? That way, when you sell it, the next person gets value as well. This is where the real utility of a NFT lies. But what is the actual outcome, is there any tangible, practical utility other than network effects or the flexibility that a particular PFP might give you? Probably very little. When we use NFT to represent physical assets, it is the opposite, NFT is almost like a document proving that you now own some physical objects. The value of NFT is that it makes it easier to transfer ownership of physical assets, especially if the physical object is stored somewhere and does not need to be moved. Knowing that physical assets are safely stored, we can trade them freely.
When you use NFT for physical commodity transactions like we do, many of the problems with other NFT projects (scams, rug pulls, item zeroing) are It won't happen because what you buy and trade is physical. I cannot scam you and I cannot rob you because you own this physical asset and it is securely stored in a bonded warehouse in Scotland. NFTs just tie you to that physical asset.
It's a different game,I think we'll see more NFT projects going in this direction - bringing Come true utility and accessibility. This is where I see NFTs headed — collaboration with the real world.
Nim: Yes, we have an auction beyond imagination coming soon, the auction is A cask from the 1988 distillation at The Macallan Distillery. This is an extremely rare cask with perfect provenance that has been in storage at the winery (only recently removed). It is also the most valuable and popular cask ever sold at auction.
Due to its rarity, it would of course need an equally stunning piece of art to match. We commissioned Italian artist Ruben Frosali to create a beautiful 1/1 animation to celebrate the cask and the Year of the Dragon, giving the new owner a beautiful treat while tasting some of the finest single malt whiskey in the world.
As far as the Chinese market is concerned, we understand that there is a great demand for barrel ownership and that there are restrictions on the use of cryptocurrencies in China. With this in mind,we are building traditional fiat payment and wire transfer channels so that Chinese users can participate in our auctions. Using fiat currency for settlement, you will have the same fun of bidding.
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia