Original title: "Understanding the concept of "soul binding token" through EIP-5114"
Original author: Overnight porridge, the way of the metaverse
< /p>
In January of this year, Vitalik, the co-founder of Ethereum, published an article entitled "Soulbound", which mentioned the source of the concept of soul binding - "Warcraft World", and the concept of the non-transferable "soul-bound NFT" associated with it.
In May, E. Glen Weyl, Puja Ohlhaver, and vitalik co-authored another article entitled "Decentralized Society: Finding the Soul of Web3" The paper talks about various usage scenarios of soul-bound NFT (also known as SBT), including unsecured lending, social recovery wallet, soul airdrop, DAO defense, etc.
So what exactly does "soul binding" mean, and what does the relevant Token standard say?
This article first explains the concept of soul binding through the rules of "World of Warcraft", and then through "EIP-5114: Soul Binding Token" written by Micah Zoltu A draft standard to help everyone further understand the meaning of soul-bound NFT (SBT).
In the game "World of Warcraft", many top-level equipment or game props have the setting of "Soulbound". The simple understanding is that after the player picks up these items, these items will be bound to the game characters and cannot be traded in the trading market. circulation.

(for example, players group to kill the final After the BOSS Illidan, there is a very small chance to get the cool-looking orange weapon Azzinoth Warglaive.)
Compared to those forged by players , Tradeable weapons and equipment, soul-bound equipment of the same level have better attributes and are more difficult to obtain.
So "soul binding" items are really not tradable?
Not so, in fact, smart players have already bypassed this binding in two ways.
The first is the so-called "G Group" service. A few slots are reserved for consuming game players who need "soul-bound" items. Once the "soul-bound" items they need appear, auctions can be held, and the fees paid by consumers will finally be in the The "G group" is allocated internally. In this way, the "soul binding" is tradable in disguise, but only before binding.
In addition, even the equipment, items or mounts after "soul binding" can also be transferred through account transactions, that is to say , the concept of "soul binding" in World of Warcraft does not mean that it is completely non-transferable, it is only bound to the game character.

(Note: The picture comes from a third-party trading platform)< /blockquote>
What is the concept of soul binding NFT (SBT) proposed by vitalik et al.? We can understand it through EIP 5114, the Token standard draft.
(note that this EIP is currently in Draft stage, so some changes may occur later, in addition, Tim Daubenschtz et al. also wrote a similar EIP-4973 Token standards, so which standard will eventually be widely accepted by the community, there is still great uncertainty).
EIP 5114: Soulbound Token (Soulbound Token) Standard
Description: Token attached to the "soul" during casting, which cannot be transferred afterwards.
By Micah Zoltu (@MicahZoltu)
Status: Draft (Draft)
Category: ERC
Creation time: 2022-05- 30
Requirements: EIP 721
Summary
A soul-bound Token refers to a Token that is bound to another non-homogeneous Token (NFT, such as an EIP-721 Token) at the time of casting, and cannot be transferred after casting.
Specification
```solidity
interface IERC5114 {
//When creating a new instance of this Token
//This event **cannot** fire twice for the same `tokenId`
event Mint ( uint256 indexed tokenId, address indexed nftAddress, uint256 indexed nftTokenId);
//Return the NFT token that owns the token
< br>
//If the token has not been minted, this function** must** throw
//This function** MUST ** Always return the same result when called after each build
//This function **MUST** return the same result as the original `Mint` event The same value found for token in
function ownerOf (uint256 index) external view returns (address nftAddress, uint256 nftTokenId);
//Returns a censorship-resistant URI containing detailed information about this token collection; //The metadata returned by this is merged with the metadata returned by `tokenUri(uint256)`
//collectionUri **must** immutable and the content is addressable (e.g. IPF://)
//collectionUri **cannot** point to mutable/censorable content (e.g. https://)
//Data from "tokenUri" takes precedence over data returned by this method
// Any external links referenced by content in `collectionUri` must also ** obey all the rules above
function collectionUri () external view returns (string collectionUri);
//Returns a censorship-resistant URI containing details about this token instance < /p>
//tokenUri **MUST** be immutable and content-addressable (eg, ipfs://)
//tokenUri **cannot** point to mutable/censorable content (eg, https://)
//Data from this takes precedence over data returned by `collectionUri`
// Any external links referenced by content in `tokenUri` also All rules above must ** be respected
function tokenUri (uint256 tokenId) external view returns (string tokenUri);
Basic principles
1. Invariance
< br>
By requiring tokens to be permanently immovable, we both guarantee inseparability and non-mergability between sets of soulbound tokens bound to a single NFT, while allowing users to aggressively cache the results.
2. URI content is required to be addressable
Soulbound tokens are permanent badges/indicators attached to a character. This means that not only can users not transfer ownership, but minters themselves cannot withdraw, transfer or change ownership. This includes converting or removing any remote content as a means of censoring or manipulating specific users.
3. tokenUri data format
The data format pointed to by "collectionUri()" and "tokenUri(uint256)" is intentionally left out of this standard in favor of a separate standard that can be iterated in the future. Regardless of the details of the data format, immutability constraints are the only thing defined to ensure the spirit of this token is maintained.
Backward Compatibility
This is a new token type and does not mean It is backward compatible with any existing Token except the existing feasible soul (such as EIP-721 Token).
Security Precautions
Some project parties may claim to implement this EIP, but for As far as the user is concerned, we need to verify that they did this truthfully.
Token authors can create a token that may appear to follow the rules when we do an initial probing of its API surface, but actually does not in this way.
For example, a contract may allow transfers via some mechanism, but simply not use them initially.
It should also be clear that the soul binding token is not bound to a human being, but to a character.
A character is any participant (it can even be a group of people) who, over time, collects multiple soulbinding tokens to build a collection of badges ).
This persona may be transferred to another person or group of people, and anyone who interacts with the persona should not assume There is one person who never changes.
Furthermore, one soulbound token can be bound to another soulbound token.
Theoretically, if all Tokens in the chain are created at the same time, they may form a loop. Software attempting to walk such a chain should take care to develop an exit strategy if a loop is detected.
Copyright
Disclaimer of copyright and related rights.
Some thoughts on soul binding NFT
Compared with games such as World of Warcraft, the transferability of blockchain accounts will be lower, because the private key is bound to the user address, which means that even if a certain blockchain account has a large value, there will be no transfer between users. It is also impossible to effectively conduct account transactions through third-party platforms or privately (there is a huge risk).
In spite of this, we still cannot simply assume that the "soul binding NFT" is bound to the user itself, but we need to consider the possibility of "soul trading" Therefore, for unsecured lending use cases, it may not be enough to rely solely on the credit value on the chain, and some other soul-bound NFT use cases will more or less have such problems.
In the author's opinion, "soul airdrop" may be a point that is most closely related to everyone. For now, in order to better establish The community will choose to airdrop free tokens to early active users, which naturally encourages Sybil attacks (that is, a user interacts with multiple addresses). Trying to dodge anti-witch measures is bad for both parties.
The "soul airdrop" method allows the project party to more accurately target the target airdrop users, which in turn encourages users to carefully cultivate their own "soul" , instead of devoting time and energy to witch attacks.
In general, "soul-bound NFT", as the core concept of a decentralized society proposed by vitalik and others, is still in a very early stage of development , On the other hand, it may be very valuable for users to find ways to make their "soul" interesting.
Related information:
1, https://vitalik.ca/general/2022/01/26/soulbound.html
2, https://www.defidaonews.com/article/6750230
3, https://github.com/ethereum/EIPs/pull/5114/files
Original link
Welcome to join the official BlockBeats community:
Telegram Subscription Group: https://t.me/theblockbeats
Telegram Discussion Group: https://t.me/BlockBeats_App
Official Twitter Account: https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia